Comparison of Validity and Accuracy of Circumference, SKF, and BIA Method in Predicting % Body Fat
1
조회
0
다운로드
3
인용
0
참고문헌
키워드
초록
The purpose of this study was to compare the difference in the percent body fat(% body fat) values estimated by the circumference method, the skinfold method(SKF), the bioelectrical impedance analysis(BIA), and the underwater weighing(UWW) and to examine the accuracy of three different field methods by comparing with reference method. Twenty-nine adults(women = 13 and men =16) volunteered to participate(age = 25 to 49 years) in this study. Body weight and height were measured, and body mass index(BMI) was calculated. Body circumferences, SKF thicknesses, BIA, and UWW were measured from five technicians(beginner level) under the guidance of a trained technician. Several validated equations appropriated to race, gender, and age were used to estimate % body fat from SKF method. The prediction equations for estimating % body fat using circumference method were developed considering only gender and age. The % body fat from BIA was calculated with the value of free fatty acids(FFA) estimated from the preset equation for the device. The data were analyzed by using one-way ANOVA to examine the difference in the % body fat results measured from four different methods, and Pearson correlation coefficients and regression analysis were measured to assess the validity and accuracy for three body composition measurements. Statistical significant was set at P < 0.05. The results showed that the % body fat values measured by four different measurements were statistically similar. However, there were differences in the accuracy for estimating % body fat among different measurements, and it was found that the SKF method was the most accurate method, and the circumference method was the lowest method for predicting % body fat. In conclusion, these results suggested that the estimation of body composition from the circumference and SKF method, and BIA can be estimated relatively accurately, even if measured by an untrained technician when following prescribed measurement methods and procedures. Our data also suggested that the population-specific equations appropriate to subject should be used to estimate body composition because they will probably predict more accurate estimates.
Abstract
The purpose of this study was to compare the difference in the percent body fat(% body fat) values estimated by the circumference method, the skinfold method(SKF), the bioelectrical impedance analysis(BIA), and the underwater weighing(UWW) and to examine the accuracy of three different field methods by comparing with reference method. Twenty-nine adults(women = 13 and men =16) volunteered to participate(age = 25 to 49 years) in this study. Body weight and height were measured, and body mass index(BMI) was calculated. Body circumferences, SKF thicknesses, BIA, and UWW were measured from five technicians(beginner level) under the guidance of a trained technician. Several validated equations appropriated to race, gender, and age were used to estimate % body fat from SKF method. The prediction equations for estimating % body fat using circumference method were developed considering only gender and age. The % body fat from BIA was calculated with the value of free fatty acids(FFA) estimated from the preset equation for the device. The data were analyzed by using one-way ANOVA to examine the difference in the % body fat results measured from four different methods, and Pearson correlation coefficients and regression analysis were measured to assess the validity and accuracy for three body composition measurements. Statistical significant was set at P < 0.05. The results showed that the % body fat values measured by four different measurements were statistically similar. However, there were differences in the accuracy for estimating % body fat among different measurements, and it was found that the SKF method was the most accurate method, and the circumference method was the lowest method for predicting % body fat. In conclusion, these results suggested that the estimation of body composition from the circumference and SKF method, and BIA can be estimated relatively accurately, even if measured by an untrained technician when following prescribed measurement methods and procedures. Our data also suggested that the population-specific equations appropriate to subject should be used to estimate body composition because they will probably predict more accurate estimates.
