과학교육에서 모델 및 모델링에 대한 고찰 -메타모델링 지식을 중심으로-
A Review of Model and Modeling in Science Education: Focus on the Metamodeling Knowledge
2
조회
0
다운로드
24
인용
0
참고문헌
키워드
초록
이 연구의 목적은 선행 연구를 바탕으로 하여 과학교육의 현장에서 모델과 모델링의 성공적인 적용을 위해 필요한 학생과 교사에게 요구 되는 모델과 모델링에 대한 지식을 의미하는 메타모델링 지식과 그구성요소에 대해서 고찰하는 것이다. 이를 위해 모델과 모델링에 대한 주요 선행 연구들을 문헌연구 방법을 통해 분석하고 범주화하였으 며, 과학교육에서 효과적으로 적용을 위한 시사점을 도출하고자 하였 다. 메타모델링 지식은 모델과 모델링에 대해 인식하는 것이고, 과학적 모델링 실습에서 과학적 모델을 만드는데 가장 결정적인 요소이다. 이 연구에서 제안하고자 하는 메타모델링 지식의 구성요소는 모델의 본성, 모델의 다양성, 모델의 목적, 모델링 과정, 모델의 평가와 수정 으로 범주화하였다. 모델의 본성에 대한 이해를 통해서 모델이 가지는 여러 가지 속성을 알게 되며 모델과 모델링에 대한 깊이 있는 이해의 틀을 가지게 된다. 모델의 다양성은 같은 자연 현상을 나타내기 위한 여러 모델이 존재하는 것과 모델의 분류에 대한 이해를 하는 것이다. 모델의 목적은 과학자들이 자연 현상을 설명하거나 예측하기 위해 모델을 만드는 것임을 학생들인 인식하여 모델을 구성하고 사용 함으로써 과학적 이해를 하는 것이다. 모델링 과정은 모델을 만들고 평가하고 수정으로 이루어진다는 것을 아는 것이다. 이를 통해 학생 들이 모델링 실습에 참여할 수 있게 되고, 교사는 모델링 실습에서 학생을 돕는 제대로 된 안내자의 역할을 할 수 있게 된다. 모델의 평가 및 수정은 학생들이 관찰한 자연 현상을 잘 설명하기 위해 다른 사람과의 의사소통을 통해 모델을 수정하는 일련의 과정으로 모델을 정교하게 만드는 것을 의미한다. 메타모델링 지식의 구성요소에 대한 이해를 통해 학생들과 교사들이 모델과 모델링에 대해서 느끼는 어려 움을 해결하고 과학교육에서 모델과 모델링 수업을 성공적으로 적용할 수 있는 지침을 제시할 수 있다.
Abstract
The purpose of this study is to examine metamodeling knowledge and its components, which means knowledge about model and modeling required for students and teachers for successful application of modeling in the field of science education based on research literature. For this, we analyzed and categorized major previous studies on modeling and modeling through research literature methods. Metamodeling knowledge aims to recognize models and modeling and is the most crucial element to create a scientific model in scientific modeling practice. The point of view of metamodeling knowledge proposed in this study is categorize nature of model, multiplicity of model, purpose of model, modeling process, and evaluation and revision of model. Students should be able to achieve more in-depth understanding through the awareness of the nature of the model. The development of metamodeling knowledge can facilitate students’ science learning.
