Beyond measurement: a deep dive into the commonly used pain scales for postoperative pain assessment
1
조회
0
다운로드
0
인용
0
참고문헌
키워드
초록
This review explores the essential methodologies for effective postoperative pain management, focusing on the need for thorough pain assessment tools, as underscored in various existing guidelines. Herein, the strengths and weaknesses of commonly used pain scales for postoperative pain—the Visual Analog Scale, Numeric Rating Scale, Verbal Rating Scale, and Faces Pain Scale—are evaluated, highlighting the importance of selecting appropriate assessment tools based on factors influencing their effectiveness in surgical contexts. By emphasizing the need to comprehend the minimal clinically important difference (MCID) for these scales in evaluating new analgesic interventions and monitoring pain trajectories over time, this review advocates recognizing the limitations of common pain scales to improve pain assessment strategies, ultimately enhancing postoperative pain management. Finally, five recommendations for pain assessment in research on postoperative pain are provided: first, selecting an appropriate pain scale tailored to the patient group, considering the strengths and weaknesses of each scale; second, simultaneously assessing the intensity of postoperative pain at rest and during movement; third, conducting evaluations at specific time points and monitoring trends over time; fourth, extending the focus beyond the intensity of postoperative pain to include its impact on postoperative functional recovery; and lastly, interpreting the findings while considering the MCID, ensuring that it is clinically significant for the chosen pain scale. These recommendations broaden our understanding of postoperative pain and provide insights that contribute to more effective pain management strategies, thereby enhancing patient care outcomes.
Abstract
This review explores the essential methodologies for effective postoperative pain management, focusing on the need for thorough pain assessment tools, as underscored in various existing guidelines. Herein, the strengths and weaknesses of commonly used pain scales for postoperative pain—the Visual Analog Scale, Numeric Rating Scale, Verbal Rating Scale, and Faces Pain Scale—are evaluated, highlighting the importance of selecting appropriate assessment tools based on factors influencing their effectiveness in surgical contexts. By emphasizing the need to comprehend the minimal clinically important difference (MCID) for these scales in evaluating new analgesic interventions and monitoring pain trajectories over time, this review advocates recognizing the limitations of common pain scales to improve pain assessment strategies, ultimately enhancing postoperative pain management. Finally, five recommendations for pain assessment in research on postoperative pain are provided: first, selecting an appropriate pain scale tailored to the patient group, considering the strengths and weaknesses of each scale; second, simultaneously assessing the intensity of postoperative pain at rest and during movement; third, conducting evaluations at specific time points and monitoring trends over time; fourth, extending the focus beyond the intensity of postoperative pain to include its impact on postoperative functional recovery; and lastly, interpreting the findings while considering the MCID, ensuring that it is clinically significant for the chosen pain scale. These recommendations broaden our understanding of postoperative pain and provide insights that contribute to more effective pain management strategies, thereby enhancing patient care outcomes.
참고문헌 (74)
- Wu CL, "Postoperative pain and quality of recovery", Curr Opin Anaesthesiol, 17, pp.455~460 (2004)
- Yoon SH, "Correlation between pain intensity and quality of recovery after video-assisted thoracic surgery for lung cancer resection", J Pain Res, 16, pp.3343~3352 (2023)
- Berkowitz R, "The impact of complications and pain on patient satisfaction", Ann Surg, 273, pp.1127~1134 (2021)
- van Boekel RLM, "Relationship between postoperative pain and overall 30-day complications in a broad surgical population : an observational study", Ann Surg, 269, pp.856~865 (2019)
- Kim BR, "Practical strategies for the prevention and management of chronic postsurgical pain", Korean J Pain, 36, pp.149~162 (2023)
- Myles PS, "Systematic review and consensus definitions for the Standardised Endpoints in Perioperative Medicine(StEP)initiative : patient comfort", Br J Anaesth, 120, pp.705~711 (2018)
- Chou R, "Management of postoperative pain : a clinical practice guideline from the American Pain Society, the American Society of Regional Anesthesia and Pain Medicine, and the American Society of Anesthesiologists' Committee on Regional Anesthesia, Executive Committee, and Administrative Council", J Pain, 17, pp.131~157 (2016)
