본문 바로가기
KERD
논문KCI 등재

Can different agents reduce the damage caused by bleaching gel to pulp tissue? A systematic review of basic research

Batista Letícia Aparecida Silva|dos Reis-Prado Alexandre Henrique|Chaves Hebertt Gonzaga dos Santos|de Arantes Lara Cancella|Morgan Luís Fernando Santos Alves|André Carolina Bosso|Suzuki Thaís Yumi|Benetti Francine
대한치과보존학회 (Korean Academy Of Conservative Dentistry)|2023.11|Restorative Dentistry and Endodontics|제48권 제4호|pp. 1-23|DOI 10.5395/rde.2023.48.e39

2

조회

0

다운로드

0

인용

0

참고문헌

키워드

Systematic reviewHydrogen peroxideInflammationDental pulpTooth bleachingCell survival
주제분류치의학

초록

Objectives: This study aimed to investigate the effectiveness of different topical/systemic agents in reducing the damage caused by bleaching gel to pulp tissue or cells. Materials and Methods: Electronic searches were performed in July 2023. In vivo and in vitro studies evaluating the effects of different topical or systemic agents on pulp inflammation or cytotoxicity after exposure to bleaching agents were included. The risk of bias was assessed. Results: Out of 1,112 articles, 27 were included. Nine animal studies evaluated remineralizing/anti-inflammatories agents in rat molars subjected to bleaching with 35%–38% hydrogen peroxide (HP). Five of these studies demonstrated a significant reduction in inflammation caused by HP when combined with bioglass or MI Paste Plus (GC America), or following KF-desensitizing or Otosporin treatment (n = 3). However, orally administered drugs did not reduce pulp inflammation (n = 4). Cytotoxicity (n = 17) was primarily assessed using the 3-(4,5-dimethylthiazol-2-yl)-2,5-diphenyltetrazolium bromide assay on human dental pulp cells and mouse dental papilla Cell-23 cells. Certain substances, including sodium ascorbate, butein, manganese chloride, and peroxidase, were found to reduce cytotoxicity, particularly when applied prior to bleaching. The risk of bias was high in animal studies and low in laboratory studies. Conclusions: Few in vivo studies have evaluated agents to reduce the damage caused by bleaching gel to pulp tissue. Within the limitations of these studies, it was found that topical agents were effective in reducing pulp inflammation in animals and cytotoxicity. Further analyses with human pulp are required to substantiate these findings.

Abstract

Objectives: This study aimed to investigate the effectiveness of different topical/systemic agents in reducing the damage caused by bleaching gel to pulp tissue or cells. Materials and Methods: Electronic searches were performed in July 2023. In vivo and in vitro studies evaluating the effects of different topical or systemic agents on pulp inflammation or cytotoxicity after exposure to bleaching agents were included. The risk of bias was assessed. Results: Out of 1,112 articles, 27 were included. Nine animal studies evaluated remineralizing/anti-inflammatories agents in rat molars subjected to bleaching with 35%–38% hydrogen peroxide (HP). Five of these studies demonstrated a significant reduction in inflammation caused by HP when combined with bioglass or MI Paste Plus (GC America), or following KF-desensitizing or Otosporin treatment (n = 3). However, orally administered drugs did not reduce pulp inflammation (n = 4). Cytotoxicity (n = 17) was primarily assessed using the 3-(4,5-dimethylthiazol-2-yl)-2,5-diphenyltetrazolium bromide assay on human dental pulp cells and mouse dental papilla Cell-23 cells. Certain substances, including sodium ascorbate, butein, manganese chloride, and peroxidase, were found to reduce cytotoxicity, particularly when applied prior to bleaching. The risk of bias was high in animal studies and low in laboratory studies. Conclusions: Few in vivo studies have evaluated agents to reduce the damage caused by bleaching gel to pulp tissue. Within the limitations of these studies, it was found that topical agents were effective in reducing pulp inflammation in animals and cytotoxicity. Further analyses with human pulp are required to substantiate these findings.

