본문 바로가기
KERD
논문KCI 등재

Casualty Evacuation in Korea, 1950-53: The British Experience

Mark Harrison
대한의사학회 (The Korean Society For The History Of Medicine)|2023.08|의사학 (Korean Journal of Medical History)|제32권 제2호|pp. 503-552

0

조회

0

다운로드

0

인용

0

참고문헌

키워드

radioevacuationhelicopterambulanceBritish ArmyBritish Commonwealthcasualty
주제분류역사학

초록

The Korean War was the first conflict in which helicopters were used extensively for casualty evacuation but their contribution to medical evacuation at that time is disputed. On the one hand, many cases undoubtedly survived because of helicopter transportation; on the other, the proportion of casualties evacuated appears to have been small and difficult to determine precisely. Taking the British army as a case study, this article looks more closely at arrangements for casualty evacuation in Korea, assessing the role of helicopters in relation to other elements of the evacuation system and its operation as a whole. The article is divided into several sections. The first examines the command structure of the medical system in Korea, which extended as far back as hospitals in Japan. It shows how medical support for British forces was closely integrated with that of other Commonwealth forces. It notes that rapid and effective integration was a major factor in the success of medical evacuation because it allowed ideas and equipment to be shared easily and because it fostered a spirit of cooperation. This section also highlights the Second World service of all senior Commonwealth medical officers as a factor conducive to integration. The second section provides an overview of the chain of evacuation from the frontline to hospitals in Japan. It describes the functions of the different medical institutions along the chain and how they were connected. Among other things, it shows how the chain for British and Commonwealth troops intersected with medical units of the United States such as Mobile Army Surgical Hospitals and hospital trains. In the third section of the article, there is a detail examination of evacuation by helicopter, describing how it was arranged, what its limitations were, and what types of casualty were evacuated. It estimates the proportion of casualties that were evacuated by this means. The fourth and fifth sections highlight the importance of command decisions in the effective working of the evacuation system. The fourth concentrates on the evolution of a system of forward treatment of minor cases, looking at the challenge posed by disease and other non- battle casualties. The fifth and final section of the article describes how the system of evacuation functioned as a whole, including the different means used to carry the sick and wounded in addition to helicopters. It stresses the importance of coordination between these different elements and places particular emphasis on the value of wireless communications. The article concludes that the success of casualty evacuation in Korea depended less on any single method of transportation than on effective command and control. In this respect, communication between constituent units of the evacuation chain and cooperation between British and other UN forces was crucial. Of equal and perhaps even greater importance was the decision to implement a policy of forward treatment of sickness and minor injuries. Without such a policy, the lines of evacuation would inevitably have become congested, having a detrimental effect on casualty survival rates. This policy drew on the lessons of the two world wars which were still relatively fresh in the minds of medical commanders. Although far less striking than the advent of the helicopter, prior knowledge of coalition warfare and the handling of mass casualties was crucial to medical success. If there is a lesson to be learned from the Korean War for own times, it is probably this.

Abstract

The Korean War was the first conflict in which helicopters were used extensively for casualty evacuation but their contribution to medical evacuation at that time is disputed. On the one hand, many cases undoubtedly survived because of helicopter transportation; on the other, the proportion of casualties evacuated appears to have been small and difficult to determine precisely. Taking the British army as a case study, this article looks more closely at arrangements for casualty evacuation in Korea, assessing the role of helicopters in relation to other elements of the evacuation system and its operation as a whole. The article is divided into several sections. The first examines the command structure of the medical system in Korea, which extended as far back as hospitals in Japan. It shows how medical support for British forces was closely integrated with that of other Commonwealth forces. It notes that rapid and effective integration was a major factor in the success of medical evacuation because it allowed ideas and equipment to be shared easily and because it fostered a spirit of cooperation. This section also highlights the Second World service of all senior Commonwealth medical officers as a factor conducive to integration. The second section provides an overview of the chain of evacuation from the frontline to hospitals in Japan. It describes the functions of the different medical institutions along the chain and how they were connected. Among other things, it shows how the chain for British and Commonwealth troops intersected with medical units of the United States such as Mobile Army Surgical Hospitals and hospital trains. In the third section of the article, there is a detail examination of evacuation by helicopter, describing how it was arranged, what its limitations were, and what types of casualty were evacuated. It estimates the proportion of casualties that were evacuated by this means. The fourth and fifth sections highlight the importance of command decisions in the effective working of the evacuation system. The fourth concentrates on the evolution of a system of forward treatment of minor cases, looking at the challenge posed by disease and other non- battle casualties. The fifth and final section of the article describes how the system of evacuation functioned as a whole, including the different means used to carry the sick and wounded in addition to helicopters. It stresses the importance of coordination between these different elements and places particular emphasis on the value of wireless communications. The article concludes that the success of casualty evacuation in Korea depended less on any single method of transportation than on effective command and control. In this respect, communication between constituent units of the evacuation chain and cooperation between British and other UN forces was crucial. Of equal and perhaps even greater importance was the decision to implement a policy of forward treatment of sickness and minor injuries. Without such a policy, the lines of evacuation would inevitably have become congested, having a detrimental effect on casualty survival rates. This policy drew on the lessons of the two world wars which were still relatively fresh in the minds of medical commanders. Although far less striking than the advent of the helicopter, prior knowledge of coalition warfare and the handling of mass casualties was crucial to medical success. If there is a lesson to be learned from the Korean War for own times, it is probably this.