- Gilron I, "Movement-evoked pain versus pain at rest in postsurgical clinical trials and in meta-analyses : an updated systematic review", Anesthesiology, 140, pp.442~449 (2024)
- Aubrun F, "Revision of expert panel's guidelines on postoperative pain management", Anaesth Crit Care Pain Med, 38, pp.405~411 (2019)
- Malviya S, "The revised FLACC observational pain tool : improved reliability and validity for pain assessment in children with cognitive impairment", Paediatr Anaesth, 16, pp.258~265 (2006)
- Rat P, "Validation of an acute pain-behavior scale for older persons with inability to communicate verbally : Algoplus", Eur J Pain, 15, pp.198~ (2011)
- Schug SA, "Acute pain management:scientific evidence", pp.62~71 (2020), ANZCA & FPM
- Mariano ER, "A multisociety organizational consensus process to define guiding principles for acute perioperative pain management", Reg Anesth Pain Med, 47, pp.118~127 (2022)
- Baamer RM, "Utility of unidimensional and functional pain assessment tools in adult postoperative patients : a systematic review", Br J Anaesth, 128, pp.874~888 (2022)
- Todd KH, "Clinical significance of reported changes in pain severity", Ann Emerg Med, 27, pp.485~489 (1996)
- Bijur PE, "Reliability of the visual analog scale for measurement of acute pain", Acad Emerg Med, 8, pp.1153~1157 (2001)
- Bond MR, "Subjective assessment of pain and its relationship to the administration of analgesics in patients with advanced cancer", J Psychosom Res, 10, pp.203~208 (1966)
- Huskisson EC, "Measurement of pain", Lancet, 2, pp.1127~1131 (1974)
- Heller GZ, "How to analyze the Visual Analogue Scale : myths, truths and clinical relevance", Scand J Pain, 13, pp.67~75 (2016)
- Scott J, "Graphic representation of pain", Pain, 2, pp.175~184 (1976)
- Ogon M, "Chronic low back pain measurement with visual analogue scales in different settings", Pain, 64, pp.425~428 (1996)
- Scott J, "Vertical or horizontal visual analogue scales", Ann Rheum Dis, 38, pp.560~ (1979)
- Williamson A, "Pain : a review of three commonly used pain rating scales", J Clin Nurs, 14, pp.798~804 (2005)
- Collins SL, "The visual analogue pain intensity scale : what is moderate pain in millimetres", Pain, 72, pp.95~97 (1997)
- Moore RA, "Comparing pain intensity rating scales in acute postoperative pain : boundary values and category disagreements", Anaesthesia, 79, pp.139~146 (2024)
- Myles PS, "Measuring acute postoperative pain using the visual analog scale : the minimal clinically important difference and patient acceptable symptom state", Br J Anaesth, 118, pp.424~429 (2017)
- Briggs M, "A descriptive study of the use of visual analogue scales and verbal rating scales for the assessment of postoperative pain in orthopedic patients", J Pain Symptom Manage, 18, pp.438~446 (1999)
- González-Fernández M, "Moving beyond the limitations of the visual analog scale for measuring pain : novel use of the general labeled magnitude scale in a clinical setting", Am J Phys Med Rehabil, 93, pp.75~81 (2014)
- Hawker GA, "Measures of adult pain: Visual Analog Scale for Pain (VAS Pain), Numeric Rating Scale for Pain (NRS Pain), McGill Pain Questionnaire (MPQ), Short-Form Mc-Gill Pain Questionnaire (SF-MPQ), Chronic Pain Grade Scale (CPGS), Short Form-36 Bodily Pain Scale (SF-36 BPS), and Measure of Intermittent and Constant Osteoarthritis Pain (ICOAP)", Arthritis Care Res (Hoboken), 63(Suppl 11), pp.S240~S252 (2011)
- Johnson C, "Measuring pain. Visual Analog Scale versus Numeric Pain Scale: what is the difference?", J Chiropr Med, 4, pp.43~44 (2005)
- Rodriguez CS, "Pain measurement in the elderly : a review", Pain Manag Nurs, 2, pp.38~46 (2001)
- Karcioglu O, "A systematic review of the pain scales in adults : which to use", Am J Emerg Med, 36, pp.707~714 (2018)
- Gerbershagen HJ, "Determination of moderate-to-severe postoperative pain on the numeric rating scale : a cut-off point analysis applying four different methods", Br J Anaesth, 107, pp.619~626 (2011)
- Gracely RH, "Ratio scales of sensory and affective verbal pain descriptors", Pain, 5, pp.5~18 (1978)
- Herr KA, "Pain intensity assessment in older adults : use of experimental pain to compare psychometric properties and usability of selected pain scales with younger adults", Clin J Pain, 20, pp.207~219 (2004)
- Tomlinson D, "A systematic review of faces scales for the self-report of pain intensity in children", Pediatrics, 126, pp.e1168~e1198 (2010)
- Herr KA, "Evaluation of the Faces Pain Scale for use with the elderly", Clin J Pain, 14, pp.29~38 (1998)
- Van Giang N, "Validity, sensitivity, and responsiveness of the 11-Face Faces Pain Scale to postoperative pain in adult orthopedic surgery patients", Pain Manag Nurs, 16, pp.678~684 (2015)
- Kawamura H, "Assessment of pain by face scales after gastrectomy : comparison of laparoscopically assisted gastrectomy and open gastrectomy", Surg Endosc, 23, pp.991~995 (2009)
- Adeboye A, "Assessment of functional pain score by comparing to traditional pain scores", Cureus, 13, pp.e16847~ (2021)
