唐玄宗《停潁王等節度誥》真偽討論— 兼論永王璘案真相
A Discussion on the Authenticity of Removal Notice of Ying Wang from the Position of Military Governor Written by Emperor Xuanzong of Tang—— concurrently discuss the true facts of so called yong king Li Lin’s Case
0
조회
0
다운로드
0
인용
0
참고문헌
키워드
초록
Contemporary scholars doubt the true facts of so called yong king Li Lin’s( 永王璘，Yong Wang Lin ) case.The reason for this is because they think a paragraph from Ce Fu Yuan Gui ( 《冊府元龜》，Imperial Book Repository Large Turtle ) have some connection with A Biography of Li Bai ( 《李白傳》 ) from Old Book of Tang ( 《舊唐書》，Old History of Tang Dynasty ).These two books show that Li Lin was the captaincy of Jianghuai and the military governor of Yangzhou at that time and emperor Xuanzong of Tang ( 唐玄宗) had second appointment.Therefore, the scholars think Removal Notice of Ying Wang from the Position of Military Governor ( 《停潁王節度誥》, Abort Ying Wang Official Edict ) is fake. This article excluded the doubts of Removal Notice one by one.Through a letter written from Xiao Ying Shi to Cui Yuan , we come to the conclusion that there’s no second appointment at all. By looking for the historical origin of the evidence, exploring the development of the official appellation of Tang Dynasty, correcting the mistakes of Old Book of Tang, we know that the paragraphs selected from Ce Fu Yuan Gui and Old Book of Tang are wrong. Li Lin disobey his father’s will, go Guangling without permission, which is a kind of treason.
Abstract
Contemporary scholars doubt the true facts of so called yong king Li Lin’s( 永王璘，Yong Wang Lin ) case.The reason for this is because they think a paragraph from Ce Fu Yuan Gui ( 《冊府元龜》，Imperial Book Repository Large Turtle ) have some connection with A Biography of Li Bai ( 《李白傳》 ) from Old Book of Tang ( 《舊唐書》，Old History of Tang Dynasty ).These two books show that Li Lin was the captaincy of Jianghuai and the military governor of Yangzhou at that time and emperor Xuanzong of Tang ( 唐玄宗) had second appointment.Therefore, the scholars think Removal Notice of Ying Wang from the Position of Military Governor ( 《停潁王節度誥》, Abort Ying Wang Official Edict ) is fake. This article excluded the doubts of Removal Notice one by one.Through a letter written from Xiao Ying Shi to Cui Yuan , we come to the conclusion that there’s no second appointment at all. By looking for the historical origin of the evidence, exploring the development of the official appellation of Tang Dynasty, correcting the mistakes of Old Book of Tang, we know that the paragraphs selected from Ce Fu Yuan Gui and Old Book of Tang are wrong. Li Lin disobey his father’s will, go Guangling without permission, which is a kind of treason.
참고문헌 (15)
- 傅璇琮主編, "唐才子傳校箋" (1987), 中華書局
- 李白, "李太白文集", 國家圖書館藏
- 李昉等, "文苑英華" (1966), 中華書局
- 劉昫等, "舊唐書" (1975), 中華書局
- 劉知幾, "史通", 四部叢刊初編
- 歐陽修, "新唐書" (1975), 中華書局
- 司馬光, "資治通鑒" (1956), 中華書局
- 司馬光, "資治通鑒考異", 四部叢刊初編
- 宋敏求, "唐大詔令集" (2008), 中華書局
- 王溥, "唐會要" (1991), 上海古籍出版社
- 王欽若等, "冊府元龜" (1960), 中華書局
- 郁賢皓, "李白與唐代文史考論" (2008), 南京師範大學出版社
- 元結, "次山集", 四部叢刊初編
- 鄧小軍, "永王璘案真相 - 並釋李白〈永王東巡歌十一首〉", 中國社會科學院文學研究所, (5) (2010), 文學遺產
- 賈二強, "唐永王李璘起兵事發微", 陜西師范大學, (1) (1991), 陝西師大學報