Labor Strike in Communist Society: A Comparison between the Soviet Union and Poland
0
조회
0
다운로드
1
인용
0
참고문헌
키워드
초록
The present study explains the difference in labor militancy between the Soviet Union and Poland by examining causes and patterns of labor strikes in the two countries. Instead of attributing the difference in labor militancy between the two countries to the different conditions of “shop-floor politics,” this study employs a strategy of a macro-level approach to labor strikes, and examined the association of strikes with fluctuations in workers’ real consumption. On this basis, this paper attempts to capture the nature of the “social contract” between the regime and labor in the communist state. The main arguments of this paper can be summarized as follows. In both countries the primary cause of labor protests was the downfall of workers’ real consumption. The primary cause of the difference in labor militancy between the two countries lay in different degrees of fluctuations in the workers’ real consumption. Frustration of rising expectation such as sharp downfall of worker’s real wage repeatedly led directly to regime-labor confrontations in Poland. In contrast, the Soviet leadership localized labor disputes while avoiding a sharply rising expectation among workers and by maintaining a stable increase in workers’ consumption at the national level. The comparison of the two countries confirms that the legitimacy of communist rule was based mainly on the economic performance of the regime. The higher level of workers’ militancy in Poland was due to the lower level of the Polish regime’s economic performance i.e. the failure to keep the “social contract.” The labor quiescence continued in the Soviet Union thanks to the regime’s capacity to provide the workers with economic security and steady increase in the standard of living, particularly during the Brezhnev leadership.
Abstract
The present study explains the difference in labor militancy between the Soviet Union and Poland by examining causes and patterns of labor strikes in the two countries. Instead of attributing the difference in labor militancy between the two countries to the different conditions of “shop-floor politics,” this study employs a strategy of a macro-level approach to labor strikes, and examined the association of strikes with fluctuations in workers’ real consumption. On this basis, this paper attempts to capture the nature of the “social contract” between the regime and labor in the communist state. The main arguments of this paper can be summarized as follows. In both countries the primary cause of labor protests was the downfall of workers’ real consumption. The primary cause of the difference in labor militancy between the two countries lay in different degrees of fluctuations in the workers’ real consumption. Frustration of rising expectation such as sharp downfall of worker’s real wage repeatedly led directly to regime-labor confrontations in Poland. In contrast, the Soviet leadership localized labor disputes while avoiding a sharply rising expectation among workers and by maintaining a stable increase in workers’ consumption at the national level. The comparison of the two countries confirms that the legitimacy of communist rule was based mainly on the economic performance of the regime. The higher level of workers’ militancy in Poland was due to the lower level of the Polish regime’s economic performance i.e. the failure to keep the “social contract.” The labor quiescence continued in the Soviet Union thanks to the regime’s capacity to provide the workers with economic security and steady increase in the standard of living, particularly during the Brezhnev leadership.
참고문헌 (49)
- Bauer, T., "Investment Cycles in Planned Economies", Acta Oeconomica, 21(3), pp.243~260 (1978)
- Berliner, Joseph, "The Innovation Decision in Soviet Industry" (1976), MIT Press
- Bersten, George, "Worker Power under Communism:The Interplay of Exit and Voice", Comparative Economic Studies, 32(1), pp.42~72 (1990)
- Bialer, Seweryn, "Stalin’s Successors: Leadership, Stability, and Change in the Soviet Union" (1980), Cambridge Univ. Press
- Blazyca, George, "Policy and Politics in Contemporary Poland" (1982), St. Martin’s Press
- Boiter, Albert, "When the Kettle Boils Over", Problems of Communism, 13(1), pp.33~43 (1964)
