긴박한 테러행위와 형사법 - 독일에서의 논쟁에 비추어 본 형사법의 “형사정책적 관점”에서의 해석 -
Impending Terrorist Acts and Criminal Law - Interpretation of Criminal Law from the Standpoint of Criminal Policy among the Heated Debates in Germany -
0
조회
0
다운로드
9
인용
0
참고문헌
키워드
초록
Since 9.11 international terrorism has been discussed in the demension of justification and excuse in criminal law. In the meantime, the theory of justification and excuse as a theory applicable against this exceptional cases has not been developed in Korea. In this viewpoint, the legal responses against the attacks against the hijacked aircraft and torture to save a life (Daschner Case in Germany) could be very interesting debates with regard to the theory of justification and excuse in criminal law. In this paper especially the possibility of the scheme of the so-called "defensive emergency (Defensivnotstand)" will be examined. The heated debates in Germany regarding Defensivnotstand will be introduced and their meaning in the future discussion in Korea will be analyzed.
Abstract
Since 9.11 international terrorism has been discussed in the demension of justification and excuse in criminal law. In the meantime, the theory of justification and excuse as a theory applicable against this exceptional cases has not been developed in Korea. In this viewpoint, the legal responses against the attacks against the hijacked aircraft and torture to save a life (Daschner Case in Germany) could be very interesting debates with regard to the theory of justification and excuse in criminal law. In this paper especially the possibility of the scheme of the so-called "defensive emergency (Defensivnotstand)" will be examined. The heated debates in Germany regarding Defensivnotstand will be introduced and their meaning in the future discussion in Korea will be analyzed.
참고문헌 (60)
- 고봉진, "현대형범에서 규범타당성과 개인귀속 - 위험, 위험인수, 의무 -", 법과정책, 17(1), pp.27~43 (2011), 법과정책연구소
- 김일수, "Punitivistische Grundtendenzen der gegenwärtigen Kriminalpolitik?", 고려법학, (56), pp.513~548 (2010), 법학연구원
- 김재윤, "위험사회라는 사회 변화에 대한 형사법의 대응", 비교형사법연구, 12(2), pp.251~276 (2010), 한국비교형사법학회
- 김호기, "전통적 책임주의에 대한 현대적 도전 - 특정 성범죄자에 대한 위치추적 전자장치 부착제도 도입이 가지는 의미 -", 형사법연구, 21(1), pp.199~222 (2009), 한국형사법학회
- 류인모, "현대과학기술의 발전과 위험사회의 형법", 비교형사법연구, 4(2), pp.1~22 (2002), 한국비교형사법학회
- 류전철, "위험원의 제거와 형법의 과제", 아주법학, 4(2), pp.197~222 (2010), 법학연구소[DOI]
- 박강우, "허용된 위험의 법리와 과실범의 구조변화", 법학연구, 19(2), pp.41~ (2008)
- 윤용규, "사회변동과 형법의 과제", 비교형사법연구, 12(2), pp.217~230 (2010), 한국비교형사법학회
- 이덕인, "형법의 기능변화와 형법의 한계: 현대사회에서의 형사정책적 요구에 형법은 어떻게 변화하고 있는가?", 2012년 하계 연합학술회의 유인물‘형법의 팽창과 형법의 과제’수록
- 이재석, "형법의 重罰化 입법경향에 관한 비판적 고찰", 법학연구, (44), pp.199~224 (2011), 한국법학회
- 이재일, "범죄인의 Magna Charta로서의 형법이념의 포기: (반시민적) 적형법", 한독법학, (17), pp.206~ (2012)
- 이재일, "형법을 통한 ‘더 많은 안전’의 기능과 한계", 외법논집, 35(1), pp.181~205 (2011), 법학연구소
- 조성용, "형사입법의 상징적 기능에 대한 비판적 고찰", 형사정책연구, 14(1), pp.189~220 (2003), 한국형사정책연구원
- 최석윤, "상징형법에 대한 비판적 고찰", 비교형사법연구, 5(2-1), pp.6~164 (2003), 한국비교형사법학회
- 최성진, "현대사회에 있어서 형법의 이원화 경향 : Jakobs의 적대형법 구상을 예로 하여", 형사정책연구, 21(3), pp.281~310 (2010), 한국형사정책연구원
- 한국형사법학회, "형사법의 현대적 과제와 도전", 2012년 하계 연합학술회, 한양대학교 법학연구소
- 허일태, "위험사회에 있어서 형법의 임무", 비교형사법연구, 5(2-1), pp.1~32 (2003), 한국비교형사법학회
- Adam, Christian, "Gefahrabwendungsfolter und Menschenwürde im Lichte des Unabwägbarkeitsdogmas des Art. 1 GG" (2008)
- Bahar, Alexander, "Auf dem Weg in ein neues Mittelalter?, In Folter im 21. Jahrhundert" (2009)
- Baum, Benjamin, "Kann das Folterverbot relativiert werden?" (2009)
