Real Option Analysis on Ship Investment Valuation
1
조회
0
다운로드
5
인용
0
참고문헌
키워드
초록
Recent collapse of shipping market right after unprecedent surge clearly demonstrates that shipping industry is extremely risky. Due to the volatile movements of the freight rates, investors tend to ask higher rate of return; higher required return reduces the total net present value of the investment project. For several decades, the Discounted Cash Flow(DCF hereafter) analysis has been the most frequently used valuation technique. However, the main problem of the DCF analysis is its assumption that the discount rate would stay the same during the project life. In other words, it usually does not address the decisions that managers have after a project has been accepted. The purpose of this study is investigate a new valuation method of investment: the Real Option Analysis(ROA hereafter) on ship investment. By replacing the existing valuation methods with the new one, the research will present a new perspective on investment with uncertainty. While uncertainty increases risk of investment and consequently discounts the value of it in the traditional feasibility analysis, in the ROA, a new valuation method which will be addressed in the research, uncertainty means some additional value of flexibility so that the tool can help investors produce more accurate decisions. Contrary to the DCF analysis, the ROA takes managerial flexibilities into account. In reality, capital budgeting and project management is typically dynamic, rather than static in nature. The ROA finds and assesses the values of managerial flexibilities or real options in the investments. The main structures of the research will be as follows: (1) overview of the ship investment project, (2) evaluation of the project by the Net Present Value analysis, (3) evaluation of the same project by the Real Option Analysis, (4) comparision of the two techniques.
Abstract
Recent collapse of shipping market right after unprecedent surge clearly demonstrates that shipping industry is extremely risky. Due to the volatile movements of the freight rates, investors tend to ask higher rate of return; higher required return reduces the total net present value of the investment project. For several decades, the Discounted Cash Flow(DCF hereafter) analysis has been the most frequently used valuation technique. However, the main problem of the DCF analysis is its assumption that the discount rate would stay the same during the project life. In other words, it usually does not address the decisions that managers have after a project has been accepted. The purpose of this study is investigate a new valuation method of investment: the Real Option Analysis(ROA hereafter) on ship investment. By replacing the existing valuation methods with the new one, the research will present a new perspective on investment with uncertainty. While uncertainty increases risk of investment and consequently discounts the value of it in the traditional feasibility analysis, in the ROA, a new valuation method which will be addressed in the research, uncertainty means some additional value of flexibility so that the tool can help investors produce more accurate decisions. Contrary to the DCF analysis, the ROA takes managerial flexibilities into account. In reality, capital budgeting and project management is typically dynamic, rather than static in nature. The ROA finds and assesses the values of managerial flexibilities or real options in the investments. The main structures of the research will be as follows: (1) overview of the ship investment project, (2) evaluation of the project by the Net Present Value analysis, (3) evaluation of the same project by the Real Option Analysis, (4) comparision of the two techniques.
참고문헌 (32)
- Amram, M, "Real Options" (1999), Harvard Business School Press
- Bendall, H, "Investment Strategies in Market Uncertainty", Maritime Policy and Management, 30(4), pp.293~303
- Bendall,H, "Ship Investment under Uncertainty: Valuign a Real Option on the Maximum of Several Strategies", Maritime Economics and Logistics, pp.19~35 (2005)
- Benaroch, M, "A Case for Using Real Options Pricing Analysis to Evaluate Information Technology Project Investments", Information Systems Research, 10(1), pp.70~86 (1999)
- Black, F, "The Pricing of Options and Corporate Liabilities", The Journal of Political Economy, 81(3), pp.637~654 (1973)
- Brennan, M. J, "Evaluating Natural Resource Investments", Journal of Business, 58(2), pp.135~157 (1985)
- 조주현, "이항옵션모형을 이용한 부동산 개발가치 평가에 관한 연구", 부동산학연구, 10(1), pp.37~60 (2004), 한국부동산분석학회
- Cox, J, "Option Pricing : A Simplified Approach", Journal of Financial Economics (1979)
- Copeland, T, "Real Options: a practitioner's guide", Thomson Texere, ~ (2003)
- Copeland, T, "Measuring and Managing the Value of Companies" (2004), Mckinsey & Company
- Drewry Shipping Consultants, "Shipping Finance: A High Risk-Low Return Business?", ~ (1996)
- Grammenos, C. Th, "Shipping Investment & Finance", Cass Business School, ~ (2004)
- Hull, J. C, "Futures, and Other Derivatives" (2006), Pearson International Edition
- Hwang,D.G, "The Valuation of Port Investments Using DCF and Real Option Analysis", Thesis, Korea Maritime University, ~ (2006)
- Jee, C, "Introduction to Finance", Hak-Hyun Press
- Jeong,G.S, "Valuation of the Investment on M&A of the Traditional Firm", MSc Dissertation, Yonsei University, ~ (2004)
- Lee,C.H, "A Study on the Lease Valuation Under Uncertainty", MSc Dissertation, Seoul National University, ~ (1989)
- Lim,J.M, "A Introduction of Real Estate Decision Making Using Option Pricing Model", Korea Real Estate Research Institute, 8, pp.215~237 (1998)
- Majd, S, "Time to Build, Option Value, and Investment Decisions", National Bureau of Economic Research, 1654 (1985)
- Myers, S. C, "Calculating Abandonment Value Using Option Pricing Theory", Working Paper, Sloan School of Management, M.I.T., ~ (1983)
- Myers,S.C, "Finance Theory and Financial Strategy", Interfaces, 14(1), pp.126~137 (1984)
- Oh,H.K, "A Study on Causes and Effects between Competitive Edge of the Shipping Industry and Ship Financing System in Korea", Ph.D Thesis, Korea Maritime University., ~ (2000)
- Paddick, J. L, "Option Valuation of Claims on Real Assets: The Case of Offshore Petroleum Leases", The Quarterly Journal of Economics, pp.479~508 (1988)
- Ross, S. A, "Fundamentals of Corporate Finance" (2003), Alternate Edition
- 서상택, "실물옵션을 이용한 관수시설 투자의 경제성 분석", 농업경제연구, 47(1), pp.31~50 (2006), 한국농업경제학회
- Sodal,S, "Fuel Cells in Shipping: Higher Capital Costs and Reduced Flexibility", Institute for Research in Economics and Business Administration, ~ (2003)
- Sodal, S, "The Value of Market Switching Options for Combination Carriers", School of Management, Agder University, ~ (2004)
- Sodal,S, "Value Based Trading of Real Assets in Shipping under Stochastic Freight Rates", School of Management, Agder University, ~ (2004)
- Tvedt,J, "Valuation of VLCCs under Income Uncertainty", Maritime Policy and Management, 24(2), pp.159~174 (1997)
- Volk,B, "The Dynamics of Supply and Demand in Tramp Shipping", Launceston, 2~9 (2002)
- Wilken,L, "Model for Freight Forecasting of Capesize Dry Bulk Carriers", MSc Dissertation, Erasmus University., ~ (2004)
- 윤원철, "실물옵션을 활용한 발전소 건설 타당성 분석", 자원환경경제연구, 12(2), pp.217~244 (2003), 한국환경경제학회