논문KCI 등재
러시아의 우크라이나 침략과 전쟁 - 반제국주의 좌파는 어떤 관점과 태도를 가질 것인가
The Russian invasion of and war on Ukraine: what are the Views and Attitudes of the Anti-Imperialist Left?
0
조회
0
다운로드
1
인용
0
참고문헌
키워드
주제분류사회과학일반
초록
러시아의 우크라이나 침공이 낳은 야만적 참상과 국제적 악영향을 확인하면서, 푸틴 정부의 반동적 성격과 이 전쟁의 제국주의적 성격을 분석한다. 이것은 전형적인 자원 약탈과 영토 강탈을 위한 침략 행위라는 것이다. 그러나 동시에 미국, 서방 제국주의, 친미적 우파들의 역사적 죄과와 책임, 이중성에 대해서도 비판한다. 이어서 반제국주의 좌파들 속에서 전개되는 여러 논쟁을 살펴보면서 무엇이 올바른 관점과 방향일지 검토한다. 그리고 이 전쟁의 앞날을 전망하며 국제적 반전평화 운동의 중요성을 강조한다.
Abstract
This paper analyzes the reactionary nature of Putin's government and the imperial nature of this war, confirming the barbaric horrors and international adverse effects of Russia's invasion of Ukraine. This is a typical act of aggression for the purpose of resource-looting and territorial extortion. At the same time, however, this paper also criticizes the historical sins, responsibilities, and duality of the U.S., Western imperialism, and pro-American rightists. It then examines the various debates unfolding among anti-imperialist leftists and examines what will be the right perspective and direction. It also emphasizes the importance of the international anti-war peace movement, predicting the future of this war.
참고문헌 (52)
- 이양수, "침공한 러시아가 아닌 침공당한 우크라이나가 전쟁 자초했다는 이재명 후보의 인식이 충격이다", 국민의힘 선대본부 이양수 수석대변인 논평, ~ (2022)
- 서방 언론은 허구였다! 러시아 뜻대로 끝나가는 전쟁, "피렌체의 식탁", 2022
- 정성진, "제1차 세계대전과 트로츠키의 대안: 평화강령과 유럽합중국 슬로건을 중심으로", 마르크스주의 연구, 11(3), pp.70~102 (2014), 사회과학연구원[DOI]
- "표트르 대제 닮으려는 푸틴 “러시아 땅 되찾는 것은 의무”" (2022), 연합뉴스[URL]
- "우크라 보고도 “평화” 타령, 침공당하면 ‘종전 선언’ 종이 흔들텐가" (2022), 조선일보[URL]
- "민간인 사망자만 3만명 육박…우크라이나 전쟁, 끝이 안 보인다" (2022), 한겨레[URL]
- "러 ‘다극체제’ 의지 실린 침공…미 ‘일극체제’ 수호역량 시험대" (2022), 한겨레[URL]
- Achcar, Gilbert, "a memorandum on the radical anti‑imperialist position regarding the war in ukraine", Anti Capitalist Resistance, ~ (2022)
- Achcar, Gilbert, "For Arms Manufacturers, the War in Ukraine Is a Profits Bonanza", Jacobin, ~ (2022)
- Akopov, Pyotr, "The World According to Russian Propaganda", New Politics, ~ (2022)
- Bilous, Taras, "A letter to the Western Left from Kyiv", open Democracy, ~ (2022)
- Bilous, Taras, "Self-Determination and the War in Ukraine", COMMONS, ~ (2022)
- Bilous, Taras, "The Left in the West Must Rethink", New Politics, ~ (2022)
- Blanc, Eric, "Anti-imperial Marxism", International Socialist Review, (#100) (2016)
- Burgis, Ben, "A No-Fly Zone in Ukraine Would Start World War III. It’s the Worst Idea Possible", Jacobin, ~ (2022)
- Carpi, Guido, "Putin’s War Is a Disaster for Ordinary Russians", Jacobin, ~ (2022)
- Chomsky, Noam, "Every Time We Build Up Our Military Budget, We’re Attacking Ourselves", Jacobin, ~ (2022)
- Colborne, Michael, "An interview with Bellingcat journalist Michael Colborne on the Azov movement in Ukraine", Europe Solidaire Sans Frontières, ~ (2022)
- Draper, Hal, "The Myth of Lenin’s ‘Revolutionary Defeatism", marxists archive, ~ (2004)
- Dutchak, Oksana, "The War in Ukraine Seen on the Ground", TRANSNATIONAL SOCIAL STRIKE PLATFORM, ~ (2022)
- ecosocialist alliance, "ecosocialist alliance statement –ukraine", climate emergency, 2022
- Ghanem, Asad, "Dear President Zelensky, your support for Israel is a disgrace", Middle East Eye, ~ (2022)
