일본 방위산업 경쟁력 분석- 포터의 다이아몬드 모델 적용 -
A Study on the Competitiveness of Japan's Defense Industry
0
조회
0
다운로드
7
인용
0
참고문헌
키워드
초록
The purpose of this study is to explain what constitutes sources of competitiveness of Japan's defense industry. This study adopts Porter's Diamond Model as a theoretical framework to evaluate competitiveness of the defense industry in a more comprehensive and strategic way. Japan’s defense industry has operated in a noncompetitive market environment, with a few companies dealing with the Japanese government as the sole buyer. Coupled with this distinctive defense acquisition process, Japan’s arms export ban policy has brought the industry to a standstill. Those companies in the market, blessed with the small but stable demand at home, continue to receive defense contract awards from the Ministry of Defense. In such an environment, Japanese defense companies with vested rights do not have to compete with one another or with foreign suppliers in the overseas market. In addition, the Japanese defense market does not attract newcomers because of the country’s static defense industrial structure and the legal restraints on arms exports. Japanese defense industry has the technological edge on sea-based subsystems, albeit more for defensive and searching systems than offensive systems. This analysis suggests that the revise of three principles of arms exports is likely to change the characteristics of Japanese defense industry significantly but not sufficiently to constitute a fundamental transformation of that industry.
Abstract
The purpose of this study is to explain what constitutes sources of competitiveness of Japan's defense industry. This study adopts Porter's Diamond Model as a theoretical framework to evaluate competitiveness of the defense industry in a more comprehensive and strategic way. Japan’s defense industry has operated in a noncompetitive market environment, with a few companies dealing with the Japanese government as the sole buyer. Coupled with this distinctive defense acquisition process, Japan’s arms export ban policy has brought the industry to a standstill. Those companies in the market, blessed with the small but stable demand at home, continue to receive defense contract awards from the Ministry of Defense. In such an environment, Japanese defense companies with vested rights do not have to compete with one another or with foreign suppliers in the overseas market. In addition, the Japanese defense market does not attract newcomers because of the country’s static defense industrial structure and the legal restraints on arms exports. Japanese defense industry has the technological edge on sea-based subsystems, albeit more for defensive and searching systems than offensive systems. This analysis suggests that the revise of three principles of arms exports is likely to change the characteristics of Japanese defense industry significantly but not sufficiently to constitute a fundamental transformation of that industry.
참고문헌 (26)
- 국방기술품질원, "2012 세계방산시장연감", ~ (2012)
- 김성철, "일본외교와 동북아" (2007), 한울아카데미
- 김진기, "탈냉전기 미국과 일본의 방위산업 협력 : 미· 일기술포럼에서의 논의를 중심으로", 국방연구, 53(2), pp.79~104 (2010), 국가안전보장문제연구소
- 김진기, "일본의 방위산업" (2012), 아연출판사
- 박영준, "미일동맹관계변화에 따른 미일 군사기술협력: FSX공동개발과 TMD공동연구결정사례를 중심으로" (2004), 국방대학원
- 정보본부, "일본의 방위산업 육성 방향", ~ (2011)
- 清谷信一, "防衛破綻―｢ガラパゴス化｣する自衛隊装備" (2010), 中央公論新社
- ジョン, "日本の防衛産業は今後如何にあるべきか？", 防衛研究所紀要, 12 (2010)
- 藤本隆宏, "生産システムの進化論" (1997), 有斐閣
- 防衛省, "防衛生産․技術基盤について", ~ (2009)
- 防衛省經理裝備局, "防衛省における國內技術交流について", ~ (2011)
- 防衛省経理装備局技術計画官, "技本の研究開発の現状と軍事技術の方向性", ~ (2011)
- 防衛生産․技術基盤研究会中間報告, "防衛生産․技術基盤研究会", ~ (2011)
- 防衛生産․技術基盤硏究會最終報告, "防衛生産", ~ (2012)
- Gavan Gray, "Japan's Defense Industry: Pacifism, Pragmatism and Necessity", 大阪女學阮, (8) (2012)
- Jennifer M. Lind, ""Pacifism or Passing Buck? Testing Theories of Japanese Security Policies", International Security, 29(1), pp.109~110 (2004)
- Peter Duus, "The Abacus and the Sword: The Japanese Penetration of Korea 1895-1910", pp.62~ (1995), University of California Press
- Tsuyoshi Kawasaki, "Postclassical Realism and Japanese Security Policy", Pacific Review, 14(2), pp.27~ (2001)
- Yamamura Kozo, "Japan's Dues ex Machine: Western Technology in the 1920s", Journal of Japanese Studies, 12(1), pp.65~ (1986)
- Yukari Kubota, "Japan's New Strategy as an Arms Exporter: Revising the Three Principles on Arms Exports", RIPS Policy Perspectives, (7), pp.11~14 (2008)
- "防衛産業｣の虚と実", SAPIO, ~ (2008)
- "防衛産業を大解剖 自衛隊のコスト", 週刊東洋經濟, ~ (2012)
- "Proposal for the New National Defense Program Guidelines", Nippon keidanren, ~ (2010)
- Japan Should Ease Ban on Weapons Expports, , Nikkei, ~ (2010)
- "Toshiba Sues Defense Ministry over F-15 Contract", Asahi Simbun, ~ (2011)
- "Japan's Policies on the Control of Arms Exports, Japan Ministry of Foreign Affairs" (2012)[URL]