Placing Korean History within Tōyō: Inaba Iwakichi and Korean Political History
1
조회
0
다운로드
1
인용
0
참고문헌
키워드
초록
The expansion of the Japanese Empire from the late nineteenth century coincided with the modernization of the nation. In this context, historical research conducted on Korea by Japanese historians from the late nineteenth century to 1945 had the double function of supporting Japan’s colonial expansion and establishing historical studies as a modern discipline, which entailed the creation of Tōyō (Japan’s Orient). While previous studies on Japanese historiography from this period have tended to focus on its function as a tool supporting Japanese colonialism and have not paid due attention to its role as a part of Tōyō, this paper examines how Japanese historians ascribed the notion of Tōyō and the position of Korea within this historical space. It achieves this by focusing on the work of Inaba Iwakichi on Korean political history. His study was based on his teacher Naito Konan’s interpretation of Chinese history. Naitō, who was a professor in the department of history at Kyōtō Imperial University, explained the Tang-Song transition as the evolution from medieval aristocracy to early modern monarchy. Following this line of thought, Inaba claimed that the political system of the Chosŏn dynasty had remained at the aristocracy stage, thus highlighting the stagnant character of Korean history. In addition, it shows that Japanese historians positioned Korea as the most backward state in Tōyō, which comprised Korea, China, and Japan.
Abstract
The expansion of the Japanese Empire from the late nineteenth century coincided with the modernization of the nation. In this context, historical research conducted on Korea by Japanese historians from the late nineteenth century to 1945 had the double function of supporting Japan’s colonial expansion and establishing historical studies as a modern discipline, which entailed the creation of Tōyō (Japan’s Orient). While previous studies on Japanese historiography from this period have tended to focus on its function as a tool supporting Japanese colonialism and have not paid due attention to its role as a part of Tōyō, this paper examines how Japanese historians ascribed the notion of Tōyō and the position of Korea within this historical space. It achieves this by focusing on the work of Inaba Iwakichi on Korean political history. His study was based on his teacher Naito Konan’s interpretation of Chinese history. Naitō, who was a professor in the department of history at Kyōtō Imperial University, explained the Tang-Song transition as the evolution from medieval aristocracy to early modern monarchy. Following this line of thought, Inaba claimed that the political system of the Chosŏn dynasty had remained at the aristocracy stage, thus highlighting the stagnant character of Korean history. In addition, it shows that Japanese historians positioned Korea as the most backward state in Tōyō, which comprised Korea, China, and Japan.
참고문헌 (50)
