Microdebrider와 Coblation을 이용한 하비갑개 수술의 장기적 효과에 대한 비교 연구
The Long Term Efficacy of Microdebrider Assisted versus Coblation Assisted Inferior Turbinoplasty
2
조회
0
다운로드
3
인용
0
참고문헌
초록
Background and Objectives The study aimed to evaluate the long term efficacy of micro-debrider assisted inferior turbinoplasty (MAIT) compared to coblation assisted inferior turbinoplasty (CAIT) for hypertrophic inferior turbinates. Subjects and Method From January 2008 to December 2008 inclusively, 96 patients with persistent hypertrophic inferior turbinates mucosa refractory to medical therapy were enrolled into this study. All patients were suffering from nasal obstruction and related symptoms. Overall, 56 patients were treated with microdebrider assisted inferior turbinoplasty (MAIT group) and 40 patients were treated with coblation assisted inferior turbinoplasty (CAIT group). Postoperative changes in degree of nasal obstruction, sneezing, rhinorrhea, minimal cross sectional area (MCA), and nasal volume from the nostril to 7 cm posteriorly (V7), operation time, duration of crust formation, intraoperative bleeding and delayed bleeding were compared be-tween the two surgical methods prospectively in the 1st and 6 months, and in the 1st and 2nd years after the procedure. Also patient’s satisfaction with procedure was evaluated. Results The nasal obstruction and related nasal symptoms improved significantly in MAIT group and persisted within the periods of 2 years after surgery, while in CAIT group the significant improvements took place in the 1st and 6th months after surgery but no significant improvements from 1 to 2 years after were noted. Nasal patency (MCA and V7) also showed more improvement and persistence in MAIT group than CAIT group. There were no significant differences in operation time and intraoperative bleeding and delayed bleeding but the duration of crust formation was significantly shorter in MAIT group. And patient satisfaction in the MAIT group was higher than that in the CAIT group. Conclusion From the analysis of this study, it can be said that MAIT is more effective and satisfactory for the long term relief of nasal obstruction, related nasal symptoms and reduction of hypertrophic inferior turbinate mucosa than CAIT.
Abstract
Background and Objectives The study aimed to evaluate the long term efficacy of micro-debrider assisted inferior turbinoplasty (MAIT) compared to coblation assisted inferior turbinoplasty (CAIT) for hypertrophic inferior turbinates. Subjects and Method From January 2008 to December 2008 inclusively, 96 patients with persistent hypertrophic inferior turbinates mucosa refractory to medical therapy were enrolled into this study. All patients were suffering from nasal obstruction and related symptoms. Overall, 56 patients were treated with microdebrider assisted inferior turbinoplasty (MAIT group) and 40 patients were treated with coblation assisted inferior turbinoplasty (CAIT group). Postoperative changes in degree of nasal obstruction, sneezing, rhinorrhea, minimal cross sectional area (MCA), and nasal volume from the nostril to 7 cm posteriorly (V7), operation time, duration of crust formation, intraoperative bleeding and delayed bleeding were compared be-tween the two surgical methods prospectively in the 1st and 6 months, and in the 1st and 2nd years after the procedure. Also patient’s satisfaction with procedure was evaluated. Results The nasal obstruction and related nasal symptoms improved significantly in MAIT group and persisted within the periods of 2 years after surgery, while in CAIT group the significant improvements took place in the 1st and 6th months after surgery but no significant improvements from 1 to 2 years after were noted. Nasal patency (MCA and V7) also showed more improvement and persistence in MAIT group than CAIT group. There were no significant differences in operation time and intraoperative bleeding and delayed bleeding but the duration of crust formation was significantly shorter in MAIT group. And patient satisfaction in the MAIT group was higher than that in the CAIT group. Conclusion From the analysis of this study, it can be said that MAIT is more effective and satisfactory for the long term relief of nasal obstruction, related nasal symptoms and reduction of hypertrophic inferior turbinate mucosa than CAIT.
