Denuclearization of North Korea: Before and After the Summits
2
조회
0
다운로드
3
인용
0
참고문헌
키워드
초록
This paper analyzes the background of the nuclear stalemate between Trump and Kim in the Hanoi Summit and investigates various issues involving North Korean denuclearization, including a detailed roadmap and proper compensation for Pyongyang. The paper uses tree cardinal perspectives of analytical tools (the will of the leader, nuclear capability, and nuclear strategy) to critically assess North Korea’s nuclear weapons program and fathom Kim Jong Un’s stance on denuclearization. The United States reaffirms CVID/FFVD principles regarding North Korea’s WMD, while Pyongyang prefers an action-for-action method of denuclearization. Although Pyongyang has announced an end to its nuclear testing and has shut down nuclear facilities, experts question whether Pyongyang really is dismantling its nuclear program. Pyongyang’s hidden nuclear facilities and accumulation of HEU in numerous places, the complicated process of verification, as well as potential traps in the details of the denuclearization agreement pose a big challenge. In light of the current nuclear stalemate, President Moon’s mediating effort to bring Kim Jong Un back to the denuclearization table is imperative.
Abstract
This paper analyzes the background of the nuclear stalemate between Trump and Kim in the Hanoi Summit and investigates various issues involving North Korean denuclearization, including a detailed roadmap and proper compensation for Pyongyang. The paper uses tree cardinal perspectives of analytical tools (the will of the leader, nuclear capability, and nuclear strategy) to critically assess North Korea’s nuclear weapons program and fathom Kim Jong Un’s stance on denuclearization. The United States reaffirms CVID/FFVD principles regarding North Korea’s WMD, while Pyongyang prefers an action-for-action method of denuclearization. Although Pyongyang has announced an end to its nuclear testing and has shut down nuclear facilities, experts question whether Pyongyang really is dismantling its nuclear program. Pyongyang’s hidden nuclear facilities and accumulation of HEU in numerous places, the complicated process of verification, as well as potential traps in the details of the denuclearization agreement pose a big challenge. In light of the current nuclear stalemate, President Moon’s mediating effort to bring Kim Jong Un back to the denuclearization table is imperative.
참고문헌 (73)
- Kim Jong Un, "New Year Address of Supreme Leader Kim Jong Un for 2019", The Rodong Sinmun, ~ (2019)
- Scott D. Sagan, "Why Do States Build Nuclear Weapons?: Three Models in Search of a Bomb", International Security, 21(3), pp.54~86 (1996)
- Daniel Byman, "Pyongyang’s Survival Strategy: Tools of Authoritarian Control in North Korea", International Security, 35(1), pp.44~74 (2010)
- Daniel R. Coats, "Statement for the Record: Worldwide Threat Assessment of the U.S. Intelligence Community", Senate Select Committee on Intelligence, 27~ (2019)
- Edward Kwon, "South Korea’s Deterrence Strategy against North Korea’s WMD", East Asia: An International Quarterly, 35(1), pp.13~ (2018)
- Institute for National Security Strategy, "The White Paper on Five Year of Misrule of Kim Jong Un Regime", pp.129~130 (2016), INSS
- "Here’s How Much a Nuclear Weapon Costs" (2017)[URL]
- "North Korea Proclaims Itself a Nuclear State in New Constitution" (2012)[URL]
- Report on Plenary Meeting of WPK Central Committee, , Korean Central News Agency of DPRK, ~ (2013)
