본문 바로가기
KERD
논문KCI 등재

The Role of Asian-Pacific Organizations in Maintaining Regional Security

1

조회

0

다운로드

0

인용

0

참고문헌

초록

There are two regular regional security organizations in Asia*the Shanghai Cooperation Organization (SCO) and ASEAN Regional Forum (ARF)*through which regional states are involved in managing security pertaining to Eurasia and the AsiaPacific, respectively. Since 2001, AsiaPacific Economic Cooperation (APEC) leaders’ meetings have addressed aspects of economic security. Whereas the SCO seems well institutionalized and purposeful, the ARF appears weakly structured and ineffective. This is because, while member states of the SCO are generally trustful of one another and hold in common most security objectives, concerns, and norms in the organization, many member states of the ARF have uneasy relations among themselves and share few security objectives, concerns, and norms in the forum. Moreover, while the SCO represents priority multilateral foreign and security policy interests for the People’s Republic of China (PRC) and Russia, its two most important constituents, the ARF represents a secondary or fall-back position for the bilateral-first foreign and security policy relations of its major players like Japan, United States, and the PRC.

Abstract

There are two regular regional security organizations in Asia*the Shanghai Cooperation Organization (SCO) and ASEAN Regional Forum (ARF)*through which regional states are involved in managing security pertaining to Eurasia and the AsiaPacific, respectively. Since 2001, AsiaPacific Economic Cooperation (APEC) leaders’ meetings have addressed aspects of economic security. Whereas the SCO seems well institutionalized and purposeful, the ARF appears weakly structured and ineffective. This is because, while member states of the SCO are generally trustful of one another and hold in common most security objectives, concerns, and norms in the organization, many member states of the ARF have uneasy relations among themselves and share few security objectives, concerns, and norms in the forum. Moreover, while the SCO represents priority multilateral foreign and security policy interests for the People’s Republic of China (PRC) and Russia, its two most important constituents, the ARF represents a secondary or fall-back position for the bilateral-first foreign and security policy relations of its major players like Japan, United States, and the PRC.

참고문헌 (56)

