슈만 <카니발 Op. 9>에 나타난 코메디아 델라르테의 수용양상 분석
Considerations on the Application of Commedia dell'Arte to Schumann's <Carnaval Op. 9>
0
조회
0
다운로드
1
인용
0
참고문헌
키워드
초록
This study aims to consider and analyze the factors of the commedia dell’arte found in Carnaval, Op. 9 and to review and organize Schumann‘s original method used in the process of integrating the external factors with music. Based on the composer‘s actual experience related to marriage when composing Carnaval, Op. 9, this study analyzed and drew connections with the masque, commedia dell’arte. As a result, the following conclusion was drawn. ‘Pierrot,‘ ‘Harlequin‘ and ‘Pantalone and Columbine,‘ the characters of the commedia dell’arte appearing in this work as a title, are associated with the inner intention to expose the real love story related to Schumann‘s broken engagement other than the primary role of description of the festival. It is thought to result from musically converting and using the main features of the commedia dell’arte under the theme of satire, parody, mask and young couple in the face of opposition to marriage after capturing them. According to their roles in the work, ‘Coquette‘ and ‘Réplique‘ are similar to a lazzi, which is an improvisation at the interval to provoke laughter in the commedia dell’arte, and the critical tendency of the commedia dell’arte is in common with Schumann‘s musical thought - criticizing existing musical society- appearing in the last movement Marche des "Davidsbündler" contre les Philistins. Schumann‘s use of external material of the commedia dell’arte was established based on literature - particularly closely related to Jean Paul‘s descriptive characteristics -. Above all, it is considered the method to imply and expose his own existence in the work effectively. Based on these characteristics, it is considered that Carnaval, Op. 9 is a clear example for Schumann‘s reference "Everything around us becomes themes and materials of works and then is expressed itself while looking for a way out in music." and the realization of the true spirit of Romanticism.
Abstract
This study aims to consider and analyze the factors of the commedia dell’arte found in Carnaval, Op. 9 and to review and organize Schumann‘s original method used in the process of integrating the external factors with music. Based on the composer‘s actual experience related to marriage when composing Carnaval, Op. 9, this study analyzed and drew connections with the masque, commedia dell’arte. As a result, the following conclusion was drawn. ‘Pierrot,‘ ‘Harlequin‘ and ‘Pantalone and Columbine,‘ the characters of the commedia dell’arte appearing in this work as a title, are associated with the inner intention to expose the real love story related to Schumann‘s broken engagement other than the primary role of description of the festival. It is thought to result from musically converting and using the main features of the commedia dell’arte under the theme of satire, parody, mask and young couple in the face of opposition to marriage after capturing them. According to their roles in the work, ‘Coquette‘ and ‘Réplique‘ are similar to a lazzi, which is an improvisation at the interval to provoke laughter in the commedia dell’arte, and the critical tendency of the commedia dell’arte is in common with Schumann‘s musical thought - criticizing existing musical society- appearing in the last movement Marche des "Davidsbündler" contre les Philistins. Schumann‘s use of external material of the commedia dell’arte was established based on literature - particularly closely related to Jean Paul‘s descriptive characteristics -. Above all, it is considered the method to imply and expose his own existence in the work effectively. Based on these characteristics, it is considered that Carnaval, Op. 9 is a clear example for Schumann‘s reference "Everything around us becomes themes and materials of works and then is expressed itself while looking for a way out in music." and the realization of the true spirit of Romanticism.
참고문헌 (22)
- 강수경, "불가코프의 『조야의 아파트』와 코메디아 델 아르테(Commedia dell’arte)", 슬라브학보, 22(3), pp.25~49 (2007), 한국슬라브학회
- 김용환, "슈만의 “다비드동맹”(Davidbund) 탄생 배경에 관한 연구", 서양음악학, 14(3), pp.87~122 (2011), 한국서양음악학회
- 김찬자, "코메디아 델라르테" (2005), 연극과 인간사
- 김찬자, "아를르캥을 통해서 본 대중성의 요소들 - 마리보 작품을 중심으로", 한국프랑스학논집, 0(51), pp.189~214 (2005), 한국프랑스학회
- 김희정, "이태리 가면희극 코메디아 델라르테(commedia dell’arte)와 한국 가면극의 복식특성 연구", Family and Environment Research, 47(2), pp.15~26 (2009), 대한가정학회
- 박경숙, "발레작품에 유입된 코메디아 델 아르테의 유형적 인물에 관한 연구", 한국무용교육학회지, 19(1), pp.39~64 (2008), 한국무용교육학회
- 배재희, "슈만의 피아노연곡에서 보여지는 다양한 유형", 연세음악연구, 17, pp.25~49 (2010), 음악연구소
- 안소영, "슈만의 피아노 싸이클《환상소품집》에서 나타나는 조성적 연관성", 음악이론연구, 11, pp.63~78 (2006), 서양음악연구소
- 유리, "1920년대 러시아 코메디아 델라르테 (Commedia dell'arte) : 불가꼬프의 『조야의 아파트』를 중심으로", 석사, 노어노문학, pp.2011
- 이미원, "한국 전통 가면극과 코메디아 델아르테", 한국연극학, 3, pp.5~23 (1989), 한국연극학회
- 임채흥, "슈만의 리트에 나타난 장 단조 혼용기법들과 남‘여 관계 모델들", 음악응용연구, 4, pp.65~96 (2011), 한국 음악응용학회
- 주성희, "슈만의 〈카니발 작품 9〉에 관한 연구 : 작품 배경과 표제 해석을 통한 음악적 특징의 고찰", 박사, 음악학과 연주(피아노)전공, pp.2012
- 주성희, "슈만의 「카니발 op.9」에 나타나는 장 파울의 문학적 특징의 고찰과 해석: 9. 스핑크스를 중심으로", 음악과 민족, (44), pp.145~168 (2012), 민족음악학회
- 주성희, "슈만 「카니발 op. 9」의 표제에 내재된 다중적 의미와 상징성의 고찰:장 파울의 문학적 특징과의 연관성을 바탕으로", 이화음악논집, 16(2), pp.77~105 (2012), 음악연구소
- Berger, Dorothea, "J ean Paul friedrich Richter" (1972), Twayne pub
- Eraka. Reiman, "Schumann‘s Piano Cycles and the novels of J ean paul" (2004), Uni of Rochester
- Frederick, Niecks, "Programma Musik in the last Four Centuries" (1969), Haskell House
- Goetz, Hans, "Der Einfluss J ean paul auf Robert Schumann" (1993), Verlag von Hermann Böhlhaus Nachfolger
- John. Daberio, "Nineteenth Century Music and the German Romantic Ideology" (1993), Shirmer Books
- Kaminsky, Peter, "Principle of formal structure in Schumann‘s early piano cycle", Music Theory Spectrum, 11(2), pp.207~225 (1989)
- Maurice, Hinson, "Carnaval Op. 9" (2007), 상지원
- Wömer, Karl, "Robert Schumann" (1949), Atlantis Musikbuch Verlag
