본문 바로가기
KERD
논문KCI 등재

소아과 질환에서 주양육자 대상의 질적연구 논문에 대한 COREQ (Consolidated Criteria for Reporting Qualitative Research) 가이드라인을 이용한 방법론적 질평가

Methodological Assessment of Qualitative Research with Caregivers in Pediatric Disease by COREQ (Consolidated Criteria for Reporting Qualitative Research) Guideline

김현호|임정태|정문주|한예지|김혜진|전채헌
대한한방소아과학회 (The Association of Pediatrics of Korean Medicine)|2018.11|대한한방소아과학회지 (The Journal of Pediatrics of Korean Medicine)|제32권 제4호|pp. 121-140|DOI https://doi.org/10.7778/jpkm.2018.32.4.121

0

조회

0

다운로드

3

인용

0

참고문헌

키워드

Qualitative researchPediatricsReviewCOREQMethodology
주제분류한의학

초록

Objectives This research was aimed to analyze and assess the articles of qualitative research of Pediatrics by following Consolidated Criteria for Reporting Qualitative Research (COREQ). Methods Two researchers analyzed and assessed the reports’ quality and appropriateness based on COREQ guideline. The articles that failed to achieve consensus from the two researchers, the third researcher made a final decision. Results A total of fifty-six reports which used caregivers as participants, were selected and adopted qualitative research methods were chosen. In most qualitative studies, COREQ was not implemented. Some parts of the studies were poorly described and elaborated when reviewing them based on the COREQ guidelines. In the ‘Research team and reflexivity’, there was lack of description about the researcher. In the ‘Study design’, there were no detailed descriptions on the approaches they took in recruiting their study participants. There was not enough detail reflexivity participants who refused, and where the recruitment took place. There were also no records of whether there was a pilot test or a data saturation. In ‘Analysis and findings’ section, there were few articles mentioning Participant checking, and the main opinion of the participants were well analyzed in all the papers, but excluding opinions of few participants. Conclusions There are still many qualitative studies that have caregivers as participants, in the field of pediatrics. However, methodological skills are insufficient. The use of the COREQ guidelines should be further implemented for more robust and methodological improvement.

Abstract

Objectives This research was aimed to analyze and assess the articles of qualitative research of Pediatrics by following Consolidated Criteria for Reporting Qualitative Research (COREQ). Methods Two researchers analyzed and assessed the reports’ quality and appropriateness based on COREQ guideline. The articles that failed to achieve consensus from the two researchers, the third researcher made a final decision. Results A total of fifty-six reports which used caregivers as participants, were selected and adopted qualitative research methods were chosen. In most qualitative studies, COREQ was not implemented. Some parts of the studies were poorly described and elaborated when reviewing them based on the COREQ guidelines. In the ‘Research team and reflexivity’, there was lack of description about the researcher. In the ‘Study design’, there were no detailed descriptions on the approaches they took in recruiting their study participants. There was not enough detail reflexivity participants who refused, and where the recruitment took place. There were also no records of whether there was a pilot test or a data saturation. In ‘Analysis and findings’ section, there were few articles mentioning Participant checking, and the main opinion of the participants were well analyzed in all the papers, but excluding opinions of few participants. Conclusions There are still many qualitative studies that have caregivers as participants, in the field of pediatrics. However, methodological skills are insufficient. The use of the COREQ guidelines should be further implemented for more robust and methodological improvement.

참고문헌 (74)

