본문 바로가기
KERD
논문

국제형사재판에 있어 재판의 공정성에 관한 연구-대륙법과 영미법의 충돌과 조화를 중심으로-

A Fair Trial in the International Criminal Tribunal

0

조회

0

다운로드

4

인용

0

참고문헌

키워드

주제분류법학

초록

구 유고 전범재판소는 초창기 기본적으로 영미의 당사자주의에 입각한 수사 및 재판절차를 채택하였다. 그러나 1995년 첫 사건의 심리를 개시한 이후 재판의 장기화라는 비판에 직면하였고, 그 이후 재판소는 절차 및 증거규칙을 개정권한을 이용하여 여러 차례에 걸쳐 재판부 주도의 재판 운영 및 서면 증거를 허용하는 방향으로 전환하였다. 이러한 전환이 재판의 공정성에 어떤 영향을 미치는지 많은 논쟁이 있었고, 특히 소송 개시 이전에 재판부가 수사기록에 접근하도록 한 점, 소추 재량권의 남용, 서면 증거, 절차 및 증거규칙 개정권한 등을 둘러싸고 그 문제점들이 지적되었다. 구 유고 전범재판소의 시행착오를 경험으로 국제형사재판소는 도입 초기부터 영미법과 대륙법의 중간적 모델을 채택하였다. 그 대표적인 것이 검사의 객관의무를 규정하여 대륙 형사절차법의 수사시스템을 도입한 것이다. 증거법에 있어 영미법상의 증거배제의 원칙을 도입하지 않고 재판부의 자유심증에 따라 그 허용 여부를 판단하도록 한 점에 있어 대륙법의 요소를 도입한 것으로 평가된다. 국제형사재판소는 영미 및 대륙법계 국가들 모두에 있어 이제까지 국제사회가 추구해 온 피고인의 기본적 인권을 보장하면서 효율적인 범죄진압이라는 기본 목표를 충족할 수 있는 통합 형사 절차 시스템의 표준으로 자리 잡을 것으로 주목을 받고 있고, 우리나라의 형사사법개혁에 있어서 반드시 참고하여야 할 핵심적 모델로 평가된다. * 논문접수 : 2006. 8. 29. * 심사개시 : 2006. 9. 4. * 게재확정 : 2006. 9. 22.

참고문헌 (92)

