경계성 인격장애 환자와 우울증 환자의 임상양상, 심리특성 및 방어기제의 차이
Differences in Clinical and Psychological Characteristics between Patients with Borderline Personality Disorder and Depression
2
조회
0
다운로드
4
인용
0
참고문헌
키워드
초록
Objectives: There has been little research into comparing characteristics of the patients with borderline personality disorder (BPD) and depression (DEP) which can often be encountered in clinical settings. This study evaluated clinical and psychological characteristics, including defense mechanisms, among patients with BPD and DEP. Methods: We recruited 38 BPD and other 38 DEP patients identified based on diagnostic criteria of the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorder, 4th edition. We compared clinical and psychological characteristics between the patients with BPD and DEP using the Symptom Checklist-90-Revised (SCL-90-R), the Minnesota Multiphasic Personality Inventory (MMPI), the Personality Disorder Questionnaire-4+(PDQ-4+), and the Defense Style Questionnaire (DSQ). Results: The patients with BPD recorded significantly higher scores in somatization, hostility, paranoid ideation of the SCL-90-R and on the F, Pd, Sc, Ma scales of the MMPI than DEP patients. On the scales of the PDQ-4+, there were significant differences between patients with BPD and DEP. BPD patients used maladaptive defense style more frequently than DEP patients. Conclusion: Since the patients with BPD and DEP show a high comorbidity,they present similar clinical aspects. However, BDP patients show more clinically serious instability, paranoid ideation,anger, and behavioral problems, and have more psychologically immature personality traits and defense mechanisms. Thus, when such features are highlighted in psychological tests or clinical interviews, clinicians should consider possibilities of personality disorder as well as depression in diagnosis & treatment.
Abstract
Objectives: There has been little research into comparing characteristics of the patients with borderline personality disorder (BPD) and depression (DEP) which can often be encountered in clinical settings. This study evaluated clinical and psychological characteristics, including defense mechanisms, among patients with BPD and DEP. Methods: We recruited 38 BPD and other 38 DEP patients identified based on diagnostic criteria of the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorder, 4th edition. We compared clinical and psychological characteristics between the patients with BPD and DEP using the Symptom Checklist-90-Revised (SCL-90-R), the Minnesota Multiphasic Personality Inventory (MMPI), the Personality Disorder Questionnaire-4+(PDQ-4+), and the Defense Style Questionnaire (DSQ). Results: The patients with BPD recorded significantly higher scores in somatization, hostility, paranoid ideation of the SCL-90-R and on the F, Pd, Sc, Ma scales of the MMPI than DEP patients. On the scales of the PDQ-4+, there were significant differences between patients with BPD and DEP. BPD patients used maladaptive defense style more frequently than DEP patients. Conclusion: Since the patients with BPD and DEP show a high comorbidity,they present similar clinical aspects. However, BDP patients show more clinically serious instability, paranoid ideation,anger, and behavioral problems, and have more psychologically immature personality traits and defense mechanisms. Thus, when such features are highlighted in psychological tests or clinical interviews, clinicians should consider possibilities of personality disorder as well as depression in diagnosis & treatment.
참고문헌 (40)
- Abela JR, "Cognitive vulnerability to depression in individuals with borderline personality disorder", J Pers Disord, 17, pp.319~329 (2003)
- Adler G., "Borderline psychopathology and its treatment" (1985), Jason Aronson
- Akkerman K, "Long-term changes in defense style among patients recovering from major depression", J Nerv Ment Dis, 187, pp.80~87 (1999)
- American Psychiatric Association, "Diagnostic and stastical manual of mental disorders" (1994), American Psychiatric Association
- Bagby RM, "Detecting overreporting on the MMPI-2", Workshop presented at the 40th Annual MMPI-2, 2005, ~
- Bellino S, "Combined treatment of major depression in patients with borderline personality disorder: a comparison with pharmacotherapy", Can J Psychiatry, 51, pp.453~460 (2006)
