Application of data driven modeling and sensitivity analysis of constitutive equations for improving nuclear power plant safety analysis code
0
조회
0
다운로드
2
인용
0
참고문헌
키워드
초록
Constitutive equations in a nuclear reactor safety analysis code are mostly empirical correlations developed from experiments, which always accompany uncertainties. The accuracy of the code can be improved by modifying the constitutive equations fitting wider range of data with less uncertainty. Thus, the sensitivity of the code with respect to the constitutive equations is evaluated quantitatively in the paper to understand the room for improvement of the code. A new methodology is proposed which first starts by dividing the thermal hydraulic conditions into multiple sub-regimes using self-organizing map (SOM) clustering method. The sensitivity analysis is then conducted by multiplying an arbitrary set of coefficients to the constitutive equations for each sub-divided thermal-hydraulic regime with SOM to observe how the code accuracy varies. The randomly chosen multiplier coefficient represents the uncertainty of the constitutive equations. Furthermore, the set with the smallest error with the selected experimental data can be obtained and can provide insight which direction should the constitutive equations be modified to improve the code accuracy. The newly proposed method is applied to a steadystate experiment and a transient experiment to illustrate how the method can provide insight to the code developer.
Abstract
Constitutive equations in a nuclear reactor safety analysis code are mostly empirical correlations developed from experiments, which always accompany uncertainties. The accuracy of the code can be improved by modifying the constitutive equations fitting wider range of data with less uncertainty. Thus, the sensitivity of the code with respect to the constitutive equations is evaluated quantitatively in the paper to understand the room for improvement of the code. A new methodology is proposed which first starts by dividing the thermal hydraulic conditions into multiple sub-regimes using self-organizing map (SOM) clustering method. The sensitivity analysis is then conducted by multiplying an arbitrary set of coefficients to the constitutive equations for each sub-divided thermal-hydraulic regime with SOM to observe how the code accuracy varies. The randomly chosen multiplier coefficient represents the uncertainty of the constitutive equations. Furthermore, the set with the smallest error with the selected experimental data can be obtained and can provide insight which direction should the constitutive equations be modified to improve the code accuracy. The newly proposed method is applied to a steadystate experiment and a transient experiment to illustrate how the method can provide insight to the code developer.
참고문헌 (33)
- MARS CODE MANUAL Vol. 1 Code Structure, System Models, and Solution Methods, "KAERI", ~ (2009)
- D. Bestion, "System Code Models and Capabilities", THICKET, Session III (2008)
- Summary of Important Results and SCDAP, "RELAP5 Analyses for OECD LOFT Experiment LP-FP2", E.W. Coryell, 1994, NUREG[DOI]
- 김연식, "Second ATLAS Domestic Standard Problem (DSP-02) for a Code Assessment", Nuclear Engineering and Technology, 45(7), pp.871~894 (2013), 한국원자력학회
- K. H. Kang, "Code assessment of ATLAS integral effect test simulating main steam-line break accident of an advanced pressurized water reactor", Journal of Nuclear Science and Technology, 55(Issue 1), pp.104~112 (2018)
- Y. S. Park, "Open calculation result of DSP-05 activity utilizing ATLAS test facility with multiple steam generator tube rupture under PAFS operation scenario", Transactions of the Korean Nuclear Society Virtual Spring Meeting (2020)
- International Standard Problem No. 20, Steam Generator Tube Rupture in the Nuclear Power Plant DOEL 2, "E. Stubbe", ~, pp.CSNI Report No. 154 (1988)