- Godz, Polina, "Ukraine Needs a Global Antiwar Movement", Jacobin, ~ (2022)
- Grosso, Joseph, "Gone Rogue: The Left and Ukraine", CounterPunch, ~ (2022)
- Hannah, Simon, "revolutionary defeatism, yesterday and today", Anti Capitalist Resistance, ~ (2022)
- Hearse, Phil, "sanctions, a question of who, where and when", Anti Capitalist Resistance, ~ (2022)
- Hensman, Rohini, "The Historical Background to Putin’s Invasion of Ukraine", New Politics, ~ (2022)
- Karadjis, Michael, "putin’s conquest of southeast ukraine: vexed questions of ‘negotiations’, gotcha moments and real imperial interests", Anti Capitalist Resistance, ~ (2022)
- Kellaway, David, "ukraine and the left", Anti Capitalist Resistance, ~ (2022)
- Kessler, Mario, "The Forgotten History of Ukrainian Independence", Rosa-Luxemburg-Stiftung, ~ (2022)
- Kobzar, Taras, "Interview with a Volunteer from the Kiev Territorial Defense", New Politics, ~ (2022)
- Kostick, Conor, "Evasions on the Left over Ukraine", Independent Left, ~ (2022)
- Lenin, V. I, "The Socialist Revolution and the Right of Nations to Self-Determination", Lenin Works Archive, ~ (1916)
- Lenin, V. I, "Letter to the Workers and Peasants of the Ukraine", Lenin Works Archive, ~ (1919)
- Marcetic, Branko, "Persecuting Ordinary Russians Won’t End Putin’s War", Jacobin, ~ (2022)
- Marcetic, Branko, "The CIA May Be Breeding Nazi Terror in Ukraine", Jacobin, ~ (2022)
- Marcetic, Branko, "The Orwellian Attacks on Critics of NATO Policy Must Stop", Jacobin, ~ (2022)
- Neale, Jonathan, "From Afghanistan to Ukraine", Anne Bonny, ~ (2022)
- Neale, Jonathan, "Putin, Modi and Trump: Ukraine and Racist Right-Wing Populism", Anne Bonny, ~ (2022)
- Neale, Jonathan, "facebook Message", ~ (2022)
- Pavlova, Valentina, "I Was Arrested at an Antiwar Demonstration in Saint Petersburg", Jacobin, ~ (2022)
- Piketty, Thomas, "The western elite is preventing us from going after the assets of Russia’s hyper-rich", Guardian, ~ (2022)
- Pirani, Simon, "The Russian Statelets in the Donbas Are No ‘People’s Republics’", Jacobin, ~ (2022)
- Putin, Vladimir, "Address by the President of the Russian Federation", President of Russia, ~ (2022)
- Reuters, "Most Ukrainians oppose territorial concessions, poll shows", ~ (2022)
- Solenberger, Peter, "The Ukraine War Will End, But How?", New Politics, ~ (2022)
- Teitelbaum, Benjamin, "Aleksandr Dugin Is the Reactionary Prophet of Russian Ultranationalism", Jacobin, ~ (2022)
- The New York Times, "The War in Ukraine Is Getting Complicated, and America Isn’t Ready", ~ (2022)
- TomDispatch, "Rajan Menon, War Is Hell", ~ (2022)
- Trotsky, Leon, "Learn to Think", Trotsky Internet Archive, ~ (1938)
- Wingate, Sophie, "Starmer warned expelling Nato-sceptic MPs could spark Labour civil war", Independent, ~ (2022)
관련 논문AI추천
마르크스주의적 시각에서 본 러시아 제국주의와 우크라이나박노자사회과학연구원 · 마르크스주의 연구2022 · 제19권 제3호A War for the Coming Multipolar World?: How Anti-Hegemonism Sometimes Evolves into a Pro-Putin Stance among the South Korean Left블라디미르 티호노프한국학중앙연구원 · Korea Journal2025 · 제65권 제2호러시아의 독재 권력, 극우민족주의, 그리고 우크라이나 침공 간의 관계 연구를 위한 시론정재원한국러시아문학회 · 러시아어문학연구논집2024 · 제85호우크라이나 전쟁이 국제 안보정세와 한반도에 미치는 영향과 함의전재성한국국방연구원 · 국방정책연구2023 · 제38권 제4호우크라이나 전쟁의 성격, 동학, 함의홍완석러시아연구소 · 슬라브硏究2022 · 제38권 제3호세계화 이후의 혼란기, 저항을 어떻게 할 것인가?박노자국학연구원 · 동방학지2024 · 제209호