- Political News Team, "3rd Plenary Meeting of 7th C.C., WPK Help in Presence of Kim Jong Un", The Rodong Sinmun, ~ (2018)
- "Kim Jong Un’s New Year Address", The Rodong Sinmun, ~ (2018)
- A Return Trip to North Korea’s Yongbyon Nuclear Complex, "Siegfried S. Hecker", Stanford University, Center for International Security and Cooperation, ~ (2010)
- Rodong News Team, "DPRK Nuclear Weapons Institute on Successful Test of H-bomb for ICBM", The Rodong Sinmun, ~ (2017)
- "What’s the Difference between a Hydrogen Bomb and a Regular Atomic Bomb?" (2017)[URL]
- "DPRK Succeeds in Nuclear Warhead Explosion Test", The Rodong Sinmun, ~ (2016)
- Hans M. Kristensen, "North Korean Nuclear Capabilities, 2018", Bulletin of the Atomic Scientists, 74(1), pp.41~51 (2018)
- Siegfried S. Hecker, "What We Really Know About North Korea’s Nuclear Weapons and What We Don’t Yet Know for Sure", Foreign Affairs (2017)
- David E. Sanger, "North Korea Tests a Ballistic Missile That Experts Say Could Hit California", The New York Times, A1~ (2017)
- Mark Landler, "North Korea Fires a Ballistic Missile, in a Further Challenge to Trump", The New York Times, A1~ (2017)
- Report to Congress on Military and Security Developments Involving the Democratic People’s Republic of Korea, "U.S. Department of Defense", 10~ (2017)
- "North Korea’s New ICBM Likely Broke Up upon Re-entry, US Official Says" (2017)[URL]
- "Selva Discusses Nature of Nuclear Deterrence at Mitchell Institute Forum" (2017)[URL]
- Scott D. Sagan, "The Spread of Nuclear Weapons: A Debate Renewed" (2003), W.W. Norton & Company
- Victor D. Cha, "North Korea’s Weapons of Mass Destruction: Badges, Shields, or Swords?", Political Science Quarterly, 117(2), pp.209~230 (2002)
- Terence Roehrig, "Strategy in the Second Nuclear Age: Power, Ambition, and the Ultimate Weapon", pp.81~98 (2012), Georgetown University Press
- "North Korea’s Evolving Nuclear Strategy, North Korea’s Nuclear Futures Series" (2015)[URL]
- Vipin Narang, "Nuclear Strategies of Emerging Nuclear Powers: North Korea and Iran", The Washington Quarterly, 38(1), pp.73~91 (2015)
- "DPRK Supreme People’s Assembly Act: Consolidating Position of Self-reliant Nuclear Weapons States", The Rodong Sinmun, ~ (2013)
- "Law on Consolidating Position of Nuclear Weapons States Adopted" (2013)[URL]
- "U.S. Should Be Accustomed to Status of DPRK as Nuclear Weapons State", KCNA, ~ (2016)
- The North Korean Nuclear Challenge: Military Options and Issues for Congress, "Kathleen J. McInnis", Congressional Research Service, 9~10, pp.Congressional Research Service R44944 (2017)
- Singapore and Beyond: Option for Denuclearizing North Korea, In Brookings Foreign Policy: Policy Brief, "Robert Einhorn", 2~ (2018)
- Edward Wang, "Trump’s Talks with Kim Jong-un Collapse, and Both Sides Point Fingers", The New York Times, A10~ (2019)
- "Remarks: Remarks by President Trump in Press Conference, Hanoi, Vietnam" (2019)[URL]
- "North Korea Contradicts Trump: Seeks Partial Lifting of Sanctions" (2019)[URL]
- Sang-Hun Choe, "Kim Jong-un Will Visit South Korea, Leaders Announce", The New York Times, A10~ (2018)
- David E. Sanger, "Korea Talks Begin as Kim Jong-un Crosses to South’s Side of DMZ", The New York Times, A1~ (2018)
- Russell Goldman, "North and South Korea Summit Is Short on Details, but Long on Theater", The New York Times, A8~ (2018)
- "Remarks on the DPRK at Stanford University" (2019)[URL]
- "Transcript: Andrew Kim on North Korea Denuclearization and U.S.–DPRK Diplomacy" (2019)[URL]
- Sang-Hun Choe, "Kim Jong-un Says He Wants Denuclearization in Trump’s Current Term", The New York Times, A10~ (2018)
