본문 바로가기
KERD
논문KCI 등재

Neutronic optimization of thorium-based fuel configurations for minimizing slightly used nuclear fuel and radiotoxicity in small modular reactors

Ismail Aznan Fazli|Kamarudin Nur Anis Zulaikha|Rabir Mohamad Hairie|Kok Siong Khoo
한국원자력학회 (Korean Nuclear Society)|2024.07|Nuclear Engineering and Technology|제56권 제7호|pp. 2641-2649|DOI 10.1016/j.net.2024.02.023

2

조회

0

다운로드

0

인용

0

참고문헌

키워드

Small modular reactors (SMRs)Thorium-based fuelNeutronic performanceFission product inventory
주제분류원자력공학

초록

Effective management of slightly used nuclear fuel (SUNF) is crucial for both technical and public acceptance reasons. SUNF management, radiotoxicity risk, and associated financial investment and technological capabilities are major concerns in nuclear power production. Reducing the volume of SUNF can simplify its management, and one possible solution is utilizing small modular reactors (SMR) and advanced fuel designs like those with thorium. This research focuses on studying the neutronic performance and radionuclide inventory of three different thorium fuel configurations. The mass of fissile material in thorium-based fuel significantly impacts Kinf, burn-up, and neutron energy spectrum. Compared to uranium, thorium as a fuel produces far fewer transuranic elements and less long-lived fission products (LLFPs) at the end of the core cycle (EOC). However, certain fission product elements produced from thorium-based fuel exhibit higher radioactivity at the beginning of the core cycle (BOC). Physical separation of thorium and uranium in the fuel block, like seed-and-blanket units (SBU) and duplex fuel designs, generate less radioactive waste with lower radioactivity and longer cycle lengths than homogeneous or mixed thorium-uranium fuel. Furthermore, the SBU and duplex feel designs exhibit comparable neutron spectra, leading to negligible differences in SUNF production between the two.

Abstract

Effective management of slightly used nuclear fuel (SUNF) is crucial for both technical and public acceptance reasons. SUNF management, radiotoxicity risk, and associated financial investment and technological capabilities are major concerns in nuclear power production. Reducing the volume of SUNF can simplify its management, and one possible solution is utilizing small modular reactors (SMR) and advanced fuel designs like those with thorium. This research focuses on studying the neutronic performance and radionuclide inventory of three different thorium fuel configurations. The mass of fissile material in thorium-based fuel significantly impacts Kinf, burn-up, and neutron energy spectrum. Compared to uranium, thorium as a fuel produces far fewer transuranic elements and less long-lived fission products (LLFPs) at the end of the core cycle (EOC). However, certain fission product elements produced from thorium-based fuel exhibit higher radioactivity at the beginning of the core cycle (BOC). Physical separation of thorium and uranium in the fuel block, like seed-and-blanket units (SBU) and duplex fuel designs, generate less radioactive waste with lower radioactivity and longer cycle lengths than homogeneous or mixed thorium-uranium fuel. Furthermore, the SBU and duplex feel designs exhibit comparable neutron spectra, leading to negligible differences in SUNF production between the two.

참고문헌 (61)