참고문헌 (68)

  1. "26 Field Ambulance, “War Diary, April 1951,” entries for 23 and 27 April, WO 281", 1269, The National Archives (hereafter TNA, UK)
  2. "“Action of 1 BW on feature HOOK – Night 18", 19 Nov 52,” Appendix A, 26 FA War Diary, November 1952, WO 281, ~
  3. "“Historical Notes: Medical Services. British and Commonwealth Forces in Korea,” pp. 1-3, Historical Notes: B.C.F.K., WO 308", 21, TNA
  4. "“I: Development of Staff Organization and General Medical Administration,” pp. 1-2, Historical Notes: B.C.F.K., WO 308", 21, TNA
  5. "“II: Medical Units,” p. 1, Historical Notes: B.C.F.K., WO 308", 21, TNA
  6. "“III: Army Health,” pp. 1-2, Historical Notes: B.C.F.K., WO 308", 21, TNA
  7. "Interview with Alan Guy (former SSgt., RAMC) and Lyn Guy, 07", 12, 1-5, Surrey history Centre, Woking, UK (2016)[DOI]
  8. "Interview with John Owen (former Sgt., RAMC), 26", 07, Museum of Military Medicine, UK (2023)[DOI]
  9. "Capt. T.A. Mac Lennan, 25 Canadian FA, “Questionnaire on Campaign in Korea,” 1952, RAMC 761", 4, WL
  11. "Col. G. Anderton, “answers to ‘Questionnaire on Campaign in Korea,’” 1952, RAMC 761", 4, WL
  12. "Col. Morgan Smith, “Monthly Liaison Letter. Serial 14 – Jul 1952,” RAMC 761", 4, WL
  13. "J.J. Bulow, ‘His recall of events whilst serving in Korea with the RADC – September 1952 to February 1954’, Papers of Capt. Bulow, RADC, RADC", PE, 109, pp.BULO, Museum of Military Medicine, Ash Vale, UK
  14. "Lt Col R.L. Marks, 26 FA, “Report for the month of Jul 52, Appendix A.: RAP Construction,” RAMC 761", 4, WL
  15. "Lt Col R.L. Marks, 26 FA, “Report for the month of Jun 52, Appendix C: Unit Personnel Stats,” RAMC 761", 4, WL
  16. "Lt Col R.L. Marks, “answers to ‘Questionnaire on Campaign in Korea’”, 1952, RAMC 761", 4, WL
  17. "Lt Col R.L. Marks, “A Medical Picture of the Forward Areas in Korea,” text of a presentation to the Royal Society of Medicine’s United Service Section, 10 June 1953, RAMC 1763, WL", ~
  18. "Maj. Montgomery, Questionnaire on Korean Campaign: Answers, Para.11, RAMC 761", 4, WL
  19. "Maj. P.M. Brentland, DDMS 1 Commonwealth Division, “Questionnaire on Campaign in Korea,” RAMC 761", 4, WL
  20. "Neville Hughes, “Korea 1951-5l,” Box 16, Cabinet No.1, Battalion Welch 1951", 1951, Korea, Combined Acc. Nos. 1993, ~
  21. "Sgt. ‘Tug’ Wilson, ‘New Year’s Eve Korea 51", 52’, Box 16, Cabinet No.1, Battalion Welch 1951, 182 & 183, Royal Welsh Regimental Museum, Brecon, UK (1952)[DOI]
  22. "Transcript of interview Philip Miles (Pip) Chambers, officer, Kings Shropshire Light Infantry, 6005", SHYKS, 2677, pp.26, Shropshire Archives, Shrewsbury, UK (2008)
  23. "Typescript of interview with Private George Andrew Casewell, Kings Shropshire Light Infantry, 6005", SHYKS, 2677, pp.24, Shropshire Archives, Shrewsbury, UK (2008)
  24. Anderton, Colonel G. O.B.E, "The Birth of the British Commonwealth Division, Korea", Journal of Royal Army Medical Corps, 99(1), pp.44~54 (1952)
  25. Anon, "Mountain Warfare", Journal of the Royal Army Medical Corps, pp.391~393 (1951)
  26. Anon, "The Medical Services in Korea", The Lancet, 261(6751), pp.154~ (1953)
  27. Brentland, Maj. P.M., "The Principles of Cold Injuries", Journal of the Royal Army Medical Corps, 100(2), pp.88~98 (1954)[DOI]
  28. "Medical Services in Korea", The Lancet, 257(6651), pp.896~ (1951)
  29. "The Lessons of War", The Lancet, 266(6808), pp.400~ (1954)
  30. Flood, J. J., "Psychiatric Casualties in U.K. Elements of the Korean Force: December 1950-November, 1951", Journal of the Royal Army Medical Corps, 100(1), pp.40~47 (1950)[DOI]
  31. Harris, F., "The Medical Services in the Korean War", The Lancet, 261(6751), pp.134~136 (1953)
  32. Harsant, A. G., "Proceedings of Royal Society of Medicine on Medical Problems in Korea", The Lancet, 261(6774), pp.1289~ (1953)
  33. Harvey, E. Bruce, "Casualty Evacuation by Helicopter in Malaya", British Medical Journal, 2(4730), pp.542~ (1951)
  34. Latta, Surg. Comdr. R. M., "Management of Battle Casualties from Korea", The Lancet, 257(6648), pp.228~231 (1951)
