본문 바로가기
KERD
논문KCI 등재

A Review on the Effectiveness of Rehabilitation : For Evidence-Based Practices of the Korean Rehabilitation System

정진성|Park, Jongha
아시아교정포럼 (Asian Forum for Corrections)|2015.08|교정담론 (Korean Journal of Correctional Discourse)|제9권 제2호|pp. 281-316

0

조회

0

다운로드

0

인용

0

참고문헌

키워드

rehabilitation사회학습이론social learning theory증거기반recidivism(reincarceration)evidence- basedindividualized approach.교정교화사업재범(재복역)개별화 접근

초록

This study made a comprehensive review of empirical research on the effectiveness of offender rehabilitation to contribute to the successful settlement of Korean rehabilitation policy. The review of conceptualization, underlying theory, and past studies of rehabilitation revealed sufficient evidence to claim that rehabilitation is the most effective intervention strategy, as opposed to its punitive counterparts. Some models of rehabilitative intervention such as Multisystemic Therapy (MST) and Faith- Based Programs have been proved to be particularly successful in reducing recidivism. The key element of the success appeared to be an individualized approach that considers each offender’s unique pathways to criminal behavior and improves his/her life both internally and environmentally. As the social learning theory posits, it is crucial that offenders change their cognitive processes in a positive direction, which is what must be secured by any rehabilitation program to be successful. To this end, scholars and practitioners need to have a strong professional knowledge and responsibility to keep administering long-term individualized tactics, which proved not only effective but even more efficient than short-term temporary expedient, particularly prevalent in Korea. This way the evidence-based practice of rehabilitation is to be settled in Korea in spite of public fear against softness on crime.

Abstract

This study made a comprehensive review of empirical research on the effectiveness of offender rehabilitation to contribute to the successful settlement of Korean rehabilitation policy. The review of conceptualization, underlying theory, and past studies of rehabilitation revealed sufficient evidence to claim that rehabilitation is the most effective intervention strategy, as opposed to its punitive counterparts. Some models of rehabilitative intervention such as Multisystemic Therapy (MST) and Faith- Based Programs have been proved to be particularly successful in reducing recidivism. The key element of the success appeared to be an individualized approach that considers each offender’s unique pathways to criminal behavior and improves his/her life both internally and environmentally. As the social learning theory posits, it is crucial that offenders change their cognitive processes in a positive direction, which is what must be secured by any rehabilitation program to be successful. To this end, scholars and practitioners need to have a strong professional knowledge and responsibility to keep administering long-term individualized tactics, which proved not only effective but even more efficient than short-term temporary expedient, particularly prevalent in Korea. This way the evidence-based practice of rehabilitation is to be settled in Korea in spite of public fear against softness on crime.

참고문헌 (93)

