법/초자아에서 사랑으로—허먼 멜빌의『빌리 버드』에 나타나는 법, 폭력, 그리고 사랑의 가능성
From Law/Superego to Love: Law, Violence, and the Possibility of Love in Herman Melville’s Billy Budd, Sailor
0
조회
0
다운로드
3
인용
0
참고문헌
키워드
초록
This essay aims to explore Herman Melville’s recognition and resolution of the vicious link between law and violence in his posthumous Billy Budd,Sailor (1924). In order to investigate the issues, this essay refers to Freud,Benjamin, Derrida, Lacan, and Zˇ izˇek, all perceptive to the uncanny affinity of law and violence. Especially, Zˇ izˇek’s arguments of “superego” as an embodiment of cruel and destructive violence supplementing the official law and of “love” as an ethical possibility beyond the limit of the problematic law are introduced in this study to make Melville’s reflection of the inseparableness between law and violence much clearer. John Claggart and Captain Vere embody the legal (superegoic) violence. Claggart even procurs secret enjoyment,in the name of maintaining positive law. Billy Budd discloses another violence defending his justness according to natural law. However, Melville suggests the possibility of suspending the problematic tie of law/violence through “love,” as portrayed at the last part of the story. The two final words from Billy and Vere, as a sort of delayed dialogue between them after the event of their secret interview before Billy’s hanging, suggest that they finally distance from the obscene nightly law of superego—respectively from outward punitiveness toward Vere and from inward punishment for Vere’s excessive enforcement of Billy’s hanging—and identify each other’s lack as their own. Their love implicated in the last words is for the real other — in Lacan’s sense — who discloses the constitutive lack or incompleteness of beings and aporia of the law. This essay’s examination of Melville’s representations about the superegoic violence as the (im-)possible condition of law and the possibility of withdrawing from it would help us recognize Billy Budd, Sailor as the author’s own last word for the possible vision of love cutting the vicious knot of law/violence.
Abstract
This essay aims to explore Herman Melville’s recognition and resolution of the vicious link between law and violence in his posthumous Billy Budd,Sailor (1924). In order to investigate the issues, this essay refers to Freud,Benjamin, Derrida, Lacan, and Zˇ izˇek, all perceptive to the uncanny affinity of law and violence. Especially, Zˇ izˇek’s arguments of “superego” as an embodiment of cruel and destructive violence supplementing the official law and of “love” as an ethical possibility beyond the limit of the problematic law are introduced in this study to make Melville’s reflection of the inseparableness between law and violence much clearer. John Claggart and Captain Vere embody the legal (superegoic) violence. Claggart even procurs secret enjoyment,in the name of maintaining positive law. Billy Budd discloses another violence defending his justness according to natural law. However, Melville suggests the possibility of suspending the problematic tie of law/violence through “love,” as portrayed at the last part of the story. The two final words from Billy and Vere, as a sort of delayed dialogue between them after the event of their secret interview before Billy’s hanging, suggest that they finally distance from the obscene nightly law of superego—respectively from outward punitiveness toward Vere and from inward punishment for Vere’s excessive enforcement of Billy’s hanging—and identify each other’s lack as their own. Their love implicated in the last words is for the real other — in Lacan’s sense — who discloses the constitutive lack or incompleteness of beings and aporia of the law. This essay’s examination of Melville’s representations about the superegoic violence as the (im-)possible condition of law and the possibility of withdrawing from it would help us recognize Billy Budd, Sailor as the author’s own last word for the possible vision of love cutting the vicious knot of law/violence.