참고문헌 (123)
- Abd-El-Khalick, F., "Inquiry in science education : international perspectives", Science Education, 88(3), pp.397~419 (2004)
- Adúriz-Bravo, A., "A semantic view of scientific models for science education", Science and Education, 22(7), pp.1593~1611 (2013)
- 안유라, "원자모형에 기초한 예비과학교사들의 과학의 본성에 대한 인식", 한국과학교육학회지, 31(4), pp.539~556 (2011), 한국과학교육학회
- Berland, L. K., "Making sense of argumentation and explanation", Science Education, 93(1), pp.26~55 (2008)
- Bogiages, C., "The development of a performance progression for science teachers’ implementation of model-based teaching", Doctor, pp.2014
- Böttcher, F., "Argumentation in science education : a model-based framework", Science and Education, 20(2), pp.103~140 (2011)
- Boulter, C. J., "Developing models in Science Education", pp.41~57 (2000), Kluwer Academic
- Brewe, E., "Modeling theory applied : modeling instruction in introductory physics", American Journal of Physics, 76(12), pp.1155~1160 (2008)
- Buckley, B. C., "Developing models in science education", pp.119~135 (2000), Kluwer Academic
- Campbell, T., "Discursive modes and their pedagogical functions in model-based inquiry(MBI)classrooms", International Journal of Science Education, 34(15), pp.2393~2419 (2012)
- Cartier, J., "Teaching the nature of inquiry : Further developments in a High School Genetics program", Science Education, 9(3), pp.247~267 (2000)
- 차정호, "과학적 모델에 대한 중.고등학생들의 견해", 대한화학회지, 48(6), pp.638~644 (2004), 대한화학회
- Chamizo, J. A., "A new definition of models and modeling in chemistry’ teaching", Science and Education, 22(7), pp.1613~1632 (2013)
- Chi, M. T. H., "Categorization and representation of physics problems by experts and novices", Cognitive Science, 5(2), pp.121~152 (1991)
- Cho, H. S., "Development and effect of argument-based modeling strategy as teaching method in middle school students", Doctor, pp.2014
- 조혜숙, "과학적 글쓰기를 활용한 논의-기반 모델링 전략의 개발", 한국과학교육학회지, 34(5), pp.479~490 (2014), 한국과학교육학회[DOI]
- 조혜숙, "중학교 과학수업에 적용한 글쓰기를 활용한 논의-기반 모델링 전략의 효과", 한국과학교육학회지, 34(6), pp.583~592 (2014), 한국과학교육학회[DOI]
- Clement, J. J., "Model-based learning as a key research area of science education", International Journal of Science Education, 22(9), pp.1041~1053 (2000)
- Clement, J. J., "An instructional model derived from model construction and criticism theory", pp.23~43 (2008), Kluwer Academic
- Crawford, B., "Research and the quality of science education", pp.309~323 (2005), Springer
- Crawford, B. A., "Supporting prospective teachers’conceptions of modelling in science", International Journal of Science Education, 26(11), pp.1379~1401 (2004)
- Davis, E. A., "MoDeLS: designing supports for teachers using scientific modeling", Paper presented at the Association for Science Teacher Education, 10 (2008)
- Devi, R., "Modelling students’construction of energy models in physics", Instructional Science, 24(4), pp.259~293 (1996)
- Everett, S., "Preservice elementary teachers’growth in knowledge of models in a science capstone course", International Journal of Science and Mathematics Education, 7(6), pp.1201~1225 (2009)
- Forbes, C. T., "Empirical validation of integrated learning performances for hydrologic phenomena : 3rd-grade students’ model-driven explanation-construction", Journal of Research in Science Teaching, 52(7), pp.895~921 (2015)
- Franco, C., "Developing models in science education", pp.93~118 (2000), Kluwer Academic Publishers
- Francoeur, E., "The forgotten tool : The design and use of molecular models", Social Studies of Science, 27(1), pp.17~40 (1997)
- Gilbert, J. K., "Model and modelling : routes to more authentic science education", International Journal of Science and Mathematics Education, 2(2), pp.115~130 (2004)
- Gilbert, J. K., "Visualization: Theory and Practice in Science Education", pp.3~24 (2008), Kluwer Academic
- Gilbert, J. K., "The International Handbook of Science Education", pp.53~66 (1997), Kluwer Academic
- Gilbert, J. K., "Models in explanations, part 1 : horses for courses", International Journal of Science Education, 20(1), pp.83~87 (1998)
- Gilbert, S. W., "Model building and a definition of science", Journal of Research in Science Teaching, 28(1), pp.73~79 (1991)
- Gil-Perez, D., "New trends in science education", International Journal of Science Education, 18(8), pp.889~901 (1996)