- "(Lead) Allies’ Top Security Adviser Discuss N. Korean Trip" (2018)[URL]
- "N. Korea’s Long-range Missile Test Site Faces Verifiable Shutdown" (2018)[URL]
- David E. Sanger, "How the Trump–Kim Summit Failed: Big Threats, Big Egos, Bad Bets", The New York Times, A1~ (2019)
- "Exclusive: With a Piece of Paper, Trump Called on Kim to Hand Over Nuclear Weapons" (2019)[URL]
- Robert D. Putnam, "Diplomacy and Domestic Politics: The Logic of Two–Level Games", International Organization, 42(3), pp.427~460 (1998)
- Michael Tackett, "Five Takeaways from Cohen’s Testimony to Congress", The New York Times, A15~ (2019)
- Michael R. Gordon, "Nuclear Talks Ran Aground Before Trump and Kim Met", The Wall Street Journal, A1~ (2019)
- Edward Kwon, "Policies of Last Resort for Dealing with North Korea’s Nuclear Weapons Programme", Asian Affairs, 49(3), pp.422~ (2018)
- The Trend of North Korea’s Trade in 2017, "KOTRA", KOTRA, 66~ (2018)
- Sang-un Choe, "Will Kim Jong-un Return to Brinkmanship? Weak Economy Is Forcing His Hand", The New York Times, A1~ (2019)
- "UN Calls for Food Aid for Starving North Koreans Despite Sanctions" (2019)[URL]
- "North Korea Appeals for Food Aid as Regime Cuts Rations Due to Drought and Sanctions" (2019)[URL]
- Victor Cha, "The Right Way to Coerce North Korea", Foreign Affairs, 97(3), pp.90~ (2018)
- Paul Sonne, "Trump Steps Up Warning", The Wall Street Journal, A1~ (2017)
- "Remarks: Remarks by President Trump to the 72nd Session of the United Nations General Assembly" (2017)[URL]
- Sang-Hun Choe, "North Korea Threatens to Halt Nuclear Talks with U.S. and Resume Tests", The New York Times, A4~ (2019)
- "Supreme Leader Kim Jong Un Makes Policy Speech at First Session of 14th SPA" (2019)[URL]
- "Trump Backs Third Summit with Kim, Says Relations ‘Very Good,’" (2019)[URL]
- "New North Korea Weapons Test Threatens Trump’s Diplomatic Achievement" (2019)[URL]
- David E. Sanger, "New North Korea Concerns Flare as Trump’s Signature Diplomacy Wilts", The New York Times, A1~ (2019)
- "Fate of DPRK–U.S. Joint Statement: Spokesperson for Ministry of Foreign Affairs of DPRK" (2019)[URL]
- Peter Baker, "After Twitter Overture, Trump and Kim Meet on North Korean Soil", The New York Times, A1~ (2019)
- Michael Crowley, "Eyeing Arms ‘Freeze’ to Ease New Talks", The New York Times, A1~ (2019)
- Political News Team, "Supreme Leader Kim Jong Un Has Historic Meeting with U.S. President Donald Trump at Panmunjom", The Rodong Sinmun, 1~ (2019)
- Nicholas D. Anderson, "Explaining North Korea’s Nuclear Ambitions: Power and Position on the Korean Peninsula", Australian Journal of International Affairs, 71(6), pp.624~625 (2017)
- "Bolton Says US Considering Libya Model for North Korean Denuclearization" (2018)[URL]
- Siegfried S. Hecker, "A Technically-informed Roadmap for North Korea’s Denuclearization" (2018), Center for International Security and Cooperation, Stanford University
- "Order from Chaos: A Step-by-Step Plan for Denuclearizing North Korea" (2018)[URL]
- Alexander Glaser, "Denuclearizing North Korea: A Verified, Phased Approach", Science, 361(6406), pp.981~983 (2018)
- David Albright, "Dismantling the DPRK’s Nuclear Weapons Program: A Practicable, Verifiable Plan of Action", United States Institute of Peace: Peaceworks, (54) (2006)
- "Argument: Total Denuclearization Is an Unattainable Goal. Here’s How to Reduce the North Korean Threat" (2018)[URL]
- "How South Korea’s ‘New Economic Map’ Could Shift Northeast Asia’s Balance of Power" (2018)[URL]
