사정변경 원칙의 명문화 방안
Legislative Arrangement on the Principles of the Circumstance Change
0
조회
0
다운로드
26
인용
0
참고문헌
키워드
초록
The principle of the change of circumstance change is a legal principle that permits the change of contract or rescission in the case that the circumstance of contract has been changed unexpectedly, and contents of original contract for both parties are so improper. The principle of circumstance change is being discussed as an applied case of new principle but is not regulated in the statement yet. But both legislative theory and precedent has sanctioned the principle of circumstance change for a long time, differentiating each contents. The amended bill of civil law of 2004 suggested the establishment of the article §544-4 that permits the change or rescission, taking the opinions establishing the principle of circumstance change. But there are many negative opinions about the article §544-4. Therefore, in the case of establishment of the principle of circumstance change, there are many problems to be solved. First, what requisites are needed for the principle of circumstance change has to be prepared. Secondly, what legislative effects will be occurred are expected. Thirdly, how legislative effects will be execute has to be solved. In this paper, first of all, legislative tendencies concerned with the principle of circumstance change are surveyed and then whether the principle of circumstance change being established in an article of civil law is appropriate or not, is considered. This paper also considers the problem that which contents and way are adopted is appropriate.
Abstract
The principle of the change of circumstance change is a legal principle that permits the change of contract or rescission in the case that the circumstance of contract has been changed unexpectedly, and contents of original contract for both parties are so improper. The principle of circumstance change is being discussed as an applied case of new principle but is not regulated in the statement yet. But both legislative theory and precedent has sanctioned the principle of circumstance change for a long time, differentiating each contents. The amended bill of civil law of 2004 suggested the establishment of the article §544-4 that permits the change or rescission, taking the opinions establishing the principle of circumstance change. But there are many negative opinions about the article §544-4. Therefore, in the case of establishment of the principle of circumstance change, there are many problems to be solved. First, what requisites are needed for the principle of circumstance change has to be prepared. Secondly, what legislative effects will be occurred are expected. Thirdly, how legislative effects will be execute has to be solved. In this paper, first of all, legislative tendencies concerned with the principle of circumstance change are surveyed and then whether the principle of circumstance change being established in an article of civil law is appropriate or not, is considered. This paper also considers the problem that which contents and way are adopted is appropriate.
참고문헌 (46)
- 郭潤直, "債權各論" (2005)
- 金疇洙, "債權各論" (1997)
- 金曾漢, "債權各論" (2006)
- 金亨培, "債權各論" (2001)
- 金相容, "債權各論(上)" (1999)
- 백태승, "민법의 쟁점연구(I)" (2007)
- 송덕수, "민법총칙" (2011)
- 양창수, "민법 I (계약법)" (2010)
- 李銀榮, "債權各論" (2007)
- 地元林, "民法講義" (2011)
- 黃迪仁, "現代民法論 IV(債權各論)" (1987)
- "民法注解(XIII) 債權(6)", ~ (1999)
- "註釋民法 債權各則(2)", ~ (1999)
- 民法改正案硏究會, "民法改正案意見書" (2002)
- 법무부, "民法(財産編)改正資料集" (2004)
- 권영준, "위험배분의 관점에서 본 사정변경의 원칙", 민사법학, 51, pp.203~262 (2010), 한국민사법학회
- 김대경, "사정변경으로 인한 계약의 해제", 경희법학, 46(1), pp.195~229 (2011), 법학연구소
- 金大貞, "事情變更의 原則을 명문화한 民法改正試案 제544조의4에 관한 검토", 法學硏究, 22 (2001), 전북대
- 金東勳, "英美契約法에서 事情의 變更과 危險分配의 原則", 人權과 正義, (244) (1996)
- 김용한, "사정변경의 원칙", 사법행정, 12(1) (1971)
- 박규용, "사정변경의 원칙과 행위기초론", 법학연구, (40), pp.85~109 (2010), 한국법학회
- 박수곤, "프랑스채권법개정시안에서의 합의의 효력", 민사법학, 45(2), pp.79~147 (2009), 한국민사법학회
- 안강현, "UNIDROIT 국제상사계약원칙에 있어서의 Hardship", 상사법연구, 21(1), pp.7~221 (2002), 한국상사법학회
- 李英俊, "事情變更의 原則에 關한 硏究 -獨逸의 行爲基礎論을 中心으로", 사법논집, 5 (1974)
- 정상현, "民法改正案 第544條의 4에 대한 批判的 檢討", 성균관법학, 20(1), pp.149~180 (2008), 법학연구소
- 정상현, "賣買目的 土地에 發生한 事情의 變更과 契約의 效力", 저스티스, (104), pp.189~221 (2008), 한국법학원
- 五十嵐 淸, "事情變更の原則の立法をどう考えるか", 民法改正を考える (2008), 法律時報增刊
- 民法(債權法)改正檢討委員會, "債權法改正の基本方針, 別冊 NBL 126호", ~ (2010)
- "民法（債権法）改正検討委員会ホームページ", 全体会議参考資料 (2008)
- von Bar, "Principles, Definitions and Model Rules of European Private Law, Draft Common Frame of Reference(DCFR)", ~ (2009)
- "Bundestagsdrucksache, 14", 6040
- "Bundesminister der Justiz, Abschlußbericht der Kommission zur Überarbeitung des Schuldrechts", ~ (1992)
- "Carbonnier, Droit Civil, t. II", ~ (1957)
- Cartwright, "Proposals for Reform of the Law of Obligations and the Law of Prescription" (2007)
- Catala Pierre, "Avant-projet de réform du droit des obligations et de la prescription" (2006), La documentation Française
- Dauner-Lieb, "Das Neue Schuldrecht", ~ (2002)
- "Esmein, Traité pratique de droit civil français, t. VI, 2e éd", ~ (1952)
- E. Allen Farnsworth, "CONTRACTS, 4th ed" (2004)
- Honnold, "Uniform Law for International Sales Under the 1980 United Nations Convention", ~ (1980)
- Horn, "Vertragsdauer, in Gutachten und Vorschläge zur Überarbeitung des Schuldrechts, Bd. Ⅰ", ~ (1981)
- Huber, "Leistungsstörungen, in Gutachten und Vorschläge zur Überarbeitung des Schuldrechts" (1981)
- Kegel, "Empfiehlt es sich, den Einfluß grundlegender Veränderungen des Wirtschaftslebens auf Vertrag gesetzlich zu regeln und in welchem Sinn?, Verhandlungen des 40. Deutschen Juristentages, Bd. I", ~ (1953)
- Lando, "The Principles of European Contract Law, Part I & Ⅱ" (2000)
- Larenz, "Geschäftsgrundlage und Vertragserfüllung, 3. Aufl" (1963)
- Oertmann, "Die Geschäftsgrundlage" (1921)
- UNIDROIT, "UNIDROIT Principles of International Commercial Contracts", ~ (2004)