A Systematic Review on Cognitive Effects of Electroconvulsive Therapy in Asian Patients
1
조회
0
다운로드
0
인용
0
참고문헌
키워드
초록
Objective: Electroconvulsive therapy (ECT) is the most efficacious treatment for many major mental illnesses but is limited by cognitive side effects. However, research on the pattern and severity of ECT-related cognitive side effects is inconsistent. Furthermore, little is known about the cognitive effects of ECT in Asian populations. A systematic review was conducted to examine objective cognitive performance following ECT in the Asian context. Methods: This review systematically identified studies assessing ECT-related cognitive effects in PubMED, PsychINFO, The Cochrane Library, Journal of ECT and major databases in Asian countries. The search included publications from peer-reviewed journals of languages other than English. Results: A total of 6,322 studies were identified; 823 were assessed for eligibility, of which 16 studies met the search criteria and were included in this review. Majority used high dose Bitemporal ECT for Depression and/or Schizophrenia. Cognitive impairment, which could occur immediate to the first ECT session, was reported in only 9 out of the 16 studies. However, deficits were observed to resolve as early as 3 weeks after the initiation of ECT. The remaining studies reported no impairment or even improvement after ECT. Conclusion: There is no consistent evidence that suggests ECT causes cognitive deficits in patients, despite the widespread use of high dose Bitemporal ECT. This review suggests that Asian patients, presenting with a different psychiatric profile, may respond to high-dose Bitemporal ECT differently from Western samples.
Abstract
Objective: Electroconvulsive therapy (ECT) is the most efficacious treatment for many major mental illnesses but is limited by cognitive side effects. However, research on the pattern and severity of ECT-related cognitive side effects is inconsistent. Furthermore, little is known about the cognitive effects of ECT in Asian populations. A systematic review was conducted to examine objective cognitive performance following ECT in the Asian context. Methods: This review systematically identified studies assessing ECT-related cognitive effects in PubMED, PsychINFO, The Cochrane Library, Journal of ECT and major databases in Asian countries. The search included publications from peer-reviewed journals of languages other than English. Results: A total of 6,322 studies were identified; 823 were assessed for eligibility, of which 16 studies met the search criteria and were included in this review. Majority used high dose Bitemporal ECT for Depression and/or Schizophrenia. Cognitive impairment, which could occur immediate to the first ECT session, was reported in only 9 out of the 16 studies. However, deficits were observed to resolve as early as 3 weeks after the initiation of ECT. The remaining studies reported no impairment or even improvement after ECT. Conclusion: There is no consistent evidence that suggests ECT causes cognitive deficits in patients, despite the widespread use of high dose Bitemporal ECT. This review suggests that Asian patients, presenting with a different psychiatric profile, may respond to high-dose Bitemporal ECT differently from Western samples.
