본문 바로가기
KERD
논문KCI 등재

Relevance of Moral Sense to Legal Reasoning

오병선
한국법철학회 (Korean Association Of Legal Philosophy)|2012.12|법철학연구 (Korean Journal of Legal Philosophy)|제15권 제3호|pp. 177-200

0

조회

0

다운로드

3

인용

0

참고문헌

키워드

공감법적 추론법관의 양심(Judge's conscience)도덕심(Moral sense)합당한 도덕심(Reasonable moral sense)법적 추론(Legal reasoning)공감(Sympathy)정의심(Sense of justice)유가적 도덕담론(Confucian moral discourse)법관의 양심도덕심합당한 도덕심정의심유가적 도덕담론
주제분류법학

초록

If we admit that judge’s conscience to be employed in judicial decision-making is an integral element of legal reasoning, this should be understood as a kind of moral sense. Moral sense manifests itself in many different forms such as sympathy, resentment, sense of justice and others. If moral sense including sense of justice is to work as a criterion of justice in the process of legal reasoning, it should be reasonable moral sense. We may find this example of reasonable moral sense in a harmonized form of Four Beginnings of Confucian moral ideas, that is, commiseration, shame and disgust, yielding and deference, and discernment.

Abstract

If we admit that judge’s conscience to be employed in judicial decision-making is an integral element of legal reasoning, this should be understood as a kind of moral sense. Moral sense manifests itself in many different forms such as sympathy, resentment, sense of justice and others. If moral sense including sense of justice is to work as a criterion of justice in the process of legal reasoning, it should be reasonable moral sense. We may find this example of reasonable moral sense in a harmonized form of Four Beginnings of Confucian moral ideas, that is, commiseration, shame and disgust, yielding and deference, and discernment.

참고문헌 (47)