- 최기용, "A SUMMARY OF 50th OECD", NEA, Nuclear Engineering and Technology, pp.2012, 44(6)[DOI]
- 김연식, "FIRST ATLAS DOMESTIC STANDARD PROBLEM (DSP-01)FOR THE CODE ASSESSMENT", Nuclear Engineering and Technology, 43(1), pp.25~44 (2011), 한국원자력학회
- J. Malet, "OECD international standard problem ISP-47 on containment thermal-hydraulicseconclusions of the TOSQAN part", Nuclear Engineering and Design, 240(Issue 10), pp.3209~3220 (2010)
- ISP-42 Description of the PANDA-Facility, "D. Lübbesmeyer", ~, pp.TM-42-98-41ALPHA-836-0 (1998)
- International Standard Problem No. 38, BETHSY Test 6,9c: Loss of Residual Heat Removal System during Mid-loop Operation, Final Comparison Report, "Kimber George", ~, pp.NEA (1998), CSNI[DOI]
- ISP-33, OECD, "NEA-CSNI International Standard Problem No. 33, PACTEL Natural Circulation Stepwise Coolant Inventory Reduction Experiment, Comparison Report, I", H. Purhonen, 1994, NEA[DOI]
- CSNI: International, Standard Problems (ISP), Brief Descriptions (1975-1999), , ~, pp.NEA (2000), CSNI[DOI]
- User Effects on the Transient System Code Calculations, "S. N. Aksan", NEA, R, pp.1994, ~[DOI]
- J.J. Lee, "Node configuration uncertainty in nuclear safety analyses", Nuclear Engineering and Design, 355(Issue 15), pp.110286~ (2019)
- Comparison Report of Open Calculations for ATLAS Domestic Standard Problem (DSP-01), "K. Y. Choi", Korea Atomic Energy Research Institute, ~, pp.KAERI (2010), TR-4073[DOI]
- J. Heo, "PAPIRUS, a parallel computing framework for sensitivity analysis, uncertainty propagation, and estimation of parameter distribution", Nuclear Engineering and Design, 292, pp.237~247 (2015)
- C. H. Ban, "Development and application of KEPRI realistic evaluation methodology (KREM) for LB-LOCA", Best Estimate-2004: Proceedings of International Meeting on Updates in Best Estimate Methods in Nuclear Installations Safety Analysis (2004)
- B. J. Yun, "Characteristics of the local bubble parameters of a subcooled boiling flow in an annulus", Nuclear Engineering and Design, 240(Issue 9), pp.2295~2303 (2010)
- S. N. Kim, "PWR pressurizer modeling", Nuclear Engineering and Design, 102(Issue 2), pp.199~209 (1987)
- T. Kohonen, "The self-organizing map", Neurocomputing, 21(Issue 1), pp.1~6 (1998)
- J. Vesanto, "Clustering of the self-organizing map", IEEE Transaction on Neural Networks, 11(3), pp.586~600 (2000)
- J. MacQueen, "Some methods for classification and analysis of multivariate observations", Proceedings of 5th Berkeley Symposium on Mathematical Statistics and Probability, pp.281~297 (1967), University of California Press
- Clustering Indices, "B. Desgraupes", University of Paris Ouest-Lab Modal’X, ~ (2013)
- P. J. Rousseeuw, "Silhouettes : a graphical aid to the interpretation and validation of cluster Analysis", Journal of Computational and Applied Mathematics, 20, pp.53~65 (1987)
- R. Tibshirani, "Estimating the number of clusters in a data set via the gap statistic", Journal of Royal Statistical Society : Series B(Statistical Methodology), 63(Issue 2), pp.411~423 (2001)
- M. D. McKay, "A comparison of three methods for selecting values of input variables in the analysis of output from a computer code", Technometrics, 21(Issue 2), pp.239~245 (1979)
- D.H. Kim, "Optimization of liquid interfacial heat transfer coefficient of MARS-KS code to match SUBO data", Transactions of the Korean Nuclear Society Virtual Spring Meeting (2020)
- W. Ambrosini, "Evaluation of accuracy of thermal hydraulic code calculation", Energia Nucleare, 7(Issue 2), pp.5~16 (1990)
- E. Keogh, "Exact indexing of dynamic time warping", Knowledge and Information Systems, 7(Issue 3), pp.358~386 (2005)
- Eamonn Keogh, "Segmenting time series : a survey and novel approach", Data Mining in Time Series Databases, 57, pp.1~21 (2004)
- Jessica Lin, "Experiencing SAX : a novel symbolic representation of time series", Data Mining and Knowledge Discovery, 15, pp.107~114 (2007)