민수기 20장 2-13절에 나타난 모세의 실패에 대한 공시적 연구
A Synchronic Reading of the Account of Moses' Failure to Enter the Promised Land in Numbers 20:2-13
0
조회
0
다운로드
2
인용
0
참고문헌
키워드
초록
이 논문은 모세가 약속의 땅 입성이 하나님으로부터 거절되었음을 다루는 민수기 20장 2-13절을 구조 분석적으로 해석한 것이다. 이것을 통해 본 논문은 민수기 20장 2-13절이 모세의 죄가 무엇인지 밝히는 것에 관심을 갖고 있지 않고, 모세가 이스라엘 백성을 가나안 땅에 이끌고 감에 있어서 정당한 지도자가 아니라는 사실을 강조하고 있음을 보여준다.
Abstract
This paper is an exegetical paper on the final form of Numbers 20:2-13, which depicts Moses' failure to enter the Promised Land. This paper is not concerned about the exposing the cause of Moses' failure, but about the intention of the text. In order to disclose the intention of the text, this paper examines the final form of the text by a synchronic approach rather than a diachronic approach. First, this paper analyzes the structure and texture of the final form of Numbers 20:2-13. The extant form of Numbers 20:2-13 is portrayed in the rhetorical scheme of inclusio of the introductory exposition on the situation (20:2a) and the concluding etiology on the name (20:13). In this framework, the main block concerning the event caused by the lack of water (20:2b-12) is described in terms of a five-part concentric design as follows: a. People's negative evaluation on Moses' action (20:2b-5), b. Moses' and Aaron's response on the people's complaint (20:6a), c. YHWH's instruction (20:6b-8), b'. Moses' and Aaron's response on YHWH's command (20:9-11), a'. YHWH's negative evaluation on Moses' action (20:12). Second, the structural analysis on Number 20:2-13 exposes the literary intention of the text. In its extant form, the third major unit concerning YHWH's instructions to Moses (20:6b-8) is most highlighted by being placed at the center of the literary block (20:2b-12) in the chiastic structure, and the first and fifth major units (20:2b-5, 12) are emphasized by composing the rhetorical scheme of inclusio. In YHWH's instructions to Moses (20:6b-8), YHWH is exhibited as not only a comforter with Moses and Aaron in trouble, but also the One who provides the best possible thing for the people in need as well as the One who restores the crisis of the leadership of Moses caused by the people's protest. The framework of the account (20:2b-5, 12) illustrates that Moses was not a legitimate leader for the people as they entered Canaan by emphasizing the negative evaluations on Moses by both the people from below and YHWH from above (cf. the law of kingship in Deut 17:14-20). Third, other texts concerning Moses' transgression (Num 20:22-29; 27:12-14; Deut 32:48-52) portray YHWH's denial of Moses and Aaron in relation to their leadership and its transfer to Joshua and Eleazer. Also, the final form of Numbers 20:2-13 shows that YHWH is the only leader of the Israelites but not Moses by the comparison between YHWH's leadership and Moses' leadership (20:12-13).
참고문헌 (32)
- 정석규, "신명기 17:14-20의 Intertextuality를 통한 해석", 구약논단, 11, pp.49~70 (2001)
- 정석규, "왕의 법(신 17: 14-20)의 이중적 기능", 구약논단, 15(4), pp.30~50 (2009), 한국구약학회
- Arden, Eugene, "How Moses Failed God", JBL, 76, pp.50~52 (1957)
- Ashley, T. R, "The Book of Numbers" (1993), William B. Eerdmans
- Beck, John A, "Why did Moses Strike out? The Narrative-Geographical Shaping of Moses' Disqualification in Numbers 20:1-13", Westminster Theological Journal, 65, pp.135~141 (2003)
- Budd, P. J, "Numbers (WBC)" (1984), Word Books
- Coats, G, "Rebellion in the Wilderness" (1968), Abingdon Press
- Coats, G, "The Wilderness Itinerary", CBQ, 34, pp.135~152 (1972)
- Coats, G, "Legendary Motifs in the Moses Death Reports", CBQ, 39, pp.34~44 (1977)
- Cross, Frank M, "Canaanite Myth and Hebrew Epic: Essays in the History of the Religion of Israel" (1973), Harvard University Press
- Davies, G. I, "The Wilderness Itineraries and the Composition of the Pentateuch", VT, 33, pp.1~13 (1983)
- Gray, G. B, "A Critical and Exegetical Commentary on Numbers (ICC)" (1903), T&T Clark
- Helfgot Nathaniel, "And Moses Struck the Rock": Numbers 20 and the Leadership of Moses", Tradition, 27(3), pp.51~58 (1993)
- Knierim, Rolf P, "Numbers (FOTL)" (2005), William B. Eerdmans Pub
- Kok, Johnson Lim Teng, "The Sin of Moses and the Staff of God: A Narrative Approach" (1997), The Netherlands: VanGorcus & Comp
- Lee, Won, "The Exclusion of Moses from the Promised Land: a conceptual approach,In Changing face of form criticism for the twenty-first century", pp.217~39 (2003), Eerdmans
- Levine, Baruch A, "Numbers 1-20: A New Translation with Introduction and Commentary" (1993), Doubleday
- Mann, T. W, "Theological Reflections on the Denial of Moses", JBL, 98, pp.481~494 (1979)
- Margaliot, M, "The Transgression of Moses and Aaron-Num 20:1-13", JQR, 74(2), pp.196~228 (1983)
- Milgrom, J, "Numbers, In JPS Torah Commentary" (1990), Jewish Publication Society
- Miller, Patrick D, "Deuteronomy" (1990), John Knox Press
- Noth, Martin, "Numbers" (1968), The Westminster Press
- Olson, Dennis T, "Numbers" (1996), John Knox Press
- Propp, William H. C, "Why Moses Could Not Enter The Promised Land", BR, 14(3), pp.36~43 (1998)
- Propp, William H. C, "The Rod of Aaron and the Sin of Moses", JBL, 107, pp.19~26 (1988)
- Sakenfeld, K. D, "and Redactional Problems in Numbers 20:2-13, In Understanding the Word: Essays in Honor of B. W. Anderson (JSOTSup 37)", pp.133~51 (1985), JSOT Press
- Sweeney, Marvin A, "TANAK: A Theological and Critical Introduction to the Jewish Bible" (2012), Fortress Press
- Tigay, Jefferey H, "Deuteronomy, In JPS Torah Commentary" (1996), Jewish Publication Society
- Tunyogi, A. C, "The Rebellions of Israel" (1969), John Knox Press
- Von Rad, Gerhard, "Deuteronomy" (1966), The Westminster Press
- Weinfeld, Moshe, "Deuteronomy 1-11 : A New Translation with Introduction and Commentary" (1991), Doubleday
- Wenham, Gordon, "Numbers, In The Tyndale Old Testament Commentaries" (1981), IVP