The Obama Administration’s Strategic Pivot to Asia: From a Diplomatic to a Strategic Constrainment of an Emergent China?
0
조회
0
다운로드
6
인용
0
참고문헌
키워드
초록
This article examines the connection between President Barack Obama’s 2011 Strategic Pivot to Asia and former Secretary of State Hillary Clinton’s 2010 Hanoi Declaration on the South China Sea dispute. Secretary Clinton’s statement during the ASEAN Regional Forum (ARF) in July 2010 evoked a new diplomatic strategy in confronting an emergent and assertive China—constrainment. This strategy involved Washington working with the ssociation of Southeast Asian Nations (ASEAN) member-states in persuading China to adhere to a multilateral approach in resolving the South China Sea issue. However, China admonished the ASEAN states not to follow the U.S. bidding. As a major economic partner and an occasional political ally of most ASEAN states, China subsequently thwarted the U.S. design to form a regional bloc for a constrainment policy. Failing diplomatically, the Obama administration is rebalancing U.S. naval /air forces toward the Asia-Pacific region. This marks a shift from a diplomatic constrainment policy to a pivot strategy that is predicated on American military power.
Abstract
This article examines the connection between President Barack Obama’s 2011 Strategic Pivot to Asia and former Secretary of State Hillary Clinton’s 2010 Hanoi Declaration on the South China Sea dispute. Secretary Clinton’s statement during the ASEAN Regional Forum (ARF) in July 2010 evoked a new diplomatic strategy in confronting an emergent and assertive China—constrainment. This strategy involved Washington working with the ssociation of Southeast Asian Nations (ASEAN) member-states in persuading China to adhere to a multilateral approach in resolving the South China Sea issue. However, China admonished the ASEAN states not to follow the U.S. bidding. As a major economic partner and an occasional political ally of most ASEAN states, China subsequently thwarted the U.S. design to form a regional bloc for a constrainment policy. Failing diplomatically, the Obama administration is rebalancing U.S. naval /air forces toward the Asia-Pacific region. This marks a shift from a diplomatic constrainment policy to a pivot strategy that is predicated on American military power.
참고문헌 (95)
- Edward Hallett Carr, "The Twenty Years’ Crisis", pp.103~ (2001), Palgrave
- Stirring Up the South China Sea: Regional Responses, "International Crisis Group", 28~, pp.Asia Report No. 229 (2012)
- "The U.S. Stands Up to China’s Bullying, A-17" (2010)[URL]
- Martin S. Indyk, "Scoring Obama’s Foreign Policy: A Progressive Pragmatist Tries to Bend History", Foreign Affairs, 91(3), pp.33~ (2012)
- Gerald Segal, "East Asia and the Constrainment of China, In East Asia Security", pp.159~187 (1996), The MIT Press
- Gerald Segal, "East Asia and the Constrainment of China, In East Asia Security", pp.185~ (1996), The MIT Press
- Michael Yahuda, "Gerald Segal’s Contribution, In Does China Matter? A Reassessment", pp.6~ (2004), Routledge
- Gerald Segal, "Does China Matter?, In Does China Matter? A Reassessment", pp.19~ (2004), Routledge
- Gerald Segal, "East Asia and the Constrainment of China, In East Asia Security", pp.186~ (1996), The MIT Press
- Gerald Segal, "East Asia and the Constrainment of China, In East Asia Security", pp.186~ (1996), The MIT Press
- Michael Yahuda, "Gerald Segal’s Contribution, In Does China Matter? A Reassessment", pp.6~ (2004), Routledge
- Gerald Segal, "East Asia and the Constrainment of China, In East Asia Security", pp.187~ (1996), The MIT Press
- Mark Lander, "How Obama Switched to a Tougher Line with China", International Herald Tribune, ~ (2012)
- David Scott, "China’s Stands up: the PRC and the International System", pp.158~ (2007), Routledge
- Russell Ong, "China’s Security Interests in the Post-Cold War Era", pp.179~ (2002), Curzon Press
- Liselotte Odgaard, "The Balance of Power in Asia-Pacific Security: U.S.-China Policies on Regional Order", pp.54~ (2007), Routledge
- Liselotte Odgaard, "The Balance of Power in Asia-Pacific Security: U.S.-China Policies on Regional Order", pp.54~ (2007), Routledge
- Neil King, "Conflict Insurance: As China Boosts Defense Budget, U.S. Military Hedges its Bets: Pentagon Orchestrates Build-up of Forces in the Pacific; Counts on Japan", Wall Street Journal, A1~ (2006)
- Neil King, "Conflict Insurance: As China Boosts Defense Budget, U.S. Military Hedges its Bets: Pentagon Orchestrates Build-up of Forces in the Pacific; Counts on Japan", Wall Street Journal, A1~ (2006)