  1. "Jiang Zemin Calls for Regional Anti-terrorism Mechanism between SCO" (2002)[URL]
  2. Bates Gill, "Rising Star: China’s New Security Diplomacy", pp.45~ (2007), Brookings Institution Press
  3. Takeshi Yuzawa, "Japan’s changing conception of the ASEAN Regional Forum: From an Optimistic Liberal to a Pessimistic Realist Perspective", Pacific Review, 18(4), pp.468~ (2005)
  4. William J. Clinton, "Fundamentals of Security for a New Pacific Century", The National Assembly of the Republic of Korea, Seoul, South Korea, ~ (1993)
  5. J.N. Mak, "The Asia-Pacific Security Order, In Asia-Pacific in the New World Order", pp.116~ (1998), Routledge
  6. Evelyn Goh, "The ASEAN Regional Forum in United States East Asian Strategy", Pacific Review, 17(1), pp.55~ (2004)
  7. "The ASEAN Secretariat"[URL]
  8. "Chairman’s Statement: The Second ASEAN Regional Forum Ministerial Meeting, Bandar Seri Begawan, Brunei Darussalam, August 1, 1995" (1995)[URL]
  9. John Ravenhill, "The Growth of Intergovernmental Collaboration in the AsiaPacific Region, In Asia-Pacific in the New World Order", pp.265~ (1998), Routledge
  10. Dominik Heller, "The Relevance of the ASEAN Regional Forum (ARF) for Regional Security in the Asia-Pacific", Contemporary Southeast Asia, 27(1), pp.138~ (2005)
  11. Joseph A. Camilleri, "Regionalism in the New Asia-Pacific Order", pp.168~ (2003), Edward Elgar
  12. Wang Jianwei, "China’s Multilateral Diplomacy in the New Millennium, In China Rising: Power and Motivation in Chinese Foreign Policy", pp.182~ (2005), Rowman & Littlefield
  13. "The Shanghai Cooperation Organization"[URL]
  14. RIA News Agency, "Moscow, in Russian 0315, ‘‘Russian Diplomat Appointed Deputy CEO of Shanghai Cooperation Organization", BBC Monitoring Former Soviet Union, ~ (2004)
  15. "The Shanghai Cooperation Organization"[URL]
  16. "The Shanghai Cooperation Organization"[URL]
  17. "The Shanghai Cooperation Organization"[URL]
  18. "Declaration by the Heads of Member-States of the Shanghai Cooperation Organization, July 5, 2005" (2005)[URL]
  19. "Australian Government Department of Foreign Affairs and Trade"[URL]
  20. "ASEAN Secretariat"[URL]
  21. Charles I. Cohen, "The ASEAN Regional Forum", McGill International Review, (Spring), pp.49~ (2005)
  22. John Garofano, "Flexibility or irrelevance:Ways forward for the ARF", Contemporary Southeast Asia, 21(1), pp.75~ (1999)
  23. Simon S.C. Tay, "The ASEAN Regional Forum: Preparing for Preventive Diplomacy", Contemporary Southeast Asia, 19(3), pp.254~ (1997)
  24. John Garofano, "Power, Institutions, and the ASEAN Regional Forum", Asian Survey, 42(3), pp.517~ (2002)
  25. Xu Tao, "‘‘On the Institutionalization of the Shanghai Cooperation Organization", International Politics, (10), pp.1~ (2003)
  26. Hua Yujie, "Shanghai Cooperation Organization: Regional Security and Economic Progress", International Politics, (4), pp.90~91 (2005)
  27. "The Shanghai Cooperation Organization"[URL]
  28. "Declaration by the Heads of Member-States of the Shanghai Cooperation Organization (Astana, July 5, 2005)" (2005)[URL]
  29. "SCO Member States Pledge Efforts to Deal with New Security Challenges" (2005)[URL]
  30. "Premier Wen Leaves for Home after SCO meeting in Moscow" (2005)[URL]
  31. "The Shanghai Cooperation Organization"[URL]
  32. Hu Qihua, "SCO Summit Flexes Anti-terror Muscles", China Daily, ~ (2005)
  33. "Shanghai grouping moves centre stage"[URL]
  34. Yu Changsen, "The Objectives of ARF and the Big Powers’ Strategies", Southeast Asian Studies, (4), pp.25~ (2000)
  35. Michael Leifer, "The ASEAN Regional Forum", Adelphi Papers, (302), pp.42~ (1996)
  36. Chen Zhiming, "Comments on the ARF", Southeast Asian Studies, (6), pp.37~ (1998)
  37. Shaun Narine, "ASEAN and the ARF: The Limits of the ‘ASEAN Way’", Asian Survey, 37(10), pp.976~977 (1997)
  38. Tsuyoshi Kawasaki, "Neither Scepticism Nor Romanticism: The ASEAN Regional Forum as a Solution for the AsiaPacific Assurance Game", Pacific Review, 19(2), pp.234~ (2006)
  39. Takeshi Yuzawa, "The Evolution of Preventive Diplomacy in the ASEAN Regional Forum", Asian Survey, 46(5), pp.798~800 (2006)
  40. Gerald Segal, "The Asia-Pacific: What Kind of Challenge?, In Asia-Pacific in the New World Order", pp.325~ (1998), Routledge
  41. Barry Desker, "The ARF: An Agenda for Progress", paper presented at the CSCAP General Meeting in Canberra (2001)
  42. "ASEAN Regional Forum Calls for Immediate Middle East Truce" (2006)[URL]
  43. "‘Remarks at the ASEAN Regional Forum"[URL]
  44. Yu Changsen, "The Objectives of ARF and the Big Powers’ Strategies", Southeast Asian Studies, (4), pp.24~ (2000)
  45. "Australia, Japan Enter a New Phase" (2007)[URL]
  46. Richard Halloran, "On the Edge", South China Morning Post, ~ (2007)
  47. Hiro Katsumata, "Research Fellow at the Institute of Defence and Strategic Studies"
  48. Shen Jianing, "APEC Shanghai Meeting and China’s International Image", Studies of International Politics, (83), pp.116~ (2002)
  49. "The Five Big Challenges to APEC in Coming Years" (2004)[URL]
  50. V. K. Aggarwal, "AsiaPacific Economic Cooperation (APEC): Transregionalism with a New Cause?, In Interregionalism and International Relations", pp.78~ (2006), Routledge
  51. [URL]
  52. "Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation"[URL]
  53. "APEC Tackles Security after Climate Compromise" (2007)[URL]
  54. William Bodde Jr, "View from the 19th Floor: Reflections of the First APEC Executive Director", pp.67~ (1994), Institute of Southeast Asian Studies
  55. Steward Goodings, "The APEC Secretariat: A Management Perspective, In APEC as an Institution: Multilateral Governance in the Asia-Pacific", pp.68~ (2003), Institute of Southeast Asian Studies
  56. Charles E. Morrison, "APEC in Sino-American Relations: AVehicle for Systemic Integration, In Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation (APEC): The First Decade", pp.126~ (2002), RoutledgeCurzon

관련 논문AI추천

이 간행물의 다른 논문 (5건)