개인과 조직 사이에서: 챌린저호 폭발사고에 대한 재해석과 STS-공학윤리의 접점 찾기
Between Individual and Organization: Reinterpreting the Challenger Disaster and Finding an Interface between STS and Engineering Ethics
0
조회
0
다운로드
3
인용
0
참고문헌
키워드
초록
On the grounds of Diane Vaughan's pioneering study into the Challenger Disaster, STS(Science and Technology Studies)scholars have recently argued that most engineers seldom face an ethical situation, in which the boundary between the ethical and the unethical is absolutely clear, and for which a serious moral decision such as “whistle blowing” is urgently needed. They have instead suggested that engineering ethics needs to address engineers' everyday routine practices, which, if accumulated, may have some impact upon the overall performance of the technological system. However, such studies have not completely resolved the tension between STS that emphasizes contextual elements in which the everyday practice of engineers are done, on the one hand, and engineering ethics that stresses individual engineer's moral decision of an existential kind, on the other. By discussing various works on the Challenger Disaster and related issues over technological risks, this paper attempts to establish an interface between STS and engineering ethics, and proposes some practical implications for the effective education of engineering ethics to engineering students.
Abstract
On the grounds of Diane Vaughan's pioneering study into the Challenger Disaster, STS(Science and Technology Studies)scholars have recently argued that most engineers seldom face an ethical situation, in which the boundary between the ethical and the unethical is absolutely clear, and for which a serious moral decision such as “whistle blowing” is urgently needed. They have instead suggested that engineering ethics needs to address engineers' everyday routine practices, which, if accumulated, may have some impact upon the overall performance of the technological system. However, such studies have not completely resolved the tension between STS that emphasizes contextual elements in which the everyday practice of engineers are done, on the one hand, and engineering ethics that stresses individual engineer's moral decision of an existential kind, on the other. By discussing various works on the Challenger Disaster and related issues over technological risks, this paper attempts to establish an interface between STS and engineering ethics, and proposes some practical implications for the effective education of engineering ethics to engineering students.
참고문헌 (26)
- 김진, "공학윤리 : 기술공학시대의 윤리적 문제들", pp.37~38 (2003), 철학과 현실사
- 양해림, "과학기술시대의 공학윤리", pp.153~154 (2006), 철학과현실사
- 조일수, "공학사례 연구", pp.407~410 (2007), 인간사랑
- Allinson, R. E., "The “Cog in the Machine” Manifesto: the Banality and the Inevitability of Evil", Business Ethics Quarterly, 8, pp.743~756 (1998)
- Bovens, M., "The Quest for Responsibility: Accountability and Citizenship in Complex Organizations" (1998), Cambridge University Press
- Bunderson, J. Stuart, "Normal Injustices and Morality in Complex Organizations", Journal of Business Ethics, 33, pp.181~190 (2001)
- Collins, Harry, "The Naked Launch: Assigning Blame for Challenger explosion. in The Golem at Large: What You Should Know about Technology", pp.30~56 (1998), Cambridge University Press
- Davis, Michael, "Engineering Ethics, Individuals, and Organizations", Science and Engineering Ethics, 12, pp.223~231 (2006)
- Dowie, Mark, "Pinto madness", Mother Jones, 2, pp.18~32 (1977)
- 이재성, "공학윤리" (2009), 홍릉과학출판사
- 노양진, "공학윤리: 기술공학시대의 윤리적 문제들", pp.274~278 (2003), 철학과 현실사
- Johnson, Deborah G., "Chapter 23. STS and Ethics: Implications for Engineering Ethics, In The Handbook of Science and Technology Studies 3rd", pp.567~582 (2008), The MIT Press
- Kline, Ronald R., "Using History & Sociology: To Teach Engineering Ethics", IEEE Technology and Society Magazine, 20, pp.13~20 (2001)
- Kranakis, Eda, "Fixing the Blame: Organizational Culture and the Quebec Bridge Collapse", Technology and Culture, 45, pp.487~518 (2004)
- Lee, Matthew T., "Pinto‘Madness’ as a Flawed Landmark Narrative: AnOrganizational and Network Analysis", Social Problems, 46, pp.30~47 (1999)
- Lynch, William T., "Engineering Practice and Engineering Ethics", Science, Technology & Human Values, 25, pp.195~225 (2000)
- 김영진, "공학윤리", pp.149~162 (2009), 교보문고
- Perlman, Bruce, "Improving Ethical Engineering Practice", IEEE Technology and Society Magazine, 21, pp.40~47 (2002)
- Van de Poel, Ibo, "Ethics and Engineering Design, Science", Technology & Human Values, 31, pp.223~236 (2006)
- Vaughan, Diane, "The Challenger Launch Decision: Risky Technology, Culture, and Deviance at NASA" (1996), The University of Chicago Press
- Vaughan, Diane, "Rational Choice, Situated Action, and the Social Control of Organization", Law & Society Review, 32, pp.23~61 (1998)
- Vaughan, Diane, "The Role of Organization in the Production of Techno-Scientific Knowledge", Social Studies of Science, 29, pp.913~943 (1999)
- Vaughan, Diane, "The Dark Aide of Organizations: Mistake, Misconduct, and Disaster", Annual Review of Sociology, 25, pp.271~305 (1999)
- Verbeek, P.P.C.C., "Materializing Morality. Design Ethics and Technological Mediation. Science", Technology & Human Values, 31, pp.361~380 (2006)
- Weick, K. E., "Collective Mind in Organizations: Heedful Interrelating on Flight Decks", Administrative Science Quarterly, 38, pp.357~381 (1993)
- Weick, K. E., "Book Review: The Challenger Launch Decision", Administrative Science Quarterly, 42, pp.395~401 (1997)