  1. Akers, R. L., "Social Learning and Social Structure: A General Theory of Crime and Deviance" (1998), Northeastern University Press
  2. Allen, F. A., "The Borderland of Criminal Justice: Essays in Law and Criminology" (1964), University of Chicago Press
  3. American Correctional Association, "The Female Offender: What Does the Future Hold?", ~ (1990)
  4. Andrews, D. A., "The Psychology of Criminal Conduct" (1998), Anderson
  5. Andrews, D. A., "Rehabilitating Criminal Justice Policy and Practice", Psychology, Public Policy, and Law, 16(1), pp.39~55 (2010)
  6. Andrews, D. A., "Classification for Effective Rehabilitation : Rediscovering Psychology", Criminal Justice and Behavior, 17(1), pp.19~52 (1990)
  7. Andrews, D. A., "Does Correctional Treatment Work? A Clinically Relevant and Psychologically Informed Meta-Analysis", Criminology, 28(3), pp.369~404 (1990)
  8. Evidence-Based Adult Corrections Programs: What Works and What Does Not, "Aos, S.", Washington State Institute for Public Policy, ~ (2006)
  9. 배임호, "출소자 재범방지를 위한 갱생보호사업*의 실태와 발전방향", 교정연구, 60, pp.113~134 (2013), 한국교정학회
  10. Bandura, A., "Self-Efficacy : Toward a Unifying Theory of Behavioral Change", Psychological Review, 84(2), pp.191~215 (1977)
  11. Bentham, J, "An Introduction to the Principles of Morals and Legislation, originally published in 1789" (1948), Hafner Press
  12. Borduin, C. M., "Multisystemic Treatment of Serious Juvenile Offenders : Long-Tem Prevention of Criminality and Violence", Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology, 63(4), pp.569~578 (1995)
  13. Bottcher, J., "Examining the Effectiveness of Boot Camps : A Randomized Experiment with a Long-Term Follow Up", Journal of Research in Crime and Delinquency, 42(3), pp.309~332 (2005)
  14. Bowers Jr., M. B., "Psychotogenic Drug Use and Neuroleptic Response", Schizophrenia Bulletin, 16(1), pp.81~85 (1990)
  15. Burgess, R. L., "A Differential Association Reinforcement Theory of Criminal Behavior", Social Problems, 14, pp.128~147 (1966)
  16. Burkhead, M. D., "The Treatment of Criminal Offenders: A History" (2007), Jefferson
  17. Chamberlain, P., "The Oregon Multidimensional Treatment Foster Care Model : Features, Outcomes, and Progress in Dissemination", Cognitive and Behavioral Practice, 10(4), pp.303~312 (2003)
  18. 조윤오, "생존분석을 활용한 교정프로그램 효과성 분석", 교정연구, 57, pp.7~30 (2012), 한국교정학회
  19. 조윤오, "범죄자 교정프로그램의 효과성 분석- 재복역율을 중심으로-", 한국경찰학회보, 14(4), pp.187~216 (2012), 한국경찰학회[DOI]
  20. 최응렬, "한국 갱생보호사업의 적용현황 및 개선방안", 교정연구, 61, pp.7~35 (2013), 한국교정학회
  21. Cohen, M. A., "The Monetary Value of Saving a High-Risk Youth", Journal of Quantitative Criminology, 14(1), pp.5~33 (1998)
  22. Crow, I. D., "The Treatment and Rehabilitation of Offenders" (2001), Sage
  23. Cullen, F. T., "Crime: Public Policies for Crime Control", pp.253~298 (2002), ICS Press
  24. Cullen, F. T., "Rehabilitation : Beyond Nothing Works", Crime and Justice, 42(1), pp.299~376 (2013)
  25. Cullen, F. T., "Assessing Correctional Rehabilitation : Policy, Practice, and Prospects", Criminal Justice, 3, pp.109~175 (2000)
  26. Cullen, F. T., "From Nothing Works to What Works : Changing Professional Ideology in the 21st Century", The Prison Journal, 81(3), pp.313~338 (2001)
  27. Cullen, F. T., "Reaffirming Rehabilitation" (1982), Anderson
  28. Curtis, N. M., "Multisystemic Treatment: A Meta-Analysis of Outcome Studies", Journal of Family Psychology, 18, pp.411~419
  29. Dishion, T. J., "Intervening on Adolescent Problem Behavior: A family Centered Approach" (2003), The Guilford Press
  30. Dishion, T. J., "The Interaction of Theory and Practice: Experimental Studies of Interventions", pp.253~282 (1992), Guilford
  31. Dowden, C., "What Works for Female Offenders : A Meta-Analytic Review", Crime and Delinquency, 45(4), pp.438~452 (1999)
  32. Eddy, J. M., "An Elementary School-Based Prevention Program Targeting Modifiable Antecedents of Youth Delinquency and Violence Linking the Interests of Families and Teachers(LIFT)", Journal of Emotional and Behavioral Disorders, 8(3), pp.165~176 (2000)
  33. Emery, R. E., "An Applied Analysis of Delinquency : The Irrelevancy of Relevant Behavior", American Psychologist, 32(10), pp.860~873 (1977)
  34. Farabee, D., "Rethinking Rehabilitation: Why Can’t We Reform Our Criminals?" (2005), AEI Press