참고문헌 (82)

  1. Barbosa JG, "Bleaching gel mixed with MI Paste Plus reduces penetration of H2O2 and damage to pulp tissue and maintains bleaching effectiveness", Clin Oral Investig, 24, pp.1299~1309 (2020)
  2. Vladislavic NZ, "In vivo evaluation of whitening toothpaste efficiency and patient treatment satisfaction : a randomized controlled trial", Clin Oral Investig, 26, pp.739~750 (2022)
  3. Gallinari MO, "Pulp response of rats submitted to bleaching and the use of different anti-inflammatory drugs", PLoS One, 14, pp.e0210338~ (2019)
  4. Costa CA, "Human pulp responses to in-office tooth bleaching", Oral Surg Oral Med Oral Pathol Oral Radiol Endod, 109, pp.e59~e64 (2010)
  5. Cintra LT, "The number of bleaching sessions influences pulp tissue damage in rat teeth", J Endod, 39, pp.1576~1580 (2013)
  6. Soares DG, "Effect of fluoride-treated enamel on indirect cytotoxicity of a 16% carbamide peroxide bleaching gel to pulp cells", Braz Dent J, 24, pp.121~127 (2013)
  7. Reis-Prado AH, "Influence of hydrogen peroxide on mineralization in dental pulp cells : a systematic review", Front Dent Med, 2, pp.689537~ (2021)
  8. Favoreto MW, "Topical application of Otosporin® before in-office bleaching: a split mouth, triple-blind, multicenter randomized clinical trial", Clin Oral Investig, 26, pp.2555~2564 (2022)
  9. Vochikovski L, "Effect of an experimental desensitizing gel on bleaching-induced tooth sensitivity after in-office bleaching-a double-blind, randomized controlled trial", Clin Oral Investig, 27, pp.1567~1576 (2023)
  10. Rezende M, "Predictive factors on the efficacy and risk", intensity of tooth sensitivity of dental bleaching : a multi regression and logistic analysis, 2016, pp.45, 1~6
  11. Benetti F, "In vivo study of the action of a topical anti-inflammatory drug in rat teeth submitted to dental bleaching", Braz Dent J, 29, pp.555~561 (2018)
  12. Carminatti M, "Experimental gel containing bioactive glass-ceramic to minimize the pulp damage caused by dental bleaching in rats", J Appl Oral Sci, 28, pp.e20190384~ (2020)
  13. Santana Jorge O, "Over-the-counter bleaching agents can help with tooth whitening maintenance", J Esthet Restor Dent, 34, pp.328~334 (2022)
  14. Souza RO, "Analysis of tooth enamel after excessive bleaching : a study using scanning electron microscopy and energy dispersive X-ray spectroscopy", Int J Prosthodont, 23, pp.29~32 (2010)
  15. Deng M, "Effects of 45S5 bioglass on surface properties of dental enamel subjected to 35% hydrogen peroxide", Int J Oral Sci, 5, pp.103~110 (2013)
  16. Yang SY, "Effects of incorporating 45S5 bioactive glass into 30% hydrogen peroxide solution on whitening efficacy and enamel surface properties", Clin Oral Investig, 26, pp.5301~5312 (2022)
  17. Adriano Fonseca Lima, "Antioxidant therapy enhances pulpal healing in bleached teeth", Restorative Dentistry and Endodontics, 41(1), pp.44~54 (2016), 대한치과보존학회
  18. Benetti F, "Hydrogen peroxide induces cell proliferation and apoptosis in pulp of rats after dental bleaching in vivo : effects of the dental bleaching in pulp", Arch Oral Biol, 81, pp.103~109 (2017)
  19. Benetti F, "Concentration-dependent effect of bleaching agents on the immunolabelling of interleukin-6, interleukin-17 and CD5-positive cells in the dental pulp", Int Endod J, 51, pp.789~799 (2018)
  20. Benetti F, "The presence of osteocalcin, osteopontin and reactive oxygen species-positive cells in pulp tissue after dental bleaching", Int Endod J, 52, pp.665~675 (2019)
