본문 바로가기
KERD
논문KCI 등재

우리나라 내부통제제도의 문제점과 개선방안에 관한 소고

A Study on the Problems and Improvement of Internal Control System in Korea

0

조회

0

다운로드

11

인용

0

참고문헌

키워드

주제분류법학

초록

As the management of a company is always accompanied by the risk, the internal control that manages risk can be thought as a business management itself. In that compliance is weak in Korea, building an internal control system is important for the company law to manage risk and compliance with applicable laws and regulations Also, the requirement of building an internal control system stems from the corporate director's duty of oversight. As Korea should follow the trend of active movement for adapting for the fast changes surrounding company such as globalization, marketization, high-tech of the world economy, it cannot avoid the requirement of building an internal control system as a way of protecting investors. Thus, considering the business environment in Korea where the risk management and compliance are not strong, the introduction of an internal control system is required for general companies. And these should be considered when it comes to the institutionalization. First, the concept, object, and constituents of the commercial law should be based on the frame of the internal control in the COSO report. However, the improvement of effectiveness and efficiency of operations and compliance would be focused among those three topics of the internal report. Second, if the internal control is legalized as a commercial law, the additional internal control for the financial institutions which is not necessary should be discarded. Third, the internal control on a financial report should be modified with respect to the specific situation of Korea. In other words, the effectiveness evaluation report of an internal accounting manager should be changed to the effectiveness evaluation report of a manager. And the role and responsibility of the organization should be clarified on building and operating of the internal control system. However, It should be noted that there is a limitation even if an internal control provide the reasonable assurance. Thus the effort to monitor and improve the system should be followed after building an internal control system.

Abstract

As the management of a company is always accompanied by the risk, the internal control that manages risk can be thought as a business management itself. In that compliance is weak in Korea, building an internal control system is important for the company law to manage risk and compliance with applicable laws and regulations Also, the requirement of building an internal control system stems from the corporate director's duty of oversight. As Korea should follow the trend of active movement for adapting for the fast changes surrounding company such as globalization, marketization, high-tech of the world economy, it cannot avoid the requirement of building an internal control system as a way of protecting investors. Thus, considering the business environment in Korea where the risk management and compliance are not strong, the introduction of an internal control system is required for general companies. And these should be considered when it comes to the institutionalization. First, the concept, object, and constituents of the commercial law should be based on the frame of the internal control in the COSO report. However, the improvement of effectiveness and efficiency of operations and compliance would be focused among those three topics of the internal report. Second, if the internal control is legalized as a commercial law, the additional internal control for the financial institutions which is not necessary should be discarded. Third, the internal control on a financial report should be modified with respect to the specific situation of Korea. In other words, the effectiveness evaluation report of an internal accounting manager should be changed to the effectiveness evaluation report of a manager. And the role and responsibility of the organization should be clarified on building and operating of the internal control system. However, It should be noted that there is a limitation even if an internal control provide the reasonable assurance. Thus the effort to monitor and improve the system should be followed after building an internal control system.

참고문헌 (24)

  1. 김완섭, "기업의 내부통제제도에 대한 한국과 미국의 규정 비교연구", 경인논집, (16) (2009)
  2. 박세화, "효과적인 내부통제 체제 구축을 위한 입법적 과제", 재산법연구, 23(2), pp.381~417 (2006), 한국재산법학회
  3. 기업의 내부통제에 관한 연구, "박정수", 한국법제연구원, ~ (2006)
  4. 정쾌영, "內部統制制度에 관한 考察 -監事·監査委員會의 監査機能 提高를 중심으로 -", 상사법연구, 26(3), pp.5~82 (2007), 한국상사법학회
  5. 林 重 鎬, "監事·監査委員會의 業務監査權의 範圍", 중앙법학, 6(4), pp.305~325 (2004), 중앙법학회
  6. 임중호, "監査委員會 監査의 現狀과 課題", 중앙법학, 10(3), pp.141~171 (2008), 중앙법학회
  7. 안수현, "내부통제의 회사법제 정비를 위한 검토", 상사판례연구, 20(2), pp.27~78 (2007), 한국상사판례학회
  8. 정대, "株式會社 理事의 內部統制義務에 관한 硏究 -대법원 2008.9.11. 선고 2006다68636 판결-", 상사판례연구, 21(4), pp.169~202 (2008), 한국상사판례학회
  9. 정대, "美國의 株式會社의 內部統制制度와 理事의 義務에 관한 硏究", 비교사법, 12(4), pp.369~423 (2005), 한국비교사법학회
  10. "Committee of Sponsoring Organization of the Treadway Commission", Internal Control-Integrated Framework, ~ (1994)
  11. Donald C. Langevoort, "Internal Controls After Sarbanes-Oxley: Revising Corporate Law's Duty of Cares As Responsibility for Systems", J. Corp. L, 31, pp.946~ (2006)
  12. Eisenberg, "The board of Directors of Directors and Internal Control", Cardozo. Rev, 19, pp.237~ (1997)
  13. Joel Seligman, "Accounting and the New Corporate Law", 中央法學, 12(1) (1993)
  14. Robert H. Montgomery, "Auditing Theory and Practice" (1912), The Roland Press Company
  15. 神作裕之, "会社の機関-選択の自由と強制", 商事法務, (1775)
  16. 黒沼悅郞, "新会社法と証券市場法制との関係", 法律時報, 78(5)
  17. 吉川吉衛, "会社法の現代化と内部統制システム - 企業において在るべきシステム-", 経営研究, 56(4)
  18. 相澤哲, "論点解説 新․会社法" (2006), 商事法務
  19. 森 淳二郞, "会社法における主要論点の評価, 中央経済社. in: 委員会等設置会社における監査委員の資格と職務 - 常勤者不在の場合監査と内部統制", 月間監査役, (472) (2007)
  20. 柿崎, "内部統制の法的研究" (2006), 日本評論社
  21. 柿崎, "内部統制と新会社法", 法律時報, 78(5)
  22. 大崎貞和, "解説 金融商品取引法" (2006), 弘文堂
  23. 小林秀之編著, "内部統制と取締役の責任" (2007), 学陽書房
  24. 兼田克幸, "内部統制報告제도の社会的役割及び制度上の諸課題", 企業法研究, (21)

관련 논문AI추천

이 간행물의 다른 논문 (11건)