참고문헌 (29)
- Fink M, "Electroconvulsive therapy: a guide for professionals and their patients" (2010), Oxford University Press
- Rasmussen KG, "What type of cognitive testing should be part of routine electroconvulsive therapy practice?", J ECT, 32, pp.7~12 (2016)
- van Schaik AM, "Cognitive impairment and electroconvulsive therapy in geriatric depression, what could be the role of rivastigmine? A case series", Clin Pract, 5, pp.780~ (2015)
- Sackeim HA, "The cognitive effects of electroconvulsive therapy in community settings", Neuropsychopharmacology, 32, pp.244~254 (2007)
- UK ECT Review Group, "Efficacy and safety of electroconvulsive therapy in depressive disorders : a systematic review and meta-analysis", Lancet, 361, pp.799~808 (2003)
- Semkovska M, "Objective cognitive performance associated with electroconvulsive therapy for depression : a systematic review and meta-analysis", Biol Psychiatry, 68, pp.568~577 (2010)
- Ingram A, "Cognitive side effects of brief pulse electroconvulsive therapy : a review", J ECT, 24, pp.3~9 (2008)
- Berman RM, "Subjective evaluation of the therapeutic and cognitive effects of electroconvulsive therapy", Brain Stimul, 1, pp.16~26 (2008)
- Wang W, "Efficacy and safety of treating patients with refractory schizophrenia with antipsychotic medication and adjunctive electroconvulsive therapy : a systematic review and meta-analysis", Shanghai Arch Psychiatry, 27, pp.206~219 (2015)
- Bagadia VN, "Evaluation of cognitive effects of ect(preliminary observations)", Indian J Psychiatry, 23, pp.324~329 (1981)
- Chatterjee SB, "Evalution of unilateral electroconvulsive therapy(a double blind study)", Indian J Psychiatry, 22, pp.185~194 (1980)
- Li Q, "The effect of MECT on the cognitive abilities of treatment-resistant depression patients", Shandong Med, 55, pp.41~43 (2015)
- Prakash J, "Evaluation of nonmemory cognitive parameters in psychiatric patients' preand post-electroconvulsive therapy : an observational study", Ind Psychiatry J, 24, pp.206~209 (2015)
- Tan L, "Effect of modified electroconvulsive therapy on memory and abstract thinking in depression", Shanghai Arch Psychiatry, 16, pp.17~19 (2004)
- Tor PC, "Effectiveness of electroconvulsive therapy and associated cognitive change in schizophrenia : a naturalistic, comparative study of treating schizophrenia with electroconvulsive therapy", J ECT, 33, pp.272~277 (2017)
- Zhang J, "Effect of modified electroconvulsive therapy (MECT) on executive functioning of adolescent patients with schizophrenia", J Psychiatry, 27, pp.30~32 (2014)
- Guo X, "A study on effect of Modified Electroconvulsive Therapy on memory of patients with depression", Sichuan Ment Health, 26, pp.219~222 (2003)
- Lou D, "Effect of modified electroconvulsive therapy on the cognition of patients with major depressive disorder", J Chongqing Med Uni, 36, pp.342~343 (2011)
- Song Z, "Study of efficacy and effect on cognitive function of modified electroconvulsive therapy in treatment of depression with different electrode places", J Neurosci Mental Health, 10, pp.274~275 (2010)
- Zhou H, "A comparative study of modified electroconvulsive therapy combined with Olanzapine in the treatment of treatment-refractory schizophrenia", J Neurosci Mental Health, 9, pp.328~331 (2009)
- Bagadia VN, "Reevaluation of ECT in schizophrenia : right temporoparietal versus bitemporal electrode placement", Convuls Ther, 4, pp.215~220 (1988)
- Fujita A, "Memory, attention, and executive functions before and after sine and pulse wave electroconvulsive therapies for treatment-resistant major depression", J ECT, 22, pp.107~112 (2006)
- Kunigiri G, "MRI T2 relaxometry of brain regions and cognitive dysfunction following electroconvulsive therapy", Indian J Psychiatry, 49, pp.195~199 (2007)
- Wang H, "Study on cognition related to ECT for depression", Chinese Journal of Behavioral Medical Science, 12, pp.517~519 (2003)
- Tao S, "The effect of modified electroconvulsive therapy on electroencephalography and cognitive functioning in mental disorders", Zhejiang Clin Res, 14, pp.49~51 (2012)
- Chanpattana W, "A survey of the practice of electroconvulsive therapy in Asia", J ECT, 26, pp.5~10 (2010)
- Little JD, "ECT in the Asia Pacific region : what do we know?", J ECT, 19, pp.93~97 (2003)
- Nordanskog P, "On electroconvulsive therapy in depressionclinical, cognitive and neurobiological aspects", pp.2015
- MacQueen G, "The long-term impact of treatment with electroconvulsive therapy on discrete memory systems in patients with bipolar disorder", J Psychiatry Neurosci, 32, pp.241~249 (2007)