본문 바로가기
KERD
논문KCI 등재

동남아시아의 민주화 이후 ‘개발’과 ‘인권’의 갈등적 공존: 시민사회의 시각

The Confrontational Co-existence of Development and Human Rights after Democratic Transition in Southeast Asia: A Civil Society Perspective

0

조회

0

다운로드

5

인용

0

참고문헌

키워드

주제분류지역학

초록

Abstract

Bring this analysis down to people-centered development perspective and looking through democratization in the Philippines, Thailand and Indonesia, we find similarities and differences among them related with the intensity of conflicts between development and human rights in the process of democratization in line with global transformation. Civil society in the Philippines criticized the developmental path in the Philippines which failed to implement land reform and eradication of poverty under the transition from 'patrimonial oligarchy' to democracy. In Thailand the coalition of military and the royalists had consolidated its power since Sarit military regime, which later paved the way 'hybrid oligarchy' era. Most Thai civil society organizations has regarded their developmental experience rather as 'maldevelopment' which disregarded economic and social rights. It has been especially believed by Thai localists that the stimulation of local markets and the building of autonomic community society will form the alternative economy without going against the conservative banner of nation, religion and king. Thaksin as a populist successfully took advantage of Thai localist ethos in favour of taking the seat of power. He projected himself as a modernizer focused on economic growth and cleaner politics. However Thaksin's procedural legitimacy was overthrown by counterattacking from military-royalist alliance, pretexting that Thaksin caused internal conflicts and lacked morality. Soeharto's New Order regime which can be called 'administrative oligarchy' had an antipathy towards notions of economic and social rights as well as civil and political rights. In spite of the fact that the fall of Soeharto opened the political space for democratic civil society organizations which had long struggled with development aggression and human rights abuses, there have been continuously a strong political and military reaction against human rights activists, NGOs and ethnic minorities such as Aceh and Papua. Nevertheless, Indonesian democracy is more promising than Philippine's and Thai democracy in terms of comparatively less pre-modern legacies.

참고문헌 (54)

