The Global War on Terrorism as Meta-Narrative: An Alternative Reading of Recent Chinese History
0
조회
0
다운로드
0
인용
0
참고문헌
키워드
초록
When we speak of the "Cultural Revolution" in China, we actually refer not to the past but to a narrative interpretation of the past, a particular organization of knowledge which has gone unquestioned for a long time. This paper attempts to develop an alternative narrative scope from which to view the final ten-plus years of politics in the People's Republic under Mao Zedong. It looks at that same period (and queries "What happened? When and Where? Who made it happen? How? And why?") not from a "Cold War" frame but from the still unfolding 21st century present of the so-called "Global War on Terrorism." Narrated as Mao Zedong's Domestic War on Revisionism, this very difficult period teaches some painful lessons that, today perhaps more than ever, concern all of us - irrespective of what our ethnicity or our politics may be.
Abstract
When we speak of the "Cultural Revolution" in China, we actually refer not to the past but to a narrative interpretation of the past, a particular organization of knowledge which has gone unquestioned for a long time. This paper attempts to develop an alternative narrative scope from which to view the final ten-plus years of politics in the People's Republic under Mao Zedong. It looks at that same period (and queries "What happened? When and Where? Who made it happen? How? And why?") not from a "Cold War" frame but from the still unfolding 21st century present of the so-called "Global War on Terrorism." Narrated as Mao Zedong's Domestic War on Revisionism, this very difficult period teaches some painful lessons that, today perhaps more than ever, concern all of us - irrespective of what our ethnicity or our politics may be.
참고문헌 (64)
- "北京日報", ~
- "解放軍報", ~
- "New York Sun", ~
- "人民日報", ~
- "浙江日報", ~
- Ankersmit, F. R., "History and Tropology:The Rise and Fall of Metaphor" (1994), University of California Press
- 關於肖X同志的問題復査情況報告, "北京市革命委員會第二學習班三分支三連黨支部", ~ (1972)
- 關於揭發“二月兵變”的情況的彙報, "北京市委機關摧舊兵團大專院校摧舊縱隊", ~ (1967)
- 關於“二月兵變”材料來源的調査報告, "北京市委機關舊兵團大專院校舊縱隊", ~ (1967)
- 薄一波, "若干重大決策與事件的回顧" (1993), 中共中央黨校出版社
- Burke, Kenneth, "A Grammar of Motives" (1969), University of California Press
- 陳伯達, "林彪文選, 2 vols", pp.264~267 (1966), 西安冶金建築學院革委會宣傳部
- 陳伯達, "無産階級文化大革命參考資料, 4 vols", pp.10 (1966), 北京經濟學院無産階級革命造反團
- 陳曉農, "陳伯達最後口述回憶" (2005), Sun Global Publishing
- 程前, "“文革”漫談", Harvard University
- 當代中國叢書編輯部, "當代中國的吉林, 2 vols" (1991), 當代中國出版社
- 當代中國商業編輯部, "中華人民共和國商業大事記:1958-1978" (1990), 中國商業出版社
- 鄧小平, "無産階級文化大革命參考資料, 4 vols", pp.8 (1966), 北京經濟學院無産階級革命造反團
- Fairbank, John King, "China:A New History" (1998), The Belknap Press of Harvard University Press
- 高文謙, "晩年周恩來" (2003), Mirror Books
- Hobsbawm, Eric, "On History" (1997), The New Press
- 胡喬木, "胡喬木談中共黨史" (1999), 人民出版社
- 康生, "林彪文選, 2 vols", pp.267~272 (1966), 西安冶金建築學院革委會宣傳部
- 康生, "無産階級文化大革命參考資料", pp.42~43 (1966), 北京汽車分公司文革大字報辦公室
- 康生, "無産階級文化大革命參考資料, 4 vols", pp.7 (1966), 北京經濟學院無産階級革命造反團
