An Integrative Neuroscientific Approach to Moral Judgment -Bridging Universal Moral Grammar and Emotional Moral Sentimentalism-
0
조회
0
다운로드
0
인용
0
참고문헌
키워드
초록
This paper examines two prominent frameworks in moral psychology that aim to explain the foundations of moral judgments: the Universal Moral Grammar (UMG) and the Emotional Moral Sentimentalist (EMS) frameworks. UMG theorists propose that moral judgments are guided by innate, unconscious principles analogous to linguistic grammar, whereas EMS advocates emphasize the role of automatic emotional responses, such as anger or guilt, in shaping moral decisions. By reviewing recent neuroscientific evidence, this paper evaluates the strengths and limitations of each approach and argues that neither framework is fully substantiated by current empirical findings. Instead, it advocates for an integrative perspective that treats UMG principles and emotional processes as complementary, hypothetical models for understanding moral cognition. This approach offers a pathway for more comprehensive investigations into the neural mechanisms underlying moral judgments, addressing the limitations of the ongoing UMG-EMS debate
Abstract
This paper examines two prominent frameworks in moral psychology that aim to explain the foundations of moral judgments: the Universal Moral Grammar (UMG) and the Emotional Moral Sentimentalist (EMS) frameworks. UMG theorists propose that moral judgments are guided by innate, unconscious principles analogous to linguistic grammar, whereas EMS advocates emphasize the role of automatic emotional responses, such as anger or guilt, in shaping moral decisions. By reviewing recent neuroscientific evidence, this paper evaluates the strengths and limitations of each approach and argues that neither framework is fully substantiated by current empirical findings. Instead, it advocates for an integrative perspective that treats UMG principles and emotional processes as complementary, hypothetical models for understanding moral cognition. This approach offers a pathway for more comprehensive investigations into the neural mechanisms underlying moral judgments, addressing the limitations of the ongoing UMG-EMS debate
참고문헌 (33)
- Akiko M., "Morality Is in the Cultural Eye of the Beholder : A Situation Sampling Study", Journal of Cognition and Culture, 23(1-2), pp.127~148 (2023)
- Barrett, L. F., "Handbook of Emotions" (2016), The Guilford Press
- Bentahila, L., "Universality and Cultural Diversity in Moral Reasoning and Judgment", Frontiers in Psychology, 12 (2021)[DOI]
- Bzdok, D., "Parsing the Neural Correlates of Moral Cognition : ALE Meta-analysis on Morality, Theory of Mind, and Empathy", Brain Structure and Function, 217, pp.783~796 (2012)
- Chomsky, N., "Reflections on language" (1975), Pantheon Books
- Cushman, F., "The Role of Conscious Reasoning and Intuition in Moral Judgment", Psychological Science, 17(12), pp.1082~1089 (2006)
- Dennett, D. C., "From Bacteria to Bach and Back: The Evolution of Minds" (2017), WW Norton & Company
- Damasio, A. R., "Descartes’ Error: Emotion, Reason, and the Human Brain" (1994), Avon Books
- D’Arms J., "Sentiment and Value", Ethics, 110, pp.722~748 (2000)
- Decety, J., "The Functional Architecture of Human Empathy", Behavioral and Cognitive Neuroscience Reviews, 3(2), pp.71~100 (2004)
- Decety, J., "The Role of the Right Temporoparietal Junction in Social Interaction : How Low-level Computational Processes Contribute to Meta-cognition", The Neuroscientist, 13(6), pp.580~593 (2007)
- Decety, J., "Neurodevelopmental Changes in the Circuits Underlying Empathy and Sympathy from Childhood to Adulthood", Developmental Science, 13(6), pp.886~899 (2010)
- Decety, J., "The Contribution of Emotion and Cognition to Moral Sensitivity : a Neurodevelopmental Study", Cereb Cortex, 22(1), pp.209~220 (2012)
- Dupoux, E., "Universal Moral Grammar : A Critical Appraisal", Trends in Cognitive Science, 11(9), pp.373~378 (2007)
- Dwyer, S., "The Innate Mind: Culture and Cognition", pp.237~256 (2006), The Oxford University Press
- Dwyer, S., "Moral Psychology: The Evolution of Morality: Adaptations and Innateness Vol. 1", pp.407~418 (2008), The MIT Press
- Dwyer, S., "The Linguistic Analogy : Motivations, Results, and Speculations", Topics in Cognitive Science, 2, pp.486~510 (2010)
- Green, J., "Moral Tribes: Emotion, Reason, and the Gap between Us and Them" (2013), Penguin
- Hauser, M., "Moral Minds : How Nature Designed Our Universal Sense of Right and Wrong" (2007), HarperCollins
- Hauser, M., "Moral Psychology: The Cognitive Science of Morality", pp.107~144 (2008), Oxford University Press
- Huebner, B, "The Role of Emotion in Moral Psychology", Trends in Cognitive Sciences, 13(1), pp.1~6 (2008)
- Mikhail, J., "Universal Moral Grammar : Theory, Evidence, and the Future", Trends in Cognitive Sciences, pp.143~152 (2007)
- LeDoux, J., "Anxious : The Modern Mind in the Age of Anxiety" (2016), Oneworld Book
- Nichols, S., "Sentimental Rules" (2004), Oxford University Press
- Rolls, E., "The Brain and Emotion" (1999), Oxford University Press
- Piccinini, G., "Integrating Psychology and Neuroscience: Functional Analyses as Mechanism Sketches", Synthese, 183, pp.283~311 (2011)
- Prinz, J., "The Emotional Construction of Morals" (2007), Oxford University Press
- Prinz, J., "Moral Psychology: The Evolution of Morality: Adaptations and Innateness" (2008), Oxford University Press
- Prinz, J., "Moral Psychology: The Cognitive Science of Morality", pp.157~170 (2008), Oxford University Press
- Sterelny, K., "Moral Nativism : A Sceptical Response", Mind and Language, 25(3), pp.279~297 (2010)
- Sterelny, K., "The Evolved Apprentice : How Evolution Made Human Unique" (2012), The MIT Press
- Young, L., "The Neural Basis of the Interaction between Theory of Mind and Moral Judgment", Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America, 104(20), pp.8235~8240 (2007)
- Young, L., "An FMRI Investigation of Spontaneous Mental State Inference for Moral Judgment", Journal of Cognitive Neuroscience, 21(7), pp.1396~1405 (2009)