우리 상속법의 비교법적 위치
The Korean law of succession in comparative context
0
조회
0
다운로드
66
인용
0
참고문헌
키워드
초록
In this article the author examines the Korean law of succession from comparative perspective. Here its structure and features are presented in relation to, or in contrast with, other major jurisdictions. The discussed subjects are, among others, range and order of heirs, right of the deceased's spouse, relationship between heirs, liability for obligations of the inheritance, due forms of testament, problems of dispositions mortis causa and forced heirship. With these analyses it is submitted that the Korean succession law is a result of the lawgiver's comparative works, although its main structure apparently goes back to the French law. It can be explained by the fact that the lawgiver received many French institutions reflected in the revised Japanese succession law. In his conclusion the author suggests the more thorough academic researches of the French law as preparatory works for interpreting and reforming the fifth book of the Korean Civil Code.
Abstract
In this article the author examines the Korean law of succession from comparative perspective. Here its structure and features are presented in relation to, or in contrast with, other major jurisdictions. The discussed subjects are, among others, range and order of heirs, right of the deceased's spouse, relationship between heirs, liability for obligations of the inheritance, due forms of testament, problems of dispositions mortis causa and forced heirship. With these analyses it is submitted that the Korean succession law is a result of the lawgiver's comparative works, although its main structure apparently goes back to the French law. It can be explained by the fact that the lawgiver received many French institutions reflected in the revised Japanese succession law. In his conclusion the author suggests the more thorough academic researches of the French law as preparatory works for interpreting and reforming the fifth book of the Korean Civil Code.
참고문헌 (62)
- 郭潤直, "民法總則" (2002)
- 郭潤直, "債權各論" (2003)
- 郭潤直, "相續法" (1997)
- 郭潤直, "相續法" (2004)
- 金疇洙, "親族ㆍ相續法" (2006)
- 金曾漢, "物權法" (1997)
- 金亨培, (2001)
- 民議院 法制司法委員會 民法案審議小委員會, "民法案審議錄" (1957)
- 박동섭, "친족상속법" (2006)
- 朴秉濠, "家族法" (1991)
- 汎女性ㆍ家族法改正促進會, "民法 第四編 親族ㆍ第五編 相續 改正法案 및 理由書"
- 梁彰洙, "民法入門" (2008)
- 李英俊, (2004), 新訂2版
- 鄭光鉉, "韓國家族法硏究" (1967)
- 최병조, "로마법강의" (1999)
- 權純漢, "死因贈與의 方式과 效力", 判例月報, 324 (1997)
- 金云淏, "相續債務", 相續法의 諸問題, ~ (1998)
- 김형석, "한정승인의 효과로서 발생하는 재산분리의 의미", 가족법연구, 22(3), pp.495~536 (2008), 한국가족법학회
- 김형석, "遺留分의 返還과 不當利得", 민사판례연구, (29), pp.145~198 (2007), 민사판례연구회
- 안영하, "일본의 상속시킨다는 취지의 유언에 대한 일고찰", 가족법연구, 21(1), pp.213~248 (2007), 한국가족법학회
- 양창수, "民法典 制定過程에 관한 殘片", 저스티스, (85), pp.83~100 (2005), 한국법학원
- 이희영, "포괄적 사인증여에 포괄유증의 효력에 관한 민법 제1078조가 적용되는지 여부", 대법원판례해설, 제25호, ~ (1996)
- 전혜정, "민법상 유언상속에 관한 연구", 가족법연구, 20(3), pp.151~180 (2006), 한국가족법학회
- 최금숙, "死因贈與에 관한 考察", 법학논집, 9(1), pp.73~91 (2004), 법학연구소
- "1987"
- 최준규, "독일의 유류분 제도", 가족법연구, 22(1), pp.257~302 (2008), 한국가족법학회
- 玄昭惠, "遺言의 解釋", 박사, pp.2009
- Burrows, A, "English Private Law", ~ (2007)
- Ferid, "Das französische Zivilrecht", 2.Aufl, ~ (1987)
- Frank, R, "Erbrecht", 2.Aufl, ~ (2003)
- von Gierke, O, "Grundzüge des deutschen Privatrechts, §§115ff. in Holzendorff (Hrsg.)", Enzyklopädie der Rechtswissenschaft, 1. Band, ~ (1915)
- Grimaldi, "Droit civil", Successions, ~ (2001)
- Henrich, "Einführung in das englische Privatrecht", 3.Aufl, ~ (2003)
- Kaser, "Römisches Privatrecht", 18.Aufl, ~ (2005)
- Koziol, "Bürgerliches Recht", Band II, 12.Aufl, ~ (2001)
- Lange, "Erbrecht", 5.Aufl, ~ (2001)
- Malaurie, Ph, "Les successions", Les libéralités, ~ (2004)
- Malaurie, Ph, "Les successions", Les libéralités, ~ (2006)
- Marty et Raynaud, "Droit civil", Les successions et les libéralités, ~ (1983)
- Mazeaud et Leveneur, "Leçons de droit civil", tome IV, 1999
- Mitteis, "Deutsches Privatrecht", 7.Aufl, ~ (1976)
- Neumayer, K.H, "Chapter 3: Intestate Succession", International Encyclopedia of Comparative Law, ~ (2002)
- Parry, "The Law of Succession", ~ (2002)
- Pollock, "The History of English Law", ~ (1898), vol. II, 2nd
- Schwind, M.A, "Chapter 8: Liability for Obligations of the Inheritance", International Encyclopedia of Comparative Law, ~ (2002)
- Smits, J.M, "Elgar Encyclopedia of Comparative Law", ~ (2006)
- Staudinger, "Eckpfeiler des Zivilrechts", ~ (2008)
- Voirin et Goubeaux, "Droit civil", tome 2, 24e éd, ~ (2006)
- Henrich, D, "Familienerbrecht und Testierfreiheit im europäischen Vergleich", ~ (2001)
- Verbeke, A, "Harmonisation of the Law of Succession in Europe", Towards a European Civil Code, 3rd ed, ~ (2004)
- de Waal, M. J, "Comparative Succession Law", The Oxford Handbook of Comparative Law, ~ (2006)
- 磯部四郞, "民法釋義 財産取得編(下)", 相續法之部, ~ (1890)
- 伊藤昌司, "相續法" (2002)
- 大久保泰甫, "ボワソナード民法典の編纂", ~ (1999)
- 太田武男, "相續法槪說", ~ (1997)
- 道垣內弘人, "ゼミナール民法入門", ~ (2008), 第4版
- 中川善之助, "相續法", ~ (2000), 第四版
- 星野通, "明治民法編纂史硏究", ~ (1943)
- "民法修正案理由書", 親族編ㆍ相續編, ~ (1898)
- 原田慶吉, "日本 民法典の史的素描", ~ (1954)
- 我妻榮, "改正 親族ㆍ相續法解說", ~ (1949)
- 來栖三郞, "相續順位", 來栖三郞著作集 III: 家族法, ~ (2004)