- 康生, "無産階級文化大革命參考資料, 4 vols", pp.8 (1966), 北京經濟學院無産階級革命造反團
- 康生, "康生言論選編, 3 vols", pp.81~85 (1968), 中共北京市委黨校資料室
- 康生, "康生同志在中直機關傳達“九大” 精神大會上的重要講話" (1969)
- 林彪, "林彪文選, 2 vols", pp.228~244 (1966), 西安冶金建築學院革委會宣傳部
- 林彪, "林彪文選, 2 vols", pp.278~280 (1966), 西安冶金建築學院革委會宣傳部
- 林彪, "林彪文選, 2 vols", pp.437~445 (1967), 西安冶金建築學院革委會宣傳部
- 林彪, "參閱文件, 12 vols", pp.1~64 (1968), 北京軍區政治部
- 劉少奇, "徹底摧毁十七年來政協工作中的劉, 鄧反革命修正主義路線", pp.63~71 (1966), 政協全國委員會機關衛東革命法戰隊
- Maier, Charles S., "Consigning the Twentieth Century to History:Alternative Narratives for the Modern Era", American Historical Review, 105(3), pp.807~831 (2000)
- 毛澤東, "接見老過愛國戰線黨文工團團長, 副團長和主要成員時的談話", 毛澤東思想萬歲, pp.176~180 (1964)
- 毛澤東, "在XXX反修報告會上的揷話", 毛澤東思想萬歲, pp.175~176 (1964)
- 毛澤東, "關於打人問題", 毛澤東思想萬歲, pp.265~ (1966)
- Milton, David, "The Wind Will Not Subside:Years in Revolutionary China-1964-1969" (1969), Pantheon Books
- Schoenhals, Michael, "The 1978 Truth Criterion Controversy", The China Quarterly, 126, pp.243~268 (1991)
- Schoenhals, Michael, "Politics as War:The Role of Metaphor in China’s Cultural Revolution", An unpublished working paper presented at Oxford University on 14 November (1996)
- Schoenhals, Michael, "China’s Cultural Revolution, 1966-1969:Not a Dinner Party" (1996), M. E. Sharpe
- Seely, Hart, "Pieces of Intelligence:The Existential Poetry of Donald H. Rumsfeld" (2003), Free Press
- 首都機械廠詩詞編輯組, "敬愛的周總理永遠活在我們心中" (1978), 丹東印刷廠
- 孫明山, "歷史瞬間Ⅱ" (2001), 群衆出版社
- 陶鑄, "無産階級文化大革命參考資料,4 vols", pp.6 (1966), 北京經濟學院無産階級革命造反團
- 王季平, "吉林省編年記事" (1989), 吉林人民出版社
- 王力, "中央首長講話, 4 vols", pp.3~9 (1967), 北京玻璃總廠紅衛兵聯絡站
- 王力, "無産階級文化大革命資料6", pp.1~8 (1967)
- 王年一, "大動亂的年代" (1988), 河南人民出版社
- White, Hayden, "Metahistory:The Historical Imagination in Nineteenth-Century Europe" (1973), The Johns Hopkins University Press
- 武力, "中華人民共和國經濟史, 2 vols" (1999), 中國經濟出版社
- 肖華, "學習文件", pp.89~100 (1967)
- 肖思科, "超級審判：圖們將軍參與審理林彪反革命集團親歷記" (1992), 濟南出版社
- 謝富治, "社會主義敎育運動文件選編", pp.209~220 (1965)
- 謝靜宜, "“Jiang Qing, Yao Wenyuan, Chi Qun, Xie Jingyi zai Zhongyang zhishu jiguan he guojia jiguan piLin piKong dongyuan dahui shangde jianghua” 江靑, 姚文元, 遲群, 謝靜宜在中央直屬機關和國家機關批林批孔動員大會上的講話. 25 January. Stenographic 63-page record as printed and circulated nationwide “for criticism” by the CCP Centre in November 1976", ~ (1974)
- 徐景賢, "十年一夢" (2004), Time International Publishing
- 中共成都市委政工組宣傳組, "徹底批判“五七一工程”紀要反革命綱領:全國計晝會議大批判書面發言材料選編之一" (1972), 中共成都市委政工組宣傳組
- 中共中央文獻研究室, "建國以來毛澤東文稿第十三冊" (1998), 中央文獻出版社
- 中共中央文獻究研室, "毛澤東傳(1949-1976)" (2003), 中央文獻出版社
- 中共中央宣傳部對外宣傳局, "中央負責同志同外賓的談話" (1980), 人民出版社
- 中華人民共和國國史稿編委會, "鄧力群國史講談錄, 5 vols" (2000), 當代中國研究所
- 周恩來, "林彪文選, 2 vols", pp.343~352 (1966), 西安冶金建築學院革委會宣傳部
- 周恩來, "中央首長講話, 4 vols", pp.260~261 (1967), 北京玻璃總廠紅衛兵聯絡站
- 朱(某), "“Jiefa jiaodai he Beijing erba zhuan’anzude lianxi” 揭發交代和北京“二八專案組”的聯系. 30 December. Handwritten 18-page copy, made by Sun Yusheng and Zhang Yuzhi on 4 February 1972, of a deposition submitted to the Tianjin University Elementary Classes Department Zhu XX Case Group. In the author’s possession", ~ (1971)