  21. Benetti F, "In vivo analysis of the presence of heme oxygenase-1, transcription factor Jun-D and CD90+", CD73+, CD45- cells in the pulp of bleached teeth, pp.Int Endod J, 2019[DOI]
  22. Cintra LT, "Penetration capacity, color alteration and biological response of 2 in-office bleaching protocols", Braz Dent J, 27, pp.169~175 (2016)
  23. Soares DG, "Increased whitening efficacy and reduced cytotoxicity are achieved by the chemical activation of a highly concentrated hydrogen peroxide bleaching gel", J Appl Oral Sci, 27, pp.e20180453~ (2019)
  24. Lee DS, "Butein protects human dental pulp cells from hydrogen peroxide-induced oxidative toxicity via Nrf2 pathway-dependent heme oxygenase-1 expressions", Toxicol In Vitro, 27, pp.874~881 (2013)
  25. da Silva Livia Maria Alves Valentim, "Influence of pain-relieving therapies on inflammation and the expression of proinflammatory neuropeptides after dental bleaching treatment", Restorative Dentistry and Endodontics, 45(2), pp.1~14 (2020), 대한치과보존학회[DOI]
  26. Louzada LM, "Anti-inflammatory potential of a carvedilol gel in the pulpal tissue of rats after dental bleaching : a histopathological evaluation", J Investig Clin Dent, 10, pp.e12401~ (2019)
  27. Page MJ, "Updating guidance for reporting systematic reviews : development of the PRISMA 2020 statement", J Clin Epidemiol, 134, pp.103~112 (2021)
  28. Haddaway NR, "The role of google scholar in evidence reviews and its applicability to grey literature searching", PLoS One, 10, pp.e0138237~ (2015)
  29. Landis JR, "The measurement of observer agreement for categorical data", Biometrics, 33, pp.159~174 (1977)
  30. Hooijmans CR, "SYRCLE’s risk of bias tool for animal studies", BMC Med Res Methodol, 14, pp.43~ (2014)
  31. Dos Reis-Prado AH, "Comparison between immediate and delayed post space preparations : a systematic review and meta-analysis", Clin Oral Investig, 25, pp.417~440 (2021)
  32. Schulte JR, "The effects of bleaching application time on the dental pulp", J Am Dent Assoc, 125, pp.1330~1335 (1994)
  33. Soares DG, "Transenamel and transdentinal cytotoxicity of carbamide peroxide bleaching gels on odontoblast-like MDPC-23 cells", Int Endod J, 44, pp.116~125 (2011)
  34. Soares DG, "Efficacy and cytotoxicity of a bleaching gel after short application times on dental enamel", Clin Oral Investig, 17, pp.1901~1909 (2013)
  35. Soares DG, "Immediate and late analysis of dental pulp stem cells viability after indirect exposition to alternative in-office bleaching strategies", Clin Oral Investig, 19, pp.1013~1020 (2015)
  36. Guazzo R, "Graphene-based nanomaterials for tissue engineering in the dental field", Nanomaterials(Basel), 8, pp.349~ (2018)
  37. Babich H, "In vitro response of human gingival epithelial S-G cells to resveratrol", Toxicol Lett, 114, pp.143~153 (2000)
  38. Soares DG, "Effective tooth-bleaching protocols capable of reducing H2O2 diffusion through enamel and dentine", J Dent, 42, pp.351~358 (2014)
  39. Kwon SR, "Spectrophotometric evaluation of potassium nitrate penetration into the pulp cavity", Oper Dent, 40, pp.614~621 (2015)
  40. Kwon SR, "Time course of potassium nitrate penetration into the pulp cavity and the effect of penetration levels on tooth whitening efficacy", J Esthet Restor Dent, 28(Supplement 1), pp.S14~S22 (2016)
  41. Kwon SR, "Effect of bleaching gel viscosity on tooth whitening efficacy and pulp chamber penetration : an in vitro study", Oper Dent, 43, pp.326~334 (2018)
  42. Balladares L, "Effects of pH and application technique of in-office bleaching gels on hydrogen peroxide penetration into the pulp chamber", Oper Dent, 44, pp.659~667 (2019)