  35. Forgatch, M. S., "Parenting through Change: A Programmed Intervention Curriculum for Groups of Single Mothers" (1994), Oregon Social Learning Center
  36. Forgatch, M. S., "MAPS: Marriage and Parenting in Stepfamilies (Parent Training Manual)" (1997), Oregon Social Learning Center
  37. Garland, D., ", Punishment and Welfare : A History of Penal Strategies" (1985), Gower
  38. Garrett, C. J., "Effects of Residential Treatment on Adjudicated Delinquents: A Meta-Analysis", Journal of Research in Crime and Delinquency, 22(4), pp.287~308 (1985)
  39. Gendreau, P., "The Choosing Correctional Options that Work: Defining the Demand and Evaluating the Supply", pp.117~130 (1996), Sage
  40. Gendreau, P., "Effective Correctional Treatment: Bibliography for Cynics", Crime and Delinquency, 25(4), pp.463~489 (1979)
  41. Gibbons, D. C., "Review Essay : Changing Lawbreakers – What Have We Learned Since the 1950s?", Crime and Delinquency, 45(2), pp.272~293 (1999)
  42. Griffin, K. W., "Effectiveness of a Universal Drug Abuse Prevention Approach for Youth at High Risk for Substance Use Initiation", Preventive Medicine, 36, pp.1~7 (2003)
  43. Henggeler, S. W., "Multisystemic Therapy with Violent and Chronic Juvenile Offenders and Their Families : The Role of Treatment Fidelity in Successful Dissemination", Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology, 65(5), pp.821~833 (1997)
  44. Henggeler, S. W., "Family Preservation Using Multisystemic Therapy : An Effective Alternative to Incarcerating Serious Juvenile Offenders", Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology, 60(6), pp.953~961 (1992)
  45. Hepburn, J. R., "Recidivism among Drug Offenders: A Survival Analysis of the Effects of Offender Characteristics, Type of Offense, and Two Types of Intervention", Journal of Quantitative Criminology, 10(2), pp.159~179 (1994)
  46. Hollin, C. R., "Psychology and Crime: An Introduction to Criminological Psychology" (2013), Routledge
  47. Irwin, J., "Prisons in Turmoil" (1971), Little Brown
  48. The Inner Change Freedom Initiative: A Preliminary Evaluation of a Faith-Based Prison Program, "Johnson, B. R.", Center for Research on Religion and Urban Civil Society, ~ (2003)
  49. Keith, S. J., "Psychiatric Disorders in America: The Epidemiologic Catchment Area Study", pp.33~52 (1991), Free Press
  50. Kirigin, K. A., "The Teaching-Family Model: A Replicable System of Care", Residential Treatment for Children and Youth, 18(3), pp.99~110 (2001)
  51. Landenberger, N. A., "The Positive Effects of Cognitive-Behavioral Programs for Offenders: A Meta-Analysis of Factors Associated with Effective Treatment", Journal of Experimental Criminology, 1(4), pp.451~476 (2005)
  52. Larzelere, R. E., "Outcome Evaluation of Girls and Boys Town’s Family Home Program", Education and Treatment of Children, 27(2), pp.130~149 (2004)
  53. Latessa, E. J., "Examining Program Integrity: Measuring Program Quality over Time - Examples from Three RSAT Programs", Offender Substance Abuse Report, 2(5), pp.65~66 (2002)
  54. Lipsey, M. W., "Can Intervention Rehabilitate Serious Delinquents?", The Annals of the American Academy of Political and Social Science, 564(1), pp.142~166 (1999)
  55. Lipsey, M. W., "The Effectiveness of Correctional Rehabilitation : A Review of Systematic Reviews", Annual Review of Law and Social Science, 3, pp.297~320 (2007)
  56. Lipsey, M. W., "The Efficacy of Psychological, Educational, and Behavioral Treatment : Confirmation from Meta-Analysis", American Psychologist, 48(12), pp.1181~1209 (1993)
  57. Lipsey, M. W., "Serious and Violent Juvenile Offenders: Risk Factors and Successful Interventions", pp.313~345 (1998), Sage
  58. Lipton, D., "The Effectiveness of Correctional Treatment: A Survey of Treatment Evaluation Studies" (1975), Praeger
  59. Multisystemic Therapy for Social, Emotional and Behavioral Problems in Youth Aged 10-17, "Littell, J.", Nordic Campbell Center, ~ (2005)
  60. Losel, F., "What Works: Reducing Reoffending, Guidelines from Research to Practice", pp.79~111 (1995), Wiley
  61. MacKenzie, D. L., "An Experimental Study of a Therapeutic Boot Camp : Impact on Impulses, Attitudes and Recidivism", Journal of Experimental Criminology, 3(3), pp.221~246 (2007)
  62. MacKenzie, D. L., "Boot Camp Prisons and Recidivism in Eight States", Criminology, 33(3), pp.327~358 (1995)
