본문 바로가기
KERD
논문KCI 등재

The Arctic: A New Issue on Asia’s Security Agenda

Stephen Blank|김연규
한국국방연구원 (Korea Institute for Defense Analyses)|2011.09|The Korean Journal of Defense Analysis|제23권 제3호|pp. 303-320|DOI 10.22883/kjda.2011.23.3.001

0

조회

0

다운로드

2

인용

0

참고문헌

초록

China has clearly emulated Russia’s previous example of making loud claims and increasing military patrols in the Arctic. China will likely become a major player in Arctic trade routes and become a main destination for goods shipped through the Northern Sea Route. It is likely that a significant part of future Russian oil and gas production will ultimately be supplied to China. What are the strategic implications of China’s active involvement in Arctic politics? The Arctic “Great Game” is often described as a new Cold War between the United States and Russia. Regionally, the two main protagonists are Russia and Norway. This article makes a different argument. The Arctic has recently become an issue on the Russo-Chinese,and possibly Russo-Japanese security agenda. The first goal of this article is to examine the Arctic policy and strategy of Russia, perhaps the most difficult nation to understand in terms of Arctic security. The second goal of the article is to explain how the Arctic has become an issue of concern in Russia’s relationship with China.

Abstract

China has clearly emulated Russia’s previous example of making loud claims and increasing military patrols in the Arctic. China will likely become a major player in Arctic trade routes and become a main destination for goods shipped through the Northern Sea Route. It is likely that a significant part of future Russian oil and gas production will ultimately be supplied to China. What are the strategic implications of China’s active involvement in Arctic politics? The Arctic “Great Game” is often described as a new Cold War between the United States and Russia. Regionally, the two main protagonists are Russia and Norway. This article makes a different argument. The Arctic has recently become an issue on the Russo-Chinese,and possibly Russo-Japanese security agenda. The first goal of this article is to examine the Arctic policy and strategy of Russia, perhaps the most difficult nation to understand in terms of Arctic security. The second goal of the article is to explain how the Arctic has become an issue of concern in Russia’s relationship with China.

참고문헌 (90)