  43. Ma Q, "Impact of transparent tray-based application of bioactive glasses desensitizer on the permeability of enamel and dentin to hydrogen peroxide : an in vitro study", BMC Oral Health, 20, pp.103~ (2020)
  44. Parreiras SO, "Effect of prior application of desensitizing agent on the teeth submitted to in-office bleaching", Braz Dent J, 31, pp.236~243 (2020)
  45. Duque CC, "Bleaching effectiveness, hydrogen peroxide diffusion, and cytotoxicity of a chemically activated bleaching gel", Clin Oral Investig, 18, pp.1631~1637 (2014)
  46. Jeong GS, "Effects of sappanchalcone on the cytoprotection and anti-inflammation via heme oxygenase-1 in human pulp and periodontal ligament cells", Eur J Pharmacol, 644, pp.230~237 (2010)
  47. Lima AF, "Transdentinal protective role of sodium ascorbate against the cytopathic effects of H2O2 released from bleaching agents", Oral Surg Oral Med Oral Pathol Oral Radiol Endod, 109, pp.e70~e76 (2010)
  48. Choi YJ, "Cell-penetrating superoxide dismutase attenuates oxidative stress-induced senescence by regulating the p53-p21(Cip1)pathway and restores osteoblastic differentiation in human dental pulp stem cells", Int J Nanomedicine, 7, pp.5091~5106 (2012)
  49. Lee YH, "The survival role of peroxisome proliferator-activated receptor gamma induces odontoblast differentiation against oxidative stress in human dental pulp cells", J Endod, 39, pp.236~241 (2013)
  50. 이동성, "Cytoprotective Effects of Sulfuretin from Rhus verniciflua through Regulating of Heme Oxygenase-1 in Human Dental Pulp Cells", Natural Product Sciences, 19(1), pp.54~60 (2013), 한국생약학회
  51. Lee YH, "Anti-inflammatory effect of pachymic acid promotes odontoblastic differentiation via HO-1 in dental pulp cells", Oral Dis, 19, pp.193~199 (2013)
  52. Vargas FS, "Dose-response and time-course of α-tocoferol mediating the cytoprotection of dental pulp cells against hydrogen peroxide", Braz Dent J, 25, pp.367~371 (2014)
  53. da Silveira Vargas F, "Protective effect of alpha-tocopherol isomer from vitamin E against the H2O2 induced toxicity on dental pulp cells", BioMed Res Int, 2014, pp.895049~ (2014)
  54. Kim D, "The protective effect of indole-3-acetic acid(IAA)on H2O2-damaged human dental pulp stem cells is mediated by the AKT pathway and involves increased expression of the transcription factor nuclear factor-erythroid 2-related factor 2(Nrf2)and its downstream target heme oxygenase 1(HO-1)", Oxid Med Cell Longev, 2017, pp.8639485~ (2017)
  55. Kim NY, "Cinnamaldehyde protects human dental pulp cells against oxidative stress through the Nrf2", HO-1-dependent antioxidant response, 2017, pp.815, 73~79
  56. Huang S, "Blockade of cyclophilin D attenuates oxidative stress-induced cell death in human dental pulp cells", Oxid Med Cell Longev, 2019, pp.1729013~ (2019)
  57. Ortecho-Zuta U, "Effects of enzymatic activation of bleaching gels on hydrogen peroxide degradation rates, bleaching effectiveness, and cytotoxicity", Oper Dent, 44, pp.414~423 (2019)
  58. Ferreira L, "Otosporin reduces pulp inflammatory reactions after dental bleaching of rat molars", Dent Press Endod, 10, pp.54~61 (2020)
  59. Ribeiro R, "Influence of manganese oxide on the esthetic efficacy and toxicity caused by conventional in-office tooth bleaching therapy", Oper Dent, 47, pp.425~436 (2022)
  60. de Oliveira Ribeiro RA, "Manganese oxide increases bleaching efficacy and reduces the cytotoxicity of a 10% hydrogen peroxide bleaching gel", Clin Oral Investig, 26, pp.7277~7286 (2022)
