Open versus Closed Surgery for Axillary Osmidrosis: A Meta-Analysis of Articles Published in Four Languages
2
조회
0
다운로드
0
인용
0
참고문헌
키워드
초록
Background: Individuals with axillary osmidrosis suffer detrimental effects to their psychosocial functioning. In Asian nations, major operations for axillary osmidrosis include subdermal excision (open surgery) and suction-curettage (closed surgery). Objective: The aim of this meta-analysis was to determine which of these two procedures is most favorable in terms of safety and efficacy. Methods: According to the Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Metaanalyses (PRISMA) guideline, we searched electronic databases for articles published in English, Japanese, Korean, and Chinese languages. Fixed-effects model meta-analyses of odds ratios (OR) and 95% confidence intervals (CI) were conducted, and the I2 was used to assess heterogeneity. Complication rates, recurrence/ineffectiveness rates, and patient satisfaction data were extracted and compared between open and closed surgeries. Results: Our search yielded 8 articles that include 1,179 patients; 560 underwent open surgery, and 619 underwent closed surgery. Our meta-analysis revealed that suction-curettage had a significantly lower risk of acute adverse events than open excision (OR, 0.15; 95% CI, 0.07∼0.32), whereas open excision was significantly superior to suction-curettage for recurrence/ineffectiveness rate (OR, 2.90; 95% CI, 1.37∼6.15). Patient satisfaction was equally high with both treatments (OR, 1.58; 95% CI, 0.69∼ 3.60). Conclusion: Since surgical treatments for axillary osmidrosis have been performed mostly in East Asian nations, it was meaningful to review articles published in four languages. This meta-analysis revealed that closed surgery was safer but less effective than open surgery. However, both patient groups expressed high satisfaction with the outcomes. Our results may be helpful for deciding surgical treatment options.
Abstract
Background: Individuals with axillary osmidrosis suffer detrimental effects to their psychosocial functioning. In Asian nations, major operations for axillary osmidrosis include subdermal excision (open surgery) and suction-curettage (closed surgery). Objective: The aim of this meta-analysis was to determine which of these two procedures is most favorable in terms of safety and efficacy. Methods: According to the Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Metaanalyses (PRISMA) guideline, we searched electronic databases for articles published in English, Japanese, Korean, and Chinese languages. Fixed-effects model meta-analyses of odds ratios (OR) and 95% confidence intervals (CI) were conducted, and the I2 was used to assess heterogeneity. Complication rates, recurrence/ineffectiveness rates, and patient satisfaction data were extracted and compared between open and closed surgeries. Results: Our search yielded 8 articles that include 1,179 patients; 560 underwent open surgery, and 619 underwent closed surgery. Our meta-analysis revealed that suction-curettage had a significantly lower risk of acute adverse events than open excision (OR, 0.15; 95% CI, 0.07∼0.32), whereas open excision was significantly superior to suction-curettage for recurrence/ineffectiveness rate (OR, 2.90; 95% CI, 1.37∼6.15). Patient satisfaction was equally high with both treatments (OR, 1.58; 95% CI, 0.69∼ 3.60). Conclusion: Since surgical treatments for axillary osmidrosis have been performed mostly in East Asian nations, it was meaningful to review articles published in four languages. This meta-analysis revealed that closed surgery was safer but less effective than open surgery. However, both patient groups expressed high satisfaction with the outcomes. Our results may be helpful for deciding surgical treatment options.