  1. Tscholsu Kim, "General Treatise on Constitution, 19th Revised Edition", pp.1581~ (2011), Bakyoungsa
  2. Tscholsu Kim, "However, Tae-Yeon Han espouses the idea that conscience in Article 103 involves not only objective sense of conscience but also subjective sense of conscience of a judge, In Study of Constitution", pp.768~769 (1977), Bupmunsa
  3. Frederick Schauer, "Formalism", Yale L. J, 97, pp.509~ (1988)
  4. Robert S. Summers, "Form and Function in a Legal System: A General Study" (2006), Cambridge University Press
  5. Jerome Frank, "Are Judges Human?", Univ. of Penn. L. Rev, 80, pp.17~ (1931)
  6. Joseph Hutcheson, Jr., "The Judgement Intuitive: The Function of the ‘Hunch’ in Judicial Decision", Cornell L. Quarterly, 14, pp.274~ (1929)
  7. Lon Fuller, "The Morality of Law, Revised Edition", pp.145~151 (1964), Yale University Press
  8. Brian Z. Tamanaha, "Beyond the Formalist-Realist Divide", pp.1~3 (2010), Princeton University Press
  9. Richard A. Posner, "How Judges Think", pp.41~ (2008), Harvard University Press
  10. Ernest J. Weinrib, "Legal Formalism: On the Immanent Rationality of Law", Yale L. J, 97, pp.949~ (1988)
  11. Steven J. Burton, "An Introduction to Law and Legal Reasoning, Third Edition", pp.89~90 (2007), Aspen Publishers
  12. Ronald Dworkin, "Law's Empire", pp.410~413 (1986), Harvard University Press
  13. Ronald Dworkin, "Natural Law Revisited", Univ. of Florida L. Rev, 34, pp.165~ (1982)
  14. Jeremy Waldron, "Do Judges Reason Morally?, In Expounding the Constitution: Essays in Constitutional Theory", pp.38~64 (2008), Cambridge University Press
  15. Samuel Stoljar, "Moral and Legal Reasoning", pp.47~ (1980), Harper & Row Publishing Inc.
  16. Richard Warner, "Three Theories of Legal Reasoning", S. Cal. L. Rev, 62, pp.1571~ (1989)
  17. David Klein, "The Psychology of Judicial Decision-making" (2010), Oxford University Press
  18. Samuel Freeman, "Rawls", pp.253~ (2007), Routledge
  19. John Rawls, "A Theory of Justice, Revised Edition, Chapter VIII" (1999), The Belknap Press of Harvard University Press
  20. James Q. Wilson, "The Moral Sense", pp.12~ (1993), The Free Press
  21. R. Jay Wallace, "Responsibility and the Moral Sentiments", pp.33~ (1994), Harvard University Press
  22. Jesse J. Prinz, "The Emotional Construction of Morals", pp.50~51 (2007), Oxford University Press
  23. John Rawls, "A Theory of Justice, Revised Edition, Chapter VIII" (1999)
  24. James Q. Wilson, "The Moral Sense", pp.32~ (1993), The Free Press
  25. Martha Nussbaum, "Upheavals of Thought, The Intelligence of Emotions", pp.302~ (2001), Cambridge University Press
  26. Lauren Wispe, "The Psychology of Sympathy" (1991), Plenum Press
  27. Martha Nussbaum, "Upheavals of Thought, The Intelligence of Emotions" (2001), Cambridge University Press
  28. James Q. Wilson, "The Moral Sense", pp.30~ (1993), The Free Press
  29. Rosalind Hursthouse, "On Virtue Ethics", pp.102~ (1999), Oxford University Press
  30. Jean-Jacques Rousseau, "Emile", pp.235~ (1979), Basic Books
  31. Amartya Sen, "The Idea of Justice" (2009), Belknap Press of Harvard University Press
  32. Adam Smith, "The Theory of Moral Sentiments", pp.319~320 (1976), Clarendon Press
  33. D. D. Raphael, "The Impartial Spectator, In Essays on Adam Smith", pp.83~99 (1975), Clarendon Press
  34. Martha C. Nussbaum, "Frontiers of Justice" (2006), The Belknap Press of Harvard University Press
  35. Liu Shu-Hsien, "Confucian Ideals and the Real World: A Critical Review of Contemporary Neo-Confucian Thought, In Confucian Traditions in East Asian Modernity", pp.109~ (1996), Harvard University Press
  36. Jang-Tae Keum, "Four-Seven Debate, In RoutlegeCurzon Encyclopedia of Confucianism, Vol. I", pp.216~217 (2003), RoutlegeCurzon
  37. Chung-ying Cheng, "Mencius, In Encyclopedia of Chinese Philosophy", pp.442~ (2003), Routlege
  38. Chong Yagyong, "What the I-ki Debate is All About, In Sourcebook of Korean Civilization, Vol. II", pp.270~271 (1996), Columbia University Press
  39. James Q. Wilson, "The Moral Sense", pp.13~14 (1993), The Free Press
  40. John Rawls, "Outline of a Decision Procedure for Ethics, In John Rawls, Collected Papers", pp.2~ (1999), Harvard University Press
  41. John W. Cairns, "Adam Smith and the Role of the Courts in Securing Justice and Liberty, In Adam Smith and the Philosophy of Law and Economics", pp.36~40 (1995), Kluwer Academic Publishers
  42. Kenneth A. B. MacKinnon, "Adam Smith on Delictual Liability, In Adam Smith and the Philosophy of Law and Economics", pp.86~90 (1995), Kluwer Academic Publishers
  43. Ronald Dworkin, "Law's Empire", pp.240~258 (1986), The Belknap Press of Harvard University Press
  44. Lawrence B. Solum, "Virtue Jurisprudence, A Virtue-centered Theory of Judging", Metaphilosophy, 34, pp.178~213 (2003)
  45. John Rawls, "Political Liberalism" (1993), Columbia University Press
  46. Lawrence B. Solum, "the Aretaic Turn in Constitutional Theory", Brooklyn L. Rev, 70, pp.475~ (2005)
  47. Lawrence B. Solum, "Virtue Jurisprudence, A virtue-centered Theory of Judging", Metaphilosophy, 34, pp.201~ (2003)

관련 논문AI추천

Function of “Normative Judgment” in Legal Reasoning김범진아시아태평양법연구소 · Journal of Korean Law2024 · 제23권 제2호법적 추론의 기능에 대한 고찰김혁기한국법철학회 · 법철학연구2010 · 제13권 제1호한국 법체계에서 자연법론의 형성과 발전 -과거를 되돌아보며 미래를 가늠하다김도균한국법철학회 · 법철학연구2008 · 제11권 제2호Emotional Rationality in Confucian EthicsXu Jia한국윤리학회 · 倫理硏究2020 · 제1권 제129호Dasan’s Moral Epistemology정소이한국학중앙연구원 · Korea Journal2013 · 제53권 제2호법관의 법적 결정이 갖는 의미와 그 정당성 확보 문제 - 현대 법이론의 관점에서 살펴 본 판결의 정당성 논의 -류승훈, 안성조법학연구소 · 외법논집2009 · 제33권 제1호

이 간행물의 다른 논문 (5건)

법치의 문제에 관한 몇 가지 결론최봉철pp. 5-40법, 규범성, 그리고 규칙 준수의 동기에 대한 관행론적 이해양선숙pp. 41-74변영만의 삶과 뜻정태욱pp. 75-118재분배, 사회권, 인정고봉진pp. 119-142법을 행위의 근거로 삼는 이유에 관한 고찰 ―법실증주의의 관점에서―권경휘pp. 143-176
원문 보기