  61. Moura SKSCF, "Design of a thermosensitive ibuprofen-loaded nanogel as smart material applied as anti-inflammatory in tooth bleaching : an in vivo study", J Drug Deliv Sci Technol, 68, pp.103123~ (2022)
  62. Dias MF, "A new approach for professional dental bleaching using a polymeric catalyst primer", J Esthet Restor Dent, 35, pp.406~415 (2023)
  63. Cintra LT, "Evaluation of an experimental rat model for comparative studies of bleaching agents", J Appl Oral Sci, 24, pp.95~104 (2016)
  64. Benetti F, "Influence of different types of light on the response of the pulp tissue in dental bleaching : a systematic review", Clin Oral Investig, 22, pp.1825~1837 (2018)
  65. Caviedes-Bucheli J, "The effect of tooth bleaching on substance P expression in human dental pulp", J Endod, 34, pp.1462~1465 (2008)
  66. Paula E, "The effect of perioperative ibuprofen use on tooth sensitivity caused by in-office bleaching", Oper Dent, 38, pp.601~608 (2013)
  67. Galler KM, "Inflammatory response mechanisms of the dentine-pulp complex and the periapical tissues", Int J Mol Sci, 22, pp.1480~ (2021)
  68. Vaseenon S, "Lipopolysaccharides and hydrogen peroxide induce contrasting pathological conditions in dental pulpal cells", Int Endod J, 56, pp.179~192 (2023)
  69. Panzarini SR, "Intracanal dressing and root canal filling materials in tooth replantation : a literature review", Dent Traumatol, 28, pp.42~48 (2012)
  70. Marinho AC, "Accuracy of turbidimetric limulus amebocyte lysate assay for the recovery of endotoxin interacted with commonly used antimicrobial agents of endodontic therapy", J Endod, 41, pp.1653~1659 (2015)
  71. Markovic L, "Micromorphology of enamel surface after vital tooth bleaching", J Endod, 33, pp.607~610 (2007)
  72. Jurema AL, "Effect of over-the-counter whitening products associated or not with 10% carbamide peroxide on color change and microhardness : in vitro study", J Contemp Dent Pract, 19, pp.359~366 (2018)
  73. Bayrak S, "Effects of casein phosphopeptide-amorphous calcium phosphate(CPP-ACP)application on enamel microhardness after bleaching", Am J Dent, 22, pp.393~396 (2009)
  74. Yassin O, "Effect of CPP-ACP on efficacy and postoperative sensitivity associated with at-home vital tooth bleaching using 20% carbamide peroxide", Clin Oral Investig, 23, pp.1555~1559 (2019)
  75. Pintado-Palomino K, "The effect of home-use and in-office bleaching treatments combined with experimental desensitizing agents on enamel and dentin", Eur J Dent, 9, pp.66~73 (2015)
  76. Charakorn P, "The effect of preoperative ibuprofen on tooth sensitivity caused by in-office bleaching", Oper Dent, 34, pp.131~135 (2009)
  77. de Souza Costa CA, "Methods to evaluate and strategies to improve the biocompatibility of dental materials and operative techniques", Dent Mater, 30, pp.769~784 (2014)
  78. de Oliveira Duque CC, "Influence of enamel", dentin thickness on the toxic and esthetic effects of experimental in-office bleaching protocols, 2017, pp.21, 2509~2520
  79. Llena C, "Hydrogen peroxide diffusion through enamel and dentin", Materials(Basel), 11, pp.1694~ (2018)
  80. Sato C, "Tooth bleaching increases dentinal protease activity", J Dent Res, 92, pp.187~192 (2013)
  81. Garcia EJ, "Immediate bonding to bleached enamel treated with 10% sodium ascorbate gel : a case report with one-year follow-up", Eur J Esthet Dent, 7, pp.154~162 (2012)
  82. The Council of the European Union, "Amending directive 76", 768, Off J Eur Union, pp.2011, 283[DOI]