- Bond M, "Empirical studies of defense style: relationships with psychopathology and change", Harv Rev Psychiatry, 12, pp.263~278 (2004)
- Bond MP, "An empirical study of the relationship between diagnosis and defense style", Arch Gen Psychiatry, 43, pp.285~288 (1986)
- Burgess JW, "Relationship of depression and cognitive impairment to self-injury in borderline personality disorder, major depression, and schizo-phrenia", Psychiatry Res, 38, pp.77~87 (1991)
- Cary GL, "The borderline condition: a structural-dynamic viewpoint", Psychoanal Rev, 59, pp.33~54 (1972)
- Chung MW, "A preliminary study for the development of a defense style questionnaire adapted for Koreans", J Korean Neuropsychiatr Assoc, 32, pp.707~716 (1993)
- Comtois KA, "Relationship between borderline personality disorder and Axis I diagnosis in severity of depression and anxiety", J Clin Psychiatry, 60, pp.752~758 (1999)
- Derogatis LR, "SCL-90: an outpatient psychiatric rating scale--preliminary report", Psychopharmacol Bull, 9, pp.13~28 (1973)
- Fertuck EA, "The impact of borderline personality disorder and anxiety on neuropsychological performance in major depression", J Pers Disord, 20, pp.55~70 (2006)
- Fyer MR, "Comorbidity of borderline personality disorder", Arch Gen Psychiatry, 45, pp.348~352 (1988)
- Gabbard GO, "Psychodynamic psychiatry in clinical practice" (2005), American Psychiatric Publishing Inc
- Gandolfo RL, "Borderline, depressive, and schizophrenic discrimination by MMPI", J Clin Psychol, 47, pp.783~789 (1991)
- Grinker RR Jr, "The borderline syndrome: a behavioral study of ego-functions" (1968), Basic Books
- Gunderson JG, "Current overview of the borderline diagnosis", J Clin Psychiatry, 48, pp.5~14 (1987)
- Hathaway SR, "The minnesota multiphasic personality inventory" (1943), University of Minnesota Press
- Joyce PR, "Borderline personality disorder in major depression: symptomatology, temperament, character, differential drug response, and 6-month outcome", Compr Psychiatry, 44, pp.35~43 (2003)
- Kelly TM, "Recent life events, social adjustment, and suicide attempts in patients with major depression and borderline personality disorder", J Pers Disord, 14, pp.316~326 (2000)
- Kernberg O, "Severe personality disorders: psychotherapeutic strategies" (1984), Yale University Press
- Kernberg O, "Structural derivatives of object relationships", Int J Psychoanal, 47, pp.236~253 (1966)
- 김대호, "정신분열병 환자의 아동기 신체, 성학대와 MMPI 특성", 신경정신의학, 46(3), pp.223~228 (2007), 대한신경정신의학회
- Kim DI, "The preliminary study of reliability and validity on the Korean version of personality disorder questionnaire-4+ (PDQ-4+)", J Korean Neuropsychiatr Assoc, 39, pp.525~538 (2000)
- Kim GI, "Korean Manual of Symptom Checklist-90-Revision" (1984), Jungangjeokseongchulpansa
- 김소영, "한국에서의 메스암페타민 남용 또는 의존 환자의 인격장애에 관한 연구", 생물치료정신의학, 9(2), pp.204~212 (2003), 대한생물치료정신의학회
- Kim YH, "Gaejeongpan Damyeonjeok Inseonggeomsa Silsiyogang" (1989), Hangukgaideonseu
- Nigg JT, "Malevolent object representations in borderline personality disorder and major depression", J Abnorm Psychol, 101, pp.61~67 (1992)
- Paris J, "Defense styles, hostility, and psychological risk factors in male patients with personality disorders", J Nerv Ment Dis, 184, pp.153~158 (1996)
- Rogers JH, "Aspects of depression associated with borderline personality disorder", Am J Psychiatry, 152, pp.268~270 (1995)
- Shane M, "Family therapy in severe borderline personality disorders", Int J Fam Psychiatry, 9, pp.241~258 (1988)
- Snyder S, "Borderline personality traits in psychiatric inpatients", Psychol Rep, 58, pp.51~60 (1986)
- Southwick SM, "Psychological dimensions of depression in borderline personality disorder", Am J Psychiatry, 152, pp.789~791 (1995)
- Stanley B, "Heightened subjective experience of depression in borderline personality disorder", J Pers Disord, 20, pp.307~318 (2006)
- Sullivan PF, "Borderline personality disorder in major depression", J Nerv Ment Dis, 182, pp.508~516 (1994)
- Underwood G, "Mood and personality: a search for the casual relationship", J Pers, 48, pp.15~23 (1980)
- Wilson ST, "Comparing impulsiveness, hostility, and depression in borderline personality disorder and bipolar II disorder", J Clin Psychiatry, 68, pp.1533~1539 (2007)
- Yang E, "Biogenetic temperament, phenotypic, and defense style profile of borderline personality disorder and their relationship to borderline psychopathology", Kor J Psychopathol, 9, pp.3~15 (2000)