- Glynn, S. M., "Learning science in the schools: Research reforming practice", pp.3~33 (1995), Erlbaum
- Gobert, J. D., "Introduction to model-based teaching and learning in science education", International Journal of Science Education, 22(9), pp.891~894 (2000)
- Gobert, J. D., "Examining the relationship between students’ understanding of the nature of models and conceptual learning in biology, physics, and chemistry", International Journal of Science Education, 33(5), pp.653~684 (2011)
- Gobert, J. D., "Fostering students’ epistemologies of models via authentic model-based tasks", Journal of Science Education and Technology, 13(1), pp.7~22 (2004)
- Greca, I. M., "Mental models, conceptual models, and modelling", International Journal of Science Education, 22(1), pp.1~11 (2000)
- Greca, I. M., "Mental, physical, and mathematical models in the teaching and learning of Physics", Science Education, 85(6), pp.106~121 (2002)
- Grosslight, L., "Understanding models and their use in science : conceptions of middle and high school students and experts", Journal of Research in Science Teaching, 28(9), pp.799~822 (1991)
- Grünkorn, J., "Assessing students’ understandings of biological models and their use in science to evaluate a theoretical framework", International Journal of Science Education, 36(10), pp.1651~1684 (2014)
- Gunstone, R., "Teaching for science education: A human constructivist view", pp.133~163 (1998), Academic Press
- 하지희, "모델링 활동에 대한 과학고등학교 학생들의 인식", 영재교육연구, 19(1), pp.187~205 (2009), 한국영재학회
- Halloun, I. A., "Schematic Modeling for meaningful learning of physics", Journal of Research in Science Teaching, 33(9), pp.1019~1041 (1996)
- Halloun, I. A., "Mediated modeling in science education", Science and Education, 16(7), pp.653~697 (2007)
- Harrison, A. G., "Secondary students’ mental models of atoms and molecules : Implications for learning chemistry", Science Education, 80(5), pp.509~534 (1996)
- Harrison, A. G., "A typology of school science models", International Journal of Science Education, 22(9), pp.1011~1026 (2000)
- Henze, I., "The change of science teachers’ personal knowledge about teaching models and modelling in the context of science education reform", International Journal of Science Education, 29(15), pp.1819~1846 (2007)
- Hestenes, D., "Modeling is the name of the game", A presentation at the NSF Modeling Conference (1993)
- Hestenes, D., "Toward a modelling theory of physics instruction", American Journal of Physics, 55(5), pp.440~454 (1987)
- Hodson, D., "Re-thinking old ways : Towards a more critical approach to practical work in school science", Studies in Science Education, 22(1), pp.85~142 (1993)
- Hodson, D., "Learning science, learning about science, doing Science : different goals demand different learning methods", International Journal of Science Education, 36(15), pp.2534~2553 (2014)
- Hogan, K., "Cognitive comparisons of students’systems modelling in ecology", Journal of Science Education and Technology, 10(4), pp.319~345 (2001)
- 장은경, "모델링 탐구 활동에서의 대학생의 모델링 유형 분석 및 인식", 한국과학교육학회지, 32(1), pp.1~14 (2012), 한국과학교육학회
- 정현석, "과학적 모형에 대한 예비 과학교사들의 인식", 교사교육연구, 53(4), pp.682~692 (2014), 과학교육연구소[DOI]
- Johnson-Laird, P. N., "Mental Models in Cognitive Science", Cognitive Science, 4(1), pp.71~115 (1980)
- Jonassen, D., "Model building for conceptual change", Interactive Learning Environments, 13(1), pp.15~37 (2005)
- Justi, R., "Modeling, teachers’ views on the nature of modeling, and implications for the education of modelers", International Journal of Science Education, 24(4), pp.369~387 (2002)
- Justi, R., "Teachers’views on the nature of models", International Journal of Science Education, 25(11), pp.1369~1386 (2003)
- Kim, H. B., "The effect of a factory analogy on student motivation and understanding of the function of cell parts", Biology education, 29(4), pp.346~353 (2001)
- 김미영, "혈액 순환 모형 기반 수업에서 고등학생들의 개념 변화 분석", 한국과학교육학회지, 27(5), pp.379~393 (2007), 한국과학교육학회
- 김소정, "과학적 모델의 사회적 구성 수업에서 구현된 두 과학 교사의 실천적 지식의 내용", 한국과학교육학회지, 33(4), pp.807~825 (2013), 한국과학교육학회
- 김혜원, "언어기반진단도구를 활용한 모형중심 교수방법의 효과 탐색", 교육정보미디어연구, 19(2), pp.175~200 (2013), 한국교육정보미디어학회
- 김애정, "중학교 과학 교과서 물질 영역의 과학적 모형 유형 분석", 대한화학회지, 56(3), pp.363~370 (2012), 대한화학회
- Koponen, I., "Models and modelling in physics education: a critical re-analysis of philosophical underpinnings and suggestions for revisions", Science and Education, 16(7–8), pp.751~773 (2007)