  1. 정진주, "보건의료분야에서의 질적연구의 적용", Korean Journal of Family Medicine, 29(08), pp.553~562 (2008), 대한가정의학회
  2. MacPherson H, "Practitioner perspectives on strategies to promote longer-term benefits of acupuncture or counselling for depression: a qualitative study", PloS One, 9(9), pp.e104077~ (2014)
  3. Soliday E, "Engaging practitioners in advancing research on acupuncture in pregnancy", J Altern Complement Med, 21(11), pp.707~712 (2015)
  4. Skjeie H, "’Big needles, small bodies’-the absence of acupuncture treatment for infants in contemporary Shanghai: a qualitative study", BMJ Open, 5(11), pp.e009486~ (2015)
  5. Lee SM, "Close look at the experiences of patients enrolled in a clinical trial of acupuncture treatment for atrial fibrillation in Korea:a qualitative study nested within a randomised controlled trial", BMJ Open, 7(2), pp.e013180~ (2017)
  6. 문아지, "고혈압-뜸 임상시험 참여자들의 혈압 관리행동에 대한 질적연구", 대한한방내과학회지, 33(4), pp.543~557 (2012), 대한한방내과학회
  7. 송승연, "EFT 집단치료 프로그램이 화병환자에게 미치는 영향에 대한 질적분석", 동의신경정신과학회지, 25(1), pp.29~38 (2014), 대한한방신경정신과학회
  8. 김혜진, "야제 환아의 한의치료에 대한 질적 연구- 주양육자의 서술을 중심으로 -", 대한한방소아과학회지, 32(1), pp.44~53 (2018), 대한한방소아과학회[DOI]
  9. Moher D, "The CONSORT statement: revised recommendations for improving the quality of reports of parallel-group randomized trials", JAMA, 285(15), pp.1987~1991 (2001)
  10. Moher D, "Improving the quality of reports of meta-analyses of randomised controlled trials: the QUOROM statement. Quality of reporting of meta-analyses", Lancet, 354(9193), pp.1896~1900 (1999)
  11. Stroup DF, "Meta-analysis of observational studies in epidemiology:a proposal for reporting. Meta-analysis Of Observational Studies in Epidemiology (MOOSE) group", JAMA, 283(15), pp.2008~2012 (2000)
  12. Moher D, "Use of the CONSORT statement and quality of reports of randomized trials: a comparative before-and-after evaluation", JAMA, 285(15), pp.1992~1995 (2001)
  13. Tong A, "Consolidated criteria for reporting qualitative research(COREQ) : a 32-item checklist for interviews and focus groups", Int J Qual Health Care, 19(6), pp.349~357 (2007)
  14. Larson EL, "Publication guidelines need widespread adoption", J Clin Epidemiol, 65(3), pp.239~246 (2012)
  15. 윤강현, "특발성 안면신경마비 환자의 안면 기공요법 경험과 안면 기공요법의 효과적인 교육 방안 : 질적 연구", Journal of Acupuncture Research, 32(1), pp.67~78 (2015), 대한침구의학회
  16. 이승민, "특발성 안면신경마비 환자의 입원치료 경험에 대한 질적 연구", Journal of Acupuncture Research, 30(5), pp.11~23 (2013), 대한침구의학회
  17. 이승환, "국내 한의학 학회지에 게재된 질적 연구 보고 분석", 동의신경정신과학회지, 27(2), pp.77~87 (2016), 대한한방신경정신과학회
  18. Dekking SAS, "A qualitative study into dependent relationships and voluntary informed consent for research in pediatric oncology", Paediatr Drugs, 18(2), pp.145~156 (2016)
  19. Page MJ, "Tools for assessing risk of reporting biases in studies and syntheses of studies:a systematic review", BMJ Open, 8(3), pp.e019703~ (2018)
  20. McGrath P, "Benefits of participation in longitudinal qualitative research study", Monash Bioeth Rev, 22(1), pp.63~78 (2003)
  21. Prussing E, "Communicating with pediatricians about complementary", alternative medicine : perspectives from parents of children with down syndrome, 2004, pp.4(6), 488~494
  22. Van den Bruel A, "Signs and symptoms in children with a serious infection : a qualitative study", BMC Fam Pract, 6, pp.36~ (2005)
  23. Østerlund CS, "Mother knows best: medical record management for patients with spina bifida during the transition from pediatric to adult care", AMIA Annu Symp Proc, pp.580~584 (2005)
  24. Jones K, "The potential impact of Medicaid reform on the health care-seeking behavior of Medicaidcovered children : a qualitative analysis of parental perspectives", J Natl Med Assoc, 101(3), pp.213~222 (2009)
  25. Taylor S, "Child involvement in the paediatric consultation : a qualitative study of children and carers’ views", Child Care Health Dev, 36(5), pp.678~685 (2010)
  26. Garth B, "Perceptions of participation: child patients with a disability in the doctor-parent-child partnership", Patient Educ Couns, 74(1), pp.45~52 (2009)
  27. Rise MB, "How do parents of child patients compare consultations with homeopaths and physicians? A qualitative study", Patient Educ Couns, 74(1), pp.91~96 (2009)
  28. Kumar R, "Parents’and primary healthcare practitioners’ perspectives on the safety of honey and other traditional paediatric healthcare approaches", Child Care Health Dev, 37(5), pp.734~743 (2011)
  29. Stewart J, "Evaluation of the Australian adaptation of the Keeping It Together (KIT-Australia) information package with carers of children with special needs", Aust Occup Ther J, 57(4), pp.268~275 (2010)
  30. Van Niekerk A, "Barriers and enablers to the use of measures to prevent pediatric scalding in Cape Town, South Africa", Public Health Nurs, 27(3), pp.203~220 (2010)
  31. Sealy YM, "Using public health detailing and a family-centered ecological approach to promote patient-provider-parent action for reducing childhood obesity", Pediatr Obes, 8(2), pp.132~146 (2012)
  32. Klassen AF, "Understanding the health impact of caregiving : a qualitative study of immigrant parents and single parents of children with cancer", Qual Life Res, 21(9), pp.1595~1605 (2012)
  33. van Staa AL, "Crossing the transition chasm : experiences and recommendations for improving transitional care of young adults, parents and providers", Child Care Health Dev, 37(6), pp.821~832 (2011)
  34. Farnesi BC, "Exploring collaboration between clinicians and parents to optimize pediatric weight management", Patient Educ Couns, 87(1), pp.10~17 (2012)
  35. Ringnér A, "Parental experiences of information within pediatric oncology", J Pediatr Oncol Nurs, 28(4), pp.244~251 (2011)
  36. Shilling V, "Processes in recruitment to randomised controlled trials of medicines for children(RECRUIT) : a qualitative study", Health Technol Assess, 15(15), pp.1~116 (2011)
  37. Marsac ML, "Child coping and parent coping assistance during the peritrauma period in injured children", Fam Syst Health, 29(4), pp.279~290 (2011)
  38. Jimenez ME, "Barriers to evaluation for early intervention services : parent and early intervention employee perspectives", Acad Pediatr, 12(6), pp.551~557 (2012)