- Manz BD, "Pain assessment in the cognitively impaired and unimpaired elderly", Pain Manag Nurs, 1, pp.106~115 (2000)
- Falzone E, "Postoperative analgesia in elderly patients", Drugs Aging, 30, pp.81~90 (2013)
- Gagliese L, "The measurement of postoperative pain : a comparison of intensity scales in younger and older surgical patients", Pain, 117, pp.412~420 (2005)
- Hølen JC, "Doloplus-2, a valid tool for behavioural pain assessment", BMC Geriatr, 7, pp.29~ (2007)
- Chibnall JT, "Pain assessment in cognitively impaired and unimpaired older adults : a comparison of four scales", Pain, 92, pp.173~186 (2001)
- DeLoach LJ, "The visual analog scale in the immediate postoperative period : intrasubject variability and correlation with a numeric scale", Anesth Analg, 86, pp.102~106 (1998)
- Machata AM, "A new instrument for pain assessment in the immediate postoperative period", Anaesthesia, 64, pp.392~398 (2009)
- Lee HJ, "Comparative study of verbal rating scale and numerical rating scale to assess postoperative pain intensity in the post anesthesia care unit : a prospective observational cohort study", Medicine (Baltimore), 100, pp.e24314~ (2021)
- Peacock S, "Cultural influences on pain", Rev Pain, 1, pp.6~9 (2008)
- Rogger R, "Cultural framing and the impact on acute pain and pain services", Curr Pain Headache Rep, 27, pp.429~436 (2023)
- "The importance of cultural competence in pain and palliative care" (2024)[URL]
- Perry M, "The influence of race, ethnicity and genetic variants on postoperative pain intensity : an integrative literature review", Pain Manag Nurs, 20, pp.198~206 (2019)
- Bartley EJ, "Sex differences in pain : a brief review of clinical and experimental findings", Br J Anaesth, 111, pp.52~58 (2013)
- Craft RM, "Sex differences in pain and analgesia : the role of gonadal hormones", Eur J Pain, 8, pp.397~411 (2004)
- Derbyshire SW, "Gender differences in patterns of cerebral activation during equal experience of painful laser stimulation", J Pain, 3, pp.401~411 (2002)
- Robinson ME, "Gender role expectations of pain : relationship to sex differences in pain", J Pain, 2, pp.251~257 (2001)
- Bond LM, "Effects of preoperative teaching of the use of a pain scale with patients in the PACU", J Perianesth Nurs, 20, pp.333~340 (2005)
- Wikström L, "Healthcare professionals' perceptions of the use of pain scales in postoperative pain assessments", Appl Nurs Res, 27, pp.53~58 (2014)
- McGlothlin AE, "Minimal clinically important difference : defining what really matters to patients", JAMA, 312, pp.1342~1343 (2014)
- Muñoz-Leyva F, "Is the minimal clinically important difference(MCID)in acute pain a good measure of analgesic efficacy in regional anesthesia", Reg Anesth Pain Med, 45, pp.1000~1005 (2020)
- Olsen MF, "Pain relief that matters to patients : systematic review of empirical studies assessing the minimum clinically important difference in acute pain", BMC Med, 15, pp.35~ (2017)
- Cepeda MS, "What decline in pain intensity is meaningful to patients with acute pain", Pain, 105, pp.151~157 (2003)
- Danoff JR, "How much pain is significant? Defining the minimal clinically important difference for the visual analog scale for pain after total joint arthroplasty", J Arthroplasty, 33, pp.S71~S75 (2018)
- Laigaard J, "Minimal clinically important differences in randomised clinical trials on pain management after total hip and knee arthroplasty : a systematic review", Br J Anaesth, 126, pp.1029~1037 (2021)
- Bayman EO, "AAAPT : assessment of the acute pain trajectory", Pain Med, 22, pp.533~547 (2021)
- Vasilopoulos T, "Patient and procedural determinants of postoperative pain trajectories", Anesthesiology, 134, pp.421~434 (2021)
- Panzenbeck P, "Procedure-specific acute pain trajectory after elective total hip arthroplasty : systematic review and data synthesis", Br J Anaesth, 127, pp.110~132 (2021)
- Kelly I, "Identifying patients vulnerable to inadequate pain resolution after cardiac surgery", Semin Thorac Cardiovasc Surg (2022)[DOI]
- Schreiber KL, "Personalization over protocolization", Anesthesiology, 134, pp.363~365 (2021)
- Lapkin S, "Reliability, validity, and responsiveness of multidimensional pain assessment tools used in postoperative adult patients : a systematic review of measurement properties", JBI Evid Synth, 19, pp.284~307 (2021)
- Buckenmaier CC 3rd, "Preliminary validation of the Defense and Veterans Pain Rating Scale(DVPRS)in a military population", Pain Med, 14, pp.110~123 (2013)
- Nassif TH, "Concurrent validity of the defense and veterans pain rating scale in VA outpatients", Pain Med, 16, pp.2152~2161 (2015)
- Cho S, "Cut-off points between pain intensities of the postoperative pain using receiver operating characteristic(ROC)curves", BMC Anesthesiol, 21, pp.29~ (2021)
- van Dijk JF, "Postoperative pain assessment based on numeric ratings is not the same for patients and professionals : a cross-sectional study", Int J Nurs Stud, 49, pp.65~71 (2012)