Effects of Narrative Exposure Therapy for Treating Depressive and Anxious Disorders: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis
0
조회
0
다운로드
0
인용
0
참고문헌
키워드
초록
Objective Narrative exposure therapy (NET) has been used in various contexts for the treatment of the effects of trauma, with promising results in clinical trials. However, its effects on anxiety and depression are still unclear. The present study is a systematic review and meta-analysis of the effects of NET on depression and anxiety.Methods The Embase, Cumulative Index of Nursing and Allied Health Literature, PubMed, Web of Science core collection, Cochrane Library, Chinese National Knowledge Infrastructure, Chinese Biomedical Database, and Wangfang databases were searched from the earliest records to March 2023. Two researchers independently screened the literature, extracted data, evaluated the risk of bias, and cross-checked the data. Meta-analysis was performed using the program RevMan 5.3.Results Eleven randomized controlled trials with a total of 754 participants were included in the study. The results showed that NET reduced both the depression (standard mean difference [SMD]=-0.51, 95% confidence interval [CI] -0.73–-0.29, p<0.00001) and anxiety (SMD=-0.65, 95% CI -1.13–-0.18, p=0.007) scores of the patients. Furthermore, NET was found to alleviate negative emotions associated with guilt (mean difference [MD]=-3.60, 95% CI -5.52–-1.68, p=0.0005) and negative change (MD=-5.80, 95% CI -9.76–-1.83, p=0.004).Conclusion This analysis showed that NET can alleviate depression and anxiety. It may thus be used in clinical settings to alleviate patients’ negative feelings and aid their overall recovery.
Abstract
Objective Narrative exposure therapy (NET) has been used in various contexts for the treatment of the effects of trauma, with promising results in clinical trials. However, its effects on anxiety and depression are still unclear. The present study is a systematic review and meta-analysis of the effects of NET on depression and anxiety.Methods The Embase, Cumulative Index of Nursing and Allied Health Literature, PubMed, Web of Science core collection, Cochrane Library, Chinese National Knowledge Infrastructure, Chinese Biomedical Database, and Wangfang databases were searched from the earliest records to March 2023. Two researchers independently screened the literature, extracted data, evaluated the risk of bias, and cross-checked the data. Meta-analysis was performed using the program RevMan 5.3.Results Eleven randomized controlled trials with a total of 754 participants were included in the study. The results showed that NET reduced both the depression (standard mean difference [SMD]=-0.51, 95% confidence interval [CI] -0.73–-0.29, p<0.00001) and anxiety (SMD=-0.65, 95% CI -1.13–-0.18, p=0.007) scores of the patients. Furthermore, NET was found to alleviate negative emotions associated with guilt (mean difference [MD]=-3.60, 95% CI -5.52–-1.68, p=0.0005) and negative change (MD=-5.80, 95% CI -9.76–-1.83, p=0.004).Conclusion This analysis showed that NET can alleviate depression and anxiety. It may thus be used in clinical settings to alleviate patients’ negative feelings and aid their overall recovery.
참고문헌 (50)
- Steel Z, "The global prevalence of common mental disorders : a systematic review and meta-analysis 1980–2013", Int J Epidemiol, 43, pp.476~493 (2014)
- Garfield AC, "Factors affecting anxiety in multiple sclero sis", Disabil Rehabil, 34, pp.2047~2052 (2012)
- Perkovic R, "The incidence of depression and anxiety among the elderly in the area of Livno, Bosnia and Herzegovi na", Mater Sociomed, 30, pp.176~179 (2018)
- Suh Y, "Physical activity, disability, and mood in the early stage of multiple sclerosis", Disabil Health J, 3, pp.93~98 (2010)
- Lester K, "The association of illness severity, self-reported cognitive impairment, and perceived illness management with depression and anxiety in a multiple sclerosis clinic population", J Behav Med, 30, pp.177~186 (2007)
- Korostil M, "Anxiety disorders and their clinical correlates in multiple sclerosis patients", Mult Scler, 13, pp.67~72 (2007)
- Moussavi S, "Depres sion, chronic diseases, and decrements in health : results from the World Health Surveys", Lancet, 370, pp.851~858 (2007)
- Macqueen G, "Systematic review of clinical practice guidelines for failed antidepressant treatment response in major depressive disorder, dys thymia, and subthreshold depression in adults", Can J Psychiatry, 62, pp.11~23 (2017)
- James AC, "Cognitive behav ioural therapy for anxiety disorders in children and adolescents", Cochrane Database Syst Rev, pp.CD004690~ (2015)
- O’Kearney RT, "Behavioural and cognitive behavioural therapy for obsessive compulsive disorder in children and adolescents", Cochrane Database Syst Rev, 2006, pp.CD004856~ (2006)
- Hunot V, "Psychological ther apies for generalised anxiety disorder", Cochrane Database Syst Rev, 2007, pp.CD001848~ (2007)
- Parker B, "Psychoanalytic", psychodynamic psychotherapy for children and adolescents who have been sexually abused, 2013, pp.(7), CD008162~
- van Bronswijk SC, "A prognostic index for long-term outcome af ter successful acute phase cognitive therapy and interpersonal psycho therapy for major depressive disorder", Depress Anxiety, 36, pp.252261~ (2019)
- Lopes RT, "Narrative therapy vs. cognitive-behavioral therapy for moderate de pression : empirical evidence from a controlled clinical trial", Psychother Res, 24, pp.662~674 (2014)
- Paré D, "White M, Epston D(1990). Narrative means to therapeutic ends", Can J Couns Psychother, 27, pp.289~290 (1993)