- Kozma, R. B., "Multimedia and understanding : expert and novice responses to different representations of chemical phenomena", Journal of Research in Science Teaching, 34(9), pp.949~968 (1997)
- Krell, M., "Students’understanding of the purpose of models in different biological contexts", International Journal of Biology Education, 2(2), pp.1~34 (2012)
- Krell, M., "Analyzing students’understanding of models and modeling referring to the disciplines biology, chemistry, and physics", Research in Science Education, 45(3), pp.367~393 (2014)
- Lederman, N. G., "Handbook of research on science education", pp.831~879 (2007), Lawrence Erlbaum Associates
- Lee, J. M., "Cognitive phychology" (2015), Hakgisa
- Lee, M. J., "Children’s mental models of the free-fall of objects", Journal of the Korean Association for Research in Science Education, 19(3), pp.389~399 (1999)
- Lim, H. J., "High school students’ understanding of the atomic model and orbitals", Journal of the Korean Association for Research in Science Education, 25(2), pp.297~306 (2005)
- Luisi, P. L., "The pictographic molecular paradigm : Pictorial communication in the chemical and biological sciences", Naturwissenschaften, 77(2), pp.67~74 (1990)
- Mandinach, E., "Systems, science and schools", System Dynamics Review, 9(2), pp.195~206 (1993)
- Mendonca, P. C. C., "An instrument for analyzing arguments produced in modeling-based chemistry lessons", Journal of research in science teaching, 51(2), pp.192~218 (2013)
- Ministry of Education(MOE), "2015 revised curriculum–Science", Ministry of Education, ~ (2015)
- Morrison, M., "Models as mediators", pp.10~37 (1999), Cambridge University Press
- National Research Council, "National education standards" (1996), National Academy Press
- National Research Council, "A framework for K-12 science education:practices, cross-cutting concepts, and core ideas. committee on a conceptual Framework for new K-12 science education standards" (2012), National Academy Press
- NGSS Lead States, "Next generation science standards: For states, by states" (2013), National Academies Press
- Nisbett, R. E., "Telling more than we can know : verbal reports on mental processes", Psychological Review, 84(3), pp.231~259 (1977)
- Odenbaugh, J., "Idealized, inaccurate but successful : a pragmatic approach to evaluating models in theoretical ecology", Biology and Philosophy, 20, pp.231~255 (2005)
- 오필석, "중등학교 지구과학 수업에서 과학적 모델의 활용 양상 분석:대기 및 해양 지구과학 관련 수업을 중심으로", 한국과학교육학회지, 27(7), pp.648~665 (2007), 한국과학교육학회
- 오필석, "과학과 과학 교육에서 사용되는 모델에 관한 예비 초등 교사들의 인식", 초등과학교육, 28(4), pp.450~466 (2009), 한국초등과학교육학회
- Oh, P. S., "What teachers of science need to know about models : an overview", International Journal of Science Education, 33(8), pp.1109~1130 (2011)
- Osborne, J. F., "Scientific argument and explanation : a necessary distinction?", Science Education, 95(4), pp.627~638 (2011)
- Ornek, F., "Models in science education : applications of models in learning and teaching Science", International Journal of Environmental & Science Education, 3(2), pp.35~45 (2008)
- Passmore, C., "Model-based inquiry and school science : creating connections", School Science and Mathematics, 109(7), pp.394~402 (2009)
- Passmore, C., "Exploring opportunities for argumentation in modelling classrooms", International Journal of Science Education, 34(10), pp.1535~1554 (2012)
- Penner, D. E., "Cognition, computers, and synthetic science: building knowledge and meaning through modeling", Review of Research in Education, 25, pp.1~35 (2001)
- Piburn, M. D., "The hidden earth: visualization of geologic features and their subsurface geometry", Paper presented at the annual meeting of National Association for Research in Science Teaching (2002)
- Portides, D. P., "The relation between idealization and approximation in scientific model construction", Science and Education, 16(7), pp.699~624 (2007)
- Raghavan, K., "Model-based analysis and reasoning in science : The MARS Curriculum", Science Education, 79(1), pp.37~61 (1995)
- Redish, E. F., "The implications of cognitive studies for teaching physics", American Journal of Physics, 62(9), pp.792~803 (1994)
- Richards, J., "Computer simulation in the science classroom", Journal of Science Education and Technology, 1(1), pp.67~79 (1992)