  39. Watermeyer J, "“This clinic is number one”: a qualitative study of factors that contribute toward “successful” care at a South African Pediatric HIV", AIDS clinic, 2012, pp.35(3), 360~379
  40. Lindenfelser KJ, "Music therapy in pediatric palliative care : family-centered care to enhance quality of life", Am J Hosp Palliat Care, 29(3), pp.219~226 (2012)
  41. Thomas M, "Consenting to pediatric critical care research : understanding the perspective of parents", Dynamics, 24(3), pp.18~24 (2013)
  42. Lewis SA, "Effective process or dangerous precipice : qualitative comparative embedded case study with young people with epilepsy and their parents during transition from children’s to adult services", BMC Pediatr, 13, pp.169~ (2013)
  43. Moreau KA, "Making program evaluation activities family-centered : a qualitative study", Disabil Rehabil, 36(11), pp.948~958 (2014)
  44. Schwartz LA, "Stakeholder validation of a model of readiness for transition to adult care", JAMA Pediatr, 167(10), pp.939~946 (2013)
  45. Young B, "Is communication guidance mistaken? Qualitative study of parent-oncologist communication in childhood cancer", Br J Cancer, 109(4), pp.836~843 (2013)
  46. Woolfall K, "Parents’ agendas in paediatric clinical trial recruitment are different from researchers’and often remain unvoiced: a qualitative study", PloS One, 8(7), pp.e67352~ (2013)
  47. Orioles A, "“To be a phenomenal doctor you have to be the whole package”: physicians’ interpersonal behaviors during difficult conversations in pediatrics", J Palliat Med, 16(8), pp.929~933 (2013)
  48. Korhonen A, "It’s time for updating primary nursing in pediatric oncology care : qualitative study highlighting the perceptions of nurses, physicians and parents", Eur J Oncol Nurs, 17(6), pp.732~738 (2013)
  49. DeCamp LR, "The voices of limited English proficiency Latina mothers on pediatric primary care : lessons for the medical home", Matern Child Health J, 17(1), pp.95~109 (2013)
  50. Gaab E, "Families’ views of pediatric palliative aquatics : a qualitative study", Pain Manag Nurs, 16(4), pp.526~533 (2015)
  51. Cipolletta S, "Family functioning as a constituent aspect of a child’s chronic illness", J Pediatr Nurs, 30(6), pp.e19~e28 (2015)
  52. Ford K, "More than just clowns--Clown doctor rounds and their impact for children, families and staff", J Child Health Care, 18(3), pp.286~296 (2014)
  53. Macías M, "Impact of hospital admission care at a pediatric unit: a qualitative study", Paediatr Nurs, 41(6), pp.285~294 (2015)
  54. Howe CJ, "Parent health literacy and communication with diabetes educators in a pediatric diabetes clinic: a mixed methods approach", J Health Commun, 20(Suppl 2), pp.50~59 (2015)
  55. Samuels-Kalow M, "Unmet needs at the time of emergency department discharge", Acad Emerg Med, 23(3), pp.279~287 (2016)
  56. Durlacher KM, "Parents’ experiences of splinting programs for babies with congenital limb anomalies", J Pediatr Rehabil Med, 8(3), pp.207~217 (2015)
  57. Bush RA, "Exploring perceptions and use of the electronic health record by parents of children with autism spectrum disorder : a qualitative study", Health Inform J, 22(3), pp.702~711 (2016)
  58. Dekking SAS, "Balancing research interests and patient interests : a qualitative study into the intertwinement of care and research in paediatric oncology", Pediatr Blood Cancer, 62(5), pp.816~822 (2015)
  59. Maree JE, "The information needs of South African parents of children with cancer", J Pediatr Oncol Nurs, 33(1), pp.9~17 (2016)
  60. Moreau KA, "A qualitative exploration of which resident skills parents in pediatric emergency departments can assess", Med Teach, 38(11), pp.1118~1124 (2016)
  61. Ruhe KM, "Putting patient participation into practice in pediatrics-results from a qualitative study in pediatric oncology", Eur J Pediatr, 175(9), pp.1147~1155 (2016)
  62. Cacioppo CN, "Expectation versus reality: the impact of utility on emotional outcomes after returning individualized genetic research results in pediatric rare disease research, a qualitative interview study", PLoS One, 11(4), pp.e0153597~ (2016)
  63. Augustine EM, "Caretakers’ perspectives on return pediatric emergency department visits : a qualitative analysis of focus groups", Pediatr Emerg Care, 32(9), pp.594~598 (2016)
  64. Ray KN, "Family perspectives on high-quality pediatric subspecialty referrals", Acad Pediatr, 16(6), pp.594~600 (2016)
  65. Rosenberg RE, "Parents’ perspectives on"Keeping Their Children Safe"in the hospital", J Nurs Care Qual, 31(4), pp.318~326 (2016)
  66. Wangmo T, "Parents’and patients’ experiences with paediatric oncology care in Switzerland--satisfaction and some hurdles", Swiss Med Wkly, 146, pp.w14309~ (2016)
  67. Konstantynowicz J, "What do children with chronic diseases and their parents think about pediatricians? A qualitative interview study", Matern Child Health J, 20(8), pp.1745~1752 (2016)
  68. Samuels-Kalow M, ""Like a dialogue" : Teach-back in the emergency department", Patient Educ Couns, 99(4), pp.549~554 (2016)
  69. Vemulakonda VM, "Barriers to participation in surgical randomized controlled trials in pediatric urology:a qualitative study of key stakeholder perspectives", J Pediatr Urol, 12(3), pp.180.e1~180.e7 (2016)
  70. Badarau DO, "Decision making in pediatric oncology: Views of parents and physicians in two European countries", AJOB Empir Bioeth, 8(1), pp.21~31 (2017)
  71. Tavallali AG, "Cross-cultural care encounters in paediatric care : Minority ethnic parents’experiences", Scand J Caring Sci, 31(1), pp.54~62 (2017)
  72. Wangmo T, "Better to know than to imagine : Including children in their health care", AJOB Empir Bioeth, 8(1), pp.11~20 (2017)
  73. Atout M, "The experience of decision making in the care of children with palliative care needs : The experiences of Jordanian mothers", Compr Child Adolesc Nurs, 40(4), pp.240~256 (2017)
  74. Beck AF, "Socioeconomic status influences the toll paediatric hospitalisations take on families : a qualitative study", BMJ Qual Saf, 26(4), pp.304~311 (2017)