- Brugger, Winfried, "Darf der Staat ausnahmsweise foltern?", Der Staat, 35, pp.67~ (1996)
- Brugger, Winfried, "Vom unbedingten Verbot der Folter zum bedingten Recht auf Folter?", JZ, 4, pp.165~ (2000)
- Brugger, Winfried, "Das andere Auge. Folter als zweitschlechteste Lösung, In Rettungsfolter im modernen Rechtsstaat?", pp.107~ (2006)
- Bruha, Thomas, "Das Folterverbot im Völkerrecht" (2006)
- Erb, Volker, "Münchener Kommentar zum Strafgesetzbuch, Band 1", pp.166~173 (2003)
- Erb, Volker, "Nothilfe durch Folter", Jura, 1, pp.24~ (2005)
- Erb, Volker, "Nowehr als Menschenrechte", NStZ, pp.593~ (2005)
- Erb, Volker, "Notwehr bei präsenter staatlicher Hilfe, In Strafrecht und Justizgewährung. Festschrift Key Nehm zum 65. Geburtstag", pp.181~ (2006), Rainer Griesbaum
- Erb, Volker, "Zur strafrechtlichen Behandlung von „Folter“ in der Notwehrlage, In Festschrift für Manfred Seebode zum 70. Geburtstag am 15. September 2008", pp.99~ (2008)
- Neumann, "Nomos Kommentar zum Strafgesetzbuch", pp.76~
- Fiechtner, Urs M, "Folter: Angriff auf die Menschenwürde" (2008)
- Gehl, "Folter - Zulässiges Instrument im Strafrecht?" (2005)
- Götz, Heinrich, "Das Urteil gegen Daschner im Lichte der Werteordnung des Grundgesetzes", NJW, 14, pp.953~ (2005)
- Groms, Maximilian, "Präventionsfolter - ein rechtsgebietsübergreifendes Problem" (2007)
- Hirsch, "Leipziger Kommentar zum Strafgestzbuch 11. Aufl", pp.72~82
- Jacobs, "Die deutsche Strafrechtswissenschaft vor der Jahrtausendwende", pp.51~ (2000)
- Jakobs, "Strafrecht Allgemeiner Teil, 2. Aufl", pp.23~ (1991)
- Järger, "Die Abwägbarkeit meinschlichen Lebens im Spannungsfeld von Strafrechtsdogmatik und Rechtsphilosophie", ZStW, pp.789~ (2003)
- Jescheck-Weigend, "Lehrbuch des Strafrechts Allgemeiner Teil, 5. Aufl" (1996)
- Kühl, "Strafrecht Allgemeiner Teil, 4. Aufl", pp.55~ (2002)
- Küper, "Grund- und Grenzfragen der rechtfertigenden Pflichtsenkollosion im Strafrecht", pp.48~ (1979)
- Küper, , JuS, pp.792~ (1981)
- Lamprecht, Florian, "Darf der Staat foltern, um Leben zu retten?" (2009)
- Lenzen, Wolfgang, "Ist Folter erlaubt?" (2006)
- Maurach-Zipf, "Strafrecht Allgemeiner Teil, 8. Aufl", pp.25~ (1992)
- Merkel, "Gründe für den Ausschuss der Strafbarkeit im Völkerstrafrecht", ZStW, pp.449~ (2002)
- Merkel, "Wenn der Staat Unschuldige opfert", Die Zeit Nr, 29(1.-2.), pp.33~ (2004)
- Möhlenbeck, Michaela, "Das absolute Folterverbot" (2008)
- Nitschke, Peter, "Rettungsfolter im modernen Rechtsstaat?" (2005)
- Pawlik, "§ 14 Abs. 3 des Luftsicherheitsgesetzes - ein Tabubruch?", JZ, pp.1045~ (2004)
- Pawlik, "Der rechtfertigende Defensivnotstand", Jura, 27 (2002)
- Pawlik, "Zum Abschuß frei - Das Bürgeropfer im Luftsicherheitsgesetz", Frankfurter Allgemeine, pp.29~ (2004)
- Reemtsma, Jan Phillip, "Folter im Rechtsstaat?" (2005)
- Roxin, Claus, "Kann staatliche Folter in Ausnahmefällen zulässig oder wenigstens straflos sein?, In Festschrift für Albin Eser zum 70. Geburtstag", pp.461~ (2005)
- Roxin., Claus, "Rettungsfolter?, In Festschrift für Kay Nehm zum 65. Geburtstag", pp.205~ (2006)
- Roxin, Claus, "Strafrecht. Allemeiner Teil, Bd. I, 4. Aufl", pp.96~166 (2006)
- Schönke-Schröder-Lenckner-Perron, "Stafgesetzbuch, 26. Aufl", pp.1~30 (2001)
- Trapp, Rainer, "Folter oder selbstverschuldetet Rettungsbefragung?" (2006)
- Wessels-Beulke, "Strafrecht Allgemeiner Teil, 33. Aufl", pp.316~ (2003)
- Wittreck, Fabian, "Menschenwürde und Folterverbot", DÖV, pp.873~ (2003)
