Mapping Legal Transfer
0
조회
0
다운로드
0
인용
0
참고문헌
키워드
초록
The topic of the present article is legal transfer. The term shall be understood broadly here as covering every incidence in which the existence of a legal norm in one legal system has contributed to the emergence of a similar norm in another system. The main claim of this article is that more scholarly attention is warranted in order to properly understand this phenomenon and to guide the related practice. The present text is programmatic in that it substantiates this claim in but a summary fashion (section I), and in that it focusses, instead, on mapping out both, the concept itself (section II) as well as potential directions for future research (section III). It draws on academic discourses that are – just like the author’s own work – mostly “Western” in their frames of reference. Its publication here is meant to be a step towards overcoming this confinement.
Abstract
The topic of the present article is legal transfer. The term shall be understood broadly here as covering every incidence in which the existence of a legal norm in one legal system has contributed to the emergence of a similar norm in another system. The main claim of this article is that more scholarly attention is warranted in order to properly understand this phenomenon and to guide the related practice. The present text is programmatic in that it substantiates this claim in but a summary fashion (section I), and in that it focusses, instead, on mapping out both, the concept itself (section II) as well as potential directions for future research (section III). It draws on academic discourses that are – just like the author’s own work – mostly “Western” in their frames of reference. Its publication here is meant to be a step towards overcoming this confinement.
참고문헌 (47)
- Christoph Althammer, "Ausländische Rechtsimplantate im nationalen Zivilprozessrecht" (2020)
- Cornish, William, "The Oxford History of the Laws of England: Volume XI: 1820–1914 English Legal System" (2010)
- Duve, Thomas, "Entanglements in Legal History: Conceptual Approaches", pp.29~ (2014)
- Graser, Alexander, "Festschrift für Otto Kaufman", pp.897~923 (2021)
- Graziadei, Michele, "The Oxford Handbook of Comparative Law", pp.444~ (2007)
- Osmany Porto de Oliveira, "Handbook of Policy Transfer, Diffusion and Circulation" (2021), Edward Elgar Publishing Limited
- Hendry, Jennifer, "Order from Transfer: Comparative Constitutional Design & Legal Culture", pp.153~ (2013), Edward Elgar
- Koschaker, Paul, "Europa und das römische Recht" (1947)
- Kurzynsky-Singer, Eugenia, "Transformation durch Rezeption? Möglichkeiten und Grenzen des Rechtsstransfers am Beispiel der Zivilrechtsreformen im Kaukasus und in Zentralasien", pp.3~ (2014), 2014
- Peter H. Solomon, "Legal Change in Post-Communist States" (2019), Columbia University Press
- Offe, Claus, "The Theory of Institutional Design", pp.199~ (1996)
- Pound, Roscoe, "The Formative Era of American Law" (1938), Little Brown
- Tom Baker, "Public Policy Circulation: Arenas, Agents and Actions" (2019), Edward Elgar Publishing Limited
- Risse, Thomas, "The Oxford Handbook of Comparative Regionalism" (2016), Oxford University Press
- Said, Edward, "The World, the Text, and the Critic" (1983), Harvard University Press
- Tania Groppi, "The Use of Foreign Precedents by Constitutional Judges" (2013), Bloomsbury Publishing
- Tischbirek, Alexander, "Die Verhältnismäßigkeitsprüfung, Methodenmigration zwischen öffentlichem Recht und Privatrecht" (2017)