  63. What Works in Corrections? An Examination of the Effectiveness of the Type of Rehabilitation Programs Offered by Washington State Department of Corrections, "MacKenzie, D. L.", University of Maryland, ~ (1998)
  64. Maltz, M. D., "Recidivism" (2001), Academic Press
  65. Martinson, R., "What Works? Questions and Answers about Prison Reform", The Public Interest, 35, pp.22~54 (1974)
  66. Martinson, R., "New Findings, New Views : A Note of Caution Regarding Sentencing Reform", Hofstra Law Review, 7, pp.243~258 (1979)
  67. Meade, B., "The Total Effects of Boot Camps that House Juveniles : A Systematic Review of the Evidence", Journal of Criminal Justice, 38(5), pp.841~853 (2010)
  68. Mendel, R. A., "Less Cost, More Safety: Guiding Lights for Reform in Juvenile Justice" (2001), American Youth Policy Forum
  69. 남선모, "국내외 갱생보호제에 관한 비교고찰", 교정연구, 61, pp.37~70 (2013), 한국교정학회
  70. Ogren, R. W., "Ineffectiveness of the Criminal Sanction in Fraud and Corruption Cases : Losing the Battle against White-Collar Crime", American Criminal Law Review, 11, pp.959~988 (1972)
  71. 박병식, "한국갱생보호사업의 현안과 해결방안", 교정담론, 5(1), pp.195~216 (2011), 아시아교정포럼
  72. Patterson, G. R., ": Applications of Social Learning to Family Life" (1975), Research Press
  73. Pearson, F. S., "A Meta-Analytic Review of the Effectiveness of Corrections-Based Treatments for Drug Use", The Prison Journal, 79(4), pp.384~410 (1999)
  74. Peters, R. H., "Screening and Assessment of Co-occurring Disorders in the Justice System" (1997), CMHS National GAINS Center
  75. Peters, R. H., "Psychopathology and Mental Health Needs among Drug-Involved Inmates", Journal of Prison and Jail Health, 11(1), pp.3~25 (1992)
  76. “Scared Straight” and Other Juvenile Awareness Programs for Preventing Juvenile Delinquency, "Petrosino, A.", The Cochrane Library, ~ (2003)
  77. Research Findings on Adult Corrections Programs: A Review, Olympia, "Phipps, R.", Washington State Institute for Public Policy, ~ (1999)
  78. Redondo, S., "The Influence of Treatment Programs on the Recidivism of Juvenile and Adult Offenders: An European Meta-Analytic Review", Psychology, Crime and Law, 5(3), pp.251~278 (1999)
  79. Antisocial Behavior in Children and Adolescents: A Developmental Analysis and Model for Intervention, "Reid, J. B.", American Psychological Association, ~ (2002)
  80. Rothman, D., "The Discovery of the Asylum: Social Order and Disorder in the New Republic" (1971), Little Brown
  81. Sechrest, L., "The Rehabilitation of Criminal Offenders: Problems and Prospects" (1979), National Academy of Sciences
  82. Education Reduces Crime: Three-State Recidivism Study. Executive Summ, "Steurer, S. J.", Correctional Education Association, ~ (2003)
  83. "Three-State Recidivism Study. Executive Summary", Correctional Education Association, ~ (2003)
  84. Visher, C. A., "Ex-Offender Employment Programs and Recidivism : A Meta-analysis", Journal of Experimental Criminology, 1(3), pp.295~315 (2005)
  85. Von Hirsch, A., "Doing Justice: The Choice of Punishments" (1976), Northeastern University Press
  86. Weissman, M. M., "Psychiatric Disorders in America: The Epidemiologic Catchment Area Study", pp.53~80 (1991), Free Press
  87. Wellisch, J., "Treatment Strategies for Drug-Abusing Women Offenders", Drug Treatment and Criminal Justice, 27, pp.5~29 (1993)
  88. Drug- Abusing Women Offenders: Results of a National Survey, "Wellisch, J.", US Department of Justice, National Institute of Justice, ~ (1994)
  89. Whitehead, J. T., "A Meta-Analysis of Juvenile Correctional Treatment", Journal of Research in Crime and Delinquency, 26, pp.276~297 (1989)
  90. Wilson, D. B., "A Quantitative Review of Structured, Group Oriented, Cognitive-behavioral Programs for Offenders", Criminal Justice and Behavior, 32(2), pp.172~204 (2005)
  91. Wilson, D. B., "A Meta-Analysis of Corrections-Based Education, Vocation, and Work Programs for Adult Offenders", Journal of Research in Crime and Delinquency, 37(4), pp.347~368 (2000)
  92. Wilson, D. B., "The Role of Method in Treatment Effectiveness Research: Evidence from Meta-Analysis", Psychological Methods, 6(4), pp.413~429 (2001)
  93. Wilson, S. J., "Are Mainstream Programs for Juvenile Delinquency Less Effective with Minority Youth than Majority Youth? A Meta-Analysis of Outcomes Research", Research on Social Work Practice, 13(1), pp.3~26 (2003)

