공개수배제도의 입법화 내용에 관한 연구
Legislation of Wanted Notice System
0
조회
0
다운로드
1
인용
0
참고문헌
키워드
초록
Most wanted system for the criminal suspects is a way of investigation used in order to arrest them effectively at an early stage. In particular, in case of committing grave crimes focused on big social interests, investigation agency shall open the case to the public through mass media in order to catch wanted persons as soon as possible. A big issue raised is that it is possible for investigation authority to violate the right of wanted person legally protected such as not opening of criminal record and of his/her private life including violating the principle of innocent presumption. It is also possible for wanted person to be stigmatized the criminal as well as to open his/her name, picture, family relations, and privacy to the public through mass media before taking final judgement as a guilty. It is therefore possible for wanted person to violate his/her human rights much more valuable than detention or any kind of criminal penalty. In order to solve this issue raised, the best alternative plan makes an legislation on wanted system. Legislation on wanted system should be included investigation agency related, stringent requirements for wanted, the scope of mass media(ex, radio, television, newspapers, internet, poster, etc), the period of official notice, reasons of revocation, and so on.
Abstract
Most wanted system for the criminal suspects is a way of investigation used in order to arrest them effectively at an early stage. In particular, in case of committing grave crimes focused on big social interests, investigation agency shall open the case to the public through mass media in order to catch wanted persons as soon as possible. A big issue raised is that it is possible for investigation authority to violate the right of wanted person legally protected such as not opening of criminal record and of his/her private life including violating the principle of innocent presumption. It is also possible for wanted person to be stigmatized the criminal as well as to open his/her name, picture, family relations, and privacy to the public through mass media before taking final judgement as a guilty. It is therefore possible for wanted person to violate his/her human rights much more valuable than detention or any kind of criminal penalty. In order to solve this issue raised, the best alternative plan makes an legislation on wanted system. Legislation on wanted system should be included investigation agency related, stringent requirements for wanted, the scope of mass media(ex, radio, television, newspapers, internet, poster, etc), the period of official notice, reasons of revocation, and so on.
참고문헌 (57)
- 경찰청, "2004 경찰백서" (2004), ㈜ 범신사
- 경찰청, "2009 경찰백서" (2009), ㈜씨마스커뮤니케이션
- 경찰청, "2012 경찰백서" (2012), 한국시각장애인연합회
- 김성룡, "인터넷을 통한 공개수배" (2007), 치안정책연구소
- 김준규, "지명수배의 운영실태와 개선방안", 형사정책연구, 5(3)통권 : 19 (1994)
- 김준성, "형사소송법상 긴급체포제도에 관한 재검토", 형사법연구, 23(3), pp.207~230 (2011), 한국형사법학회
- 박노섭, "독일형사소송법" (2009), 박영사