참고문헌 (37)
- 민승기, "사랑의 윤리학.라깡, 사유의 모험", pp.225~271 (2010), 서울: 마티
- 신문수, "허만 멜빌: 탈색된 진실의 추구자" (1995), 서울:건국대학교 출판부
- 정진만, "윤리와 충동: 칸트와 사드에 관한 라깡의 논의를 중심으로", 라깡과 현대정 신분석, 4(1), pp.197~220 (2002)
- Arendt, Hannah, "On Revolution" (1963), London: Faber and Faber
- Arendt, Hannah, "Reflections on Violence", pp.19~31 (1969), The New York Review of Books
- Arvin, Newton, "Departure Melville’s Short Novels", pp.401~406 (2002), New York and London: W.W. Norton
- Benjamin, Walter, "Critique of Violence Reflections: Essays, Aphorisms, Autobiographical Writings", pp.277~300 (1978), New York: Schocken Books
- Billy Budd, "Terence Stamp" (1962), Allied Artists
- Caranti, Luigi, "Perpetual War for Perpetual Peace? Reflections on the Realist Critique of Kant’s Project", Journal of Human Rights, 5, pp.341~353 (2006)
- Claviez, Thomas, "Rainbows, Fogs, and Other Smokescreens: Billy Budd and the Question of Ethics", Arizona Quarterly, 62(4), pp.31~46 (2006)
- Cohen, Hennig, "Herman Melville’s Malcolm Letter: Man’s Final Lore" (1992), New York: Fordham UP and The New York Public Library
- Derrida, Jacques, "Force of Law: The Mystical Foundation of Authority Deconstruction and the Possibility of Justice", pp.3~67 (1992), New York and London: Routledge
- "Forgiveness, In Merriam-Webster’s Collegiate Dictionary. 11th ed" (2003)
- Freud, Sigmund, "Totem and Taboo The Standard Edition of the Complete Psychological Works of Sigmund Freud Vol. 13" (1953), London: The Hogarth Press
- Kant, Immanuel, "The Metaphysics of Morals" (1996), Cambridge: Cambridge UP
- Kotsko, Adam, "Zˇ izˇek and Theology" (2008), London and New York: T&T Clark
- Lacan, Jacques, "The Four Fundamental Concepts of Psycho-Analysis" (1977), New York: Penguin Books
- Lacan, Jacques, "The Seminar of Jacques Lacan, Book VII (The Ethics of Psychoanalysis 1959-1960)" (1997), New York and London: W.W. Norton
- Leyda, Jay, "The Melville Log: A Documentary Life of Herman Melville, 1819- 1891. Vol. 2" (1969), New York: Gordian Press
- Manwaring, G. E., "The Floating Republic" (1966), New York: Augustus M. Kelley
- McGowan, Todd, "The End of Dissatisfaction?: Jacques Lacan and the Emerging Society of Enjoyment" (2004), Albany: SUNY Press
- Melville, Herman, "Billy Budd, Sailor (An Inside Narrative)" (1962), Chicago and London: U of Chicago P
- O’Dwyer, Kathleen, "The Possibility of Love: An Interdisciplinary Analysis" (2009), Newcastle upon Tyne, UK: Cambridge Scholars Publishing
- Orend, Brian, "Kant’s Just War Theory", Journal of the History of Philosophy, 37, pp.323~353 (1999)
- Rogin, Michael Paul, "Fathers and Children: Andrew Jackson and the Subjugation of the American Indian" (1975), New York: Alfred A. Knof
- Rogin, Michael Paul, "Subversive Genealogy: The Politics and Art of Herman Melville" (1979), Berkeley: U of California P
- Sharpe, Matthew, "Zˇ izˇ ek and Politics: A Critical Introduction" (2010), Edinburgh: Edinburgh UP
- Shneidman, Edwin S, "Some Psychological Reflections on the Death of Malcolm Melville", Suicide and Life-Threatening Behavior, 6(4), pp.231~242 (1976)
- Stern, Milton R, "The Fine Hammered Steel of Herman Melville" (1957), Urbana: U of Illinois P
- Stewart, Randall, "Moral Crisis as Structural Principle in Fiction: A Few American Examples", The Christian Scholar: The Quarterly Journal of the Commission on Christian Higher Education of the National Council of the Churches of Christ in the United States of America, 42, pp.284~289 (1959)
- Thomas, Brook, "Cross-Examinations of Law and Literature: Cooper, Hawthorne, Stowe, and Melville" (1987), Cambridge and New York: Cambridge UP
- Weiner, Susan, "Law in Art: Melville’s Major Fiction and Nineteenth-Century American Law" (1992), New York, San Francisco, and Berlin: Peter Lang
- Zˇizˇ ek, Slavoj, "For They Know Not What They Do: Enjoyment as a Political Factor" (1991), London and New York: Verso
- Zˇizˇ ek, Slavoj, "Tarrying with the Negative: Kant, Hegel, and the Critique of Ideology" (1993), Durham: Duke UP
- Zˇizˇ ek, Slavoj, "The Plague of Fantasies" (1997), London and New York: Verso
- Zˇizˇ ek, Slavoj, "The Puppet and the Dwarf: The Perverse Core of Christianity" (2003), Cambridge, Massachusettes: The MIT Press
- Zˇizˇ ek, Slavoj, "The Zˇizˇek Reader" (1999), Oxford:Blackwell