생명공학특허에 있어서 인권 문제
The Issue of Human Rights in Biotechnology Patents
0
조회
0
다운로드
2
인용
0
참고문헌
키워드
초록
The objective of this paper is to consider the relationship between human rights and patent rights for biotechnology by examining the legal meaning of international human rights and comparing with the Korean Constitution Articles. Patent rights issues have interacted with human rights, negatively or positively. The exercise of patent rights, for instance, has implications for the right to health. The patent protection of drugs for illnesses like HIV/AIDS can be considered to negatively impact on human rights. Besides, the problem of patents of life forms, plant varieties and biotechnology based on indigenous people's knowledge without prior informed consent are among the most serious issues in the contemporary conflicts between intellectual property rights and human rights. Further concern has been expressed over the growing process of monopolization that is taking place in the seed and biotechnology industries. The processes of "bio-piracy" - the exploitation and private appropriation of traditional forms of knowledge - have serious implications for farmers in countries where technological and industrial resources are simply inadequate to prohibit such piracy. Under these circumstances, pro-patent perspective without considering human rights will result in meaningless conflicts and cause a vicious circle between human rights and intellectual property rights. Overall, my view is that it is necessary for intellectual property experts to review intellectual property system through the eyes of human rights advocates.
Abstract
The objective of this paper is to consider the relationship between human rights and patent rights for biotechnology by examining the legal meaning of international human rights and comparing with the Korean Constitution Articles. Patent rights issues have interacted with human rights, negatively or positively. The exercise of patent rights, for instance, has implications for the right to health. The patent protection of drugs for illnesses like HIV/AIDS can be considered to negatively impact on human rights. Besides, the problem of patents of life forms, plant varieties and biotechnology based on indigenous people's knowledge without prior informed consent are among the most serious issues in the contemporary conflicts between intellectual property rights and human rights. Further concern has been expressed over the growing process of monopolization that is taking place in the seed and biotechnology industries. The processes of "bio-piracy" - the exploitation and private appropriation of traditional forms of knowledge - have serious implications for farmers in countries where technological and industrial resources are simply inadequate to prohibit such piracy. Under these circumstances, pro-patent perspective without considering human rights will result in meaningless conflicts and cause a vicious circle between human rights and intellectual property rights. Overall, my view is that it is necessary for intellectual property experts to review intellectual property system through the eyes of human rights advocates.
참고문헌 (32)
- 김철수, "헌법학개론" (2000), 박영사
- 남희섭, "특허권과 인권-글리벡사건을 중심으로", 민주사회를 위한변론, 통권 : 43 (2001), 통권 제43호
- 박성호, "우리나라의 생명공학특허제도와 ‘유전자원’의 보호문제", AIPPI 저널 (2001), 한국국제산업재산권보호협회
- 박성호, "지적재산권과 인권", 과학기술과 인권 (2001), 당대
- 박성호, "생명권, 건강권, 그리고 특허권―글리벡 특허권에 대한 강제실시문제", JURIST (2002)
- 박성호, "저작권법의 이론과 현실" (2006), 현암사
- 박성호, "지적재산권에 관한 헌법 제22조 제2항의 의미와 내용", 법학논총 (2007), 한양대 법학연구소
- 박은정, "생명공학시대의 법과 윤리" (2000), 이화여대 출판부
- 신혜은, "유전공학 관련 발명의 특허성과 그 효율적 보호방안에 관한 연구", 박사, 법학과, pp.2006
- 위라만트리, "인권과 과학기술의 발전", 유네스코포럼, (11) (1999), ,
- 이대훈, "신자유주의 공세와 인권운동의 과제", 과거 10년간의 인권상황 평가와 향후 인권개혁 과제 (1998), 민주사회를 위한 변호사모임 창립10주년 기념 심포지움
- 이대훈, "생물다양성.지적재산권.생명", 세계의 화두 (1998), 개마고원
- 임미원, "인격권 개념의 기초적 고찰", 민사법학, (36) (2007), 박영사
- 정관혜, "생명공학 분야의 나쁜 특허들", 다른과학, (8) (2000), ,
- 정상조, "유전공학의 발전과 특허법적 보호의 문제점", 법학, 35(1) (1994), 서울대 법학연구소
- 정인섭, "국제법의 이해" (1996), 홍문사
- 정진섭, "국제지적재산권법" (1995), 육법사
- 카렐바삭, "인권론", 실천문학사, ~ (1986)
- 토마스 버겐탈, "국제인권법(증보판)", 국제인권법 (2001), 교육과학사
- 한재각, "인간 게놈과 인권에 관한 보편선언", 유네스코포럼, (4) (1998), ,
- 홍성욱, "과학과 인권", 인권평론, 1 (2006), 한길사
- Drahos Peter, "Intellectual Property and Human Rights, Intellectual Property Rights : Critical Concepts in Law 1" (2006), Routledge
- Halbert, J. Debora, "Patenting the body : Resisting the commodification of the human, Resisting Intellectual Property, Routledge, 2005", ~ (2005)
- McCabe W. Kevin, "The January 1999 Review of Article 27 of the TRIPS Agreement: Diverging Views of Developed and Developing Countries toward the Patentability of Biotechnology", Journal of Intellectual Property Law (1998)
- Shiva Vandana, "Biopiracy : The Plunder of Nature and Knowledge" (1997), South End Press
- Shiva Vandana, "Protect or Plunder?:Understanding Intellectual Property Rights" (2001), Zed Books
- 渡?雄二, "深刻化する‘種’獨占の威脅", 週刊金曜日, 237 (1998)
- 茶園成樹, "生物多樣性條約と知的財産權", 日本工業所有權法學會年報, 22 (1998)
- 中川淳司, "生物多樣性條約と國際法的技術規制", 日本國際經濟法學會年 報, 6 (1997)
- "동아일보, 2007년 10월 17일자, A20면", ~ (2007)
- "FINANCIAL TIMES, 2001. 10. 21.자, 3면", ~ (2001)
- "FINANCIAL TIMES, 2001. 11. 6.자, 4면, 19면", ~ (2001)