관련 논문AI추천

소아청소년과 의료진의 가족중심돌봄 인식정소영한국아동간호학회 · Child Health Nursing Research2018 · 제24권 제4호최근 10년간 간호학술지에 게재된 질적연구 분석: JKAN과 ANR 중심으로송은옥, 장혜영질적연구학회 · 질적연구2019 · 제20권 제2호국내 한의학 학회지에 게재된 질적 연구 보고 분석성우용, 이승환, 임정화대한한방신경정신과학회 · 동의신경정신과학회지2016 · 제27권 제2호저신장 및 성장과 관련된 질적연구에 대한 체계적 문헌 고찰김현호, 김혜진, 노민영, 임정태, 전채헌, 정문주, 한예지대한한방소아과학회 · 대한한방소아과학회지2019 · 제33권 제4호CARE 지침에 따른 대한한방소아과학회지의 증례보고에 대한 질평가김지환, 이명수, 이주아, 이혜림대한한방소아과학회 · 대한한방소아과학회지2018 · 제32권 제3호종양관련 질적연구 보고 표준에 대한 문헌분석손행미대한종양간호학회 · Asian Oncology Nursing2023 · 제23권 제4호

이 간행물의 다른 논문 (11건)

방풍통성산의 지방대사조절을 통한 비알콜성 지방간 유도 인슐린저항성 개선 효과김기봉, 서일복, 안상현pp. 1-12중학생에 있어서 음양 기질과 행동문제의 상관관계이수진, 이윤동, 채한, 박은영, 황정희pp. 13-23소아 특발성 관절염의 한약치료에 대한 문헌 고찰김미연, 정민정pp. 24-41한방치료로 호전된 자폐스펙트럼장애 1례 보고강주봉, 설재현, 장규태pp. 42-50성장 치료를 목적으로 한방병원에 내원한 환아에 대한 임상적 고찰박은정, 최선희pp. 51-62
원문 보기