- "Paper presented at the Conference on the History of Historiography in East Asia 東アジア史學史のために", 2018, ~, pp.Ritsumeikan University
- 정상우, "20세기 전반 일본인 연구자들의 ‘만주사’ 만들기", 만주연구, (30), pp.165~204 (2020), 만주학회[DOI]
- 정상우, "일제 하 일본인 학자들의 한국사에 대한 通史的 이해 -1930년대 중반의 저작들을 중심으로-", 역사와 현실, (104), pp.83~123 (2017), 한국역사연구회[DOI]
- Chŏng Sangu 정상우, (2018), Ayŏn Ch’ulp’anbu
- Chōsenji Gakai 朝鮮史學會, (1927), Chikazawa Shōten Insatsubu
- Cumings, Bruce, "Universities and Empire: Money and Politics in the Social Sciences During the Cold War", pp.159~188 (1998), The New Press
- "Han’guksa simin kangjwa 한국사 시민강좌", 1994, 199~204
- Deuchler, Martina M. 도이힐러, "The Confucian Transformation of Korea: A Study of Society and Ideology" (1992), Council on East Asian Studies, Harvard University
- "oria hyōron コリア評論", 1958, 36~40
- "Tōa 東亞", 1935, 48~61
- "Rekishi kyoiku 歷史敎育", 1932, 11~22
- "Shigaku zasshi 史學雑誌", 1932, 1~36
- Hisayuki Miyakawa, "An Outline of the Naito Hypothesis and Its Effects on Japanese Studies of China", Far Eastern Quarterly, 14(4), pp.533~552 (1955)
- "Chōsen 朝鮮", 1937, 2~21
- Inaba Iwakichi 稻葉岩吉, , pp.3~201 (1935), Heibonsha
- "Seikyū gakusō 青丘學叢", 1933, 1~25
- "Tōa keizai kenkyū 東亞經濟硏究", 1931, 4~41
- "Tōa keizai kenkyū 東亞經濟硏究", 1931, 1~11
- Inaba Iwakichi 稻葉岩吉, (1925), Yūzankaku
- Inaba Iwakichi 稻葉岩吉, (1918), Waseda Daigaku Shupanbu 早稻田大學出版部
- "Kikan sanzenri 季刊三干里", 1981, 33~41
- "Han’guksa simin kangjwa 韓國史市民講座", 1987, 20~52
- 강진원, "식민주의 역사학과 ‘우리’ 안의 타율성론", 역사비평, (115), pp.212~231 (2016), 역사문제연구소
- "Asea", 1969, 84~90
- Kim Yongsŏp 김용섭, "Yŏksa ŭi osolgil ŭl kamyŏnsŏ: Haebang sedae hakcha ŭi yŏksa yŏn’gu yŏksa kangŭi 역사의 오솔길을 가면서: 해방세대 학자의 역사 연구 역사 강의" (2011), Chisik Sanŏpsa
- "Yŏksa hakpo 歷史學報", 1966, 128~147
- "Sasanggye", 1963, 252~257
- Ledyard, Gari, "Review of A Short History of Korea, by The Center for East Asian Cultural Studies", Journal of the American Oriental Society, 85(3), pp.456~459 (1965)
- "Kikan sanzenri 季刊三干里", 1980, 48~53
- Naitō Torajirō 內藤虎次郞, (1924), Hakubundo
- "Rekishi to chiri 歷史と地理", 1922, 1~14
- Naitō Torajirō 內藤虎次郞, (1914), Bunkaido Shoten
- 노용필, "森谷克己의 植民主義 社會經濟史學 批判", 韓國史學史學報, (22), pp.217~253 (2010), 한국사학사학회
- 박준형, "하타다 다카시의 중국 촌락 연구와한국사 서술에의 영향", 한국학연구, (62), pp.47~90 (2021), 한국학연구소
- 박근칠, "變革論의 동아시아적 환류- 최근 中國史學界의 ‘唐宋變革期’ 연구와 관련하여", 일본역사연구, (38), pp.5~34 (2013), 일본사학회
- 신현승, "日本의 東洋史學者 内藤湖南의 歷史認識 —支那認識과 文化史觀을 중심으로—", 동아시아고대학, 19, pp.321~353 (2009), 동아시아고대학회
- 손병규, "시카타 히로시(四方 博)의 조선시대 ‘인구･가족’ 연구에 대한 재검토", 韓國史學報, (52), pp.307~336 (2013), 고려사학회
- "Nippon rekishi 日本歴史", 1995, 21~42
- Taisuke Hayashi 林泰輔, (1912), Fuzanbō
- Tanaka, Stefan, "Japan’s Orient : Rendering Pasts into History" (1993), University of California Press
- Wagner, Edward W, "Social Background of early Yi Dynasty Neo-Confucianists", Han’guk ŭi ch’ŏrhak 한국의 철학, 10, pp.131~151 (1982)
- "Yŏksa hakpo 歷史學報", 1980, 115~157
- Wagner, Edward W, "Studies in Asian Genealogy", pp.141~152 (1972), Brigham Young University Press
- Yi Kibaek 李基白, (1961), Taesŏngsa
- "Han’guksa simin kangjwa 한국사 시민강좌", 1987, 1~19
- "Han’guksa simin kangjwa 한국사 시민강좌", 1987, 53~69
- "Asea 亞細亞", 1969, 70~75