Podcasting in medical education: a review of the literature
0
조회
0
다운로드
1
인용
0
참고문헌
키워드
초록
Podcasts are increasingly being used for medical education, both within teaching institutions and on an international scale by major journals. To date, there are no evidence-based guidelines for the development of educational podcasts. To review the state of the literature, MEDLINE, SCOPUS, and ERIC were searched in May 2016 for articles describing audio format podcasts used in medical education. Eighty-four articles met inclusion criteria. A qualitative synthesis of the evidence was done using Kirkpatrick’s model for evaluating outcomes. Twenty-four articles described reaction outcomes, eleven described learning outcomes, and one described behavioral outcomes. None measured patient impact. The literature demonstrates that podcasts are both feasible and accepted by learners. The mean length of reported podcasts was 18 minutes, which falls within the recommended range in at least one paper, and is consistent with reported listener preference. Interview format, clear disclosures, and accurate information were reported as desirable. There is limited evidence showing the efficacy of podcasts as teaching tools, or regarding best practices in making podcasts. More rigorous studies evaluating efficacy, changes in behavior, and changes in patient outcomes need to be performed in order to prove podcasts’ value and to justify production costs.
Abstract
Podcasts are increasingly being used for medical education, both within teaching institutions and on an international scale by major journals. To date, there are no evidence-based guidelines for the development of educational podcasts. To review the state of the literature, MEDLINE, SCOPUS, and ERIC were searched in May 2016 for articles describing audio format podcasts used in medical education. Eighty-four articles met inclusion criteria. A qualitative synthesis of the evidence was done using Kirkpatrick’s model for evaluating outcomes. Twenty-four articles described reaction outcomes, eleven described learning outcomes, and one described behavioral outcomes. None measured patient impact. The literature demonstrates that podcasts are both feasible and accepted by learners. The mean length of reported podcasts was 18 minutes, which falls within the recommended range in at least one paper, and is consistent with reported listener preference. Interview format, clear disclosures, and accurate information were reported as desirable. There is limited evidence showing the efficacy of podcasts as teaching tools, or regarding best practices in making podcasts. More rigorous studies evaluating efficacy, changes in behavior, and changes in patient outcomes need to be performed in order to prove podcasts’ value and to justify production costs.
참고문헌 (46)
- Fletcher S, "Magnetic tape recording in the teaching of histopathology", Br J Med Educ, 2(4), pp.283~292 (1968)
- "Audible revolution" (2004)[URL]
- Cadogan M, "Free Open Access Meducation (FOAM): the rise of emergency medicine and critical care blogs and podcasts (2002-2013)", Emerg Med J, (e1), pp.e76~e77 (2014)
- Ahn J, "Podcasts: accessing, choosing, creating, and disseminating content", J Grad Med Educ, 8(3), pp.435~436 (2016)
- Sandars J, "Twelve tips for using podcasts in medical education", Med Teach, 31(5), pp.387~389 (2009)
- Beckman TJ, "Developing scholarly projects in education: a primer for medical teachers", Med Teach, 29(2-3), pp.210~218 (2007)
- Jalali A, "Use of podcasting as an innovative asynchronous e-learning tool for students", US China Educ Rev, A6, pp.741~748 (2011)
- Matava CT, "eLearning among Canadian anesthesia residents : a survey of podcast use and content needs", BMC Med Educ, 13, pp.59~ (2013)
- Petrovic T, "Podcasting:is it a technology for informal peer learning?", Paper presented at: ASCILITE 2008 (2008)
- Gill P, "Online learning in paediatrics: a student-led web-based learning modality", Clin Teach, 7(1), pp.53~57 (2010)
- Münch-Harrach D, "Audio podcasts in practical courses in biochemistry: cost-efficient e-learning in a well-proven format from radio broadcasting", GMS Z Med Ausbild, 30(4) (2013)
- Lichtenheld A, "Development and implementation of an emergency medicine podcast for medical students:EMIGcast", West J Emerg Med, 16(6), pp.877~878 (2015)
- Jones K, "Dialogue vodcasts: a qualitative assessment", Med Educ, 47(11), pp.1130~1131 (2013)
- Wilson P, "After the gold rush? A systematic and critical review of general medical podcasts", J R Soc Med, 102(2), pp.69~74 (2009)
- White J, "Podcasting: a technology, not a toy", Adv Health Sci Educ Theory Pract, 17(4), pp.601~603 (2012)