- 류지영, "긴급체포제도의 문제점과 개선방안", 형사법연구, (20), pp.277~296 (2003), 한국형사법학회
- 문봉규, "공개수배제도의 문제점 및 해결방안", 한국비교형사법학회춘계공동학술회의 자료집 (2011), 2011년도 한국형사법학회
- 문봉규, "수배제도의 합리적인 운영방안에 관한 연구: 수배자의 인권침해방지를 중심으로", 박사, 형사법, pp.2010
- 문성도, "영장주의의 비교법적 고찰 - 한국 헌법 제12조 제3항과 미연방헌법 수정 제4조의규범적 특징을 중심으로 -", 형사법연구, (24), pp.163~186 (2005), 한국형사법학회
- 피의자 공개수배의 법적 성격에 관한 연구, "문성도", 경찰청수사구조개혁단, ~ (2011)
- 설계경, "행정법강의" (2007), 법률출판사
- 오경식, "수배제도에 관한 연구", 치안정책연구, (11) (1998)
- 프라이버시의 보호와 범죄자 신상공개, "이병희", 형사정책연구원, ~ (2001)
- 이상돈, "정보보호와 형사절차", 저스티스, (29) (1996)
- 이주일, "독일 지명수배의 법적절차를 규정한 형사소송법", 최신 외국법제정보, 2008(2) (2008)
- 이진국, "독일형법상 원상회복 옹호론과 비판론", 형사정책, 12(1) (2000)
- 피의자 공개수사의 근거와 한계에 관한 연구, "이형범", ~ (2009)
- 이훈동, "정보화사회와 실명범죄공개", 외법논집, 11 (2001)
- 정지운, "경‧검 수사권의 합리적인 조정에 관한 연구", 비교형사법연구, 12(1), pp.251~273 (2010), 한국비교형사법학회
- 조대환, "지명수배제도에 관한 연구", 법조, (462) (1995)
- 지병길, "경찰수배에 대한 소고", 경찰 2 (1963)
- 천진호, "영장청구권의 귀속 주체에 관한 검토", 법학논고, (26), pp.331~346 (2007), 법학연구원
- 치안본부, "일본경찰: 외국경찰제도 연구 총서 Ⅰ" (1987), 치안본부
- 하태훈, "매스컴을 이용한 피의자(내지 용의자) 공개수배의 형사소송법적 문제점과 개선방안", 안암법학, 11 (2000)
- 황정익, "지명수배 등에 의한 체포의 합법성문제와 개선방안", 형사정책, (8) (1996)
- "검찰사건사무규칙(법무부령 제766호, 2012. 3. 15, 일부개정)", ~ (2012)
- "범죄수사규칙(경찰청훈령 제669호, 2012. 7. 16, 폐지제정)", ~ (2012)
- "인권보호수사준칙(법무부훈령 제556호, 2006. 6. 26, 개정)", ~ (2006)
- "지명수배규칙(경찰청훈령 제655호, 2012. 4. 25, 폐지제정)", ~ (2012)
- "지명수배규칙(해양경찰청훈령 제917호, 2012. 6. 19, 전부개정)", ~ (2012)
- "특정강력범죄의 처벌에 관한 특례법(법률 제11048호, 2011. 9. 15, 타법개정)", ~ (2011)
- "훈령․예규 등의 발령 및 관리에 관한 규정(대통령훈령 제248호, 2009. 4. 23, 제정)", ~ (2009)
- 平川宗信, "犯罪報道と人権をめぐる諸問題", 名古屋大学法政学論集, 123 (1988)
- 長沼範良, "寺崎嘉博, 刑事訴訟法" (2005), 有斐閣
- "中國刑事訴訟法", ~
- "被疑者の公開捜査について", 警察庁丁刑企発, (136) (1967)
- Colin Sumner, "Social Control: the History and Politics of a Central Concept in Anglo-American Sociology, In Social Control and Political Order - European Perspectives at the End of the Century" (1997), SAGE Publications
- Jock Young, "New Labour, crime control and social exclusion, In The New Politics of Crime and Punishment" (2003), Willan Publishing
- Susan(Deschler) Oakes, "Megan's Law: Analysis On Whether It Is Constitutional To Notify The Public Of Sex Offenders Via The Internet", John Marshall Journal of Computer and Information Law, (Summer) (1999)
- Thomas J. Miles, "Estimating the Effect of America's Most Wanted: A Duration Analysis of Wanted Fugitives", Journal of Law and Economics (2005)
- Wayne R. LaFave, "Criminal Procedure" (2000), St. Paul․Minn
- Hans Hilger, "Zum Strafverfahrensrechtsänderungsgesetz 1999 (StVÄG 1999) - 1.Teil" (2000), Neue Zeitschrife für Strafrecht(NStZ)
- Hans-Ullrich Paeffgen, "Systematischer Kommemter zum Strafgesetzbuch -Strafprozeßordnung (SK-StPO)" (2003), Carl Heymanns Verlag
- "Strafprozeßordnung(StPO)", ~ (2011)
- "Exhibit 9.3.2-2(07-02-2004), Title 1- 7, United States Attorneys’ Manual, Media Relations", ~ (1997)
- "There is a “compelling interest” in protecting the physical and psychological well-being of children", See also H.R. Rep, 104~555 (1997)
- "Russell v. Gregoire, 124 F.3d 1079, 1089", ~ (1997)