- Breslauer, George W., "Khrushchev and Brezhnev as Leaders: Building Authority in Soviet Politics" (1982), George Allen & Unwin
- Breslauer, George W., "The Soviet Polity in Modern Era" (1984), Aldine
- Buck, Trevor, "Modern Soviet Economic Performance" (1987), Basil Blackwell
- Bunce, Valerie, "Do New Leaders Make a Difference?: Executive Succession as Public Policy under Capitalism and Socialism" (1981), Princeton Univ. Press
- Bunce, Valerie, "Soviet Politics in the Brezhnev Era", pp.1~26 (1980), Praeger
- Burawoy, Michael, "The Politics of Production: Factory Regimes under Capitalism and Socialism" (1985), New Left Books
- Chapman, Janet G., "Industrial labor in the USSR", pp.151~183 (1979), Pergamon Press
- Connor, Walter D., "Industrial labor in the USSR", pp.313~332 (1979), Pergamon Press
- Cook, Linda J., "Brezhnev’s ‘Social Contract’ and Gorbachev’s Reform", Soviet Studies, 44(1), pp.37~56 (1992)
- Dahlstedt, Roy, "Cyclical Fluctuation under Central Planning: An Inquiry into the Nature and Causes of Cyclical Fluctuation in the Soviet Economy", pp.1980
- Edwards, P. K., "Conflict at Work: A Materialist Analysis of Workplace Relation" (1986), Basil Blackwell
- Gidwitz, Betsy, "Labor Unrest in the Soviet Union", Problems of Communism, 31(6), pp.25~42 (1982)
- Goldman, Marshall I., "USSR in Crisis: The Failure of an Economic System" (1983), W. W. Norton
- Goodwyn, Lawrence, "Breaking the Barrier: The Rise of Solidarity in Polan" (1991), Oxford Univ. Press
- Gregory, Paul R., "Soviet Economic Structure and Performance" (1990), Harper & Row
- Hewett, Edward A., "Reforming the Soviet Economy: Equality versus Efficiency" (1988), The Brookings Institution
- Hoffman, Erik, "The Soviet Polity in Modern Era" (1984), Aldine
- Kahan, Arcadius, "Industrial Labor in the USSR" (1979), Pergamon Press
- Kornai, Janois, "The Hungarian Reform Process: Visions, Hopes and Reality", Journal of Economic Literature, 24(4), pp.1687~1737 (1986)
- Laba, Roman, "The Roots of Solidarity" (1991), Princeton Univ. Press
- Lane, David, "The Soviet Industrial Worker" (1978), Martin Robertson
- Ludlam, Janine, "Reform and The Redefinition of the Social Contract under Gorbachev", World Politics, 43(2), pp.284~312 (1991)
- Majkowski, Wladyslaw, "People’s Poland" (1985), Greenwood Press
- Mieczkowski, Bogdan, "The Relationship between Changes in Consumption and Politics in Poland", Soviet Studies, 30(2), pp.262~269 (1978)
- Montias, J. M., "Blue-Collar Workers in Eastern Europe", pp.175~187 (1981), George Allen & Unwin
- Norr, Henry, "Shchekino: Another Look", Soviet Studies, 38(2), pp.141~169 (1986)
- Nuti, Domenico Mario, "The Socialist Register", pp.104~143 (1981), The Merlin Press
- Pravda, Alex, "Industrial Labor in the USSR", pp.333~366 (1979), Pergamon Press
- Pravda, Alex, "Blue-Collar Workers in Eastern Europe", pp.43~69 (1981), George Allen & Unwin
- Ruble, Blair A., "The Applicability of Corporatist Models to the Study of Soviet Politics: The Case of the Trade Unions", The Carl Beck Papers in Russian and East European Studies, (303), pp.1~70 (1983), University of Pittsburgh
- Sabel, Charles F., "Planning, Politics and Shop-Floor Power: Hidden Forms of Bargaining in Soviet-Imposed State-Socialist Societies", Politics and Society, 11(4), pp.439~475 (1982)
- Schapiro, Leonard B., "The Soviet Worker" (1981), St. Martin’s Press
- Seeger, Murray, "The Soviet Worker", pp.76~105 (1981), St. Martin’s Press
- Shapiro, Ian, "Fiscal Crisis of the Polish State: Genesis of the 1980Strikes", Theory & Society, 10(4), pp.469~502 (1981)
- Simatupang, Bartara, "Economic Crisis and Full Employment: The Polish Case", The Journal of Communist Studies, 4(3), pp.282~300 (1988)
- Staniszkis, Jadwiga, "Poland’s Self-Limiting Revolution" (1984), Princeton University Press
- Teague, Elizabeth, "Solidarity and the Soviet Workers" (1988), Croom Helm
- Triska, Jan F., "Blue-Collar Workers in Eastern Europe" (1981), George Allen & Unwin
- Tyson, D’Andrea, "Blue-Collar Workers in Eastern Europe", pp.108~135 (1981), George Allen & Unwin
- Wheeler, Hoyt N., "Industrial Conflict: An Integrative Theory" (1985), University of South Carolina Press
- Wilczynski, J., "Industrial Relation in Planned Economies, Market Economies, and the Third World" (1983), St. Martin’s Press
- Woodall, Jean, "Policy and Politics in Contemporary Poland" (1982), St. Martin’s Press
- Zaslavsky, Viktor, "The Regime and the Working Class in the USSR", Telos, (42), pp.5~20 (1979)