  1. Scott G. Borgerson, "The Great Game Moves North", Foreign Affairs (2009)
  2. Scott G. Borgerson, "The Arctic Meltdown", Foreign Affairs (2008)
  3. Charles K. Ebinger, "The Geopolitics of Arctic Melt", International Affairs, 85(6), pp.1222~1225 (2009)
  4. Chris Arsenault, "A Scramble for the Arctic", Al Jazeera, ~ (2010)
  5. Lawson Brigham, "The Arctic", Foreign Policy, pp.3~ (2010)
  6. Espen Barth Eide, "The Return of Geopolitics and Energy Security, In High North: High Stakes: Security, Energy, Transport, and Environment", pp.42~43 (2008), Fagbokforlaget
  7. Charles Emmerson, "The Future History of the Arctic", pp.160~161 (2010), Public Affairs
  8. Rob Huebert, "The Newly Emerging Arctic Security Environment", pp.3~15 (2010), Canadian Defence & Foreign Affairs Institute
  9. Marlene Laruelle, "Russian Military Presence in the High North: Projection of Power and Capacities of Action, In Russia in the Arctic" (2011), Strategic Studies Institute, U.S. Army War College
  10. Pavel Baev, "Trouble-Making and Risk Taking: The North in Russian Military Activities, In Russia and the North", pp.21~ (2009), University of Ottawa Press
  11. Russia’s Arctic Policy: Geopolitics, Mercantilism, and Identity- Building, "Pavel Baev", Finish Institute of International Affairs, ~, pp.Briefing Paper no. 73 (2010)
  12. Aleksandr Stepanov, "The Great Arctic: Russia Is Not Ready For a Large-Scale War Above the Arctic Circle", Moscow, Nasha Versiya Website, ~ (2010)
  13. Open Source Center, "Foreign Broadcast Information Service, Central Eurasia (Henceforth FBIS-SOV)", ~ (2010)
  14. "Moscow, Interfax-AVN Online, FBIS-SOV", ~ (2009)
  15. Open Source Center, "OSC Feature, Moscow, Rossiya 24, September 23, 2010, FBISSOV, September 23, 2010", ~
  18. "Moscow, ITAR-TASS, in Russian, September 23, 2010, FBIS-SOV, September 213, 2010", ~
  19. Elana Wilson Rowe, "Introduction: Policy Aims and Political Realities in the Russian North, In Russia and the North", pp.9~10 (2009), University of Ottawa Press
  20. "Moscow, ITAR-TASS, in Russian, September 14, 2010, FBIS-SOV, September 14, 2010", ~
  21. Ministry of Energy of the Russian Federation, "Energeticheskaya Strategiya Rossii Na Period do 2030 Goda", ~ (2009)
  22. "Russian Scientist Says Arctic Has Almost As Much Oil and Gas As the Gulf", Moscow, ITAR-TASS, September 22, 2010, FBIS-SOV, September 22, 2010, ~
  23. "Moscow, Interfax- AVN Online, August 9, 2010, FBIS-SOV, August 9, 2010", ~
  24. "Moscow, Interfax, September 9, 2010, FBIS-SOV, September 9, 2010", ~
  25. Reykjavik, Eyjam, "September 23, 2010, FBIS-SOV, September 23, 2010", ~
  26. "Equatorial Guinea Sings Gazprom Deals", Reuters, ~ (2010)
  27. "Moscow, Interfax, August 31, 2010, FBIS-SOV, August 31, 2010, Putin Says LNG, Shelf Gas Projects a Priority", Reuters Africa, ~ (2010)
  28. "Moscow, Interfax, September 17, 2010, FBIS- SOV, September 17, 2010", ~
  29. , October 2, 2010, FBIS-SOV, October 6, 2010, Moscow, ITAR-TASS, October 6, 2010,
  30. "FBIS-SOV, October 2, 2010", ~ (2010)
  31. "Open Source Center, OSC Report, FBIS-SOV, September 7, 2007", ~ (2007)
  32. Kristian Atland, "The Introduction, Adoption and Implementation of Russia’s “Northern Strategic Bastion” Concept, 1992–1999", Journal of Slavic Military Studies, X(4), pp.499~528 (2007)
  33. "Russia and Norway’s Arctic Challenge", Jane’s Intelligence Digest, ~ (2008)
  34. "FBIS-SOV, November 28, 2010", ~ (2010)
  35. "Reforma Flota", ~
  36. Mikhail Lukanin, "Navy Prepares to Defend Russian Oil", Moscow, Trud, November 24, 2010, FBIS-SOV, November 28, 2010, ~
  37. "Reforma Flota: Glavnaya Ugroza na Dalnem Vostoke"[URL]
  38. , September 13, 2006, FBIS-SOV, September 13, 2006, , ~
  39. "Moscow, ITAR-TASS, May 5, 2008, FBIS-SOV, May 5, 2008", ~
  40. , May 15, 2008, FBIS-SOV, May 15, 2008, , ~
  41. "Moscow, IRAR-TASS, March 20, 2008, FBISSOV, March 20, 2008", ~
  42. Dmitri Litovkin, "We Didn’t Send Him For a Star; Moscow", Agentstvo Voyennykh Novostey, ~ (2008)
  47. "Solna, Sweden, SIPRI, March 1, 2010, FBIS-SOV, March 4, 2010", ~
  48. China and the Arctic: Threat or Cooperation Potential for Canada, "Frederic Lassere", Centre of International Relations, University of British Columbia, 3~5, pp.China Papers, no. 11 (2010)
  49. Linda Jakobson, "China Prepares For an Ice-free Arctic", SIPRI Insights on Peace and Security, (2), pp.3~12 (2010), SIPRI Institute (Stockholm International Peace Research Institute)
  50. Arvind Gupta, "Geopolitical Implications of Arctic Meltdown", Strategic Analysis, XXXIII(2), pp.177~ (2009)
  52. , September 15, 2010, , 2010
  53. "FBIS-SOV, September 15, 2010", ~ (2010)
  54. "China’s Arctic Play"[URL]
  55. Minnie Chan, "Admiral Urges Government to Stake Claim in the Arctic", South China Morning Post, 7~ (2010)
  56. Geoff Dyer, "Beijing Builds to Hold U.S. Power at Bay", Financial Times, 6~ (2011)
  57. China Naval Modernization: Implications for U.S. Navy Capabilities- Background and Issues for Congress, "Ronald O’Rourke", Congressional Research Service, 5~7 (2010)
  58. Annual Report to Congress on Military and Security Developments Involving the People’s Republic of China 2010, "U.S. Department of Defense", 29~37 (2010)
  59. China’s Out of Area Naval Operations: Case Studies, Trajectories, Obstacles, and Potential Solutions, "Christopher D. Yung", Fort Lesley J. McNair, Center for Strategic Operations, Institute for National Security Studies, National Defense University, ~ (2010)
  60. "China Seeks Piece of Arctic Pie"[URL]
  61. Ashley J. Tellis, "Overview: Strategic Asia Continuing Success With Continuing Risk, In Strategic Asia 2010-11: Asia’s Rising Power and America’s Continuing Purpose", pp.9~10 (2010), National Bureau of Asian Research
  62. Gillian Wong, "Russia Wants to supply All of China’s Gas Needs" (2010), Associated Press
  63. Sergei Blagov, "Russia Plans Increased Energy Exports", Eurasia Daily Monitor, ~ (2010)
  64. "Moscow, Moscow Times Online, May 27, 2010", ~ (2010)
  65. "FBIS-SOV, May 27, 2010", ~ (2010)
  67. One Step Forward, Two Steps Back?: The Realities of a Rising China and Implications for Russia’s Energy Ambitions, "Igor Danchenko", 2~, pp.Brookings Policy Paper, no. 22 (2010)
  68. Stephen Blank, "Russo-Chinese Energy Relations: Politics in Command" (2006), Global Markets Briefing
  69. Mansur Mirovalev, "Russia, China Postpone Major Gas Deal" (2011), Associated Press
  70. How the Chinese See Russia, "Bobo Lo", Institut Francais des Relations Internationales, 8~12, pp.Russie.Nei Reports, no. 6 (2010)
  71. "Navy Commander Says Russia to Fight for Arctic As China Sets Its Eyes On it", Moscow, ITAR-TASS, News Agency, ~ (2010)
  72. "FBIS-SOV, October 4, 2010", ~ (2010)
  73. , November 12, 2010, , 2010
  74. "FBIS-SOV, November 13, 2010", ~ (2010)
  76. Roger McDermott, "Russian Military Doctrine Looks East", Eurasia Daily Monitor, ~ (2010)
  77. Jacob Kipp, "Russia’s Nuclear Posture and the Threat That Dare not Speak Its Name", Conference Strategy and Doctrine in Russian Security Policy (2010), National Defense University, Fort Lesley J. McNair
  79. Russia’s Nuclear Posture and the Threat That Dare Not Speak Its Name, "Jacob Kipp", Strategic Studies Institute, U.S. Army War College, ~
  81. , October 16, 2009, FBIS-SOV, October 16, 2009, , ~
  82. "Moscow, Interfax-AVN Online, December 20, 2010, FBIS-SOV, December 20, 2010", ~
  83. "Ballistic Missile, PLA Second Artillery Force Reinforces Deployments Against Japan, Russia", Toronto, Kanwa Asian Defense, May 1–31, 2010, FBIS-SOV June 2, 2010, ~
  85. Chu Shulong, "China: Dynamic Minimum Deterrence, In The Long Shadow: Nuclear Weapons and Security in 21st Century Asia", pp.170~ (2008), Stanford University Press
  86. , July 8, 2010, FBIS-SOV, August 23, 2010,
  87. "Private conversation with Roger McDermott", ~ (2010)
  88. Ashley J. Tellis, "China’s Grand Strategy; The quest for Comprehensive National Power and Its Consequences, In The Rise of China: Essays on the Future Competition", pp.33~ (2009), Encounter Books
  89. M. Taylor Frawel, "International Relations Theory and China’s Rise: Assessing China’s Potential for Territorial Expansion", International Studies Review, XII(4), pp.505~531 (2010)

