Comparison of the Periodization Methodologies of the Korean Bronze Age and the Japanese Yayoi Period
0
조회
0
다운로드
0
인용
0
참고문헌
키워드
초록
In this article, I will examine the research history of subdivision/periodization of Korea’s Bronze Age and Japan’s Yayoi period and compare the methodologies of the two countries. The subdivisions of the Korean Bronze Age and the Japanese Yayoi period are similar in that they set changes in pottery as the basis, but show clear differences in their contents. The subdivision of the Korean Bronze Age set at first the changes in metalware and later the changes in pottery as the standard. However, after the concept of “types” was introduced, cultural epochs became the standard. Of course, periodization is initially done using material culture including pottery, followed by cultural interpretations of other archaeological aspects. However, it can be seen as a methodological limitation. The subdivision of the Japanese Yayoi period, however, used changes in pottery as the standard since the formation of Japanese archaeology. Whether good or bad, it is said to be the most important characteristic of Japanese archaeology. Of course, the idea is that classification is not simply based on changes in pottery form but includes changes in pottery types under the concept of “model,” but is limited in its actual application.
Abstract
In this article, I will examine the research history of subdivision/periodization of Korea’s Bronze Age and Japan’s Yayoi period and compare the methodologies of the two countries. The subdivisions of the Korean Bronze Age and the Japanese Yayoi period are similar in that they set changes in pottery as the basis, but show clear differences in their contents. The subdivision of the Korean Bronze Age set at first the changes in metalware and later the changes in pottery as the standard. However, after the concept of “types” was introduced, cultural epochs became the standard. Of course, periodization is initially done using material culture including pottery, followed by cultural interpretations of other archaeological aspects. However, it can be seen as a methodological limitation. The subdivision of the Japanese Yayoi period, however, used changes in pottery as the standard since the formation of Japanese archaeology. Whether good or bad, it is said to be the most important characteristic of Japanese archaeology. Of course, the idea is that classification is not simply based on changes in pottery form but includes changes in pottery types under the concept of “model,” but is limited in its actual application.
참고문헌 (54)
- An, Jaeho, "Hanguknongyeonsahoiui seongrip", Hanguk gogohakbo, 43, pp.41~66 (2000)
- 배진성, "檢丹里類型의 成立", 한국상고사학보, 48(48), pp.5~28 (2005), 한국상고사학회
- 천선행, "한반도 돌대문 토기의 형성과 전개", 한국고고학보, 57, pp.61~97 (2005), 한국고고학회
- Cheon, Seonhaeng, "Mumuntogisidaeui jogi seoljeonggwa siganjeok beomwi", Hanguk cheongdonggihakbo, 1, pp.4~27 (2008)
- Do, Yuho, "Jitapli yujeok balgul josa jungganbogo 2. Munhwa yusan, no. 6" (1957)
- Gogohak∙Minsokhak yeonguso, "Jitamni wonsi yujeok balgulnogo je 8 jip" (1961), Gwahakwon chulpansa
- Ha, Insu, "Yeongnamjibang dandomayeontogie daehan singochal", Thesis, pp.1989
- Hamada, Kousaku, "Yayoisikidokikeisikibunruisyuseizuroku. In Kyototeikokudaigaku bungakubu koukogakukenkyusitsu houkoku 6" (1919), Kyototeigokudaigaku..
- Hamada, Kousaku, "Tsuron Koukogaku" (1922), Daitoukaku
- Huziguchi, Kenzi, "Cyosenmumondoki to yayoidoki. In Yayoibunka no kenkyu 3. Yayoidoki", pp.147~162 (1986), Yuuzankaku
- Huzita, Ryousaku, "Cyosennosekizidai", Touyosikouza, 1, pp.43~139 (1942)
- Huzita, Saburo, "Yamatochiiki. In Yayoidoki no yousiki to hennen Kinkihen Ⅰ", pp.147~199 (1989), Mokujisya
- Izumi, Takura, "Yayoizidaiwaitsuhazimattaka. In Souten Nihonnorekisi ①", pp.44~72 (1991), Sinzinbutsuoraisya
- Jeon, Yeongrae, "Hangukcheongdonggimunhwaui gyebowa pyeonnyeon", Jeonbukyujeokjosabogo, 7, pp.4~88 (1977)
- Jeong, Handeok, "Hunamriyuhyeong hyeonseonggwajeong jaegeomtoe daehan torong", Hoseo gogohak, 1, pp.99~101 (1999)