  35. Marks, R. L., "Proceedings of the Royal Society of Medicine on Medical Problems in Korea", The Lancet, 261(6774), pp.1288~ (1953)
  36. Royal Society of Medicine, "Medical Problems in Korea", The Lancet, 261(6774), pp.1289~ (1953)
  37. Watts, Lt Col J. C., "Cold Injury in Korea", Journal of the Royal Army Medical Corps, 97(6), pp.1~7 (1952)
  38. Watts, J.C., "War Surgery in the Korean Campaign", Postgraduate Medical Journal, pp.22~29 (1954)[DOI]
  39. "The British Army"[URL]
  40. "The U.S. Army Center of Military history"[URL]
  41. Bonanno, Joseph, "The Helicopter in Combat", Ordnance, 38(203), pp.868~872 (1954)
  42. Barr, Justin, "Helicopter medical evacuation in the Korean War : Did it matter?", Journal of Trauma Acute Care Surgery, 87(Suppl. 1), pp.10~13 (2019)[DOI]
  43. "In 1940s Burma, a New Kind of Flying Machine Joined the War: The Helicopter" (2019)[URL]
  44. Boyne, Walter J., "How the Helicopter Changed Modern Warfare" (2011), Pelican
  45. Chinnery, Philip D., "Vietnam : The Helicopter War" (1991), Naval Institute Press
  46. "Medevac from Luzon" (2010)[URL]
  47. Copp, Terry, "Battle Exhaustion: Soldiers and Psychiatrists in the Canadian Army, 1939-1945" (1990), McGill-Queen’s University Press
  48. Drew, Robert, "Commissioned Officers in the Medical Services of the British Army 1660-1960, Volume II" (1968), The Wellcome Historical Medical Library
  49. Driscoll, R. S., "New York Chapter history of Military Medicine Award. U. S. Army medical helicopters in the Korean War", Military Medicine, 166(4), pp.290~296 (2001)
  50. Fitzpatrick, K. Meghan, "Prostitutes, Penicillin and Prophylaxis : Fighting Venereal Disease in the Commonwealth Division during the Korean War, 1950–1953", Social distory of Medicine, 28(3), pp.555~575 (2015)
  51. Fitzpatrick, K. Meghan, "Invisible Scars : Mental Trauma and the Korean War" (2017), UBC Press
  52. Grey, Jeffrey, "The Commonwealth Armies and the Korean War : An Alliance Study" (1988), Manchester University Press
  53. Harrison, Mark, "Medicine and Victory : British Military Medicine in the Second World War" (2004), Oxford University Press
  54. Harrison, Mark, "The Medical War : British Military Medicine in the First World War" (2010), Oxford University Press
  55. Kim, Jeong-Ran, "Malaria and Colonialism in Korea, c. 1876–c. 1945", Social distory of Medicine, 29(2), pp.360~383 (2016)
  56. "Rise of the Helicopter during the Korean War" (2011)[URL]
  57. Linklater, Eric, "Our Men in Korea" (1952), HMSO
  58. Matthew, Allen, "Military Helicopter Doctrines of the Major Powers, 1945-1992" (1993), Greenwood Press
  59. Mackenzie, S. P., "Cold Comfort: The Politics of Winter Kit for British Troops in Korea, 1950-53", Journal of the Society for Army Historical Research, 89(359), pp.241~260 (2011)
  60. McIntyre, Darryl, "Australia in the Korean War 1950-53, Vol.1", pp.570~585 (1981), The Australian War Memorial and the Australian Government Publishing Service
  61. Nair, E. J., "A British Army Nurse in the Korean War" (2007), Tempus
  62. Olson, C. M., "Forward Aeromedical Evacuation : A Brief history, Lessons Learned from the Global War on Terror, and the Way Forward for US Policy", Journal of Acute Trauma Care Surgery, 75(Suppl. 2), pp.130~136 (2013)
  63. Parker, Lt Col Gary W., "A history of Marine Medium Helicopter Squadron 161" (1978), US Marine Corps distory and Museums Division
  64. Schrader, Charles R., "The First Helicopter War: Logistics and Mobility in Algeria, 1954-1962" (1999), Praeger
  65. Schwarzkopf, Konrad, "The First German Army Helicopter Evacuation Mission in World War 2", Air Medical Journal, 41(2), pp.257~258 (2022)
  66. Sibul, "Eric, A. Medical Railroading during the Korean War : 1950-1953", Railroad distory, 204, pp.64~80 (2011)
  67. Whatmore, D. E., "One Road to Imjin : A National Service Experience" (1993), Dew Line Publications
  68. "Battlefield Medicine in the Korean War" (2021)[URL]