  1. Cassese, "International Criminal Law" (2003), Cassese
  2. Christopher J. M. Safferling,, "Towards An International Criminal Procedure" (2001)
  3. Gabrielle Kirk McDonald, "Substantive and Procedural Aspects of International Criminal Law", 1 (2000)
  4. G?ran Sluiter, "International Criminal Adjudication and the Collection of Evidence Obligations of States" (2002)
  5. Ilias Bantekas, "International Criminal Law" (2003)
  6. John E. Ackerman, "Practice and Procedure of the International Criminal Tribunal for the Former Yugoslavia" (2000)
  7. Leila Nadya Sadat, "The International Criminal Court and the Transformation of International Law: Justice for the New Millennium" (2002)
  8. Louise Arbour, "The Prosecutor of a Permanent International Court" (2000)
  9. M. Cherif Bassiouni, "The Law of the International Criminal Tribunal for the Former Yugoslavia" (1996)
  10. M. Cherif Bassiouni, "Introduction to International Criminal Law" (2003)
  11. Mauro Politi, "The Rome Statute of the International Criminal Court" (2001)
  12. ka, "The faces of Justice and State Authority" (1986)
  13. "European Criminal Procedures" (2002)
  14. "The International Criminal Court" (2004)
  15. "International Criminal Evidence" (2002)
  16. "Archbold: International Criminal Courts: practice" (2003)
  17. "Human Rights in International Criminal Proceedings" (2003)
  18. "An Insider's Guide to the International Criminal Tribunal for the Former Yugoslavia", 1,2 (1995)
  19. "An Introduction to the International Criminal Court" (2001)
  20. "“국제 형사재판과 한국 형사재판의 비교법적 고찰”", (359) (2006)
  21. "Reflections on Two Models Inquisitorial Themes in American Criminal Procedure" (1973)
  22. "Enhancing the Legitimacy and Accountability of Prosecutorial Discretion at the International Criminal Court", pp.97~ (2003)
  23. "Juries in International Criminal Adjudication" (2004), 79 New York University L Rev
  24. "the War over Kosovo" (2002)
  25. "The Rule of Law and Prospects for Criminal Procedure Reform in Chile 5 Southwestern J of L and Trade in the Americas" (1998)
  26. "The Statute of the International Criminal Court", pp.10~ (1999)
  27. "The Precedent of Nuremberg Confirmed" (1994)
  28. "The Procedural Law of the International Criminal Court in Outline Anatomy of a Unique Compromise" (2003)
  29. "Due Process in International Criminal Courts" (2001)
  30. "The Statute of the International Criminal Court", pp.48~ (1999)
  31. "Prosecutorial Discretion before National Courts and International Tribunals" (2005)
  32. "Rules of Procedure and Evidence of the International Tribunal for the Former Yugoslavia" (1994)
  33. "Improving the Operation and Functioning of the International Criminal Tribunals", pp.94~ (2000)
  34. "The Contribution of the ICTY to the Emergence of the ICC Procedural and Evidentiary Aspects from a Practitioner's Perspective in The International Centre for Criminal Law Reform and Criminal Justice Policy The Changing Face of International Criminal Law" (2002)
  35. "48 American J of Comparative L" (2000)
  36. "The Procedural and Evidentiary Rules of the Post-World War II War Crimes Trials Did They Provide an Outline for International Legal Procedure 37 columbia J of Transnational L" (1999)
  37. "Substantive and Procedural Aspects of International Criminal Law", 1 (2000)
  38. "More Likely to Do Justice 26 Harvard J of L and Public Policy" (2003)
  39. "Prosecutorial Power in An Adversarial System Lessons from Current White Collar Cases and the Inquisitorial Model" (2004)
  40. "Creating Laws of Evidence for International Criminal Law The ICTY and the Principle of Flexibility" (2001)
  41. "Prosecutorial Independence and the Democratic Requirement of Accountability in Italy", 38 brit j crimi(logy) (1998)
  42. "Adversary Excesses in the American Criminal Trial" (1992)
  43. "European Perspectives on the Accused as a Source of Testimonial Evidence" (1998)
  44. "A Non-Adversary Approach to International Criminal Tribunals", pp.26~ (2002)
  45. "Historical Foundations of the Law of Evidence A View from the Ryder Sources" (1996)
  46. "The Legal Basis for an ICC in Louise Arbour and others The Prosecutor of a Permanent International Court" (2000)
  47. "'Comparative Summary of the National Reports' in Louise Arbour and others The Prosecutor of a Permanent International Court" (2000)
  48. "inquisitorial or mixed" (2003)
  49. "A Comparative View of Standards of Proof", pp.50~ (2002)
  50. "of German Criminal Justice and its Unique Exclusionary Rules Based on the Right of Personality" (2001)
  51. "Toward a Theory of Effective Supranational Adjudication" (1997), Helfer and Anne-Marie Slaughter
  52. "Assessment of the United States Position The Case Against the International Criminal Court" (2002)