- Savel RH, "The iCritical care podcast: a novel medium for critical care communication and education", J Am Med Inform Assoc, 14(1), pp.94~99 (2007)
- Bensalem-Owen M, "Education research: evaluating the use of podcasting for residents during EEG instruction: a pilot study", Neurology, 77(8), pp.e42~e44 (2011)
- Swallow J, "Development of educational podcasts for GPs", Educ Prim Care, 24(3), pp.222~223 (2013)
- Childers RE, "Podcast pearls in residency training", Ann Intern Med, 160(1), pp.70~ (2014)
- Evans DJ, "Using embryology screencasts: a useful addition to the student learning experience?", Anat Sci Educ, 4(2), pp.57~63 (2011)
- Heydarpour P, "Medical podcasting in Iran: pilot, implementation and attitude evaluation", Acta Med Iran, 51(1), pp.59~61 (2013)
- McHugh SM, "A targeted e-learning program for surgical trainees to enhance patient safety in preventing surgical infection", J Contin Educ Health Prof, 30(4), pp.257~259 (2010)
- Moriarity SA, "The Neurology podcast:2007-2012: can you hear me now?", Neurology, 79(10), pp.956~957 (2012)
- Rowell MR, "Internet-based dissemination of educational audiocasts: a primer in podcasting: how to do it", AJR Am J Roentgenol, 186(6), pp.1792~1796 (2006)
- Shantikumar S, "From lecture theatre to portable media : students’ perceptions of an enhanced podcast for revision", Med Teach, 31(6), pp.535~538 (2009)
- Walkinshaw E, "Medical podcasts going viral", CMAJ, 183(14), pp.1577~1578 (2011)
- Alam F, "E-learning optimization : the relative and combined effects of mental practice and modeling on enhanced podcast-based learning-a randomized controlled trial", Adv Health Sci Educ Theory Pract, 21(4), pp.789~802 (2016)
- Alla A, "PodMedPlus: an online podcast resource for junior doctors", Med Educ, 48(11), pp.1126~1127 (2014)
- Bhatti I, "E-learning vs lecture: which is the best approach to surgical teaching?", Colorectal Dis, 13(4), pp.459~462 (2011)
- Florescu CC, "Evaluating didactic methods for training medical students in the use of bedside ultrasound for clinical practice at a faculty of medicine in Romania", J Ultrasound Med, 34(10), pp.1873~1882 (2015)
- Geyer H, "To podcast or not to podcast? Students’ feedback on a different learning experience in histology", Paper presented at: European Conference on E-Learning (2008)
- Kurien G, "Can a multisensory teaching approach impart the necessary knowledge, skills, and confidence in final year medical students to manage epistaxis?", J Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg, 42(1), pp.51~ (2013)
- O’Neill E, "Effectiveness of podcasts as an adjunct learning strategy in teaching clinical microbiology among medical students", J Hosp Infect, 75(1), pp.83~84 (2010)
- Tigges S, "Medical student performance after a vertically integrated radiology clerkship", J Am Coll Radiol, 13(1), pp.67~71 (2016)
- Vasilopoulos T, "Prior podcast experience moderates improvement in electroencephalography evaluation after educational podcast module", Anesth Analg, 121(3), pp.791~797 (2015)
- Lorimer J, "Incorporating learning technologies into undergraduate radiography education", Radiography, 15(3), pp.214~219 (2009)
- Shetty N, "Infectious diseases teaching for medical students: do podcasts work?", Med Teach, 33(7), pp.593~ (2011)
- Quitadamo P, "Do pediatricians apply the 2009 NASPGHAN-ESPGHAN guidelines for the diagnosis and management of gastroesophageal reflux after being trained?", J Pediatr Gastroenterol Nutr, 59(3), pp.356~359 (2014)
- Lin M, "Quality indicators for blogs and podcasts used in medical education: modified Delphi consensus recommendations by an international cohort of health professions educators", Postgrad Med J, 91(1080), pp.546~550 (2015)
- Chan TM, "Examining reliability and validity of an online score(ALiEM AIR)for rating free open access medical education resources", Ann Emerg Med, 68(6), pp.729~735 (2016)
- Chan TM, "Derivation of two critical appraisal scores for trainees to evaluate online educational resources : a METRIQ Study", West J Emerg Med, 17(5), pp.574~584 (2016)
- Graves JC, "Medical sound recording" (1965), The Focal Press
- Cheston CC, "Social media use in medical education : a systematic review", Acad Med, 88(6), pp.893~901 (2013)
- Zanussi L, "Podcasting in medical education: can we turn this toy into an effective learning tool?", Adv Health Sci Educ Theory Pract, 17(4), pp.597~600 (2012)
- Petersen S, "Time for evidence based medical education", BMJ, 318(7193), pp.1223~1224 (1999)
- Archer J, "Without proper research funding, how can medical education be evidence based?", BMJ, 350, pp.h3445~ (2015)