장애인 피해자에 대한 경찰의 진술증거 수집에 관한 연구
A Study on the Police Investigation Related to Collecting the Verbal Evidence from the Disabled Victims
0
조회
0
다운로드
9
인용
0
참고문헌
키워드
초록
This study intends to meet the real justice in the area of criminal investigation, enhancing the communication skill between police investigator and the disabled victims in the course of collecting verbal evidence. Recent criminal justice system has greatly stressed on how successfully the parties of criminal procedure present their opinions including submitting their verbal evidence properly. Therefore, justice seems to be administered proportionately according to how people could express their assertion rather than what the system might offer for the victims and how the system might protect their human rights. As a result of that, the vulnerable victims just who have intellectual disability in expressing their own opinion are likely to fail in accusing the offender of their crimes to the court. With this reason, many disabled persons have been revictimized by the very offenders who attacked them first. This is not the criminal justice system which we want to arrive. To solve such a difficult problem, police responses are very crucial rather than any other public authorities. Police officers who are charged with the preliminary investigation should try to develop communication skills with the disabled person in collecting the verbal evidence, including the provision of proper support for them. Such an effort makes a progressive advance for the criminal justice system of our society.
Abstract
This study intends to meet the real justice in the area of criminal investigation, enhancing the communication skill between police investigator and the disabled victims in the course of collecting verbal evidence. Recent criminal justice system has greatly stressed on how successfully the parties of criminal procedure present their opinions including submitting their verbal evidence properly. Therefore, justice seems to be administered proportionately according to how people could express their assertion rather than what the system might offer for the victims and how the system might protect their human rights. As a result of that, the vulnerable victims just who have intellectual disability in expressing their own opinion are likely to fail in accusing the offender of their crimes to the court. With this reason, many disabled persons have been revictimized by the very offenders who attacked them first. This is not the criminal justice system which we want to arrive. To solve such a difficult problem, police responses are very crucial rather than any other public authorities. Police officers who are charged with the preliminary investigation should try to develop communication skills with the disabled person in collecting the verbal evidence, including the provision of proper support for them. Such an effort makes a progressive advance for the criminal justice system of our society.
참고문헌 (26)
- 김용세, "피해자학" (2010), 형설출판사
- 법무연수원, "아동 증인의 조사지침. in: 수사과학연구회 자료집" (2003)
- 배복주, "장애여성의 성 그리고 성폭력 상담지원. in: 제24기 성폭력전문상담원 교육자료집" (2005)
- 배종대, "형사소송법" (2004), 홍문사
- 2000년도 장애인 실태조사, "변용찬", 보건복지부 한국보건사회연구원, ~, pp.2001-03 (2001)
- 보건복지가족부, "장애등급 판정기준, 고시 제2009-227호", ~
- 이윤호, "범죄학개론" (2010), 박영사
- 신희원, "유형별 성폭력. in: 제24기 성폭력전문상담원 교육자료집" (2005)
- 신동운, "신형사소송법" (2007), 법문사
- 조성숙, "자폐성 장애아동의 화행(speech acts) 능력", 언어청각장애연구, 12(2), pp.215~236 (2007), 한국언어청각임상학회
- Ceci S. J., "Suggestibility of the child witness : A historical review and synthesis", Psychological Bulletin, 113 (1993)
- Clare Wilson, "A guide to interviewing children" (2001), Routledge
- Ericson, K., "Witness competency, communication issues and people with developmental disabilities", Developmental Disabilities Bulletin, 22 (1994)
- Hayes, J., "Sexual Violence Against Intellectually Disabled Victims", AIC Conference Proceedings (1992)
- Hooper,S.R., "Learning disability subtyping : Neuropsychological foundation, conceptional models and issues in clinical differntiation" (1989), Springer - Verlag
- Issacs, B., "Witnesses with developmental disabilities : The cognitive interview, Time delay and suspect indentification", Paper presented at the Biennial Conference of the American Psychology- Law Society (1998)
- Johnson, "Silent Victims : a Study of People with Intellectual Disabilities as Victims of Crime" (1988), Victorian Office of the Public Advocate
- John P. J. Dussich, "Raising the Global Standards for Victims : The Proposed Convention on Justice for Victims of Crime and Abuse of Power" (2008), TIVI
- Mark Brennan, "Procedures for responding to sexual assaualt of adults with an intellectual disability" (1993), New South Wales
- Mark Brennan, "Cleartalk : Police responding to intellectual disability. Wagga Wagga School of Education" (1994), Charles Stuart Univ.
- Perlman, N., "The developmentally handicapped witness : Competency as a function of question format", Law and Human Behaviour, 18 (1994)
- Rebbeca Mille, "Investigative interviewing - psychology and practice -" (2001), Wiley
- Russell, P., "Children with disabilities - a challenge for child protection procedures,Good practice in child protection : A manual for professionals" (1993), Jessica Kingsley
- Sanders, A., "Victims with learning disabilities : Negotiating the criminal justice system" (1997), Oxford University Centre for Criminological Research