반 프라쎈의 경험동등성 논변과 시공간에 대한 해석
Van Fraassen on Empirical Equivalence Argument and Interpretations of Space-time
0
조회
0
다운로드
0
인용
0
참고문헌
키워드
초록
본 논문은 반 프라쎈의 뉴턴 시공간에 대한 해석에 기초한 경험동등성 논변을 비판한다. 필자의 주장은 반 프라쎈이 시공간에 대한 오해에서 절대속도라는 뉴턴 시공간이 가지는 여분의 구조를 통해 부적절한 비판을 낳고 있다는 것이다. 반 프라쎈의 경험동등성 논변은 모형의 다양한 측면을 무시한 뉴턴 시공간에 대한 부주의한 해석에 근거한다.
Abstract
This essay criticizes Van Fraassen’s argument for empirical equivalence among competing theories, which is based on his interpretation of Newtonian space-time. I argue that his misleading interpretation of the ontology of absolute space-time results in his ineffective attacks against a residual structure of space-time, absolute velocity. Van Fraassen’s argument basically misleads us into empirical equivalence in that his literal reading of Newtonian space-time disregards a variety of aspects of its model.
참고문헌 (22)
- Alexander, H. G, "The Leibniz-Clark Correspondence" (1959), Manchester University Press
- Aharonov, Y., "Significance of Electromagnetic Potentials in the Quantum Theory", Physical Review, 115, pp.485~491 (1959)
- Belot, G., "Whatever Is Never And Nowhere Is Not: Space, Time, and Ontology in Classical and, Quantum Gravity", 박사, pp.1996
- Belot, G., "Understanding Electromagnetism", British Journal of Philosophy of Science, pp.531~555 (1998)
- Butterfield, J, "Spacetime and Philosophical Challenge of Quantum Gravity, In Physics meets Philosophy at the Planck Scale", pp.33~89 (1999), Cambridge University Press
- Cartwright, N., "How Law of Physics Lie" (1983), Oxford University Press
- Chang, H., "The Quantum Counter-Revolution : Internal Conflicts in Scientific Change", Studies in History and Philosophy of Modern Physics, 26, pp.121~136 (1995)
- Cho, I., "Dogma of Underdetermination of Theories?", Philosophy (Korean), 42, pp.132~158 (1994)
- Cushing, J., "Models and Methodologies in Current theoretical High-Energy Physics", Synthese, 50, pp.5~101 (1982)
- DiSalle, R., "Newton, Einstein, and the Empirical Foundations of Spacetime Geometry", International Studiesin Philosophy of Science, 6, pp.181~189 (1992)
- DiSalle, R., "On Dynamics, Indisernability, and Spacetime Ontology", British Journal of Philosophy of Science, 45, pp.265~287 (1994)
- Earman, J., "World Enough Space-Time" (1989), MIT Press
- Earman, J., "The Meaning and Status of Newton’s Law of Inertia and the Nature of Gravitational Forces", Philosophy of Science, 40, pp.329~359 (1973)
- Hardin, C. L., "In Defense of Convergent Realism", Philosophy of Science, 49, pp.604~615 (1982)
- Leplin, J, "Scientific Realism" (1984), California University Press
- Laudan, L., "Empirical Equivalence and Underdetermination", Journal of Philosophy, 88, pp.449~472 (1991)
- Newton, I., "Mathematical Principle of Natural Philosophy, In Trans" (1972), University of California Press
- Sklar, L., "Space, Time, Spacetime" (1974), University of California Press
- Stein, H., "Newtonian Space-time", Texas Quarterly, 10, pp.174~200 (1967)
- Van Fraassen, B. C., "An Introduction to the Philosophy of Time and Space" (1970), Columbia University Press
- Van Fraassen, B. C., "Scientific Image" (1980), Oxford University Press
- Van Fraassen, B. C., "Quantum Mechanics, In An Empiricist View" (1991), Oxford University Press