본문 바로가기
KERD
논문KCI 등재

체결된 계약 내용의 수정 및 조정

Adaptation of the Contract

0

조회

0

다운로드

3

인용

0

참고문헌

키워드

주제분류법학

초록

Abstract

The modification, adjustment of contract is possible by agreement. There are two possible schemes. One is the pre-contract special mechanism for reflection of the changes, and the other is agreement to a post-contractual change of circumstances If there is no agreement between the ptheies, the negotiation process by court may be operated to reflect changes in circumstances. In the theicle is described the outline of the most relevant structural features of the contract adaptation and the Aspects of contract adaptation. In Pthe Ⅱ deal with the ptheies' negotiations, in Pthe Ⅲ post-contractual contract adaptation- the tdjustment of the contract through the facilitating of negotiations. There are facilitating contract negotiations by legal norms and bargaining in the shadow of the law on using utility functions to support legal negotiation, and facilitate negotiations by special arrangement - renegotiation and adaptation clause. Direct negotiations between parties may also be subject to certain formalities prescribed by the contract itself. To cite a few examples, many hardship clauses establish duties regarding, inter alia, timely written Information, a waiting period, and a meeting of the parties. The parties may have agreed in advance that one of them is empowered to make unilateral decisions on gaps or changes. Here, we are not in the presence of true negotiation but only decision-making by one party. Whether the parties can validly do this depends on the applicable municipal law and its concept of party autonomy. If the parties do not deem direct ad hoc negotiations as an adequate means for contract adaptation, they may have recourse to the intervention of a third party. If an adaptation of the contract through the mutual agreement of the parties is neither envisaged in the contract nor possible in the immediate situation, it is still possible that a unilateral decision might bring about the adaptation. In Part Ⅳ is dealt with the contract adaptation by the court. Courts can change a contract and adapt it to new circumstances if so allowed by the substantive law of contract. If the parties do not reach an agreement, they may have recourse to the courts or to an arbitral tribunal. Courts or arbitral tribunals, however, even if they may act under flexible legal concepts of contract adaptation do not necessarily have the same wide scope of flexibve thethe parties would themselves have in a private renegotiation. Although many legal systems do not generally give relief to a party who is burdened with excessive hardship, these same systems generally recognize party autonomy to provide for the adaptation of contracts to changed circumstances. Consequently, it is fairly common in contracts, particularly those that have long durations, to make provisions for revision of the contract in case of changed circumstances. Having laid the structural features of the contract adaptation and the aspects of contract adaptation is dealt in Part Ⅴ with a more general question, whether we need a classical contract theory(will theory) to the relational contract theory. Is certainty and contractual security better promoted by rigid rules or by leaving room for flexibility? The answer turns on the nature of the contract. In contracts certainty is all important. Certainty means security. The aim of the contract law, contractual security, recognised under the heading of faveur pour le contrat, is recognised in various provisions for example those on interpretation, and on the power of the court to adapt a contract. Also, the debtor's right to cure a non-conforming performance can be seen as being aimed at the preservation of the contractual relationship, as this right may avoid the execution of remedies, including termination. Further, a general mechanism to supplement the agreement is provided in order to make it workable when it is necessary to provide for a matter which the parties have not foreseen or provided for, thus "favouring the contract"(maintaining the contractual relationship) and increasing contractual security.

참고문헌 (21)

  1. 고영남, "계약구속력의 정당성, in: 「민사법의 현대적 과제와 전망」(서광민교수정년기념논문집)" (2007)
  2. 권영준, "민사재판에 있어서 이론, 법리, 실무", 서울대학교 법학, 49(3), pp.313~354 (2008), 법학연구소
  3. 김오수, "건설클레임으로 인한 계약금액조정에 관한 연구", 한국경제, 27 (2000)
  4. 백태승, "사정변경의 원칙, in: 한국민법이론의 발전(이영준선생화갑기념논문집)" (1999)
  5. 이영준, "사정변경의 원칙에 관한 연구", 사법논집, 5 (1974)
  6. 이재목, "계약사정의 변경과 계약내용의 조정", 비교사법, 8(1) (2001)
  7. 임시규, "자동차종합보험약관의 업무상 재해 면책조항 -대법원 2005.3.17. 선고 2003다2802 전원합의체 판결-", 민사재판의 제문제, 14 (2005)
  8. 정종휴, "불안의 항변권의 현대적 전개, in: 민사법의 실천적 과제(정환담교수화갑기념논문집)" (2000)
  9. 한동수, "사정변경으로 인한 계약해제권의 발생 여부", 판례연구(전주지방법원), ~ (1999)
  10. 内田貴, "契約の時代" (2000), 岩波書店
  11. 内田貴, "米國における關係的契約の檢討", NBL, (669), pp.6~ (1999)
  12. FIDIC, "Conditions of Contract for Works of Civil Engineering Construction", ~ (1987)
  13. Glossner, Ottoarndt, "Contract Adaptation through Third Party Intervener; The Referee Arbitral", Adaptation and Renegotiation of Contracts in International Trade and Finance, ~ (1985)
  14. Hartkamp, "Contract Law in der Netherlands" (1995)
  15. Ian R. Macneil, "Relational Contract Theory as Sociology", Inst. & Thoretical Econ, 143, pp.272~
  16. Horn, Norbert, "Procedures of Contract Adaptation and Renegotiation in International Commerce", Adaptation and Renegotiation of Contracts in International Trade and Finance, ~ (1985)
  17. Horn, Norbert, "Standard Clauses in Contract Adaptation in International Commerce", Adaptation and Renegotiation of Contracts in International Trade and Finance, ~ (1985)
  18. Kahn, Ph., "Lex mercatoria et contrats internationaux", Le Contrat E'conomique International, ~ (1975)
  19. Mnookin, Robert, "in the shadow of the law: the case of divorce", ~ (1979)
  20. Mnookin, Robert H, "Bargaining in the Shadow of the Law: The Case of Divorce", Yale Law Journal, 88, pp.950~ (1979)
  21. John Zeleznikow, "Geraldine Mackenzie, Bargaining in the shadow of the law - using utility functions to support legal negotiation", ~ (2007)

관련 논문AI추천

이 간행물의 다른 논문 (20건)