배상 규정의 법률유보 관점에서 환경과언론 ADR 비교
Comparative Evaluation between Environmental and Media ADR in terms of Legal Reservation of Compensation Clause
0
조회
0
다운로드
0
인용
0
참고문헌
키워드
초록
Media ADR is currently emerging as one of successful cases in South Korea while environmental ADR was known not to satisfy both defendants and offenders. Thus, this paper is intended to present proper remedies for typical compensation schemes of environmental ADR by comparing the two ADRs regarding legal reservation of compensation clause. It was found that the media ADR helped clients achieve a more fast and easy dispute resolution by providing compensation standards based on various categories such as types and scopes of compensation. However, the compensation scheme of environmental ADR brought out public complaints and inadequate services due to inconsistency and instability in terms of legal reservation. The results indicate that the compensation clause based on the reservation of laws in media ADR could be used not only as a checklist to confirm limitations of environmental ADR, but also as realistic evidences to adjust the compensation standard systematically that is under development and requires remodelling. As a result, the research findings have opened the new possibilities of "the quality assurance of environmental ADR based on the domestic legislation", proposed as an initial aim of this paper.
Abstract
Media ADR is currently emerging as one of successful cases in South Korea while environmental ADR was known not to satisfy both defendants and offenders. Thus, this paper is intended to present proper remedies for typical compensation schemes of environmental ADR by comparing the two ADRs regarding legal reservation of compensation clause. It was found that the media ADR helped clients achieve a more fast and easy dispute resolution by providing compensation standards based on various categories such as types and scopes of compensation. However, the compensation scheme of environmental ADR brought out public complaints and inadequate services due to inconsistency and instability in terms of legal reservation. The results indicate that the compensation clause based on the reservation of laws in media ADR could be used not only as a checklist to confirm limitations of environmental ADR, but also as realistic evidences to adjust the compensation standard systematically that is under development and requires remodelling. As a result, the research findings have opened the new possibilities of "the quality assurance of environmental ADR based on the domestic legislation", proposed as an initial aim of this paper.
참고문헌 (24)
- 강재규, "환경분쟁과 중재제도", 중재연구, 15(2), pp.163~196 (2005), 한국중재학회
- 강정혜, "대체적 분쟁해결제도(ADR)로서의 환경분쟁조정과 환경소송", 환경법연구, 30(3), pp.185~204 (2008), 한국환경법학회
- 김상찬, "ADR에 의한 건설분쟁해결의 문제점과 개선방안", 중재연구, 21(1), pp.87~108 (2011), 한국중재학회
- 金泓均, "환경행정소송과 공법상 구제의 확대", 인권과 정의, 321, pp.7~ (2003), 대한변호사협회
- 박영세, "환경분쟁의 소송 대체적 해결기제(ADR)에 관한 연구: 한일 환경분쟁 조정제도를 중심으로", 지방정부연구, 11(1), pp.249~271 (2007), 한국지방정부학회
- 박태현, "환경분쟁조정제도의 선진화를 위한 법적 과제", 환경법연구, 30(3), pp.161~183 (2008), 한국환경법학회
- 양경승, "언론중재제도의 법제사적 의미", 언론중재 (2001), 언론중재위원회
- 양삼승, "언론피해구제법(가칭) 제정을 위한 입법론적 방안", 언론중재위원회 주최, 언론관련 법률쟁점과 개선방안, 세미나, pp.23~25 (2000)
- 언론중재위원회, , 보도자료, ~ (2007)
- 2009년도 언론중재위원회 이용만족도조사 보고서, "언론중재위원회", ~ (2009)
- 언론중재위원회, "조정중재 ․시정권고사례집", ~ (2009)
- 이재진, "언론중재 제도의 조정전치 기능에 대한 재고찰: 소송에 갈음하는 분쟁해결방안(ADR)의 효율성 관점에서", 한국언론학보, 48(2), pp.267~293 (2004), 한국언론학회
- 장호순, "최근의 언론보도 피해양상과 구제현황", 언론중재위원회 주최, ‘정간법 개정과 언론피해구제제도의 개선방향’ 세미나 (2003)
- 전경운, "환경침해로 인한 위법성판단과 환경정책기본법 제31조의 효력", 민사법학, (22) (2002), 한국민사법학회
- 정남철, "환경소송과 인인보호", 환경법연구, 28(1), pp.239~268 (2006), 한국환경법학회
- 환경분쟁조정 기능 강화 등 중장기 발전방향 연구, "중앙환경분쟁조정위원회", ~ (2006)
- 환경분쟁조정제도에 대한 인지도 조사, "중앙환경분쟁조정위원회", (주) 월드리서치, ~ (2008)
- 중앙환경분쟁조정위원회, "환경분쟁조정사례집", ~ (2005)
- 최병록, "우리나라 환경분쟁조정제도의 현황과 발전방안", 환경법연구, 29(2), pp.497~532 (2007), 한국환경법학회
- 함인선, "환경피해에 대한 공법적 구제", 환경법연구, 28(3), pp.59~98 (2006), 한국환경법학회
- 홍준형, "환경분쟁 재정절차 배상액 현실화 방안 - 공사장 소음ㆍ진동으로 인한 정신적 피해를 중심으로 -", 환경법연구, 33(1), pp.3~39 (2011), 한국환경법학회
- 홍정선, "행정법원론(상)" (2008), 박영사
- Stephen M. Johnson, "Economic v. Equity: Do Market-Based Environmental Reforms Exacerbate", Wash. & Lee L. Rev, 56, pp.111~ (1999)
- Stephen K. Huber, "International ADR in the 1990's: The Top Ten. Developments” Houston Business", Tax Law Journal (2001)