Understanding Results-based Conditionality in Development Cooperation: A Comparative Case Analysis
0
조회
0
다운로드
0
인용
0
참고문헌
키워드
초록
Growing concerns over aid effectiveness in recent years have changed views around the aid contract, in part the role of aid conditionality and its perceived limits. This research seeks answers to questions on how results-based conditionality has been applied by exploring the multiple results-based aid programs through a case study from a comparative perspective. By investigating theoretical background on conditionality and reviewing recent discussions on results-based conditionality, this paper proposes a conceptual framework to discover key elements of results-based conditionality and to analyze them to see how the new approach may affect the process and result of aid delivery in comparison with traditional conditionality. The case analysis shows that results-based approach shifts the focus of aid by altering and strengthening the nature of incentives from various aspects of non-financial incentives, selectivity, payment, performance management, and sustainability with varying degrees. The paper concludes with challenges and limitations of results-based approach.
Abstract
Growing concerns over aid effectiveness in recent years have changed views around the aid contract, in part the role of aid conditionality and its perceived limits. This research seeks answers to questions on how results-based conditionality has been applied by exploring the multiple results-based aid programs through a case study from a comparative perspective. By investigating theoretical background on conditionality and reviewing recent discussions on results-based conditionality, this paper proposes a conceptual framework to discover key elements of results-based conditionality and to analyze them to see how the new approach may affect the process and result of aid delivery in comparison with traditional conditionality. The case analysis shows that results-based approach shifts the focus of aid by altering and strengthening the nature of incentives from various aspects of non-financial incentives, selectivity, payment, performance management, and sustainability with varying degrees. The paper concludes with challenges and limitations of results-based approach.
참고문헌 (43)
- "About Gavi, the Vaccine Alliance" (2015)[URL]
- Birdsall, N., "Cash on delivery: a new approach to foreign aid" (2012), CGD Books
- "Second Gavi Evaluation" (2010)[URL]
- Evaluation of the First Five Years of Gavi Immunization Services Support Funding, "Chee, G.", Abt Associates Inc, ~ (2007)
- A Comparison of The Global Fund and The Gavi Alliance with Emphasis on Health System Strengthening, "Chinedu, A.", Bill & Melinda Gates Foundation, ~ (2009)
- Sharpening incentives to perform: DFID’s Strategy for Payment by Results, "DFID(Department for International Development)", ~ (2014)
- DFID(Department for International Development), "Draft Operational Guidance for Payment By Results", ~ (2013)
- Partnerships for poverty reduction : rethinking conditionality, "DFID(Department for International Development)", ~ (2005)
- De Renzio, P., "The Trouble with Cash on Delivery Aid: A note on its potential effects on recipient country institutions", Note prepared for CGD initiative on cash on delivery (2008)
- The Policy Implications of Evolving Aid Modalities, "Dodsworth, S.", ~ (2012)
- Dollar, D., "What explains the success or failure of structural adjustment programmes?", The Economic Journal, 110, pp.894~917 (2000)
- Easterly, W., "Was development assistance a mistake?", American Economic Review, 97, pp.328~332 (2007)
- Easterly, W., "What did structural adjustment adjust? : The association of policies and growth with repeated IMF and World Bank adjustment loans", Journal of Development Economics, 76, pp.1~22 (2005)
- "Uncovering the Politics of “Evidence” and “Results”. A framing paper for development practitioners" (2013)[URL]
- "Gavi Immunization Service Support"[URL]
- "Gavi IRC Review Criteria for 2016", Gavi, ~ (2016)
- "Gavi Alliance Country Eligibility Policy", Gavi, ~ (2009)
- Should the MCC Provide Financing Through Recipient Country’s Budgets?, "Herrling, S.", Center for Global Development, ~ (2006)
- Kanbur, R., "Handbook of the Economics of Giving, Altruism and Reciprocity 2", pp.1559~1588 (2006)
- Kanbur, R., "Aid, conditionality and debt in Africa", African Journal of International Affairs and Development, 5, pp.1~15 (2000)
- Killick, T., "Principals, agents and the failings of conditionality", Journal of International Development, 9, pp.483~495 (1997)
- Results-Based Aid (RBA): New Aid Approaches, Limitations and the Application to Promote Good Governance, "Klingebiel, S.", German Development Institute, ~ (2012)
- Conditionality Revisited: Concepts, Experiences, and Lessons Learned, "Koeberle, S.", The World Bank, ~ (2005)
- Lim, S. S., "Tracking progress to-wards universal childhood immunisation and the impact of global initiatives : a systematic analysis of three-dose diphtheria, tetanus, and pertussis immunisation coverage", The Lancet, 372(9655), pp.2031~2046 (2008)
- Lucas, S. T., "MCC Principles into Practice Country Ownership", ~ (2011)
- Millennium Challenge Corporation, "Guide to the MCC Indicators and the Selection Process for Fiscal Year 2016", ~ (2015)
- Millennium Challenge Corporation, "Guide to the MCC Indicators and the Selection Process for Fiscal Year 2014", ~ (2013)
- MCC Policy for Monitoring and Evaluation of Compacts and Threshold Programs, "Millennium Challenge Corporation", ~ (2012)
- Morrissey, O., "Conditionality and Aid Effectiveness Re-evaluated", The World Economy, 27, pp.153~171 (2004)
- Mosley, P., "Aid and power: the World Bank and policy-based lending. Volume 1: analysis and policy proposals" (1995), Routledge
- Ostrom, E., "Aid, Incentives, and Sustainability" (2001), Sida
- Results based aid and results based financing: What are they? Have they delivered results?, "Pearson, M.", HLSP Institute, ~ (2011)
- Does Results-Based Aid Change Anything? Pecuniary Interests, Attention, Accountability and Discretion in Four Case Studies, "Perakis, R.", CGD, ~, pp.CGD Policy Paper, 52 (2015)
- On fast-disbursing policy-based loans, "Ranis, G.", Economics Department, Yale University, ~ (1995)
- Scholl, A., "Aid effectiveness and limited enforceable conditionality", Review of Economic Dynamics, pp.377~391 (2009)
- Notes on Case Studies of Instructional Media Projects, "Schramm, W.", Academy for Educational Development, ~ (1971)
- "Study: Nations inflate vaccine numbers to get more aid" (2008)[URL]
- Svensson, J., "When is foreign aid policy credible? Aid dependence and conditionality", Journal of Development Economics, 61, pp.61~84 (2000)
- Evaluation of Results Based Aid in Rwandan Education-2013 Evaluation Report, "Upper Quartile", Institute of Policy Analysis and Research Rwanda, ~ (2014)
- Review: results based management in development cooperation, "Vähämäki, J.", Riksbankens Jubileumsfond, ~ (2011)
- Williamson, C. R., "Exploring the failure of foreign aid : The role of incentives and information", The Review of Austrian Economics, 23, pp.17~33 (2010)
- Wood, A., "The “Perestroika of Aid”? New Perspectives on Conditionality", ~ (1999)
- Yin, R. K., "Case study research: Design and methods (Vol. 5)" (2009), Sage