관련 논문AI추천

효율적인 갱생보호사업의 방향-출소자의 재범방지를 중심으로-정진연한국교정학회 · 교정연구2004 · 제23권 소년수형자 정규교육의 교정･교화 및 재범 예방 효과에 관한 연구: 문헌 고찰 및 국내외 사례분석을 중심으로이장한, 정여경한국교정학회 · 교정연구2025 · 제35권 제3호한국 갱생보호사업의 적용현황 및 개선방안최응렬한국교정학회 · 교정연구2013 · 제61권 Neighborhood Contexts and Recidivism: Current Status and Future Directions김병배, 이백철아시아교정포럼 · 교정담론2019 · 제13권 제2호출소자의 재범방지를 위한 지역사회중심의 갱생보호사업에 관한 연구이신영한국교정학회 · 교정연구2008 · 제38권 회복사법 프로그램의 재범방지 효과성에 대한 비판적 소고김병배아시아교정포럼 · 교정담론2020 · 제14권 제3호

이 간행물의 다른 논문 (9건)

법가의 사회질서론에 관한 분석이송호pp. 1-30소년원에서의 회복적 대화모임실천 이야기한영선pp. 31-52징벌 수용자 교화를 위한 인성개발의 방향성에 관한 고찰정종기, 최락인pp. 53-78범죄기회와 위험요인이 소년 교도소 수형자의 범죄에 미치는 영향:범죄 유형별 분석박선영pp. 79-108화이트칼라 범죄에 대한 외국의 연구동향 - 통제(control)적 이론을 중심으로 -성빈pp. 109-144
원문 보기