- Watson, Alan, "Legal Transplants: An Approach to Comparative Law" (1974), University of Georgia Press
- Winter, Gerd, "Verwaltungsarchiv", pp.408~ (2010)
- Amstutz, Marc, "Rechtsmutation: Zu Genese und Evolution des Rechts im transnationalen Raum", Rechtsgeschichte, 8, pp.13~ (2006)
- Arai, Makoto, "Alternde Gesellschaft und System der sozialen Sicherheit in Japan", Zeitschrift für Japanisches Recht, 10, pp.15~ (2000)
- Beckert, Jens, "Institutional Isomorphism Revisited: Convergence and Divergence in Institutional Change", Soc. Theory, 28(2), pp.150~ (2010)
- Berkowitz, Daniel, "The Transplant Effect", Am. J. Comp. L, 51, pp.163~ (2003)
- Deakin, Simon, "Evolution for Our Time: A Theory of Legal Memetics", Current Legal Problems, 55, pp.1~ (2002)[DOI]
- DiMaggio, Paul J, "The Iron Cage Revisited: Institutional Isomorphism and Collective Rationality in Organizational Fields", Am. Soc. R, 48, pp.147~ (1983)
- Foljanty, Lena, "Legal Transfers as Processes of Cultural Translation: On the Consequences of a Metaphor", Kritische Vierteljahresschrift für Gesetzgebung und Rechtswissenschaft, 89 (2015), Max Planck Institute
- Frankenberg, Günter, "Constitutional transfer: The IKEA theory revisited", Int’l J. Const. L, 8, pp.563~ (2010)
- Gonod, Pascale, "Über den Rechtsexport des deutschen Verwaltungsrechts aus französischer Sicht", Die Verwaltung, 48, pp.337~ (2015)
- Graser, Alexander, "Rechtstransfer: Über eine praxisgeleitete Theorie hin zu einer theoriegeleiteten Praxis?", Zeitschrift für ausländisches und internationales Arbeits- und Sozialrecht, 36, pp.78~82 (2022)
- on scholae sed vitae discimus”, "Am. J. Comp. L", 2009, 863~
- Häberle, Peter, "Grundrechtsgeltung und Grundrechtsinterpretation im Verfassungsstaat - Zugleich zur Rechtsvergleichung als “fünfter” Auslegungsmethode", JuristenZeitung, pp.913~ (1989)
- Kahn-Freund, Otto, "On Uses and Misuses of Comparative Law", The Modern L. R, 37, pp.1~ (1974)
- Kim, Yoo Hwan, "The Formation and Development of the Korean Administrative Procedure Act: From the Perspective of Legal Transfer", KLRI J. L. & Legis, 14(2), pp.35~ (2024)
- Knieper, Rolf, "Möglichkeiten und Grenzen der Verpflanzbarkeit von Recht", RabelsZ, 72, pp.88~ (2008)
- La Porta, Rafael, "Law and Finance", J. Pol. Econ, 106, pp.1113~ (1998)
- Legrand, Pierre, "The Impossibility of ‘Legal Transplants’", Maastricht J. Eur. & Comp. L, 4, pp.111~ (1997)
- Linos, Katerina, "Diffusion through Democracy", Am. J. Pol. Sci, 55, pp.678~ (2011)
- "Limits of Legal Evolution: Knowledge and Normativity in Theories of Legal Change" (2019)[URL]
- Michaels, Ralf, "Comparative Law by Numbers?", Am. J. Comp. L, 57, pp.765~ (2009)
- Nußberger, Angelika, "Constitutional Law Transfer from West to East: Illusion, Disillusion", Osteuropa, 60, pp.81~ (2010)
- Pistor, Katharina, "The Evolving Legal Framework in the Former Socialist Countries", Columbia International Affairs Online (CIAO) Case Studies (2002)
- Rehm, Gebhard, "Rechtstransplantate als Instrument der Rechtsreform und transformation", RabelsZ, 72, pp.1~ (2008)
- Sacco, Rodolfo, "Legal Formants : A Dynamic Approach to Comparative Law", Am. J. Comp. L, 39, pp.1~ (1991)
- Secord, James, "Knowledge in Transit", Isis, 95, pp.654~ (2004)
- Strang, David, "Adding Social Structure to Diffusion Models : An Event History Framework", Soc. Methods & Res, 19, pp.324~ (1991)
- Teubner, Gunther, "Legal Irritants: Good Faith in British Law or How Unifying Law Ends up in New Divergences", The Modern L. Rev, 61, pp.11~ (1998)
- Watson, Alan, "Comparative Law and Legal Change", The Cambridge L. J, 37, pp.313~ (1978)