Ways of (Un)Seeing Race and History in Clint Eastwood's Revisionist Western Unforgiven
0
조회
0
다운로드
0
인용
0
참고문헌
키워드
초록
This paper is a kind of interdisciplinary studies which connect a Western film criticism with a criticism of minority literature in America. My purpose in this paper is to put on the table such a sensitive issue as racial representation and representativeness in Clint Eastwood's revisionist Western, Unforgiven. We admit generally that Western films have contributed to the white American myth-making of how the West was won. Yet, since the mid-1960s, a growing number of revisionist Westerns were produced so as to raise a question about the conventional way of looking at what happened in the American West. In order to analyze the problem inherent in the way of seeing, I pay attention to how the director Eastwood (re)presents a character named W. W. Beauchamp in the film. Presumably, what the character Beauchamp misses in the West can be overlapped with what ordinary film viewers miss in the genre of Westerns. Given this, interrogating both what Beauchamp sees and what he misses within the movie, I attempt to disclose how much of the West has been unseen from his biased viewpoint. By doing so, I argue why it is important to focus on some passing scenes that touch on the irony of a Native American train passenger, the gaze of the mute Native American housewife, the abrupt disappearance of Asian American men, the lynching of African-American ex-cowboy, and the self-determination of the saloon prostitutes. Then I hope that, conservative and mainstream though the director is, his way of revising the Western is not quite far from my minority-conscious critical position.
Abstract
This paper is a kind of interdisciplinary studies which connect a Western film criticism with a criticism of minority literature in America. My purpose in this paper is to put on the table such a sensitive issue as racial representation and representativeness in Clint Eastwood's revisionist Western, Unforgiven. We admit generally that Western films have contributed to the white American myth-making of how the West was won. Yet, since the mid-1960s, a growing number of revisionist Westerns were produced so as to raise a question about the conventional way of looking at what happened in the American West. In order to analyze the problem inherent in the way of seeing, I pay attention to how the director Eastwood (re)presents a character named W. W. Beauchamp in the film. Presumably, what the character Beauchamp misses in the West can be overlapped with what ordinary film viewers miss in the genre of Westerns. Given this, interrogating both what Beauchamp sees and what he misses within the movie, I attempt to disclose how much of the West has been unseen from his biased viewpoint. By doing so, I argue why it is important to focus on some passing scenes that touch on the irony of a Native American train passenger, the gaze of the mute Native American housewife, the abrupt disappearance of Asian American men, the lynching of African-American ex-cowboy, and the self-determination of the saloon prostitutes. Then I hope that, conservative and mainstream though the director is, his way of revising the Western is not quite far from my minority-conscious critical position.
참고문헌 (21)
- Allen, James, "Without Sanctuary: Lynching Photography in America" (2007), Twin Palms Publishers
- Appiah, Kwame Anthony, "Africana: The Encyclopedia of the African and African American Experience" (1999), Basic Civitas
- Banning, Maria, "The Limits of PC Discourse: Linking Language Use to Social Practice", Pedagogy, 4(2), pp.191~214 (2004)
- Bingham, Dennis, "Acting Male: Masculinities in the Films of James Stewart, Jack Nicholson, and Clint Eastwood" (1994), Rutgers UP
- Berger, John, "Ways of Seeing" (1972), Penguin
- Catherine, Ingrassia, "Writing the West: Iconic and Literal Truth in Unforgiven", Literature, 1998, pp.26(1), 53~59
- Chan, Sucheng, "Asian Americans: An Interpretive History" (1991), Twayne
- Cook, Pam, "Women and the Western. in: The Western Reader", pp.293~300 (1998), Limelight
- Durgnat, Raymond, "Six Creeds That Won the Western. in: The Western Reader", pp.69~83 (1998), Limelight
- Eng David, "Racial Castration: Managing Masculinity in Asian America" (2001), Duke UP
- Gagnier, Nancy, "Political Extremists, Postmodern Professors, and Other Politically Correct Bedfellows", Review. Social Text, 36, pp.98~105 (1993)
- Grenier, Richard, "Clint Eastwood Goes PC", Commentary, 97(3), pp.51~53 (1994)
- Kingston, Maxine Hong, "China Men. 1980" (1989), Vintage
- Kitses, Jim, "Post-modernism and The Western. in: The Western Reader", pp.15~31 (1998), Limelight
- Lee, Michel, "The Americas of Asian American Literature: Gendered Fictions of Nation and Transnation" (1999), Princeton UP
- Lowe, Lisa, "Immigrant Acts: On Asian American Cultural Politics" (1998), Duke UP
- McGee, Patrick, "From Shane to Kill Bill: Rethinking the Western" (2007), Blackwell
- Ruth, Perry, "A Short History of the Term Politically Correct. in: Beyond PC: Toward a Politics of Understanding", pp.71~79 (1992), Graywolf Press
- Tompkins, Jane, "West of Everything: The Inner Life of Western" (1992), Oxford UP
- Smith, Paul, "Clint Eastwood: A Cultural Production" (1993), U of Minnesota P
- Worland, Rick, "The New Western American Historiography and the Emergence of the New American Westerns. in: Back in the Saddle Again", pp.181~196 (1998), British Film Institute Publishing