  1. E. S. Aziman, "Remediation of thorium(IV)from wastewater : current status and way forward", Separ. Purif. Rev, 50(2), pp.177~202 (2021)
  2. Uranium 2022: resources, production and demand AGENCY, "NEA", Oecd, 12~13 (2023)
  3. Introduction of thorium in the nuclear fuel cycle Short-to long-term considerations, "Nuclear Energy Agency", Nuclear Energy Agency, 133~ (2015)
  4. M. H. Rabir, "Neutronics calculation of the conceptual TRISO duplex fuel rod design", Nuclear Materials and Energy, 27 (2021)
  5. C. N. A. Che Zainul Bahri, "Synthesis of thorium tetrafluoride(ThF 4)by ammonium hydrogen difluoride(NH 4 HF 2)", Nucl. Eng. Technol, 51(3), pp.792~799 (2019)
  6. M. H. Rabir, "Review of the microheterogeneous thoriaurania fuel for micro-sized high temperature reactors", Int. J. Energy Res, 45(8), pp.11440~11458 (2021)
  7. A. F. Ismail, "Investigation of activated carbon adsorbent electrode for electrosorption-based uranium extraction from seawater", Nucl. Eng. Technol, 47(5), pp.579~587 (2015)
  8. X. Xu, "Ultrahigh and economical uranium extraction from seawater : via interconnected open-pore architecture poly(amidoxime)fiber", J. Mater. Chem. A, 8(42), pp.22032~22044 (2020)
  9. M. B. Schaffer, "Abundant thorium as an alternative nuclear fuel Important waste disposal and weapon proliferation advantages", Energy Pol, 60, pp.4~12 (2013)
  10. Edwin H. Uguru, "Burn-up calculation of the neutronic and safety parameters of thorium-uranium mixed oxide fuel cycle in a Westinghouse small modular reactor", Int. J. Energy Res, 45(8), pp.12013~12028 (2021)
  11. Edwin Humphrey Uguru, "Investigation on the effect of 238U replacement with 232Th in small modular reactor(SMR)fuel matrix", Prog. Nucl. Energy, 118, pp.103108~ (2020)
  12. B. Zohuri, "Nuclear Reactor Technology Development and Utilization" (2020), Elsevier Ltd
  13. C. García, "Evaluation of uranium thorium and plutonium thorium fuel cycles in a very high temperature hybrid system", Prog. Nucl. Energy, 66, pp.61~72 (2013)
  14. S. M. Mirvakili, "Comparison of neutronic behavior of UO 2 , (Th- 233 U)O 2 and (Th- 235 U)O 2 fuels in a typical heavy water reactor", Nucl. Eng. Technol, 47(3), pp.315~322 (2015)
  15. C. Qiu, "Multiphysics analysis of thorium-based fuel performance with a two-layer SiC cladding under normal operating and transient conditions in a light water reactor", Ann. Nucl. Energy, 163, pp.108543~ (2021)
  16. C. Dugal, "Modeling and mitigation of bundle end power peaking in pressure tube heavy water reactor advanced fuels using thorium dioxide", Ann. Nucl. Energy, 120, pp.625~629 (2018)
  17. B. M. Elsheikh, "ScienceDirect Safety assessment of molten salt reactors in comparison with light water reactors", Journal of Radiation Research and Applied Sciences, 6(2), pp.63~70 (2013)
  18. G. Zheng, "Thorium-based molten salt SMR as the nuclear technology pathway from a market-oriented perspective", Ann. Nucl. Energy, 116, pp.177~186 (2018)
  19. C. Zou, "Transition to thorium fuel cycle in a small modular molten salt reactor based on a batch reprocessing mode", Ann. Nucl. Energy, 138, pp.107163~ (2020)
  20. M. A. Alzamly, "Burnup analysis for HTR-10 reactor core loaded with uranium and thorium oxide", Nucl. Eng. Technol, 52(4), pp.674~680 (2020)
  21. M. H. Rabir, "A neutronic investigation of tristructural isotropic-duplex fuel in a high-temperature reactor prismatic seed-and-blanket fuel block configuration with reduced power peaking", Int. J. Energy Res, 45(13), pp.19265~19288 (2021)
  22. H. J. Rütten, "Research on the incineration of plutonium in a modular HTR using thorium-based fuel", Nucl. Eng. Des, 195(3), pp.353~360 (2000)
  23. N. R. Brown, "High volume packing fraction TRISObased fuel in light water reactors", Prog. Nucl. Energy, 146, pp.1~17 (2022)
  24. G. Zhu, "Uranium utilization with thorium blanket in Pebble Bed Fluoride salt-cooled high temperature reactor", Prog. Nucl. Energy, 83, pp.374~386 (2015)
  25. H. Chang, "Thorium-based fuel cycles in the modular high temperature reactor", Tsinghua Sci. Technol, 11(6), pp.731~738 (2006)
  26. A. A. Galahom, "Reducing the plutonium stockpile around the world using a new design of VVER-1200 assembly", Ann. Nucl. Energy, 119, pp.279~286 (2018)
  27. A. A. Galahom, "Examine the possibility of increasing the plutonium incineration rate in the current operating pressurized water reactor", Prog. Nucl. Energy, 142, pp.104026~ (2021)
  28. Ming Ding, "Thorium utilization in a small long-life HTR. Part II : seed-and-blanket fuel blocks", Nucl. Eng. Des, 267, pp.245~252 (2014)
  29. A. A. Galahom, "Minimization of the fission product waste by using thorium based fuel instead of uranium dioxide", Nucl. Eng. Des, 314, pp.165~172 (2017)
  30. A. V. Colton, "Lattice physics evaluation of 35-element mixed oxide thorium-based fuels for use in pressure tube heavy water reactors", Ann. Nucl. Energy, 117, pp.259~276 (2018)