참고문헌 (22)
- Liu CM, "Microdebrider-assisted versus radiofrequency-assisted inferior turbinoplasty", Laryngoscope, 119(2), pp.414~418 (2009)
- Cingi C, "Microdebrider-assisted versus radiofrequency-assisted inferior turbinoplasty:a prospective study with objective and subjective outcome measures", Acta Otorhinolaryngol Ital, 30(3), pp.138~143 (2010)
- Lee JY, "Comparative study on the long-term effectiveness between coblation- and microdebrider-assisted partial turbinoplasty", LARYNGOSCOPE, 116(5), pp.729~734 (2006), LIPPINCOTT WILLIAMS & WILKINS
- Kizilkaya Z, "Comparison of radiofrequency tissue volume reduction and submucosal resection with microdebrider in inferior turbinate hypertrophy", Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg, 138(2), pp.176~181 (2008)
- Hol MK, "Treatment of inferior turbinate pathology:a review and critical evaluation of the different techniques", Rhinology, 38(4), pp.157~166 (2000)
- Bergler WF, "Long-term results of inferior turbinate reduction with argon plasma coagulation", Laryngoscope, 111(9), pp.1593~1598 (2001)
- Lagerholm S, "Laser-turbinectomy:long-term results", J Laryngol Otol, 113(6), pp.529~531 (1999)
- Lin HC, "Radiofrequency for the treatment of allergic rhinitis refractory to medical therapy", Laryngoscope, 113(4), pp.673~678 (2003)
- Lee CF, "Power microdebrider-assisted modification of endoscopic inferior turbinoplasty:a preliminary report", Chang Gung Med J, 27(5), pp.359~365 (2004)
- 홍순관, "레이저 대 Coblation 하비갑개성형술：수술 성적에 의한 비교 연구", 대한이비인후과학회지 두경부외과학, 45(6), pp.589~593 (2002), 대한이비인후과학회
- Van delden MR, "Endoscopic partial inferior turbinoplasty", Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg, 121(4), pp.406~409 (1999)
- Wexler D, "Partial inferior turbinectomy using the microdébrider", J Otolaryngol, 34(3), pp.189~193 (2005)
- Friedman M, "A safe,alternative technique for inferior turbinate reduction", Laryngoscope, 109(11), pp.1834~1837 (1999)
- Bielamowicz S, "Endosocopic inferior turbinate reduction:a new technique", Laryngoscope, 109(6), pp.1007~1009 (1999)
- Powell NB, "Radiofrequency volumetric reduction of the tongue.A porcine pilot study for the treatment of obstructive sleep apnea syndrome", Chest, 111(5), pp.1348~1355 (1997)
- Kim CS, "Correlation between nasal obstruction symptoms and objective parameters of acoustic rhinometry and rhinomanometry", Auris Nasus Larynx, 25(1), pp.45~48 (1998)
- McCaffrey TV, "Clinical evaluation of nasal obstruction.A study of 1,000 patients", Arch Otolaryngol, 105(9), pp.542~545 (1979)
- Chen YL, "Comparison of microdebrider-assisted inferior turbinoplasty and submucosal resection for children with hypertrophic inferior turbinates", Int J Pediatr Otorhinolaryngol, 71(6), pp.921~927 (2007)
- Chen YL, "Long-term efficacy of microdebrider-assisted inferior turbinoplasty with lateralization for hypertrophic inferior turbinates in patients with perennial allergic rhinitis", Laryngoscope, 118(7), pp.1270~1274 (2008)
- Wolfswinkel EM, "A modified technique for inferior turbinate reduction:the integration of coblation technology", Plast Reconstr Surg, 126(2), pp.489~491 (2010)
- Farmer SE, "Efficacy of inferior turbinate coblation for treatment of nasal obstruction", J Laryngol Otol, 123(3), pp.309~314 (2009)
- Leong SC, "Coblation® inferior turbinate reduction:a long-term follow-up with subjective and objective assessment", Rhinology, 48(1), pp.108~112 (2010)