  53. "and the Crisis of Criminal Procedure" (1997)
  54. "'The Prosecutors of the International Tribunals the Cases of the Nuremberg and Tokyo Tribunals and the ICC Compared' in Louise Arbour and others The Prosecutor of a Permanent International Court" (2000)
  55. "Negotiating the Treaty of Rome on the Establishment of an International Criminal Court" (1999)
  56. "Prosecutorial Discretion within the International Criminal Court" (2004)
  57. "The Diminution of Live Testimony at the ICTY" (2003)
  58. "The Marriage of Common and Continental law at the ICTY and its Progeny" (2004)
  59. "Politics and Human Rights in International Criminal Law Our Case Against NATO and the Lessons to Be Learned from It" (2001)
  60. "A Critique of the Yugoslavia War Crimes Tribunal 25 Denver J of Intl L and Policy" (1997)
  61. "Rights of Suspects and Accused in Gabrielle Kirk McDonald and Olivia Swaak-Goldmann Substantive and Procedural Aspects of International Criminal Law", 1 (2000)
  62. "From the International Criminal Tribunal For the Former Yugoslavia to the International Criminal Court 26 North Carolina J of Intl Law and Commercial Regulation" (2001)
  63. ka, "Evidentiary Barriers to Conviction and Two Models of Criminal Procedure 121 University of Pennsylvania L Rev" (1973)
  64. ka, "The Uncertain Fate of Evidentiary Transplants", pp.45~ (1997)
  65. "Use of Unnamed Witnesses Against Accused", pp.90~ (1996)
  66. Nancy Armoury Combs, "Copping a Plea to Genocide The Plea Bargaining of International Crimes 151 University of Pennsylvania L Rev" (2002)
  67. "The ICTY Prosecutor and the Review of the NATO Bombing Campaign Against the Federal Republic of Yugoslavia", pp.12~ (2001)
  68. "The International Criminal Tribunal for the Former Yugoslavia Comes of Age Some Observations on Day-to-Day Dilemmas of an International Court Washington University J of L and Policy" (2001)
  69. Patricia M, "To Establish Incredible Events by Credible Evidence The Use of Affidavit Testimony in Yugoslavia War Crimes Tribunal Proceedings" (2001)
  70. "Ensuring Fair and Expeditious Trials at the International Criminal Tribunal for the Former Yugoslavia", pp.11~ (2000)
  71. "It's Broke so Let's Fix it Using a Quasi-Inquisitorial Approach to Limit the Impact of Bias in the American Criminal Justice System", pp.7~ (1996)
  72. e Lettow Lerner, "The Intersection of Two Systems An American on Trial for an American Murder in the French Cour D'assises 2001 University of Illinois L Rev" (2001)
  73. Richard May, "Trends in International Criminal Evidence" (1999)
  74. "Humanrightsism and the International Criminal Tribunal For The Former Yugoslavia" (1999)
  75. "'The German System' in Mireille Delmas-Marty and J" (2002)
  76. Sara Stapleton, "Ensuring a Fair Trial in the International Criminal Court Statutory Interpretation and the Impermissibility of Derogation 31 New York University J of Intl L and Politics" (1999)
  77. Scott T, "On the Road to Disaster The Rights of the Accused and the International Criminal Tribunal for the Former Yugoslavia", pp.10~ (1998)
  78. "Progress and Jurisprudence of the International Criminal Tribunal For the Former Yugoslavia", pp.93~ (1999)
  79. Sean Doran, "Rethinking Adversariness in Nonjury Criminal Trials 23 American J of Crim L" (1995)
  80. "The Rule of Procedure and Evidence of the International Criminal Court in Olympia Bekou and Robert Cryer" (2004)
  81. Silvia A, "The Role of the Prosecutor in Mauro Politi and Giuseppe The Rome Statute of the International Criminal Court" (2001)
  82. "The Role of the ICTY in the Development of International Criminal Adjudication", simo(vic) (1999)
  83. William Pizzi, "The New Italian Code of Criminal Procedure The Difficulties of Building an Adversarial Trial System on a Civil Law Foundation 17 Yale J of Intl L" (1992)
  84. William T, "Crime Victims in German Courtrooms A Comparative Perspective on American Problems" (1996)
  85. "Rome Statute of the International Criminal Court" (1998), United Nations Document A[DOI]
  86. "ICC-Rules of Procedure and Evidence ICC-ASP", 1, pp.2002[DOI]
  87. Prosecutor v Slobodan Milosevic, "Decision on Review of Indictment"
  88. "Decision in the Trial Chamber on Prosecution's Request to have written statements admitted under Rule 92bis"
  89. 23 May 2001, "Decision in the Trial Chamber on Prosecutor's Application to Admit Transcripts under Rule 92bis"
  90. Prosecutor v Kordic, "Decision in the Appeals Chamber regarding the Admission into Evidence of Seven Affidavits and One formal statement"
  91. "Decision in the Appeals Chamber Regarding Statement of a Deceased Witness"
  92. 15 July 1999, "Decision on Appeal by Dragan Papic Against Ruling to Proceed by Deposition"

관련 논문AI추천

이 간행물의 다른 논문 (11건)