  1. 박기덕, "라모스정권의 경제개혁과 민주체제의 공고화", 동남아시아연구, 6 (1998)
  2. 박사명, "필리핀의 민주주의와 인권", 민주주의와 인권, 1(2) (2001), 전남대 5․18연구소
  3. 박승우, "필리핀의 과두제 민주주의 - 정치적 독점의 해체 없는 민주화 -", 민주사회와 정책연구, 12(12), pp.93~128 (2007), 민주사회정책연구원
  4. 박승우, "민주주의 이행 이후 필리핀의 사회경제적 독점과 그 변형적 재편 in:아시아 민주화와 사회경제적 불평등의 동학" (2009), 한울
  5. 박은홍, "타이 민주주의의 전환 - 과두정치로서의 '포퓰리즘'의 진화 -", 민주사회와 정책연구, 12(12), pp.129~152 (2007), 민주사회정책연구원
  6. 우수명, "필리핀 경제개발정책의 성과", 지역경제, 3 (1996)
  7. 전제성, "국가의 온정주의와 노동의 보완적 교섭전략", 노동사회 (2005)
  8. 조희연, "아시아 민주화와 사회경제적 불평등의 동학" (2009), 한울
  9. 코로넬, 쉐일라, "THE NEWS" (2008), 푸른숲
  10. 페러, 미리암 코로넬, "필리핀의 인권과 민주주의. 세계의 민주주의와 인권", 5.18 20주년 기념 국제학술 심포지엄 자료집 (2000)
  11. 풍키 인다르띠, "인도네시아의 인권을 위한 장기 항전과 무니르(Munir)의 삶", ~ (2006)
  12. Arat, Zehra F, "Democracy and Human Rights in Developing Countries" (1991), Lynne Rienner Publishers
  13. Abinales, Patricio N, "Philippines: Weak State, Resilient President", Southeast Asian Affairs 2008 (2008), ISEAS
  14. Apichat, Satitniramai, "Economic Boom, Shrinking Autonomy, and the Decline of the Thai State", Paper presented at KAIS International Conference (2007)
  15. Barton, Greg, "Indonesia's Year of Living Normally", Southeast Asian Affairs 2008 (2008), ISEAS
  16. Bello, Walden, "The Anti-Development State: The Political Economy of Permanent Crisis in the Philippines" (2004), Focus on the Global South. Weidenfeld & Nicolson
  17. Labour Politics in Thaksin's Thailand, "Brown, Andrew", City University of Hong Kong, ~, pp.Working Paper Series 62 (2004)
  18. Castro, Renato Cruz De, "Philippine Elite-Democracy during the 1997 Asian Financial Crisis: The Populist Interlude", Paper presented at KAIS International Conference (2007)
  19. Chantana Banpasirchote, "Civil Society Discourse and the Future of Radical Environmental Movements in Thailand in:Civil Society in Southeast Asia" (2004), ISEAS
  20. Clarke, Gerard, "The Politics of NGOs in South-East Asia" (1998), Routledge
  21. Compton, Robert W, "East Asian Democratization" (2000), Praeger
  22. Donnelly, Jack, "Human Rigts, Democracy, and Development", Human Rights Quarterly, 21(3) (1999)
  23. Dorn, James A, "Economic Liberty and Democracy in East Asia", Orbis, 37(4) (1993)
  24. Eldridge, Philip J, "The Politics of Human Rights in Southeast Asia" (2002), Routledg
  25. Foweraker, J, "Citizenship Rights and Social Movements" (1997), Oxford University Press
  26. Freedman, Amy L, "Political Change and Consolidation" (2006), Palgrave Macmillan
  27. Hadiz, Vedi R, "Indonesia a Decade after Reformasi: Continuity or change?" (2007), Unpublished paper
  28. Hewison, Kevin, "Resisting Globalization: A Study of Localism in Thailand", The Pacific Review, 13(2) (2000)
  29. Hewison, Kevin, "Constitutions, Regimes and Power in Thailand", Democratization, 14(5) (2007)
  30. Hutchison, Jane, "Poverty of Politics in the Philippines in:The Political Economy of South-East Asia: Markets, Power and Contestation" (2006), Oxford University Press
  31. Jayasuriya, Kanishka, "New Trajectories for Political Regimes in Southeast Asia", Democratization, 14(5) (2008)
  32. Ji Ungpakorn, "A Coup for the Rich" (2007), Workers Democracy Publishing
  33. McCargo, Duncan, "The Thaksinization of Thailand" (2005), NIAS Press
  34. McCoy, Alfred W, "An Anarchy of Families" (2002), Ateneo de Manila University Press
  35. Monshipouri, Mahmood, "Democratization, Liberalization & Human Rights in the Third World" (1995), Lynne Rienner Publishers
  36. Nemenzo, Franciso, "Reflections on Democracy and Democratization in:States of Democracy: Oligarchic Democracies and Asian Democratization" (2009), Earthworm Books
  37. O'Donnell, Guillermo, "Transitions from Authoritarian Rule" (1986), The Johns Hopkins University Press
  38. Pasuk, Phongpaichit, "Recent Popular Movements in Thailand in Global Perspective", Asian Review 2002, 15 (2002)
  39. The Only Good Populist is a Rich Populist, "Pasuk, Phongpaichit", City University of Hong Kong, ~, pp.Working Paper Series 36 (2002)
  40. Economic Crisis, Institutional Changes and the Effectiveness of Government: the Case of Indonesia, "Perdana, Ari", ~, pp.CSIS Economics Working Paper Series (2007)
  41. Priyono, AE, "Oligarchic Democracy" (2008), Problems and Options in Indonesia
  42. Pye, Oliver, "The 2006 Anti-Thaksin Movement in Thailand: An Analysis", Journal of Contemporary Asia, 38(1) (2008)
  43. Quimpo, Nathan Gilbert, "The Use of Human Rights for the Protraction of War", Kasarinlan: Journal of Third World Studies, 21(1) (2006)
  44. Robison, Richard, "Reorganizing Power in Indonesia: The Politics of Oligarchy in an Age of Markets" (2004), Routledge
  45. Robison, Richard, "Neo-Liberalism and the Market State: Concepts and Issues in:The Neo-Liberal Revolution:Forging the Market State" (2006), Palgrave Macmillan
  46. Robison, Richard, "Indonesia: Crisis, Oligarchy, and Reform in:The Political Economy of South-East Asia: Markets, Power and Contestation" (2006), Oxford University Press
  47. Rothstein, Robert, "Democracy, Conflict, and Development in Third World", Washington Quarterly, 14(2) (1991)
  48. Shigetomi, Shinichi, "Thailand: A Crossing of Critical Parallel Relationships in:The State and NGOs:Perspective from Asia" (2002), ISEAS
  49. Stepan, Alfred, "Rethinking Military Politics" (1987), Princeton University Press
  50. Subono, Nur Iman, "The Floating and Marginalized Democrats in:Making Democacy Meaningful:Problems and Options in Indonesia" (2008), Demos
  51. Tadem, Teresa S. Encarnation, "Philippine Social Movement after Martial Law in:Philippine Politics and Governance" (2006), Cor Asia, Inc
  52. Tadem, Teresa S. Encarnation, "The Perennial Drift to the Right:Transition to Democracy in the Philippines in:States of Democracy:Oligarchic Democracies and Asian Democratization" (2009), Earthworm Books
  53. Velasco, Renato S, "Philippine Democracy: Promise and Performance in:Democratization in Southeast and East Asia" (1997), Silkworm Books
  54. Weiss, Stanley, "What's Holding Indonesia Back", Herald International Tribune September, 1(2) (2007)

관련 논문AI추천

이 간행물의 다른 논문 (5건)