  31. S. Atkinson, "Small modular high temperature reactor optimisation – Part 1 : a comparison between beryllium oxide and nuclear graphite in a small scale high temperature reactor", Prog. Nucl. Energy, 111, pp.223~232 (2019)
  32. M. Ding, "Parametric neutronics design of a small and long-life HTR", Proceedings of HTR, 9 (2010)
  33. Ming Ding, "Thorium utilization in a small long-life HTR. Part I:Th", U MOX fuel blocks, 2014, pp.267, 238~244
  34. J. Verrue, "Thorium utilisation in a small long-life HTR. Part III : composite-rod fuel blocks", Nucl. Eng. Des, 267, pp.253~262 (2014)
  35. M. H. Rabir, "The neutronics effect of TRISO duplex fuel packing fractions and their comparison with homogeneous thorium-uranium fuel", Int. J. Energy Res, 46(13), pp.19072~19089 (2022)
  36. M. H. Rabir, "A micro-sized high-temperature thorium reactor with Duplex TRISO fuel with enhanced thorium utilization compared to the SBU configuration", Fuel, 354, pp.129316~ (2023)
  37. J. Frybort, "Comparison of the radiological hazard of thorium and uranium spent fuels from VVER-1000 reactor", Radiat. Phys. Chem, 104, pp.408~413 (2014)
  38. U. E. Humphrey, "Viability of thorium-based nuclear fuel cycle for the next generation nuclear reactor : issues and prospects", Renew. Sustain. Energy Rev, 97, pp.259~275 (2018)
  39. B. S. Van Gosen, "Uranium for Nuclear Power: Resources, Mining and Transformation to Fuel (Iv)", pp.253~296 (2016)
  40. M. J. B. Kabeyi, "Sustainable energy transition for renewable and low carbon grid electricity generation and supply", Front. Energy Res, 9, pp.1~45 (2022)
  41. L. Carlson, "Implications of HALEU fuel on the design of SMRs and micro-reactors", Nucl. Eng. Des, 389, pp.111648~ (2022)
  42. D. T. Wojtaszek, "Reactor physics assessment of annular plutoniumthorium fuels for use in prismatic fuel blocks in a HTGR-SMR with a hydrogenbased moderator", International Conference on Mathematics and Computational Methods Applied to Nuclear Science and Engineering M&C 2023 (2023)
  43. M. Grodzki, "Monte Carlo analysis of the battery-type high temperature gas cooled reactor", Arch. Therm, 38(4), pp.209~227 (2017)
  44. A. S. Gerasimov, "Comparison of decay heat power of uranium, plutonium, and thorium spent fuel at long-term storage", International Conference on Nuclear Engineering, Proceedings, ICONE 4(SMiRT 18), pp.481~484 (2002)
  45. A. A. Hassan, "Investigation of using U-233 in thorium base instead of conventional fuel in Russian PWR by SERPENT Code", J. Phys. Conf, 1689(1) (2020)
  46. Sergei V. Beliavskii, "Effect of fuel nuclide composition on the fuel lifetime of reactor KLT-40S", Nucl. Eng. Des, 360, pp.110524~ (2020)
  47. A. A. Galahom, "Explore the possible advantages of using thorium-based fuel in a pressurized water reactor(PWR)Part 1 : neutronic analysis", Nucl. Eng. Technol, 54(1), pp.1~10 (2022)
  48. N. R. Brown, "Impact of thermal spectrum small modular reactors on performance of once-through nuclear fuel cycles with low-enriched uranium", Ann. Nucl. Energy, 101, pp.166~173 (2017)
  49. E. Shwageraus, "Microheterogeneous thoria-urania fuels for pressurized water reactors", Nucl. Technol, 147(1), pp.20~36 (2004)
  50. H. C. Lee, "A neutronic feasibility study on a small LEU fueled reactor for space applications", Ann. Nucl. Energy, 77, pp.35~46 (2015)
  51. X. Zhao, "A PWR thorium pin cell burnup benchmark", Proceedings of the PHYSOR 2000 - ANS International Topical Meeting on Advances in Reactor Physics and Mathematics and Computation into the Next Millennium, pp.1~14 (2000)
  52. J. Li, "Neutronic characteristics and feasibility analysis of microheterogeneous duplex ThO2-UO2 fuel pin in PWR", Nucl. Eng. Des, 382, pp.111382~ (2021)
  53. H. B. van der Walt, "Implementation of in-rod axially heterogeneous thorium-uranium fuel in a typical PWR", Nucl. Eng. Des, 408, pp.112319~ (2023)
  54. N. Kodochigov, "Neutronic features of the GT-MHR reactor", Nucl. Eng. Des, 222(2–3 SPEC), pp.161~171 (2003)
  55. S. Beliavskii, "Effect of fuel nuclide composition on the fuel lifetime of the RITM-200 reactor unit", Ann. Nucl. Energy, 173, pp.109105~ (2022)
  56. F. El Banni, "Neutronic feasibility study of(Th-233U)-ZrH1. 65 fuel in a modelled TRIGA research reactor", J. King Saud Univ. Sci, 34(2), pp.101769~ (2022)
  57. Fission Energy Release for 16 Fissioning Nuclides, Electric Power Research Institute (Report), "C. B. R Sher", EPRI, ~, pp.NP, 1771 (1981)
  58. A. G. Croff, "Comparative assessment of thorium fuel cycle radiotoxicity", Nucl. Technol, 194(2), pp.271~280 (2016)
  59. D. Raj, "Operational characteristics of LWR core fuelled with thoriumbased fuel", Ann. Nucl. Energy, 188, pp.109801~ (2023)
  60. Michael Todosow, "Use of thorium in light water reactors", Nucl. Technol, 151(2), pp.168~176 (2005)
  61. C. J. Jeong, "Dynamic analysis of a thorium fuel cycle in CANDU reactors", Ann. Nucl. Energy, 35(10), pp.1842~1848 (2008)