- Kim, Gwonjung, "Yeongseojiyeok cheongdonggisidae jugeojiui pyeonnyeon mit seonggyok. In Gwangwonjiyeokui cheongdonggimunhwa", pp.111~144 (2005), Gangwongogohakhoi
- Kim, Hansik, "Gyeonggijiyeok yeoksamdong yuhyeongui jeonlib gwajeon. In Seoulgyeonggijiyeok cheongdonggimunhwaui yuhyeonggwa byoncheon", pp.7~37 (2006), Seoul Gyeonggi gogohakhoi
- 김장석, "무문토기시대 조기설정론 재고", 한국고고학보, 69(69), pp.94~115 (2008), 한국고고학회
- 김재윤, "韓半島 刻目突帶文土器의 編年과 系譜", 한국상고사학보, 46(46), pp.31~70 (2004), 한국상고사학회
- Kim, Jeonghak, "Seidoukizidai. In Kankokun no koukogaku", pp.68~105 (1972), Kawadesinsya
- Kim, Wonryong, "Hanguk munhwaui gogohakjeok yeongu", Hanguk munhwa sadaegye, 1, pp.1~30 (1964)
- Kim, Wonryong, "Hanguk gogohakgaeseol 1 pan" (1973), Iljisa
- Kim, Wonryong, "Hanguk gogohakgaeseol 3 pan" (1986), Iljisa
- Kobayasi, Tatsuo, "Jomondoki no yousiki to keisiki to katasiki. In Jomondokidaikan 4", pp.248~257 (1989), Shogakukan
- Kobayasi, Yukio, "Yamato karako yayoi iseki no kenkyu Kyototeikokudaigaku bungakubu koukogaku kenkyusitsu houkoku 16" (1943), Rinsensyoten
- Kobayasi, Yukio, "Keisiki∙Keiskigakuteki kenkyuhou. In Zukai Koukogakuziten", pp.296~297 (1959), Sougansinsya
- Kobayasi, Yukio, "Ronsyu Nihonbunkanokigen Koukogaku" (1971), Heibonsya
- Kobayasi, Yukio, "Yayoisikidoki syusei zuroku" (1939), Tokyokoukogakukai
- Kosugi, Yasushi, "Dokikeisiki to dokikatasiki", Sundaisigaku, 94, pp.58~130 (1995)
- Lee, Baekgyu, "Gyeonggido mumuntogi", majeseokgi. Gogohak, 3, pp.53~129 (1974)
- Lee, Cheonggyu, "Namhangibang mumuntogi munhwa jeongaewa gongryeoltogi munhwaui wichi", Hanguk sangosahakbo, 1, pp.37~92 (1988)
- Lee,Hongjong, "Cheongdonggisahoiui togiwa jugeo" (1996), Seogyeongchulpansa
- Lee, Seongju, "Sinseokigisidae. In Hangukseonsagogohaksa", pp.77~168 (1992), Kachi
- Lim, Byeontae, "Hangangyuyeok mumuntogiui yeongdae. In Ihongjikbaksahoigabginyeom hanguksaninchong, ed. Ihongjikbaksahoigabginyeom nonmunjibganhaengeuiwonhoi", pp.88~109 (1969), Singumunhwasa
- Lim, Byeontae, "Hanguk cheongdonggisidai yeongueui oneulgwa naiil", Seonsamunhwa, 1, pp.18~29 (1992)
- Maida, Souziro, "Yaoisiki doki (Kaitsukadoki ni nitte usude no mono) hatken ni tsukete", Tokyozinruigakuzatsi, 11(122) (1896)
- Morimoto, Rokuzi, "Yayoisikidokizusyu" (1933), Tokyokoukogakukai
- Morimoto, Rokuzi, "Yayoisikidoki ni okeru nisya-Yousiki youso tanni kettei no mondai", Koukogaku, 5(1) (1935)
- Morioka, Hideto, "Gyoseki to sono ronten. In Yayoidoki no yousiki to hennen Kinkihen Ⅰ", pp.3~26 (1989), Mokujisya
- Nakayama, Heiziro, "Kyusyuhokubu ni okeru sensi gensi ryouziki cyukan kikan no ibutsu ni tsuite", Koukogakuzatsi, 7(10) (1917)
- Park, Jinil, "Jeomtodaetogi, gurigo cheongdonggisidaewa chogicheolgisidae", Hanguk cheongdonggihakbo, 1, pp.84~114 (2008)
- Sahara, Makoto, "Yayoisiki doki seisaku ni kansuru nisan no kousatsu", Watasitachinokoukogaku, 20, pp.2~11 (1959)
- Sahara, Makoto, "Nougyonokaisitokaikyusyakainokeisei. In Iwanamikouza Nihonsi 1", pp.113~182 (1975), Iwanamikouza
- Sugihara, Sousuke, "Nougyo no hatsei to bunka no hengaku. In Sekai koukogaku daikei 2", pp.136~153 (1960), Heibionsya
- Suzuki, Tokuo, "Keisikigakutekihouho ③. In Zyoumonzidainokoukogaku rekisonomonosasi", pp.72~85 (2008), Douseisya
- Terasawa, Kaoru, "Kakutiikinoheikoukankei∙Kaisetsu. In Yayoidoki no yousiki to hennen Kinkihen Ⅰ", pp.322~327 (1989), Mokuhisya
- Tsuboi, Syogoro, "Teikokudaigaku no rinchi ni kaijuka no konseki ari", Tokyogakugeizatsi, 6(91) (1889)
- Tsude, Hiroshi, "Kohunsyutsugenkizenyano syudankankei: Yodogawa suikeio cyusinni", Koukogakukenkyu, 20(4) (1974)
- Yawata, Ichiro, "Minamisakugunnokoukogakutekikenkyu" (1928), Okasyoin
- Yi, Kisung, "Ikoukiniokerukannichihikaku", Cyosenkodaikenkyu, 7, pp.1~19 (2006)
- 이기성, "일본 죠몽ㆍ야요이 전환기의 석기 변화 - 킨키지방(近畿地方)을 중심으로 -", 한국상고사학보, 59(59), pp.21~49 (2008), 한국상고사학회
- 이기성, "일본 죠몽 야요이 전환기 연구 방법론의 검토: 문화요소의 확산과 수용 방식을 중심으로", 고고학, 7(1), pp.37~49 (2008), 중부고고학회
- Yi, Kisung, "Seoulgyeonggijiyeok mumuntogisidae jeon∙junggiui seokigi yangsang. In Seoul Gyeonggi mumuntogimunhwaui heureum", pp.107~125 (2008), Seoul Gyeonggigo gohakhoi
- Yun, Mubyeong, "Hanguk cheongdongyumului yeonggu", Baeksanhakbo, 12, pp.59~134 (1972)