관련 논문AI추천

Antioxidant therapy enhances pulpal healing in bleached teethAdriano Fonseca Lima, Carlos Alberto de Souza Costa, Diana Gabriela Soares, Giselle Maria Marchi, Josimeri Hebling, Marcelo Rocha Marques대한치과보존학회 · Restorative Dentistry and Endodontics2016 · 제41권 제1호Effect of medium or high concentrations of in-office dental bleaching gel on the human pulp response in the mandibular incisorsde Souza Costa Carlos Alberto, Favoreto Michael Willian, Loguercio Alessandro D., Reis Alessandra, Roderjan Douglas Augusto, Soares Diana Gabriela, Stanislawczuk Rodrigo대한치과보존학회 · Restorative Dentistry and Endodontics2023 · 제48권 제2호Evaluation of at-home bleaching protocol with application on different surfaces: bleaching efficacy and hydrogen peroxide permeabilityDias Roberta Micheten, Favoreto Michael Willian, Ferreira Borges Christiane Philippini, Forville Heloisa, Loguercio Alessandro D., Reis Alessandra, Wendlinger Michel대한치과보존학회 · Restorative Dentistry and Endodontics2023 · 제48권 제4호Effective application duration of sodium ascorbate antioxidant in reducing microleakage of bonded composite restoration in intracoronally-bleached teeth권태엽, 김영경, 박재영대한치과보존학회 · Restorative Dentistry and Endodontics2013 · 제38권 제1호Influence of pain-relieving therapies on inflammation and the expression of proinflammatory neuropeptides after dental bleaching treatmentBenetti Francine, Briso André Luiz Fraga, Cintra Luciano Tavares Angelo, da Silva Livia Maria Alves Valentim, de Alcântara Sibele, Ervolino Edilson, Gallinari Marjorie de Oliveira, Rahal Vanessa대한치과보존학회 · Restorative Dentistry and Endodontics2020 · 제45권 제2호Effect of three nanobiomaterials on microhardness of bleached enamelFarinaz Shirban, Maryam Khoroushi, Samaneh Doustfateme,, Sara Kaveh대한치과보존학회 · Restorative Dentistry and Endodontics2016 · 제41권 제3호

이 간행물의 다른 논문 (9건)

Micro-CT evaluation of the removal of root fillings using rotary and reciprocating systems supplemented by XP-Endo Finisher, the Self-Adjusting File, or Er,Cr:YSGG laserKiraz Gülsen, Kaya Bulem Üreyen, Ocak Mert, Uzuner Muhammet Bora, Çelik Hakan Hamdipp. 1-15Investigation of fracture prevalence of instruments used in root canal treatments at a faculty of dentistry: a prospective studyEskibağlar Mehmet, Özata Merve Yeniçeri, Ocak Mevlüt Sinan, Öztekin Farukpp. 1-10Does minimally invasive canal preparation provide higher fracture resistance of endodontically treated teeth? A systematic review of in vitro studiesUsta Sıla Nur, Silva Emmanuel João Nogueira Leal, Falakaloğlu Seda, Gündoğar Mustafapp. 1-12Evaluation of at-home bleaching protocol with application on different surfaces: bleaching efficacy and hydrogen peroxide permeabilityFavoreto Michael Willian, Forville Heloisa, Wendlinger Michel, Dias Roberta Micheten, Ferreira Borges Christiane Philippini, Reis Alessandra, Loguercio Alessandro D.pp. 1-12Effect of dentin roughening and type of composite material on the restoration of non-carious cervical lesions: an in vivo study with 18 months of follow-upVerma Sanjana, Singla Rakesh, Gill Gurdeep Singh, Jain Namitapp. 1-14
원문 보기