참고문헌 (27)
- Morioka D, "Clinical features of axillary osmidrosis : a retrospective chart review of 723Japanese patients", J Dermatol, 40, pp.384~388 (2013)
- Morioka D, "Axillary osmidrosis: past, present, and future", Ann Plast Surg, 84, pp.722~728 (2020)
- Wang C, "Axillary osmidrosis treatment using an aggressive suction-curettage technique : a clinical study on paired control", Aesthetic Plast Surg, 39, pp.608~615 (2015)
- 정성규, "A Prospective, Long-Term Follow-Up Study of 1,444 nm Nd:YAG Laser: A New Modality for Treating Axillary Bromhidrosis", Annals of Dermatology, 26(2), pp.184~188 (2014), 대한피부과학회
- Shin JY, "Osmidrosis treatment approaches : a systematic review and meta-analysis", Ann Plast Surg, 78, pp.354~359 (2017)
- Zhang L, "The curative effect of liposuction curettage in the treatment of bromhidrosis: a meta-analysis", Medicine(Baltimore), 96, pp.e7844~ (2017)
- Inaba M, "New instrument for hircismus and hyperhidrosis operation : subcutaneous tissue shaver", Plast Reconstr Surg, 59, pp.864~866 (1977)
- Ou LF, "Treatment of axillary bromhidrosis with superficial liposuction", Plast Reconstr Surg, 102, pp.1479~1485 (1998)
- Moher D, "Preferred reporting items for systematic reviews and metaanalyses : the PRISMA statement", BMJ, 339, pp.b2535~ (2009)
- Oteng-Ntim E, "Interpregnancy weight change and adverse pregnancy outcomes : a systematic review and meta-analysis", BMJ Open, 8, pp.e018778~ (2018)
- Matsuda K, "Surgical treatment of axillary osmidrosis with the shaver system", Jpn J Plast Reconstr Surg, 47, pp.1253~1259 (2004)
- Li BW, "Comparision of three methods in treatment of osmidrosis", Chin J Med Aesthet Cosmetol, 15, pp.107~109 (2009)
- Li WW, "Comparison study on the efficacy of three methods for the treatment of osmidrosis", Zhonghua Zheng Xing Wai Ke Za Zhi, 26, pp.348~350 (2010)
- Zhang JZ, "Comparison among two small incision procedures in treating axillary osmidrosis", China Med Her, (26), pp.62~64 (2014)
- 남상호, "표재성 지방흡입술을 이용한 액취증 수술에서 변형된 수술법과 일반적 수술법에 대한 비교 연구", 대한피부과학회지, 53(7), pp.523~529 (2015), 대한피부과학회
- Li L, "Comparative study on the efficacy of two different micro-invasive treatment for axillary bromhidrosis", Chin J Aesthetic Med, 24, pp.17~19 (2015)
- Hu RL, "Comparison of the clinical efficacy of subcutaneous pruning combined with Xiaozhiling infusion and negative pressure suction combined with Xiaozhiling perfusion in the treatment of axillary odor", Chin J Aesthet Plast Surg, 30, pp.28~31 (2019)
- Morrison A, "The effect of English-language restriction on systematic review-based meta-analyses : a systematic review of empirical studies", Int J Technol Assess Health Care, 28, pp.138~144 (2012)
- Niiyama S, "Treatment of osmidrosis using the ultrasonic surgical aspirator", Acta Derm Venereol, 86, pp.238~240 (2006)
- Huang YH, "Reduction in osmidrosis using a suction-assisted cartilage shaver improves the quality of life", Dermatol Surg, 36, pp.1573~1577 (2010)
- Li ZR, "Excision of apocrine glands with preservation of axillary superficial fascia for the treatment of axillary bromhidrosis", Dermatol Surg, 41, pp.640~644 (2015)
- Wu WH, "Surgical treatment of axillary osmidrosis : an analysis of 343 cases", Plast Reconstr Surg, 94, pp.288~294 (1994)
- Shi Z, "Modified tumescent superficial suction with curettage treatment for axillary bromidrosis : clinical experience of 280 cases", Aesthetic Plast Surg, 38, pp.151~155 (2014)
- Lee JC, "Treatment for axillary osmidrosis with suction-assisted cartilage shaver", Br J Plast Surg, 58, pp.223~227 (2005)
- Wu WH, "Ablation of apocrine glands with the use of a suction-assisted cartilage shaver for treatment of axillary osmidrosis : an analysis of 156 cases", Ann Plast Surg, 62, pp.278~283 (2009)
- Yang HH, "Minimally invasive approaches to axillary osmidrosis treatment: a comparison between superficial liposuction with automatic shaver curettage, subcutaneous laser treatment, and microwave-based therapy with a modified technique", J Cosmet Dermatol, 18, pp.594~601 (2019)
- Liu Q, "Surgical subcision as a cost-effective and minimally invasive treatment for axillary osmidrosis", J Cosmet Dermatol, 9, pp.44~49 (2010)