관련 논문AI추천

Searching for an optimal fuel for a supercritical water reactor (SCWR) to dispose of minor actinides resulting from the nuclear wasteAlanazi Sitah, Al-Aqeel Muneerah, Algarawi Maha, Alnassar Nassar, Galahom A. Abdelghafar, Khaliil Ahmed Salah한국원자력학회 · Nuclear Engineering and Technology2025 · 제57권 제2호Nuclear waste attributes of near-term deployable small modular reactorsBoing L., Dixon B., Kim Taek K.한국원자력학회 · Nuclear Engineering and Technology2024 · 제56권 제3호Searching for the viability of using thorium-based accident-tolerant fuel for VVER-1200Abdel-Rahman Mohamed A.E., Alnassar Nassar, Galahom A. Abdelghafar, Mohsen Mohamed Y.M., Omar Ahmed한국원자력학회 · Nuclear Engineering and Technology2024 · 제56권 제1호Burnup dynamics and reactivity change in proton induced Tc-99 transmutation fuel assembly김영인, Chang M. Kang한국원자력학회 · Nuclear Engineering and Technology2025 · 제57권 제7호Searching for incinerating the accumulated plutonium around the world by mixing it with thorium and using this mixture as a nuclear fuel in the CANDU-6Alnassar Nassar, Galahom A. Abdelghafar, Ibrahim Amr한국원자력학회 · Nuclear Engineering and Technology2025 · 제57권 제1호A core physics design and analysis of micro-modular lead cooled fast reactor (MMLFR) cores for autonomous ultra-long-life operation이승남, 홍서기한국원자력학회 · Nuclear Engineering and Technology2025 · 제57권 제12호

이 간행물의 다른 논문 (49건)

Experimental study of the radiation shielding characteristics of new PbO– Na2O–B2O3–BaO glassesSayyed M.I., Elsafi Mohamed, Rilwan U., Mahmoud K.A.pp. 2437-2443Advanced radiation shielding materials: PbO2-doped zirconia ceramics synthesized through innovative sol-gel methodAljaafreh Mamduh. J., Alanazi Sitah, Alhindawy Islam G., Marashdeh Mohammad. W., Mahmoud K., Al-Hmoud Mohannadpp. 2444-2451Assessment of soil density and distribution coefficient of Cs-137 for deriving DCGLs in korea research reactor unit 1 and 2김광표, 김근호, 김일국pp. 2452-2457Experimental study of turbulent flow in a scaled RPV model by PIV technologyXiong Jinbiao, Liu Yu, Qu Wenhai, Liu Luguo, Li Songwei, Jiang Guangmingpp. 2458-2473Enhancement of critical heat flux with additive-manufactured heat-transfer surfaceFuruya Masahiro, Kano Tatsuya, Ono Rintaropp. 2474-2479
원문 보기