- Minami T, "Bench marks for psychotherapy efficacy in adult major depression", J Consult Clin Psychol, 75, pp.232~243 (2007)
- Gwozdziewycz N, "Meta-analysis of the use of narra tive exposure therapy for the effects of trauma among refugee popula tions", Perm J, 17, pp.70~76 (2013)
- Robjant K, "The emerging evidence for Narrative Exposure T herapy : a review", Clin Psychol Rev, 30, pp.1030~1039 (2010)
- May JC, "Family attachment narrative therapy : healing the experience of early childhood maltreatment", J Marital Fam Ther, 31, pp.221~237 (2010)
- Gask L, "Improving access to psychosocial interventions for common mental health problems in the United Kingdom : narrative review and development of a conceptual model for complex interventions", Bmc Health Serv Res, 12, pp.249~ (2012)
- Mondin TC, "Long-term effects of cognitive therapy on biological rhythms and depressive symptoms : a randomized clinical trial", J Affect Disord, 187, pp.1~9 (2015)
- Weber M, "Narrative therapy, eating disorders and groups : enhancing outcomes in rural NSW", Australian Social Work, 59, pp.391~405 (2006)
- Petersen S, "Narrative therapy to prevent illness-related stress disorder", J Counsel Dev, 83, pp.41~47 (2005)
- Brown CA, "How do you write pain? A preliminary study of narrative therapy for people with chronic pain", Diver Health Care, 7, pp.43~56 (2010)
- Knight K, "The effects of group motivational interviewing and externalizing conversations for adolescents with Type-1 diabetes", Psychol Health Med, 8, pp.149~157 (2003)
- Chenail RJ, "Discursive per spectives in therapeutic practice", pp.224~244 (2012), Oxford University Press
- Vromans LP, "Narrative therapy for adults with major depressive disorder : improved symptom and interpersonal outcomes", Psychother Res, 21, pp.4~15 (2011)
- Lopes RDCT, "Long-term effects of psychotherapy on moderate depression : a com parative study of narrative therapy and cognitive-behavioral therapy", J Affect Disord, 167, pp.64~73 (2014)
- Lloyd-Williams M, "A pilot randomised controlled trial to reduce suffering and emotional distress in patients with advanced cancer", J Affect Disord, 148, pp.141~145 (2013)
- Moher D, "PRISMA Group. Pre ferred reporting items for systematic reviews and meta-analyses : the PRISMA statement", PLoS Med, 6, pp.e1000097~ (2009)
- Cumpston M, "Updated guidance for trusted systematic reviews : a new edition of the Cochrane Handbook for Systematic Reviews of Interventions", Cochrane Database Syst Rev, pp.ED000142~ (2019)
- Seagroatt V, "Bias in meta-analysis detected by a simple, graphical test. Test had 10% false positive rate", BMJ, 316, pp.470~ (1998)
- Zang Y, "Adapting narrative exposure therapy for Chi nese earthquake survivors : a pilot randomised controlled feasibility study", BMC Psychiatry, 14, pp.262~ (2014)
- Zang Y, "A randomised controlled pilot study : the ef fectiveness of narrative exposure therapy with adult survivors of the Sichuan earthquake", BMC Psychiatry, 13, pp.41~ (2013)
- Salloum A, "Grief and trauma intervention for children after disaster : exploring coping skills versus trauma narration", Behav Res Ther, 50, pp.169~179 (2012)
- Vega BR, "Com bined therapy versus usual care for the treatment of depression in on cologic patients : a randomized controlled trial", Psychooncology, 20, pp.943~952 (2011)
- Rocha J, "Women generating narratives after an unwanted prenatal diagnosis result : randomized controlled trial", Arch Womens Ment Health, 21, pp.453~459 (2018)
- Lloyd-Williams M, "Pilot randomised controlled trial of focused narrative intervention for moderate to severe depression in palliative care patients : DISCERN trial", Palliat Med, 32, pp.206~215 (2018)
- Wise M, "Suffering in advanced cancer : a randomized control trial of a narrative intervention", J Palliat Med, 21, pp.200~207 (2018)
- Alghamdi M, "The effectiveness of Narrative Expo sure Therapy with traumatised firefighters in Saudi Arabia : a random ized controlled study", Behav Res Ther, 66, pp.64~71 (2015)
- Ertl V, "Community-imple mented trauma therapy for former child soldiers in Northern Uganda : a randomized controlled trial", JAMA, 306, pp.503~512 (2011)
- Zong J, "Random control trial study on effect of narrative medicine mode on rehabilitation of patients underwent radical nephrectomy", Chin J Pract Nurs, 33, pp.1525~1529 (2017)
- Li Y, "Effect of narrative nursing on mood and symptom management of patients with advanced lung cancer", Nurs J Chin PLA, 35, pp.28~31 (2018)
- Brown NR, "Working the double edge : unbraiding pathology and resiliency in the narratives of early-recovery trauma survivors", Psychol Trauma, 4, pp.102~111 (2012)
- Hoge EA, "Generalized anxiety disorder : diagnosis and treatment", Bmj, 345, pp.e7500~ (2012)
- Schauer M, "Narrative exposure therapy : a short term intervention for traumatic stress disorders after war. terror, or torture" (2005), Hogrefe & Huber
- Bichescu D, "Narrative exposure thera py for political imprisonment-related chronic posttraumatic stress dis order and depression", Behav Res Ther, 45, pp.2212~2220 (2007)
- Mørkved N, "A comparison of Narrative Exposure Therapy and Prolonged Exposure therapy for PTSD", Clin Psychol Rev, 34, pp.453~467 (2014)
- Volpe EM, "Narrative exposure therapy : a proposed model to address intimate partner violence-related PTSD in parenting and pregnant adolescents", Fam Community Health, 40, pp.258~277 (2017)
- Schulz KF, "CONSORT 2010 Statement : updated guidelines for reporting parallel group ran domised trials", BMC, 340, pp.c332~ (2010)
