고고학 자료와 고대 문헌 사이의 상관관계 – 아마르나 시대 게셀을 중심으로
The Correlation Between Material Evidence and Written Documents in the Light of Gezer in the Amarna Period.
0
조회
0
다운로드
0
인용
0
참고문헌
키워드
초록
성경을 포함한 고대 문헌과 고고학 자료 사이의 상관관계를 알아보기 위해 게셀을 중심으로 후기 청동기 아마르나 시대 가나안의 8 도시 국가들에 대한 문헌 기록과 고고학 자료를 비교하여 역사를 재구성할 시 문헌과 고고학이 바라봐야 할 각각의 방향성을 제시한다.
Abstract
The object of this research is to examine the correlation between material evidence and ancient documents in the light of Gezer in the Amarna period. Some gaps appear between ancient documents and archaeological materials in reconstructing the ancient history. While some unearthed archaeological evidences are correctly identified with written texts, all the written records are not confirmed in the archaeological material evidence. In particular, the city state of Gezer was recorded as one of the key roles in the Amarna Period but the archaeological data can not support its significant role as recorded in the correspondence of the Amarna Letters. So this research tries to compare the archaeological date of Gezer with the written date of Amarna letters as well as the other seven city states mentioned in the twelve letters sent from Gezer. The Amarna Letters sent from the rulers of Gezer are EA 267-271 (Milkilu), EA 292-294 (Adda-danu or Ba'lu-šipți), EA 297-300 (Yapahu), and EA 378 (Yapahu). The Letters from other rulers mentioned the rulers of Gezer are EA 249-50 (Ba'lu-UR.SAG of Gitipadalla), EA 253-54 (Lab'ayu of Shechem), EA 273 (NIN-UR.MAḪ. MEŠ of Ṣapuma), EA 287, EA 289-290 (Abdi-heba of Jerusalem), and EA 369 (one letter from Pharaoh to the ruler of Gezer). The other seven city states are Gitipadalla (EA 249-50), Shechem (EA 253-54), Sapuma (EA 274), Jerusalem (EA 287, 289-300), Ginti-carmel (EA 249), Ashkelon (EA 287), and Lachish (EA 287). Among the researched eight city-states including Gezer, only two city-states, Lachish and Shechem, reveal ample material evidence. The rest of them give meager evidence or nothing. Archaeology might not yet find material remains, or archaeology might incorrectly interpret material remains. conflicts within the Canaanite city-states seem to be not as severe as those drawn in the Amarna Archives because only the city of Shechem exposes the debris of destruction by fire in the Amarna period. In conclusion, Reconstruction of ancient history should not focus on one side. Archaeology recognizes that archaeological data would not be objective, while scholars respect that archaeological data is useful. It is necessary to carry out a valid interpretation of documents and archaeological data, as well as ancient documents and archaeological excavation materials.
참고문헌 (28)
- 강후구, "예루살렘에 대한 고고학적 연구: 구약 시대를 중심으로", 구약논단, 24(2), pp.202~225 (2018), 한국구약학회[DOI]
- 레스터 L. 그래비, "고대 이스라엘 역사: B.C. 2,000년경~B.C. 539년" (2022), CLC
- 유진 메릴, "제사장의 나라-구약 이스라엘의 역사" (2008), CLC
- Clamer, Christa, "Canaanite Temple at Tell Lachish", Biblical Archaeologist, 40(2), pp.71~76 (1977)
- Davis, Thomas W., "Shifting Sands: The Rise and Fall of Biblical Archaeology" (2004), Oxford University Press
- Nelson Glueck School of Biblical Archaeology 4, "Gezer IV: The 1969-71 Seasons in Field VI, the “acropolis”, Annual of the Hebrew Union College", pp.1986, Dever, W. G.
- Freedman, David N., "The Anchor Bible Dictionary" (1992), Bantam Doubleday Dell Publishing Group, Inc
- Garfinkel, Y., "Lachish Fortifications and State Formation in the Biblical Kingdom of Judah in Light of Radiometric Datings", Radiocarbon, 61(3), pp.695~712 (2019)
- Geva, H., "The New Encyclopedia of Archaeological Excavations in the Holy Land. Vol. 2", pp.698~716 (1993), Israel Exploration Society
- Goren, Yuval, "The Seat of Three Disputed Canaanite Rulers According to Petrographic Investigation of the Amarna Tablets", Tel Aviv: Journal of the Institute of Archaeology of Tel Aviv University, 29(2), pp.221~237 (2002)
- Master, Daniel M., "The Oxford Encyclopedia of the Bible and Archaeology" (2013), Oxford University Press
- Mazar, Amihai, "Timnah (TEL BATASH) III: The Finds from the Second Millennium BCE, edited by Nava Panitz-Cohen and Amihai Mazar. Qedem Monographs of the Institute of Archaeology the Hebrew University of Jerusalem 45" (2006), The Hebrew University
- Mazar, Amihai, "The 1997-1998 Excavations at Tel Reḥov : Preliminary Report", Israel Exploration Journal, 49(1-2), pp.1~42 (1999)
- Mazar, Amihai, "It Is the Land of Honey : Beekeeping at Tel Reḥov", Near Eastern Archaeology, 70(4), pp.202~219 (2007)
- Moran, William L., "The Amarna Letters" (1992), Johns Hopkins University Press
- Moran, William L., "Amarna Studies: Collected Writings" (2003), Eisenbrauns
- Na’aman, Nadav, "Canaan in the Second Millennium BCE Collected Essays: Vol. 2" (2012), Eisenbrauns
- Na’aman, Nadav, "Fire Signals of Lachish:Studies in the Archaeology and History Israel" (2011), Eisenbrauns
- Na’aman, Nadav, "Ugarit-Forschangen" (1979), Neukirchen-Vluyn
- Negev, Avraham, "Archaeological Encyclopedia of the Holy Land" (1990), Macmillan General Reference
- Gezer 2013 Report, "Ortiz, Steven M.", ~ (2013)
- Ortiz, Steven M., "The Late Bronze and Early Iron Ages of Southern Canaan" (2019), De Gruyer
- Pritchard, J. B., "The Ancient Near Eastern Texts Relating to the Old Testament" (1969), Princeton University Press
- Provan, Iain W., "A Biblical History of Israel" (2015), Westminster John Knox Press
- Ross, James F., "Gezer in the Tell El-Amarna Letters", The Bibical Archaeologist, 30, pp.62~70 (1967)
- Schloen, David, "Recent Discoveries at Ashkelon", The Oriental Instute News and Notes, 145(Spring) (1995)
- Ussishkin, David, "Biblical Lachish: A Tale of Construction, Destruction, Excavation and Restoration", pp.2014, Israel exploration society
- Watamabe, Hiroaki, "Middle Bronze-Late Bronze Transitional Period in Palestine", pp.2002