- Christopher D. Yung, "Introduction, In The Chinese Navy: Expanding Capabilities, Evolving Roles", pp.15~ (2011), National Defense University Press
- Edward Wong, "China Asserts Role as a Naval Power", International Herald Tribune, ~ (2010)
- Michael A. Glosny, "Getting Beyond Taiwan? Chinese Foreign Policy and PLA Modernization", Strategic Forum, (261), pp.4~ (2011)
- Bates Gill, "China as a Regional Military Power, In Does China Matter? A Reassessment", pp.124~164 (2004), Routledge
- Robert Ross, "Balance of Power Politics and the Rise of China: Accommodation and Balancing in East Asia, In Chinese Security Policy: Structure, Power and Politics", pp.87~115 (2009), Routledge
- Hillary Rodham Clinton, "America’s Engagement in the Asia-Pacific", Speech delivered to the East-West Center, 2~ (2010)
- Satu Limaye, "Introduction: America’s Bilateral Relations with Southeast Asia—Constraints and Promise", Contemporary Southeast Asia, 32(3), pp.312~313 (2010)
- Edward Wong, "China Asserts Role as a Naval Power", International Herald Tribune, 1~ (2010)
- Marvin Ott, "Asia’s Clouded Horizon", International Herald Tribune, ~ (2010)
- The South China Sea Dispute: Increasing Stakes and Rising Tension, "Clive Schofield", The Jamestown Foundation, 1~ (2009)
- Michael A. Glosny, "Getting Beyond Taiwan? Chinese Foreign Policy and PLA Modernization", Strategic Forum, (261), pp.5~ (2011)
- "U.S. Takes on Maritime Spats: Clinton Plan Would Set Up Legal Process for Asian Nations to Resolve Claims in the South China Sea" (2010)[URL]
- Carlyle A. Thayer, "The United States, China and Southeast Asia", Southeast Asian Affairs 2011, pp.20~ (2011), Institute of Southeast Asian Affairs
- Jay Solomon, "U.S. Takes on Maritime Spats", Wall Street Journal, 2~ (2010)
- "Chinese Diplomacy off Course" (2010)[URL]
- "Battle of the South China Sea" (2010)[URL]
- "U.S. State Department Press Release 2010/T32-21, Secretary of State Hillary Clinton, Remarks at Press Availability" (2010)[URL]
- Frederick Z. Brown, "Rapproachment between Vietnam and the United States", Contemporary Southeast Asia, 32(2), pp.335~ (2010)
- Richard Weitz, "Nervous Neighbors: China Finds a Sphere of Influence", World Affairs, 173(6), pp.2~ (2011)
- Mark J. Valencia, "The Future of Southeast Asia: Back to the Future?", Global Asia, 5(4), pp.9~ (2010)
- Ralph Cossa, "Regional Overview: U.S. Profile Rises, China Image Falls, North Korea Changes", Comparative Connections: A Quarterly E-Journal on East Asian Bilateral Relations, 12(3), pp.6~ (2010)
- Richard Weitz, "Nervous Neighbors: China Finds a Sphere of Influence", World Affairs, 173(6), pp.10~ (2011)
- "ASEAN Shows Sudden Resolve against Beijing" (2011)[URL]
- Wall Street Journal, "Battle of the South China Sea", 2~
- "U.S.-China Tensions Flare over South China Sea Dispute" (2010)[URL]
- "China Rejects U.S. Suggestion for ASEAN Mediation on Territory" (2010)[URL]
- Carlyle A. Thayer, "The United States, China and Southeast Asia", Southeast Asian Affairs, pp.21~ (2011)
- Ralph A Cossa, "Regional Overview: US Profile Rises, China Image Falls, North Korea Changes?", Comparative Connections, 12(3) (2010)
- Greg Torode, "ASEAN Shows Sudden Resolve against Beijing", South China Morning Post, 2~ (2011)
- "U.S. Riles Beijing over South China Sea Dispute: Clinton Stand on a Chinese Core Interest Causes Tension at Forum" (2010)[URL]
- South China Morning Post, "U.S. Riles Beijing over South China Sea Dispute: Clinton Stand on a Chinese Core Interest Causes Tension at Forum", 2~ (2010)
- "China Renews Claim to South China Sea, Vows Freedom of Navigation" (2010)[URL]
- Barry Wain, "Chinese Diplomacy off Course", Wall Street Journal Asia, 1~ (2010)
- Barry Wain, "Chinese Diplomacy off Course", Wall Street Journal Asia, 2~ (2010)
- Dana R. Dillon, "Countering Beijing in the South China Sea", Policy Review, 167, pp.52~ (2011)
- "China Says Philippines Harming Sovereignty, Interests in Spratlys" (2011)[URL]
- "China Navy Reaches Far, Unsettling the Region" (2011)[URL]
- "“Joint Philippine-Australia Statement” at the Philippine-Australia Ministerial Meeting" (2011)[URL]
- "China Tells U.S. to Stay Out of its Backyard: Rival Claimants to South China Sea Islands are Tempting Fate by Cosying Up to the United States" (2011)[URL]
- Teddy Ng, "China Tells U.S. to Stay Out of its Backyard: Rival Claimants to South China Sea Islands are Tempting Fate by Cosying Up to the United States", South China Morning Post, 1~ (2011)