관련 논문AI추천

Observations from the Korean War for Modern Military MedicineMartin CM Bricknell대한의사학회 · 의사학2023 · 제32권 제3호Unstable Expansion: The Development of the Military Medical Evacuation Chain in Korea, 1948–1953강재구, 박윤재대한의사학회 · 의사학2023 · 제32권 제2호한국전쟁기 의료지원 연구: 미 제8군 육군이동외과병원의 활동을 중심으로한봉석의학사연구소 · 연세의사학2021 · 제24권 제1호6·25전쟁 시기 육군 의무 체계 발전 고찰손경호육군군사연구소 · 군사연구2025 · 제160호Medicine in the Korean War: concluding reflectionsJeong-Ran Kim, Mark Harrison대한의사학회 · 의사학2023 · 제32권 제3호Development and Influence of Military Medicine during the Korean War: the Medical Field Service School and Training in the U.S.김진혁대한의사학회 · 의사학2023 · 제32권 제3호

이 간행물의 다른 논문 (9건)

Medicine in the Korean WarMark Harrison, 김정란pp. 453-462Unstable Expansion: The Development of the Military Medical Evacuation Chain in Korea, 1948–1953박윤재, 강재구pp. 463-501A Foundation for a “Cheerful Society”: The Korean War and the Rise of Psychiatry신지혜, 임성빈pp. 553-591의학교육에서 의사학의 자리를 찾아 (3) - 의과대학 의사학 교육 방법을 중심으로최은경pp. 593-594의과대학에서 의학사를 어떻게 가르칠 것인가?: 시기, 구성, 교수법박승만, 박지영pp. 595-621
원문 보기