관련 논문AI추천

The Russian Approach to National Security in the ArcticAlexey Kravchuk, Sergey Sevastyanov한국국방연구원 · The Korean Journal of Defense Analysis2017 · 제29권 제1호The Arctic and Asia in Russian Naval StrategyStephen Blank한국국방연구원 · The Korean Journal of Defense Analysis2017 · 제29권 제4호Russiaʼs Arctic Military Strategy and Its Implications in the Post–Cold War Era윤지원한국국방연구원 · The Korean Journal of Defense Analysis2021 · 제33권 제2호Non-traditional Maritime Security Threats in Northeast Asia: Implications for Regional Cooperation임경한국제학연구소 · Journal of International and Area Studies2015 · 제22권 제2호Russo-Chinese Energy Collaboration and Divergence in the Arctic Ocean Region: from Yamal LNG to Arctic LNG 2윤익중, Maxim Nazarov동유럽발칸연구소 · 동유럽발칸연구2022 · 제46권 제4호‘일대일로’ 전략에서 본 중국의 북극 ‘빙상실크로드’김덕기한국해양안보포럼 · 한국해양안보논총2019 · 제2권 제1호

이 간행물의 다른 논문 (7건)

North-South Korea Relations under the Lee Myung-bak Administration: The North’s Provocations and the South’s Principled Response박원곤pp. 321-333The Security Crisis in Korea and its International Context: Sources and Lessons from a Russian PerspectiveGeorgy Tolorayapp. 335-352New Games in Tightly Fixed Structures: North Korea’s Volatile Desperation and China’s Cornered StrategyShi Yinhongpp. 353-368RMA Diffusion Paths and Patterns in South Korea’s Military ModernizationMichael Raskapp. 369-385East Asian Developments and Contrasting Views among ASEAN Member Nations over East Asian Regionalism김형종, Lee Poh Ping, Mohammad Raduan Mohammad Ariffpp. 387-402
원문 보기