- Edward Wong, "China Navy Reaches Far, Unsettling the Region", New York Times, 4~ (2011)
- "ASEAN, China Agree on SC SEA Conflict Guidelines" (2011)[URL]
- "ASEAN and China Endorse Guide Lines on South China Sea" (2011)[URL]
- Ronald O’ Rourke, "PLAN Force Structure: Submarines, Ships, and Aircraft, In The Chinese Navy: Expanding Capabilities, Evolving Roles", pp.154~155 (2011), National Defense University Press
- Nan Li, "The Evolution of China’s Naval Strategy and Capabilities: From ‘Near Coast’ and ‘Near Sea’ to ‘Far Seas’, In The Chinese Navy: Expanding Capabilities, Evolving Roles", pp.129~ (2011), National Defense University Press
- Daniel M. Hartnett, "Toward a Maritime Security Strategy: An Analysis of Chinese Views since Early 1990s, In The Chinese Navy: Expanding Capabilities, Evolving Role", pp.101~ (2011), National Defense University Press
- Peter Dutton, "Three Disputes and Three Objectives: China and the South China Sea", Naval War College Review, 54(4), pp.47~ (2011)
- NIDS China Security Report, "National Institute for Defense Studies", National Insitute for Defense Studies, 14~21 (2011)
- "PLA Carrier Launch Downplayed Refitted Soviet Vessel for Training, Beijing Says; Two Home-Produced Carriers Reportedly on Way" (2011)[URL]
- Philip Saunders, "Buy, Build, Or Steal: China’s Quest for Advanced Military Aviation Technologies", pp.47~ (2011), National Defense University Press
- Daniel J. Kostecka, "From the Sea: PLA Doctrine and the Employment of Sea-Based Airpower", Naval War College Review, 64(3), pp.14~15 (2011)
- Nan Li, "The Evolution of China’s Naval Strategy and Capabilities: From ‘Near Coast’ and ‘Near Sea’ to ‘Far Seas’, In The Chinese Navy: Expanding Capabilities, Evolving Roles", pp.134~ (2011), National Defense University Press
- Christopher D. Yung, "Introduction, In The Chinese Navy: Expanding Capabilities, Evolving Roles" (2011), National Defense University Press
- NIDS China Security Report 2011, "National Institute for Defense Studies", The National Institute for Defense Studies, 20~ (2012)
- Kailash K. Prasad, "An Assessment of the Goals, Drivers and Capabilities of China’s Modernizing Navy", The Korean Journal of Defense Analysis, 24(1), pp.51~65 (2012), 한국국방연구원
- Mark Landler, "How Obama Switched to a Tougher Line with China", International Herald Tribune, 1~ (2012)
- Mark Landler, "How Obama Switched to a Tougher Line with China", International Herald Tribune, 4~ (2012)
- "In Asia, Keeps Focus off Terrorism" (2011)[URL]
- Pivot to the Pacific? The Obama Administration’s ‘Rebalancing’ toward Asia, "Mark E. Manyin", Congressional Research Service, 1~ (2012)
- Aaron Friedberg, "Buckling Beijing: An Alternative U.S. China Policy", Foreign Affairs, 91(5), pp.2~ (2012)
- Pivot to the Pacific? The Obama Administration’s ‘Rebalancing’ toward Asia, "Mark E. Manyin", Congressional Research Service, 2~ (2012)
- Thomas Fargo, "The Military Side of Strategic Rebalancing", Asia Policy, 14, pp.27~28 (2012)
- "U.S.: Less Counter-Insurgency, More Asia in New U.S. Strategy" (2012)[URL]
- Thom Shanker, "Downsizing is Key Word in Planning at Pentagon", International Herald Tribune, 1~16 (2012)
- "President Obama Unveils Leaner Pentagon Budget: The Navy is Expected to Keep its Current Aircraft Carriers" (2012)[URL]
- "U.S. Gives Explanation for its “Pivot” to Asia" (2012)[URL]
- "Panetta Out to Reassure Allies Defense Chief Says U.S. Commitment, Asian Pivot Real" (2012)[URL]
- Emil J. Kirchner, "Regional and Global Security: Changing Threats and Institutional Responses, In Global Security Governance: Competing Perceptions of Security in the 21st Century", pp.282~ (2007), Routledge
- Pivot to the Pacific? The Obama Administration’s ‘Rebalancing’ toward Asia, "Mark E. Manyin", Congressional Research Service, 4~ (2012)
- Jeremy Page, "U.S. Seeks to reassure China on Defense", Wall Street Journal, 1~ (2011)
- "Panetta Outlines U.S. Military Strategy for Asia: The Defense Secretary Hopes to Back Allies, Not Antagonize China" (2012)[URL]
- "Xinhua Analyses New Asia-Pacific Policy" (2012)[URL]
- "U.S.-China Relations: Creating a New Type of Major Power Relations" (2012)[URL]
- Robert Sutter, "China-Southeast Asian Relations: China Muscles Opponents on South China Sea", Comparative Connections, pp.1~2 (2012)
- Tom Donilon, "The United States and the Asia-Pacific in 2013", speech delivered to the Asia Society, 3~ (2013)
- Mark Lippert, "The Rebalancing One Year Later", speech delivered at the Center for Strategic and International Studies—Georgetown U.S. Studies Conference, 3~ (2013)