- Romberg, T., "Understanding mathematics and science matters", pp.3~26 (2005), Erlbaum
- Rosenblueth, A., "The role of models in science", Philosophy of Science, 12(4), pp.316~321 (1945)
- Rouse, W. B., "On looking into the black box : Prospects and limits in the search for mental models", Psychological Bulletin, 100(3), pp.349~363 (1986)
- Schecker, H. P., "Learning physics by making models", Physics Education, 28(2), pp.102~106 (1993)
- Schwarz, C. V., "Keeping learning complex: The Proceedings of the Fifth International Conference of the Learning Sciences (ICLS)" (2002), Erlbaum
- Schwarz, C. V., "Developing preservice elementary teachers’knowledge and practices through modeling-centered scientific inquiry", Science Education, 93(4), pp.720~744 (2009)
- Schwarz, C. V., "Using a guided inquiry and modeling instructional framework(EIMA)to support preservice K-8science teaching", Science Education, 91(1), pp.158~186 (2007)
- Schwarz, C. V., "Developing a learning progression for scientific modeling : making scientific modeling accessible and meaningful for learners", Journal of Research in Science Teaching, 46(6), pp.632~654 (2009)
- Schwarz, C. V., "Metamodeling knowledge : developing students’ understanding of scientific modeling", Cognition and Instruction, 23(2), pp.165~205 (2005)
- 심영숙, "연소 모델의 사회적 구성과정에서 나타나는 소집단 활동 특징 탐색", 한국과학교육학회지, 35(2), pp.217~229 (2015), 한국과학교육학회[DOI]
- Sins, P. H. M., "The difficult process of scientific modelling : An analysis of novices’reasoning during computer-based modelling", International Journal of Science Education, 27(14), pp.1695~1721 (2005)
- Sins, P., "The relation between students’epistemological understanding of computer models and their cognitive processing on a modelling task", International Journal of Science Education, 31(9), pp.1205~1229 (2009)
- Snow, R. E., "New approaches to cognitive and conative assessment in education", International Journal of Educational Research, 14(5), pp.455~473 (1990)
- Stewart, J., "Science as model building : Computers and high-school genetics", Educational Psychologist, 27(3), pp.317~336 (1992)
- Stratford, S. J., "Secondary students’dynamic modelling processes : Analysing, reasoning about, synthesizing, and testing models of stream ecosystems", Journal of Science Education and Technology, 7(3), pp.215~234 (1998)
- Talanquer, V., "Macro, submicro, and symbolic : the many faces of the chemistry"triplet"", International Journal of Science Education, 33(2), pp.179~195 (2011)
- Treagust, D. F., "Students’understanding of the role of scientific models in learning science", International Journal of Science Education, 24(4), pp.357~368 (2002)
- Treagust, D. F., "Students’understanding of the descriptive and predictive nature of teaching models in organic chemistry", Research in Science Education, 34(1), pp.1~20 (2004)
- Valanides, C., "Learning and teaching about scientific models with a computer-modeling tool", Computers in Human Behavior, 24(2), pp.220~233 (2008)
- van Driel, J. H., "Teachers’ knowledge of models and modeling in science", International Journal of Science Education, 21(11), pp.1141~1153 (1999)
- van Driel, J. H., "Experienced teachers’ knowledge of teaching and learning of models and modeling in science education", International Journal of Science Education, 24(12), pp.1255~1272 (2002)
- Vosniadou, S., "Capturing and modeling the process of conceptual change", Learning and Instruction, 4(1), pp.45~69 (1994)
- White, B. Y., "Thinker Tools : causal models, conceptual change, and science education", Cognition and Instruction, 10(1), pp.1~100 (1993)
- White, B. Y., "Inquiry, modeling, and metacognition : Making science accessible to all students", Cognition and Instruction, 16(1), pp.3~118 (1998)
- Windschitl M., "Beyond the scientific method : Model-Based Inquiry as a new paradigm of preference for school science investigations", Science Education, 92(5), pp.941~967 (2008)
- Windschitl, M., "The modeling toolkit", Science Teacher, 80(6), pp.63~69 (2013)
- 윤혜경, "초등 예비교사의 자기 모델 탐구 과정과 과학적 모델에 대한 이해 변화", 초등과학교육, 30(3), pp.353~366 (2011), 한국초등과학교육학회
- Zhang, B., "Using computer-based modelling for primary science learning and assessment", Paper presented at the 32nd Annual Conference of the International Association of Educational Assessment (IAEA) on “Assessment in an Era of Rapid Change: Innovations and Best Practices” (2006)
