동성혼으로 말해 온 것과 말해야 할 것
The History and Future of Discourse about Same-Sex Marriage
0
조회
0
다운로드
10
인용
0
참고문헌
키워드
초록
Today, the discourse about same-sex relationship is moved from the prohibition of discrimination by sexual orientation toward the recognition of same-sex marriage. Actually many states introduced the same-sex partnership similar to marriage by legislation and several states accepted same-sex marriage. Of course, such a trend is good for gay/lesbian human rights movements. But the situating marriage as an ultimate ends is not desirable in some points: although same-sex intimate relationship has the potential of alternative life style, the legalization of same-sex marriage is just included in hetero-sex legal marriage therefore used as the naturalization of marriage. Moreover the question and critique about the reason of which state has the authority over intimacy are not founded. Accordingly, now is the time that legal marriage itself should be abolished.
Abstract
Today, the discourse about same-sex relationship is moved from the prohibition of discrimination by sexual orientation toward the recognition of same-sex marriage. Actually many states introduced the same-sex partnership similar to marriage by legislation and several states accepted same-sex marriage. Of course, such a trend is good for gay/lesbian human rights movements. But the situating marriage as an ultimate ends is not desirable in some points: although same-sex intimate relationship has the potential of alternative life style, the legalization of same-sex marriage is just included in hetero-sex legal marriage therefore used as the naturalization of marriage. Moreover the question and critique about the reason of which state has the authority over intimacy are not founded. Accordingly, now is the time that legal marriage itself should be abolished.
참고문헌 (36)
- 임옥희, "젠더의 조롱과 우울의 철학―주디스 버틀러 읽기" (2006), 도서출판 여이연
- 김우중, "동성혼에 관한 국제적 입법동향", 비교사법, 9(4), pp.~7 (2002), 한국비교사법학회
- 김민중, "독일의 새로운 가족법상의 제도로서의 동성 사이의 생활동반자관계", 가족법연구, 15(2) (2001)
- 서동진, "한국의 소수자, 실태와 전망 in: 성적 시민권과 비이성애적 주체" (2004), 한울아카데미
- 양선숙, "철학과 현실 in: 동성결혼 허용의 문제" (2004), 철학문화연구소
- 오정진, "동성결합과 결혼체계의 자체생산", 성균관법학, 18(2), pp.277~294 (2006), 법학연구소
- 이덕환, "미국법상 동성혼에 관한 고찰", 비교사법, 12(1)통권 : 28 (2005)
- 이석태, "성적 소수자의 인권 in: 성적 지향에 근거한 차별과 대책" (2002), 사람생각
- 이영진, "시민과 변호사 in: 최근 미국의 동성결혼 판결에 대하여" (2004), 서울지방변호사회
- 이은우, "한국에서 동성 결혼은 가능한가 in: 동성애자의 결혼과 가정은 어떻게 보호되어야 하나?", 퀴어문화축제 무지개 2004 토론회 (2004)
- 장복희, "성적 소수자의 인권 in: 동성간 동반자관계에 관한 국제인권법 및 비교법적 고찰" (2002), 사람생각
- 한채윤, "한국에서 동성 결혼은 가능한가 in: 외국의 동성 결혼 현황", 퀴어문화축제 무지개 2004 토론회 (2004)
- 한채윤, "성적 소수자의 인권 in: 성적 소수자 차별의 본질과 실제 그리고 해소 방안" (2002), 사람생각
- 다이애너 기틴스, "가족은 없다" (1997), 일신사
- 프랑수아즈 조나벵, "가족의 역사 1 in: 가족에 대하여" (2001), 이학사
- 辻村 みよ子, "ジェンダ―と法" (2005), 不磨書房
- 伊田廣行, "シングル單位の社會論-ジェンダ-․フリ-な社會ヘ" (1998), 世界思想社
- Chamallas, Martha, "Introduction to feminist legal theory" (2003), ASPEN
- Curry, Hayden, "A Legal Guide for Lesbian & Gay Couples" (2004), NOLO
- Dangerous Bedfellows, "Domesticating partnerships, policing public sex" (1996), South End Press
- Robinson, Ruthann, "Sappho Goes to Law School" (1998), Columbia University Press
- Strasser, Mark, "On same-sex marriage, civil unions, and the rule of law" (2002), Praeger
- Thaler, Richard H, "Nudge: Improving Decisions About Health, Wealth, and Happiness" (2008), Princeton University Press
- 吉田 克己, "‘公私’の再構成 in 家族における‘公私’の再編" (2000), 有斐閣
- 渡邊泰彦, "家族-ジェンダーと自由と法 in 同性カップルの法的保護" (2006), 東北大學出版會
- 鈴木伸智, "成年養子緣組と同性愛", 靑山學院論集, 41(1) (1999)
- 瀧澤聿代, "日本とフランスの家族觀 in 日本の家族法における人的關係" (2003), 有斐閣
- 棚村政行, "小野幸二 敎授 古稀記念論集 in 21世紀の家族と法 in 事實婚․同性婚の法的保護" (2007), 法學書院
- 森村 進, "キャス․サンスティ-ンとリチャ-ド․セイラ-の ‘リバタリアン․パタ-ナリズム’", 一橋法學, 7(3) (2008)
- Auchmuty, Rosemary, "Same-sex Marriage Revived: Feminist Critique and Legal Strategy in Sexuality and Identity, USA and England" (2006), Ashgate Publishing Company
- Butler, Judith, "Competing Universalities in The Judith Butler Reader, USA and UK" (2004), Blackwell Publishing
- Delphy, C, "Marriage et divorce: une impasse à double face", pp.333~334 (1974), Les Temps moderne
- Douglas, Gillian, "The Civil Partnership Act 2004-parallel marriage or a second-class status for same-sex partners?, 21世紀の家族と法, 小野幸二 敎授 古稀記念論集" (2007), 法學書院
- Ettelbrick, Paula L, "Since when is marriage a path to liberation? Lesbian and gay marriage: private commitments" (1992), public ceremonies
- Herman, Didi, "The Politics of Law Reform: Lesbian and Gay Rights into the 1990s in Activating Theory: Lesbian, Gay, Bisexual Politics" (1993), Lawrence and Wishart
- Hunter, Nan, "Marriage, Law and Gender: a Feminist Inquiry in Sex Wars: Sexual Dissent and Political Culture" (1995), Routledge