참고문헌 (31)
- National Institutes of Health, "Health Implication of Obesity: National Institutes of Health Consensus Development Statement", Annals of Internal Medicine, 103(1), pp.147~151 (1985)
- Goodpaster BH, "Obesity, Regional Body Fat Distribu-tion, and The Metabolic Syndrome in Older Men and Women", Archives of Internal Medi-cine, 165(7), pp.777~783 (2005)
- Björntorp P., ""Portal" Adipose Tissue as A Generator of Risk Factors for Cardiovascular Disease and Diabetes", Arteriosclerosis, 10(4), pp.493~496 (1990)
- Friedl KE, "Size Metters", The American Jour-nal of Clinical Nutrition, 93(3), pp.485~486
- Heyward VH, "Evaluation of Body Composi-tion", Current issues. Sports Medicine, 22(3), pp.146~156 (1996)
- Jackson AS, "Practical Assess-ment of Body Composition", The Physician and Sports Medicine, 13(5), pp.76~90 (1985)
- Jackson AS, "Gener-alized Equations for Predicting Body Density of Women", Medicine and Science in Sports and Exercise, 12(3), pp.175~181 (1980)
- Jackson AS, "Generalized Equations for Predicting Body Density of Men", The British Journal of Nutrition, 40(3), pp.497~504 (1978)
- Weltman A, "Accurate Assessment of Body Composition in Obese Females", The American Journal of Clinical Nutrition, 48(5), pp.1179~1183 (1988)
- Tran ZV, "Generalized Equa-tion for Predicting Body Density of Women from Girth Measurements", Medicine and Sci-ence in Sports and Exercise, 21(1), pp.101~104 (1989)
- Wilmore JH, "An Anthropo-metric Estimation of Body Density and Lean Body Weight in Young Women", The Ameri-can Journal of Clinical Nutrition, 23(3), pp.267~274 (1970)
- Dehghan M, "Is Bioelectrical Impedance Accurate for Use in Large Epide-miological Studies?", Nutrition Journal, 7(1), pp.26~26 (2008)
- Ackland TR, "Current Status of Body Com-position Assessment in Sport", Sports Medi-cine, 42(3), pp.227~249 (2012)
- Aandstad A, "Validity and Relia-bility of Bioelectrical Impedance Analysis and Skinfold Thickness in Predicting Body Fat in Military Personnel", Military Medicine, 179(2), pp.208~217 (2014)
- Hodgdon JA, "Use of Bioelectri-cal Impedance Analysis Measurements as Predictors of Physical Performance", The American Journal of Clinical Nutrition, 64(3 Suppl), pp.463S~468S (1996)
- Norgan NG, "Laboratory and Field Measure-ments of Body Composition", Public Health Nutrition, 8(7A), pp.1108~1022 (2005)
- Hayes PA, "Sub-cutaneous Fat Thickness Measured by Magnetic Resonance Imaging, Ultrasound, and Calipers", Medicine and Science in Sports and Exercise, 20(3), pp.303~309 (1988)
- Lohman TG, "Methodological Factors and The Prediction of Body Fat in Fe-male Athletes", Medicine and Science in Sports and Exercise, 16(1), pp.92~96 (1984)
- Lohman TG, "Applicability of Body Composi-tion Techniques and Constants for Children and Youths", Exercise and Sport Sciences Re-views, 14, pp.325~357 (1986)
- Thomas KT, "Ethnic and Age Trends for Body Composition in Women Residing in The U.S. Southwest: II. Total Fat", Medicine and Science in Sports and Exercise, 29(1), pp.90~98 (1997)
- Katch FI, "Measurement and Prediction Errors in Body Composition As-sessment and The Search for The Perfect Prediction Equation", Research Quarterly for Exercise and Sport, 51(1), pp.249~260 (1980)
- Brandon LJ, "Comparison of Existing Skinfold Equations for Estimating Body Fat in African American and White Women", The American Journal of Clinical Nutrition, 67(6), pp.1155~1161 (1998)
- Boren HG, "The Veter-ans Administration-army Cooperative Study of Pulmonary Function: II. The Lung Volume and Its Subdivisions in Normal Men", The American Journal of Medicine, 41(1), pp.96~114 (1966)
- Goldman HI, "Respiratory Function Tests, Normal Values at Median Al-titudes and The Prediction of Normal Re-sults", American Review of Tuberculosis and Pulmonary Diseases, 79(4), pp.457~467 (1959)
- Heyward VH, "Applied Body Composition Assessment" (1996), Human Kinetics
- Callaway CW, "Circumferences. Anthropomet-ric Standardization Reference Manual" (1988), Hu-man Kinetics
- Katch VL, "Essen-tials of Exercise Physiology" (2011), Lippincott Williams & Wikins
- Siri WE, "Body Composition from Fluid Spaces and Density: Analysis of Methods. Techniques for Measuring Body Composi-tion", National Academy of Sciences, ~ (1961)
- Lohman TG, "Advances in Body Composition Assessment. Current Issues in Exercise Sci-ence Series" (1992), Human Kinetics